Into a Darkening Storm

Status
Not open for further replies.

socrates2479

Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
19
Hi All, this is my first post. I'm an amateur writer and have written the start of a lengthy piece. Any critique would be appreciated; although I have an idea of what I want to achieve I am not sure how I am doing.



Into a Darkening Storm

Chapter 1 - part1

It was dark. From the brief glimpses through the canopy overhead, Vicky saw the moon was a tiny sliver of white amongst the ebony blackness of the sky. The night was so dark not even the stars could be seen. It was the perfect night for someone trying not to be seen.

The black cloak she wore, hood pulled up to cover her face, blended her into the inkiness surrounding her. In the depths of her cowl, her eyes shone back silver, her adaptive eyesight compensating for the lack of light by dilating her pupils so that her hazel irises were only a thin band around the pupil. The only witnesses to her passage were the mighty trees of the forest, some of which were born before her people even set foot on these shores. A wind arose, moaning through the trees and ruffling her cloak, almost like the trees were disapproving of her ventures this night; she smiled to herself as she held onto her hood.

A long time ago her eldest brother, Guy, had told her trees were the souls of all the Raatians that had died in the Great Wars, and for a very long time she had always been frightened to do any wrong in sight of the them, afraid they may judge her. But she had lost all belief in that the day his body had been brought back from the front line. The giant figure that he had grown into lay still on the stretcher they had carried him on. At first she had thought he was merely sleeping, but the crying people told her something was very wrong. She remembered him lying there in his armour; his eyes, once so full of laughter, were forever closed and bound by a black scarf. The lips that had told her grand tales of heroes and their princesses and giant beasts were forever silent.

Ducking her head against the wind, and ignoring the trees’ accusations, she carried along the narrow path that wound its way through the trees. It was autumn now, and the trees had begun their shedding. All around her were the dead and decomposing leaves from the trees. The path she followed was kept clean of the leaves during the day, but in the dark some had fallen to lie like sentries in her path. She ignored these just like she had ignored the words of Scar earlier, but in the back of her mind she wondered if, in the end, all this trouble would be worth it.

After a while the path opened into a small clearing, and she carefully crept forward, mindful of the lack of cover. Not all people possessed her night-sight, but there was little need to take any risk. She hugged the tree line as she half-walked half-ran to the other side of the clearing where the path continued again. In the middle of the clearing were three small buildings that looked like holding pens, silent now as the beasts they held had been moved from this, their grazing ground, back the way she had came to the Heart.

There was very little noise beyond the chirping of insects and the occasional rustling of bushes as an animal wandered past. There were no predators in the forest, at least none that roamed wild. Almost all the animals had been domesticated long ago. She knew that she would not meet any people here on the ground, but she still felt uncomfortable. As she re-entered the shadows of the trees, her eyes wandered up to the canopy, now hidden from sight, but she imagined she could see families moving around the platforms high above, or walking across the rope bridges that rocked gently in the wind as they hurried home to loved ones.


It was strange for her being alone. Throughout her whole life she had been surrounded by people, mainly guards; she supposed they were for her protection, but with them in tow she was limited in what she could do or where she could go. Part of her knew that there was danger in being alone, especially since the war had intensified recently, but being cooped at home and protected more than usual had taken its toll, so she had decided to sneak away. The fact that she had not spoken to her parents for over a week meant that they were less likely to check on her, and for all they knew she was still in her room with the guards posted outside. All would be watching her door, making sure that no-one went in and that she did not leave. But then she had not used the door to escape her room.
 
Into a Darkening Storm

Chapter 1 - part1

It was 1dark. From the brief glimpses through the canopy overhead, Vicky saw the moon was a tiny sliver of white amongst the 2ebony 3blackness of the sky. The night was so 4dark 5not even the stars could be seen. It was the 6perfect night for someone trying not to be seen. I know that you are trying to set the scene of it being a dark night however you have told me this 6 times. Try condensing this: From the brief glimpses through the canopy overyhead, Vicky saw the moon as a tiny sliver of white. It was the perfect night for someone trying not to be seen.

The black cloak she wore, hood pulled up to cover her face, blended her into the inkiness (surrounding her) could remove this. In the depths of her cowl, her eyes shone (back) silver, her adaptive eyesight compensating for the lack of light by dilating her pupils so that her hazel irises were only a thin band (around the pupil.) The only witnesses to her passage were the mighty trees of the forest, some of which were bornare trees born? before her people (even) set foot on these shores. A wind arose, moaning through the trees and ruffling her cloak, almost like the trees were disapproving of her ventures this night(;). She smiled to herself as she held onto her hood.

A long time ago her eldest brother, Guy, had told her trees were the souls of all the Raatians that had died in the Great Wars, and for a very long time she had always been frightened to do any wrong in sight of the them, afraid they may judge her. But she had lost all belief in that the day his body had been brought back from the front line. The giant figure that he had grown into lay still on the stretcher they had carried him on. At first she had thought he was merely sleeping, but the crying people told her something was very wrong. She remembered him lying there in his armour; his eyes, once so full of laughter, (were) forever closed and bound by a black scarf. The lips that had told her grand tales of heroes and their princesses and giant beasts were forever silent.The use of the word 'had' slows down the reader. Try to remove some.

Ducking her head against the wind, and ignoring the trees’ accusations, she carried along the narrow path that wound its way through the trees. It was autumn (now), and the trees had begun their shedding. All around her were the dead and decomposing leaves from the trees. The path she followed was kept clean of the leaves during the day, but in the dark some had fallen to lie like sentries in her path I like this. She ignored these just like she had ignored the words of Scar earlier, but in the back of her mind she wondered if, in the end, all this trouble would be worth it.

After a while the path opened into a small clearing, and she carefully crept forward, mindful of the lack of cover. Not all people possessed her night-sight, but there was little need to take any risk. She hugged the tree line as she half-walked half-ran to the other side of the clearing where the path continued (again). In the middle of the clearing were three small buildings that looked like holding pens, silent now as the beasts they held had been moved from this, their grazing ground, back the way she had came to the Heart. Too much info for one sentence i think.

There was very little noise beyond the chirping of insects and the occasional rustling of bushes as an animal wandered past. There were no predators in the forest, at least none that roamed wild. Almost all the animals had been domesticated long ago. She knew that she would not meet any people here on the groundWhy?, but she still felt uncomfortable. As she re-entered the shadows of the trees, her eyes wandered up to the canopy, now hidden from sight, but she imagined she could see families moving around the platforms high above, or walking across the rope bridges that rocked gently in the wind as they hurried home to loved ones.


It was strange for her being alone. Throughout her whole life she had been surrounded by people, mainly guards; she supposed they were for her protection, but with them in tow she was limited in what she could do or where she could go. Part of her knew that there was danger in being alone, especially since the war had intensified recently, but being cooped at home and protected more than usual had taken its toll, so she had decided to sneak away. The fact that she had not spoken to her parents for over a week meant that they were less likely to check on her, and for all they knew she was still in her room with the guards posted outside. All would be watching her door, making sure that no-one went in and that she did not leave. But then she had not used the door to escape her room.

I like the way the story is headed. It seems to me that you are using too many words to describe events. Try to cut out words that tell us nothing new. And keep the reader in the present, watch the use of the word had.
Great work. Keep it comming. ;)
 
Thanks for the very useful comments.

Paragraph 1 - fair point - I tend to over-describe things, I think because I am writing the way I would like to read something - drilling in the idea (we get it! it's dark!!!)

P2 - It's hard to get a full idea with this short excerpt, but trees are born in their mythology

P3 - was thinking that not much happens in this scene, so interspersed it with a bit of background story/history, otherwise would be a boring journey.

Rest of points are also gratefully received. I have a little more of this, about 10 pages, but think it needs more work before I can post it.
 
I think some of the tips you've received may be an issue with my own work, I'll have to take a deep breath and post so I can find out!

What you've shared definitely makes me want to read more of it, so I think you are on to a good hook in the tale to start.

I would take a moment to consider what the time period is here, and the environment of the people/place. Vicky would not be an appropriate name, even as a shortened variant for Victoria, for less modern times.
 
Redhawk - I felt the same before I posted this piece. I'm always critical of my work, and i imagined that I would get slated - but sometimes that is exactly what you need. I didn't want to continue writing in the same fashion if there were problems inherent in my style. Best to change early before they become too set.

In terms of names - Makes me relate to the characters better if I imagine them as real, rather than some made up name like Thorgar or R'kilu''kll (apologies if you do indeed have those names :)). I'll use real names or something descriptive until I can think of something more suitable. And I think the name will remain Vicky (short for Victoria) for reasons I can't really go into.
 
In terms of names - Makes me relate to the characters better if I imagine them as real, rather than some made up name like Thorgar or R'kilu''kll (apologies if you do indeed have those names ). I'll use real names or something descriptive until I can think of something more suitable. And I think the name will remain Vicky (short for Victoria) for reasons I can't really go into.
I like this story quite a bit, however, I do agree with Redhawk on this one. You use the name "Raatians" for a group of people (or whatever), which is a name on would only find in SFF, but you name your character "Vicky." The two don't really mesh well.
 
socrates2479 said:
Hi All, this is my first post. I'm an amateur writer and have written the start of a lengthy piece. Any critique would be appreciated; although I have an idea of what I want to achieve I am not sure how I am doing.



Into a Darkening Storm

Chapter 1 - part1

It was dark. From the brief glimpses through the canopy overhead, Vicky saw the moon was a tiny sliver of white amongst the ebony blackness of the sky. The night was so dark not even the stars could be seen. It was the perfect night for someone trying not to be seen.
the only way the stars will disappear is cloud cover, which will reduce the moon to a blur rather than a sliver. Otherwise, the darker, the more stars.
The black cloak she wore, hood pulled up to cover her face, blended her into the inkiness surrounding her. In the depths of her cowl, her eyes shone back silver, her adaptive eyesight compensating for the lack of light by dilating her pupils so that her hazel irises were only a thin band around the pupil. The only witnesses to her passage were the mighty trees of the forest, some of which were born
sprouted; but possibly "were old", giving even more time
before her people even set foot on these shores. A wind arose, moaning through the trees and ruffling her cloak, almost like the trees were disapproving of her ventures this night; she smiled to herself as she held onto her hood.
A long time ago her eldest brother, Guy, had told her trees were the souls of all the Raatians that had died in the Great Wars, and for a very long time she had always been frightened to do any wrong in sight of the them, afraid they may
might
judge her. But she had lost all belief in that the day his body had been brought back from the front line. The giant figure that he had grown into lay still on the stretcher they had carried him on. At first she had thought he was merely sleeping, but the crying people told her something was very wrong. She remembered him lying there in his armour; his eyes, once so full of laughter, were forever closed and bound by a black scarf. The lips that had told her grand tales of heroes and their princesses and giant beasts were forever silent.
Ducking her head against the wind, and ignoring the trees’ accusations, she carried along the narrow path that wound its way through the trees. It was autumn now, and the trees had begun their shedding. All around her were the dead and decomposing leaves from the trees.
repetition of "trees"; there must be some acceptable synonym
The path she followed was kept clean of the leaves during the day, but in the dark some had fallen to lie like sentries in her path. She ignored these just like she had ignored the words of Scar earlier, but in the back of her mind she wondered if, in the end, all this trouble would be worth it.
After a while the path opened into a small clearing, and she carefully crept forward, mindful of the lack of cover. Not all people possessed her night-sight, but there was little need to take any risk. She hugged the tree line as she half-walked half-ran to the other side of the clearing where the path continued again. In the middle of the clearing were three small buildings that looked like holding pens, silent now as the beasts they held had been moved from this, their grazing ground, back the way she had came to the Heart.
"looked like"; but they were holding pens, according to the end of your (somewhat extended) sentence. And are "pens" really classifiable as "buildings"?
There was very little noise beyond the chirping of insects and the occasional rustling of bushes as an animal wandered past. There were no predators in the forest, at least none that roamed wild.
meaning they kept tame predators (oh, cats, but that's not the image the word gives) Or the predators were human?
Almost all the animals had been domesticated long ago. She knew that she would not meet any people here on the ground, but she still felt uncomfortable. As she re-entered the shadows of the trees, her eyes wandered up to the canopy, now hidden from sight, but she imagined she could see families moving around the
moving around the platforms (on the surrounding branches) or moving around on the platforms?
platforms high above, or walking across the rope bridges that rocked gently in the wind as they hurried home to loved ones.
It was strange for her
comma
being alone. Throughout her whole life she had been surrounded by people, mainly guards; she supposed they were for her protection, but with them in tow she was limited in what she could do or
and
where she could go. Part of her knew that there was danger in being alone, especially since the war had intensified recently, but being cooped at home and protected more than usual had taken its toll, so she had decided to sneak away. The fact that she had not spoken to her parents for over a week meant that they were less likely to check on her, and for all they knew she was still in her room with the guards posted outside. All would be watching her door, making sure that no-one went in and that she did not leave. But then she had not used the door to escape her room.
 
Azathoth - glad you like it. It is a SF/Fantasy story, but there is a lot of back history to the story, which is too much to go into here. However, I take your point about the names. For the moment I think I will leave it as is - I have kind of gotten used to her by that name.
 
chrispenycate - thanks for the detailed comments, very helpful.

meaning they kept tame predators (oh, cats, but that's not the image the word gives) Or the predators were human? ---- they are not cats, nor are they humans, it's revealed a bit later in the story

moving around the platforms (on the surrounding branches) or moving around on the platforms? ---- what do you mean here? It says they are moving on the platforms ...


 
The way this reads, it implies that the families are moving the platforms physically:)
 
OK - so if I change to :
but she imagined she could see families moving around on the platforms high above

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top