3.04: Who Watches the Watchers

ray gower

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2001
Messages
3,315
Synopsis
Counselor Troi's life is put on the line and Captain Picard is mistaken for a god-like being by the inhabitants of a primitive culture.

A team of Federation anthropologists, working in a camouflaged outpost on Mintaka III, have been observing the Mintakans — a race of Vulcan-like humanoids whose development is at the equivalent of earth's Bronze Age. But when an explosion rips through the post, the expedition's leader, Barron, and his assistant, an elderly woman named Warren, are seriously injured. A third team member, a young man named Palmer, is dazed in the blast and wanders away from the site.

Beaming down to assist the Federation officials, the Away Team is spotted by two Mintakans, Liko and his son Oji. Stunned by the sight of Warren being beamed up to the U.S.S. Enterprise, Liko accidentally slips and is critically injured in a fall. To save his life, Dr. Crusher beams Liko up to the ship, although it violates the Federation's Prime Directive, which states that members are not to interfere with other cultures.

Regaining consciousness in Sickbay, Liko overhears Picard promising Barron that he will find Palmer. Despite the fact that Crusher performs a procedure to remove his short term memory, it doesn't work and Liko returns to the planet describing "the Picard" to other Mintakans as a god, capable of healing wounds and reversing death.

To find Palmer and minimize any cultural contamination, Riker and Troi beam down to the planet disguised as Mintakans. They overhear Liko telling his friends about "the Picard's" powers and are shocked when three Mintakan hunters walk in carrying Palmer. Liko immediately assumes that Palmer is a servant of "the Picard" and it would please the god if they presented Palmer to him.

While Troi diverts the Mintakans, Riker beams himself and Palmer up to the Enterprise. When Liko and the group realize what Riker has done, they fear that "the Picard" will be angry with them for losing Palmer. To redeem themselves, they seize Troi with the intention of killing her to prove their loyalty to "the Picard."

Fearing for Troi's life, Picard has Nuria, the Mintakan leader, beamed aboard the U.S.S. Enterprise, hoping that if she is convinced that he is not a god, she will be able to persuade her people of that fact. Despite all his efforts, Picard is unable to convince Nuria that he is a mere mortal — until she sees him stand by helplessly in Sickbay when Warren dies and she realizes Picard has no power over life and death.

Just as Troi is about to be sacrificed, Nuria and Picard return to Mintaka III. Liko, still believing that Picard is a god, attempts to prove Picard's omnipotence by firing a crossbow at him. Only when he sees Picard suffering from his wound is Liko convinced of his mistake. Troi is freed and after Picard is healed, he bids farewell to the Mintakans, who are left to progress on their own.
 
Apart from proving what a pompous ass, Picard is. Just how mind numbingly irritating Doctor Crusher can be, plus a few other nit-picks of that nature. The episodes most notable feature is just how badly the Prime Directive is thought out.

There appears to be no guidelines for what happens if your anthropologists are caught with their fingers in the cookie jar, or if your resident quack see's a native fall off a cliff.

The later case is simple and logical. One lets them get on with it.

Okay, it would equal a short episode. So we let the red head rescue the faller. But why didn't Picard arrange the Courts Martial, if the Prime Directive is so high on his personal list?

But the biggest problem is the 'Correcting the Evolutionary Progress of the Civilisation' bit.

Just what did Picard expect?

Suddenly whisking away the leader of a race, to show her something that she never knew existed, is more likely to result in violent fainting, than sudden understanding. Besides it would have an even greater effect than simply whisking away your captured crew members.

At least the later action would, if the locals are as logically inclined as suggested, quickly be consigned to the level of ghost stories.
What is wrong with having a few Gods?
What gives Picard the right to change the development of a race by telling them there is no God?
Afterall it has not done the Bajoran's any harm and they know they have gods.
Unless, of course, Picard is a complete aetheist?
 
I have to agree with you, although I like this episode.

Originally posted by ray gower
The episodes most notable feature is just how badly the Prime Directive is thought out.

True, but wouldn't we visit other low-tech civilisations in just that way. It brought the idealistic 'Prime Directive' to the real world.

Compare the use of the duck-blind, to Kirk and Spock's trips down to primitive worlds. Who makes the most effort to keep to the 'Prime Directive'?

Originally posted by ray gower
Afterall it has not done the Bajoran's any harm and they know they have gods.
Unless, of course, Picard is a complete aetheist?

Picard was supposed to be very interested in Bajoran culture, history, and heritage. That's why he was the one who pressed for them to join the Federation (unsuccessfully.) He didn't ask for them to abandon their gods.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top