WadeK
Member
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2006
- Messages
- 10
I just finished re-reading The Hedge Knight and The Sworn Sword, and I am now firmly convinced that Ser Duncan the Tall is in fact not even a knight. He lied about Sir Arlan of Pennytree knighting him on his deathbed. Here's why -
in The Hedge Knight
1. He thinks briefly about finding another knight to take service with as a squire. If Arlan had really knighted Dunk, why would that even occur to him?
2. He hesitates to knight Sir Raymun FossFossoway. Any knight may make a knight, but Duncan doesn't want to perform the act because he doesn't want his lie to affect his friend.
in The Sworn Sword
1. When Lady Rohanne asks Dunk flat out if Ser Arlan knighted him, Dunk responds evasively - "No one else was like to do it."
I am sure that there are other clues that I missed, but I am convinced that Ser Duncan is living a lie. We know he ends up as Lord COmmander of Aegon's Kingsgaurd...will his lie come back to haunt him at some point?
in The Hedge Knight
1. He thinks briefly about finding another knight to take service with as a squire. If Arlan had really knighted Dunk, why would that even occur to him?
2. He hesitates to knight Sir Raymun FossFossoway. Any knight may make a knight, but Duncan doesn't want to perform the act because he doesn't want his lie to affect his friend.
in The Sworn Sword
1. When Lady Rohanne asks Dunk flat out if Ser Arlan knighted him, Dunk responds evasively - "No one else was like to do it."
I am sure that there are other clues that I missed, but I am convinced that Ser Duncan is living a lie. We know he ends up as Lord COmmander of Aegon's Kingsgaurd...will his lie come back to haunt him at some point?