Lacedaemonian - Yi'Lian Heights/ Traporian

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lacedaemonian

A Plume of Smoke
Joined
May 10, 2004
Messages
3,146
Location
The Road
This critique contains adult language and expletives.

Just a scrappy piece I strung together. I enjoy the potential angle this short dialogue adds to my overall story. It reconfirms the nature of the magical Yi and once again builds on the relationship between the two central characters. They are chatting before facing an unknown enemy, which has been tracking them through the woodlands.

Please be as critical as you want, and I thank those that take the time to read this.


“Rumour tells of a wind that battered the Yi’Lian Heights for seven seasons straight. Not a hurricane. A mad, howling, ghoul whispering gale. Cimprid described it in her journals as ‘Voca a fa entre’ – The voices at the door. Those who saw the eighth season, and whose brains were not completely addled or had only half chewed the tongues from their heads named it simply ‘Karam’o’ which loosely translates as…. . not sure how to describe it – God’s Revenge?”

“Revenge for what?”

“Settling on the Heights. The sacred ground of the Yi.”

“But the Yi have not been among us for several millennia.”

“Aye it is so. But their blood still courses through many a vein, elfin and clan both.”

“So they say”.

“I hears the scepticism in your voice but I knows you knows it must be true. Does the think that it was chance that we were gifted with invincible life?”

“We are not invincible Emerald. When have you been grievously injured?”

“I aint never. Not even been cut deep enough to be called anything other than a scratch by you fighting folk. Sees what I mean? I canst even be injured.”

“What if I were to drive this sword through your guts?”

“Why not tries it Danae? A pale of silver says you canst. I am protected by the Yi.”

“You do realise that if I was a greedy man you would be staring at a hole in your guts now?”

“Ah so true, I bless the Yi for making you such a selfless creature, Danae.”

“The Yi? I will die one day Emerald and then you shall know clear as dew that you wagered and lost and that the forest witch was nothing but a foolsayer.”

“I shall hold you to that.”

“Aye no doubting you will. Just stand behind me and play me something old.”

“An Elfin dirge for the Fallen.”

“Seems appropriate.”

“Assuming that the Yi ever fell.”

“C**t!”

Danae lifted up the crooked make shift staff and braced himself, testing the weight of it in his hands. ‘might win myself that wager today, Emerald. This is the poorest weapon I have ever had to wrought war with.’

“Then take one of their weapons.”

“You know I cant.”

“F**k clan law, Danae.”

“No I mean I can’t.”

It came then crashing through the trees, a huge Traporian.

“I aint never seen one that big, Danae.”

“Nah?”

“The Yi protect us.”

“F**k the Yi!”

………….

‘F**k the Yi indeed. Danae stove the Traporians head in with his mailed fist after his staff broke across the beast’s ankle. I tolds Danae after that it was only a young Traporian and that the adult Traporians in the northern reaches were twice as big. The truths was in all the books I read and all the tales I had heard – never been a Traporian so big. Never. ’
 
Mate, I told you I would read these tonight, but I am drunk and feel I would do them a disservice :( I will definitely give them proper attention asap, though. The titles remind me of Erikson (which is a good thing).

PS - see you on the PES.
 
Okaaaaaaaay. I've sobered up a bit, so here we go (didn't take that long, really. Brett was sending me links to 90s pop classics on youtube, and I forgot to keep drinking).

On the whole, this bit is interesting,. I sense the same style carrying over from the last thing I read. It's definitely quirky and the dialogue seems pretty good, though could probably do with a grammatical polish here and there. I'm sure that some people will have a problem with the expletives, but I'm fine with it (because it fits the tone of the other stuff I've read).

Ok, the nitty gritty.



“Rumour tells of a wind that battered the Yi’Lian Heights for seven seasons straight. Not a hurricane. A mad, howling, ghoul whispering gale. Cimprid described it in her journals as ‘Voca a fa entre’ – The voices at the door. Those who saw the eighth season, and whose brains were not completely addled or had only half chewed the tongues from their heads named it simply ‘Karam’o’...

This bit feels like narrative to me. It's a good lead into the piece, but I don't think it feels very realistic as dialogue. Is this scene told from Emerald's POV? It suits a narrative voice, but not Emerald's actual way of speaking. EDIT - looking back over the order of dialogue, I think this is Danae. Is that right? It's a bit confusing.

“But the Yi have not been among us for several millennia.”
Ok, around about here I think you need to put in a bit of that stage direction. Only a bit, though - just enough to break up the flow of dialogue a bit. The odd "... he said, wiping the snot from his lip with the back of his hand." etc.

“You do realise that if I was a greedy man you would be staring at a hole in your guts now?”
Generally your dialogue flows well, but this line seems to jar a bit with the structure. You will probably sort that out with the next re-write, though.

“The Yi? I will die one day Emerald and then you shall know clear as dew that you wagered and lost and that the forest witch was nothing but a foolsayer.”
Again, this feels a little mis-structured, but I remember the witch from your last post, and you have grabbed my interest with her :)

“Aye no doubting you will. Just stand behind me and play me something old.”
I really like this line.

‘might win myself that wager today, Emerald. This is the poorest weapon I have ever had to wrought war with.’
I'm a bit confused about what the wager was. At first, I thought it was do with whether or not Danae could get a hit on Emerald, but after a quick re-glance, is it something to do with the witch that we don't know about?

“F**k clan law, Danae.”
Cool. Bit of mystery - makes me wonder what the clan laws are all about.

“F**k the Yi!”
Excellent :) Blunt, but realistic.

The idea of the Yi intrigues me. I'm thinking it's something like the Force but I will wait to learn more of it. Generally, this stuff is good - it flows fast and is pretty well contained. I think it could do with the odd extra bit of description, but not too much. Just the odd "he said," and a bit of stage direction, etc. Just to break up the dialogue and remind us who is speaking, and what he's doing at the time. There is little (no) description of the characters, but that doesn't really bother me. I have a picture of both characters from earlier scenes.
 
I'm with Green here on this. Add a few 'he said as he squashed a bug in his hands' types of things so that the reader can follow who is speaking. I also agree that the first paragraph doesn't fit the dialogue in style. If you want to leave it that way you can use one of those tricks like 'I heard the old witch chant this tale over a fire and a pint' kind of thing where we know it is being recited from someone else, word for word.

I've not read many your other pieces but this makes me want to do so.
 
I like it better without the "said as he..." stuff. It is really hard to pull that off right and I think you did it well, as in many of your other stuff. Are all these connected? And for some reason, the last line..F the Yi....made me giggle for some reason....
 
Thanks for reading my extract and posting people. Always a great help! And the line 'F*** the Yi!' was delightful. It made my day when I wrote it. It means so much more than you lot can imagine at this point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top