A Wrinkle in Time, I'm Clueless

Tree94

New Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Messages
4
I am taking a Children's Lit class. I have tried to do research as to why fantasy books have been banned. I have only found that people don't like challanges to anything. Please help me do any of you know why books like this have been banned. According to my Lit Teacher there are many fantasy and science fiction books that have been challanged. Thanks for your time!

To be honest I don't read much sci-fi and Fantasy but I really think I'll have to give them a try after this.
 
Last edited:
There are different reasons why fantasy books get banned, but with YA it is chiefly due to some distorted idea that they promote some sort of occult agenda, or at least an anti-Christian one. This has happened with the Harry Potter series, with the Oz books by Baum, Alan Garner's books... the list goes on.

SF books that have been challenged are frequently because they question things, or because they're viewed as "inappropriate". So, in a sense you are quite right... they don't like challenges, they don't like things that expect the audience to actually think or examine things.
 
I once read a magazine interview with Madeleine L'Engle (author of "A Wrinkle in Time") and she gave her thoughts on why her book had been banned. If I remember correctly, some groups didn't like it because it contained Christian references. For instance, she quotes from the Bible at least once. Some Christians didn't like it because Mrs. Which actually looks like a stereotypical halloween witch, but is a wise, good woman. There is also a reference where Jesus is named among other major religious leaders, but this upset some Christians because they wanted to see Jesus' name elevated above the others. The author identifies herself as Christian, so she was quite troubled by other people's perceptions of her book.
 
Most people that I have talked too that have objections to books use the argument that they go against christian beliefs or the promote majic and that is devil worship. Rear of the unknown or of differing ideas is a big reason
 
books like "a wrinkle in time" are probably a good litmus test for a culture.

banning books of this type = failure to meet the basic moral and decency requirements of civilisation.

therefore probably a bad idea to live in such a region, unless you are orthodox.
 
I am convinced that at some point in time, most likely many, many millenniums ago, magic was your everyday thing, and nobody fretted about or gave it a second thought. I also believe that the same as many species have evolved from big beings into much smaller ones, so it did with the nowadays called ‘magic. To cut a long story short, as time went by, fewer and fewer people were able to display those abilities. You don’t have to be a brain surgeon or a nuclear physicist to come up with the immediate result, good old envy and fear went wild. The end result is that hiding behind high moral values, religious beliefs and political sleaze your everyday mediocre and rather dumb John and Mary Doe, were easily led by their noses into reacting to extents beyond belief against anything and everything that was not what the status quo had already come up with. And so we come to today, where the only ‘magic’ left is that of believing that once upon a time, long ago and far away there was a magical place where magic was an everyday thing.

But the most noticeable detail is that the great majority of the banned fantasy books are for children. Funny no? On one hand is OK to let them watch program after program of extremely violent, unpleasant or downright diminishing TV programs. It is also OK to let them have video games where the only purpose of the game is to kill and destroy. And whilst we are at it, lets not forget the all time favourite, lets prove them beyond any reasonable doubt that the best way to keep peace is through war. So I suppose that these could be the some of the reasons why all those books were banned, after all we don’t want anything interfering with the children’s perfect brain wash, imagine what could happen if they grow up without it? They might start believing in magic or worst still they might start recovering that long ago lost sense. Yes, I know the though is really frightening, don’t you think?
 
Do you have any recomended Fantasy books for a person who has only read one?
 
I undertsand that some Christians had a fit over C. S. Lewis' work too. I'm not surprised.

Tree94, are you looking specifically for children's fantasy? Have you tried any of the Narnia books by C. S. Lewis?

If not, I believe there is a board around here somewhere for book recommendations, but . . . let's see now . . .

The First and Second Chronicles of Thomas Covenant the Unbeliever by Stephen R. Donaldson (The One Tree, book two of the Second, is so far my all time favorite fantasy novel)

The Sword of Truth by Terry Goodkind

The Swords of Night and Day by David Gemmel

Mortal Suns by Tanith Lee

A Man of His Word and A Handful of Men by Dave Duncan (all eight of these books are tied for second place on my favs list)

The Cursed by Dave Duncan

And, of course, let's not forget The Hidden Stars by Madeline Howard! (It's a *really* good book - hint, hint) :)
 
Last edited:
I didn't really think about the Narnia books as fantasy. I guess counting thoses I'v read 4 fantasy books.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top