Have they thrown their science advisor overboard?

ray gower

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2001
Messages
3,315
Or is anybody worried by the shuttlepods?

This is something that has been seriously bothering me, but it is only now (since watching Shuttlepod 1), I've realised exactly what it is.

The shuttlepods aren't fit to grace a fairground ride, let alone get into space!

My prize exhibit is the door.

It is an unlined oven door, held on with a bit of piano hinge and held open with a couple of light gas struts. It also opens outwards.

It notably manages to miss useful features like locks, seals or anything else that might prevent the occupants leaking out into space.

I would also add that space is a jolly cold place to be. Because of this NASA lags its shuttles with serious amounts of insulation. The shuttlepods being unlined are going to require the sort of heating that makes steam pipes glow to counter this- Or perhaps they use infra-red and cook their inhabitants?
 
It's worse than that, he's dead Jim!

André Boramis (their science advisor) has started writing scripts -- so that means he has no excuse at all if he *****-up!
 
maybe its some undiscussed future heating or insolating techknology...sure blame everything on that one...
 
Star Trek's Warped Cartography

The other problem with Enterprise is the speed of the NX-01 at Warp 4.5 (Max Warp 5) yet it's ability to reach a new planet every week. Warp 4.5 is meant to be about 90c or 90 times the speed of light. I remember reading that the speed of the the original Enterprise was deliberately set so that it could just about feasibly visit a new star system and planets each week. The NX-01 is half as fast.

Just take 'Broken Bow' as an example. In Star Trek Monthly #103 there is a question to Larry Nemecek concerning this. It only took a few days for them to get to Qo'nos. If it took a week, then that would make it between one and two light years away. Yet the nearest star to Earth is Proxima Centauri at 4.3 light years.

They also visited Rigel on the way to Qo'nos. If that was the real star Rigel, then it is 1,000 light years away. In the Star Trek Star Charts by Geoffrey Mandel which I recently purchased, he changes Rigel to a nearer star called Beta Rige (an optical double that he made up.) He also says that the NX-01 must have used a subspace shortcut to get to Qo'nos.
 
It is claimed the Galaxy is expanding.

Everything was further away in TOS times, so they had to go faster! :D

Perhaps it is the drugs!
 
perhaps more time has passed each week than just a week?
 
The Star Trek Chronology assumes that since there are approximately 24 episodes/year then each episode spans 2 weeks. I can accept that, but my problem with Enterprise is that Archer and Admiral Forest often discuss how many days it will take to reach certain planets -- I can't remember other examples now -- but 'Broken Bow' is the prime example.

As for the shuttlepods, they do look like they are made from fibreglass, but don't they have 'structural integrity fields' to hold them together? I doubt that the crew would be safe if it were only those few millimetres of Duranium?? between them and deep space.
 
Don't think they have anything like integrity fields on the shuttlepods, or Trip and Reed wouldn't have sprung a leak when they went drifting off on their own
 

Similar threads


Back
Top