Which episode was your favorite?

[MythingLink]

Everyone loved City on the Edge of Forever, but I can't say it was one of my favorites. I think the one I remember the most is 'Charley' for some reason. Maybe because it was the first one aired and also because I liked the actor who played Charley. I think it also kind of set the mood for the way Kirk was going to handle most problems with compassion and a strong hand.

So Mac, ewlyn, Dave, et.al? What is your favorite episode?

Cheers,

 

[peachy]

for me, it's just got to be the tribble's one, i just loved that, especially when they got into kirks coffee and chicken sandwich, at least i think thats what he was having for lunch my memory aint what it used to be
...peachy

 

[MacavityCat]

Actually I had four favorite episodes.
Amok Time
This Side of Paradise
The Paradise Syndrome
The Trouble with Tribbles

 

[MythingLink]

Did you all know that the idea for The Trouble With Tribbles was borrowed from a book by Heinlein called The Rolling Stones?

Cheers,

 

[peachy]

you learn something new everyday...peachy

 

[MacavityCat]

Nope... it would appear that my worldliness to The Rolling Stones is limited to the group whose lead singer is Mick Jagger! *L*

 

[Neo]

'Mud' was my favourite... made me laugh so much

 

[Dave]

Would have to go with:

Amok Time
Trouble with Tribbles
City on the Edge of Forever

Didn't know the Rolling Stones thing, but very few stories are completely original.

 

[MacavityCat]

Dave... excellent choices... Forgot about the City on the Edge of Forever! That too was one of my favorites.

In the novels, Kirk has a ship named after Edith Keeler. *s*

mc

 

[Neo]

I did like trouble with tribbles.... was one of those classic funny episodes....

Ws also impressed that Ds9 used it as well

 

[Dave]

Now that I have started adding individual episode threads, I have come to the conclusion that the first Season is easily the best. I like almost all of the first Season episodes, most of the second, and much less of the third.

I forgot to mention 'The Menagerie' and 'Space Seed' before which I also think are some of the best.

 

[Highlander II]

well - i gotta start watching TOS again -- so i can really pick a favorite -- hard to pick a fave if you haven't seen them all --

however, TOS has to wait - it comes on at the same time as the BTVS reruns - (which are almost finished w/ the series run now and will start over about mid-march) -- but i'll get back to TOS! got on a Buffy kick - blame James Marsters - and can't get off --

but - never fear - i'll be back to TOS and catch up w/ those too!

i do like "Trouble w/ Tribbles" and "City on the Edge of Forever" - but i think there are others i really like too -- but, i'll have to watch some eps again - b/c i can't seem to match titles and storylines at the moment ---