Nicholas Seafort (David Feintuch)

ray gower

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2001
Messages
3,315
Nicholas Seafort

There can be few fictional characters more tortured than this chap, even in the most deranged and masochistic doodlings of Stephen King!

But after the umpteenth re-reading, I have finally got a handle on his world, but still none to sure I understand it!

As a start we have a service (the UNN).
To some extent it is understandable that they would force strong discipline aboard their ships. The ships have a small crew and they are consigned to spend years in a small confined space with little or nothing to do and no contact with others. But to take discipline back to levels that even the Royal Navy gave up 200 years ago?

The UNN is controlled by a set of strict but nominally christian religious ethics, therefore the world must also be controlled by similar extremism.
Forget the rather woolly world of the Catholic church (still the largest religion in the world), we are beyond them, or even the rather dour Presbyterians, certainly not the URC which the books quote. We are galloping down the open maw of fervent Welsh Methodism, where any outward sign of emotion will immediately consign you to eternal damnation! Appologies to any member of any religious order, no offence is intended in any way, but Welsh Chapel doctrine decrees you are condemned to eternal servitude and pergitude at birth!

From the books, Seafort is from Cardiff (not a traditional hot bed Methodist fervor, but close enough- it is on the map of Wales) and his father is most evidently a staunch Methodist. This at least I can understand and he does behave more or less as I would expect based on this.

Yet few, if any, of those he meets, Uppies or trannies, even remotely approach the same level of fervor. So how do they remain in control and why?
 
Nicolas Seafort was throughly miserable human being. I read the first 3 books and then I got sick to death of him.
 
Seafort was miserable because of his strict religious upbringing in Wales. I read the entire series and loved every bit of it. I rate Nicholas Seafort above Honor Harringtion even though both are Hornblower in space. It's such a shame Feintuch passed so early, I would have loved to see where he would have taken the Seafort Saga. There is a mythical unpublished novel, but that may be wishful thinking.
 
Seafort was miserable because of his strict religious upbringing in Wales. I read the entire series and loved every bit of it. I rate Nicholas Seafort above Honor Harringtion even though both are Hornblower in space. It's such a shame Feintuch passed so early, I would have loved to see where he would have taken the Seafort Saga. There is a mythical unpublished novel, but that may be wishful thinking.

His refusal to bend caused problems not only for him , but the people around him.

Yes David Feintuch was a very good writer. I just couldn't like Nicholas Seafort.
 
I remember reading and enjoying these back in the day. I don't remember Seafort being miserable, as such, but he did have a lot of guilt. Survivor guilt perhaps?
 
I remember reading and enjoying these back in the day. I don't remember Seafort being miserable, as such, but he did have a lot of guilt. Survivor guilt perhaps?
That was part of it, but he also felt he'd damned his soul for eternity for being false with a mutineer or terrorist if I recall. It didn't help that when he told his religious father about it he agreed that Nicholas was indeed damned for eternity.
 
That was part of it, but he also felt he'd damned his soul for eternity for being false with a mutineer or terrorist if I recall. It didn't help that when he told his religious father about it he agreed that Nicholas was indeed damned for eternity.

My memory is a big foggy bu I think it was that , he promised he wouldn't shoot them if they surrender but he said nothin about executing then via another method.
 
I read all of these, but they were a slog at best. Doing the right thing was never rewarded and often punished.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top