1.09: Tigh Me Up, Tigh Me Down

Dave

Non Bio
Staff member
Joined
Jan 5, 2001
Messages
23,257
Location
Way on Down South, London Town
1.09 Tigh Me Up, Tigh Me Down

-----------------------------
Creating topic, remember you
can only discuss this episode
inside this topic. Reviews of
the episode are encouraged
-----------------------------

Colonel Tigh is stunned when his wife miraculously turns up in the fleet, having escaped the Cylon attack and wishing to reconcile.
 
I'm not sure on the title of this episode. I think it got changed for some reason. Titles don't seem to appear in the programme credits and Sky One doesn't yet have an episode review up at the time I'm writing this.

It begins as Starbuck again catches Baltar busy with No.6 – this time with his flies undone. I’ve come around to agreeing with Rik_the_Riff though – that people just seem to think he is very odd character, but useful to them, so accepting of the oddness.

I was surprised that President Laura Roslin actually believed Adama could be a Cylon – although his behaviour was odd and suggested something unusual was going on – don’t they now trust each other enough to just ask for an explanation rather than sending out spies? As Adama said, if he was a Cylon, then they are “really screwed.†But by the end of this episode it seems that no one trusts anyone anymore.

I found it too convenient that Colonel Tigh finally decided to throw away his ever-filling bottle of Whiskey, just on the very same day that his Ambrosia (i.e. Crème de Menthe) swilling, tramp wife, Ellen turned up.

I found the set piece showdown in Baltar’s lab very funny.

The Cylon raiders ploy would still have worked, if it had had a bigger explosive aboard, but you see why Adama needs Tigh, even if he is an alcoholic.

Ellen Tigh tests negative as a Cylon, or does she? Now Baltar leaves the possibility that he may have lied. It’s is even more believable since he lied about Sharon and this time we don’t see the flashing green/red monitor to confirm it or deny it.

No more until Jan 3rd!!!
 
A great episode lots covered.

The paronia set in from last week comes to full effect. Roseyln going off her head trying to second guess whether Adama is a Cylon especially when she hears he has cancelled his test for Helens (Tigh`s wife) to start.

Baltar is such a star getting caught with his pants down was a right laugh, Baltar then says "Im doing my morning excersies"

Once Helen was onboard her character has you screaming "shes a Cylon" but as Adama says later "she had better be a Cylon or we are all in trouble" she is one loose cannon.

Cylon occupied Caprica again took another turn. It was revealed that the Cylon agents only experience true emotions when they live with and love humans. No6 showing her pain from her loss of connection with Baltar.

There is an underlying tone where this is plot is going and I think it will suprise many.

As Dave said the ending scene in the lab was terrific it turned into a right saga as everyone started pointing the finger etc.

But again Baltar does not say whether she was actually a Cylon, and I think if she were it would of been a little too convenient for the plot.

As for the Cylon raidder heading for a suicide run on the ship, I reckon that was over dramatised especially as the BattleStar G was built to withstand nukes (mini film and starting credits show this) so a small raidder surely would not of created too much damage, oh well teh point was need to bring Tigh and Adama back online.

Still great stuff, plenty of human stories going on etc cant wait for January!!


Ranger
 

Similar threads


Back
Top