1.05: Time Out of Mind

Dave

Non Bio
Staff member
Joined
Jan 5, 2001
Messages
23,198
Location
Way on Down South, London Town
----------------------------------------------------
Creating episode thread: Remember only
this episode should be discussed here,
or the spoiler tag used.
----------------------------------------------------
 
In his continuing unsuccessful quest to make his fortune from his knowledge of the future, Kurt Mendle becomes manager to, and also marries a young woman who is destined to be a big star in the music world 5 years hence, but whose South American Techno music is currently unheard of, and who was working as a waitress.

He tries to push her music visiting several record labels without success, even when he tells them about the future of their current top acts. Apparently, his gambling wins have gained hims some notoriety too

Neil Taggert finds some information on a website with government documents, but I didn't catch what it was.

Then, one by one, the Odyssey 5 members start losing their memories. First, Angela forgets Kurt, then Neil starts doing stunts on his motorbike like a 17 year-old, then Sarah forgets Chuck too. In desperation, Chuck and Kurt consult a theoretical physicist & renowned sci-fi writer who is lecturing at a local science fiction convention, claiming that they need help with the science in a time-travel novel they are working on. But all they determine is that each victim has the urge to type a bunch of weird symbols on a computer screen just before losing their memories of the next 5 years.

I thought that the criticisms of the 'Odyssey 5' plot by the sci-fi writer was funny. The shows writers can disarm all their critics that way, just like 'Stargate SG-1' did in 'Wormhole Xtreme'.

I could understand them losing their memories of the next 5 years, but why would they lose their memory of the previous few weeks? This is the first thing that they've really done wrong IMHO.

Finally, Mendel is the lone survivor. As if stuggling with his new marriage wasn't trouble enough, if his memory goes before he can figure out what is going on, there will be no one left to save the earth from ultimate destruction. Luckily, he left himself a note in the ice-box, and a video to remind himself who he is. Just before his wife leaves him, she tells him that the symbols are MIDI code for music. The resulting noise is able to reboot all their memories. Reset button!

Nice ending at the diner though!
 
First off.... Is Kurt dumb or what?
If making a bet (ok ok, so it was a very large one) can change the future, doesn't it seem a bit daft that he actually seemed to think this ploy might have worked? I mean, people getting famous these days generally has to do with them being in the right place at the right time, from what I can tell. Doomed from the beginning I tells ya. He would be much better off if he made a great many small bets, then it would only be making very small changes to the way things happened originally.
I did like very much how we were thrown a curve ball with Kurt's rousing speech, that in any othr movie or tv programme would have persuaded the music execs, against the odds, to sign the girl. But, alas no, real life had more influence in this segment than fantasy.

Secondly... Like the previous week's episode of SG1, this episode of O5 (hows that for an abbreviation?) completely ignores the cliffhanger from the preceeding episode. The episode was wonderful, so I am not annoyed in the slightest, but I am beginning to understand the criticisms that the show has been very slow moving in terms of actually getting to the bottom of the conspiracy.

As I just mentioned - wonderful episode! I have to say I loved every minute, and my flatmate kept coming in to the room to figure out what I was guffawing at, only to leave disgusted that it was still "that ******* SciFi show" :D :blush:

My favourite part has got to be Kurt's 'physicist' friend. And the scenes at the convention, and the mention of the 'Falcons', and the tongue in cheek statement that "that's the kind of storyline you see in cheap tv shows". ROFLMAO!
The actors really seem to be settling into their characters, especially Weller, who really stood out in this episode for me. I can't pinpoint anything exactly, but he was just great, both in his reactions to the crisis, and more importantly (for me), to the pompous English novelist.

Posted by dave
Luckily, he left himself a note in the ice-box, and a video to remind himself who he is. Just before his wife leaves him, she tells him that the symbols are MIDI code for music. The resulting noise is able to reboot all their memories. Reset button!
This is my only real criticism. Just was too much a shot in the dark... How this failsafe mechanism implanted by the Seeker would have been able to figure out how to express itself confuses me. Also, with neil being such a computer geek, wouldn't he have known what that code was? Or was he put out of the picture before he had the chance?
Although I was a bit onfused by the 'partial' amnesia. Very strange.
 
Originally posted by Tabitha
First off.... Is Kurt dumb or what?

Yes, I think Kurt is dumb! There are people like him though, so he is totally believable.

Originally posted by Tabitha
As I just mentioned - wonderful episode! I have to say I loved every minute.

Even though it was twinned on Sky One with, IMHO, the best SG-1 S6 episode yet, I still enjoyed this O5 episode more! It's really growing on me. Pity that there only seems to be us two watching it here at ASciFi.
 
Totally love it, as I say in other places it gets better and better with each episodes. I love it from beginning to end but totally love when Chuck lose his memory and Mendel have to leave his house with a gun pointed at him. Also enjoy the way Mendel leave messages to himself, first the refrigerator and then the video. :) And Neil's getting back to his punk behavior when he loses his recolection and how Chuck let him in jail. Definitely a great episode.


Krystal :p
 
Hehe, okay, Kurt is dumb. I think the reason I am having difficulty with this concept is that 1) he is obviously very very intelligent to have got so far in his field (genetics?) and 2) he has some interest, as we know from both the premiere and this episode, in Science fiction.
I suppose I assumed someone like that should be really thinking these things through. Although 20/20 hindsight is a fine thing...


I do think that pairing this episode with SG1 Abyss was perfect, I felt like I had a great night - fantastic tv and no substantial complaints, woohoo!

I am absolutely loving this show, it would be criminal to cancel it, or at least if it is going to be a short run, they had better give us a good ending.
 
Originally posted by Krystal
Totally love it.... And Neil.... and how Chuck let him in jail. Definitely a great episode.

I forgot the jail scene. It was funny, especially Chuck's expression when he realised Neil had no memory, and Neil's expression when Chuck changed his mind.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top