Babylon 5 Motion Picture Poll

What kind of Babylon 5 motion picture would you like to see?

  • Crusade Movie

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Babylon 5: The Fall of the Interstellar Alliance

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    5
Status
Not open for further replies.

Whitestar

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2004
Messages
365
JMS has stated in the B5 Lurker's Guide website that as soon as Star Wars Episode 3 is released in theaters, he will begin working on a possible B5 motion picture for the big screen. He has apparently hinted that the movie could focuse on the Telepath War. I have reason to believe that that it may be the case. Still, I think there are other possibilities. With that in mind, I decided to place a poll on what kind of B5 movie do fans want to see. Here they are:


1) Babylon 5: The Telepath War

2) Babylon 5: The Return of Valen (which picks up where W.W.E. part 2 left off)

3) Crusade Movie

4) Babylon 5: The Fall of the Interstellar Alliance

5) Babylon 5: The New Earth Chronicles (where humans are now on the Vorlon homeworld and the new guardians of the universe)


Whitestar
 
The problem, in my opinion, is pincipally one of making sure it's a story that really works. That means not simply a story but a very good story that ties in very well with Bab5.

It would be great to see some of the original central characters - G'Kar and Londo most especially - but my personal perception is that anything too close to the end of series 5 will be in danger of looking conceptually messy.

That, to myself, rubs out the Telepath War as an option - although it would be great to see main characters, it's perhaps better to leave a good job finished badly, than try to add extra bits to the end in a well-meaning attempt to improve it.

Picking up on more distanced plot concepts would perhaps be the most valuable - not simply for Babylon 5 fans, but also for introducing other people to the concept. Showing something of the original Shadow War (option 2) could be very useful there - it could serve as an excellent prologue to Babylon 5 overall - there's certainly plenty of information that could be tied in from the original Bab5 seasons into it. The question is, how much can you actually do with a prologue that's worthwhile?

As for Crusade - that's over my head - and will be for a lot of people outside of the US, I suspect. So I'm not convinced it could possibly market well (ie, "here's a film about a story arc many of you won't have seen, won;t know about, won;t care about").

Fall of the Interstellar Allance - well, again, this sounds too close after Season 5 (unless I miscontrue the concept), and - let's face it - unless it's the Shadows themselves who physically destroy it, then the only other options of the Shaodws angry little brother, or a drawn out political process that could be meaningless to most viewers.

New Earth Chronicles sounds interesting - set far into the future, yes? In which case it could be like a clean break, and a good point from which to launch a whole new set of characters and even a series. If it involves the topic of humans evolving into angelic form then there's room for J Michael Straczynski to return to his own spiritual insights, and make a very meaningful story.

So, looking at it, the last option to myself I see as the one with the most potential - not so as to try and close the chapters of a book already written, but to open a new book related to the first, carrying it's strengths, but abandoning its weaknesses.

2c
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top