Phoebe walks into the kitchen to see Prue trying to use her telekinesis. She gets kind of scared that Prue's power won't work. It was only her astral body trying to use telekinesis. Then Prue complains about her tooth 'cause it hurts. She is driving to the dentist for her appointment when she is stopped by a road construction crew. Before they wave her through, Cole sends a bus by her that has "Save the Innocent" on the side of it. While she's figuring that out, he changes the direction on a sign, so when she's waved thru, she goes the wrong direction. She drives on, and eventually comes to a building. A construction guy tells her that there's a man in the building who has lived there for four years and he won't come out, even though they have to blow the building up. When she finds the guy's apartment, she uses her power to slide open the chain lock and goes in. There's this guy huddled up in a corner, mumbling about the pain he feels. Prue tries to get closer to him, but he just yells, "Keep away! Your pity is like knives, stabbing me." When she gets home, Piper is trying to convince Leo to go out on a date in public. Prue tells them about the man, and Leo says that the man must be an impath, a person who feels human emotion. When they die, they get reborn as people who can help others. Prue leaves to go help the guy. And just as Phoebe and Cole are going to leave, Leo says that maybe it would be fun to go on a double date with them. Prue shows up at the building to help the guy out when a cop stops her. She tells him that Cole Turner wants to keep the guy out of jail and the cop lets her upstairs. She goes and tries to convince the guy that his power is good, but he won't believe her. So she casts a spell to remove his powers, and at the last second, he grabs onto her hand. When she leaves, the cop comes up and tries to take the guy away, but it turns out the "guy" is a demon and kills the cop. Prue then heads on to the dentist, and while she talks to the receptionist, some guy behind her pinches his girlfriend's butt. She turns around and goes "ooh!" just as the girl behind her does. Meanwhile, the demon, Vinceras, was killing a lady at a church because he wanted to know where the priest that cursed him was. Cole just brought Phoebe back and Prue tells Phoebe that she hadn't felt anything like that since Andy was alive. She had felt Cole and Phoebe's love. She got them all together in the kitchen and proved that she could feel everyone else's emotions. Phoebe left to see Cole, and Prue went upstairs to look in the Book of Shadows, but not before she told Leo and Piper that they should work out their relationship problems. Leo told Piper that he wished he would have been able to pay for lunch (because Piper had paid) and that in his day, men were all chivalrous. Then they started kissing, and Prue yelled out, "Not now, I have a headache!" While Phoebe was at Cole's, they had sex. After a while, Prue started to get really upset and her head felt like it was going to explode from everyone's emotions. Leo, Piper and Phoebe brought her along to the apartment building they were going to blow up, and Phoebe got a premonition of the cop, a lady, and then a man at a psychiatric hospital getting killed. They went to the place and brought the priest who was committed there home. While the priest was trying to convince Prue that she could beat Vinceras, Vinceras shows up. He was immune to Piper's freezing and even more so immune to Phoebe's karate skills. Prue came to her senses and started to beat up Vinceras. She was kicking his butt when she remembered he couldn't stand human emotion and astral projected inside him. He couldn't take the feelings of billions of people and exploded. Prue's astral body came out of him, and Prue smiled at her astral self before it went back inside her.
