Darkweaver or Imperial

[Threddy]

I was just wondering who prefers the Darkweaver Legace and who prefers the Imperial Series and why.
I'll start, I prefer the Darkweaver Legacy, because I like all the characters as they are cool.

 

[Joel007]

While i do enjoy the Darkweaver Legacy, Mark's writing and storytelling has improved so much in the Imperial series that I've just got to vote for them

 

[Threddy]

I do agree with you on that, but it was the Darkweaver Legacy that has inspired me to write a book of my own and it will be one that I enjoy and it will always inspire me.

 

[Joel007]

The main downside on Darkweaver I've heard is that Calvyn's character is too "shiny". He doesn't make mistakes or appear to have much of a dark side, except in the 2nd book
I didn't really mind it, as it is aimed at YA after all, the character feels real enough, and given his responsibilities and trials its nice to see him rewarded, as he's such a nice guy.

 

[Threddy]

Yes, do you know if he(Calvyn) is going to get another series, I know he makes an appearance in Imperial Spy as Lord Shanier, but thats not quite the same.

 

[Joel007]

This is projecting ahead a way... I have plans to write Derrigan Darkweaver's story in a trilogy that will tell of his rise to power, his forging of the amulet and his eventual downfall. I also eventually intend to write a further trilogy about Calvyn and company set 3 years after the events of the Darkweaver Legacy. I have a lot of writing to do before that, though!

As far as i know these plans still stand

 

[Threddy]

Yay!!!!

 

[Mark Robson]

Interesting poll. I had better abstain, of course, but I shall be intrigued to see which is the more popular series.

 

[Red_Dragon]

Darkweaver of course. nothing can beat the different types of magic in it. and also the fights.

 

[Joel007]

I was quite impressed with the surreptitious magic in Assassin, and the way it bewildered everyone who wasn't looking too closely. Getting too used to it in Darkweaver just set me up to be surprised that no one looking for the guild had thought of it.
The fights in Assassin are great, a good mix of styles and scenarios, and some amusing lucky moments.
My favorite is still Bek v Serrius though.

 

[Derkas]

Darkweaver was just to happy, its like "oh no the world could end, lets just go and train a bit YAY" but still really good

 

[Red Phoenix]

Short and Sweet Answer - well not necessarily sweet but:

The Imperial Series get the gold sorry to all those who lost out. It seems more realistic and colder so much more evilerest. - whoops... huge typo im going to do NOTHING about.
The imperial Series was - and of course - still is more realistic and the better read; however, the Darkweaver series sets the scene for the Imperial series and still is a must read.

Construtive Criticism - I know what im talking about...?

- One critical point i have on both books is that you take to log to write them

(note: Keep up the great work)

 

[Joel007]

Taking longer to write a book means you get a better book
well, not always, but you get the idea.
Imperial in the lead by 1 vote!

 

[Atra]

It'll always be Darkweaver for me, mostly for the good memories of constantly bugging and tracking Mark during the time I got them... plus, they really stick in your head - it's been a while since I last read them, but I can always remember the scene of 'freezing' time.

 

[5e4n]

I think they are both very good in there own way!

-Darkweaver for the magic and battles.
-Imperial for it's suspense and mystery

I'm very glad to hear that Mr Robson will be writing more about Calvyn but I also can't wait for Imperial Traitor you left so much unfinished in Imperial Assasin.

 

[billyboy]

i would say cant decide bcz i onli read one of the imperial trilogy so far and all the darkweaver

 

[Threddy]

That is a very good point, we don't know what will happenin the third Imperial book. It sounds good, i read the blurb on amazon.

 

[IMPERIAL.??????]

HELLO PEOPLE OF THE WORLD..........
ooo its 6 all betwen imperial and darkweaver oooooooooo