The Revived Tolkien Trivia

I am! A bell with teeth-marks on it for you.

Bonus question: guess how many hundreds of YouTube videos are devoted to the subject of the "nameless things".
 
Even Sauron knows them not. They are older than he."

I never understood how that could be. It doesn't fit in with the whole creation story, although it does have a wonderful imagery to it.

Edit (add)
Bonus question: guess how many hundreds of YouTube videos are devoted to the subject of the "nameless things".

So I'm not alone
 
I've always wondered if JRRT had been reading HPL the night before...

Who donned masks to scare their opponents during battles, which were also useful in another way against certain enemies?
 
Oh, sorry. I'd like one, but if people haven't the books to hand I'll accept a rough idea of the context.
 
I knew this off the top of my head, but it took a while to track it down. The answer is Dwarves.

"For the Naugrim withstood fire more hardily than Elves or Men, and it was their custom moreover to wear great masks in battle hideous to look upon; and those stood them in good stead against the dragons." (Silmarillion ch20: Of the Fifth Battle)
 
Who gave voice-activated jewellery, and to whom?

(No quote needed but I want giver and recipient, what the jewellery was and how it worked.)
 
Not an answer, but re the age of the things under Moria and Treebeard being the oldest living thing under the sun -

My assumption is that Gandalf only counts the age of Maia on Middle Earth from when they incarnated there. Or at least, that's the most rational response I can think of.
 
Is this the phial of Galadriel, activated by "Gilthoniel A Elbereth" etc in Shelob's Lair (or actually the chapter after that.
 
Is this the phial of Galadriel, activated by "Gilthoniel A Elbereth" etc in Shelob's Lair (or actually the chapter after that.
It's a good guess, and I would have given it except it doesn't quite fit the criteria. The phial doesn't respond directly or immediately to Sam's voice, but a few lines later, "as if his indomitable spirit had set its potency in motion".

I will say the gift was given to a Hobbit, but a lot earlier.
 
No ideas?

The gift was a pair of things, and the voice-activation related to them being together or not.
 
This took some dredging up!

Bilbo is meeting Gandalf for the very first time (to speak to), and it's only when he's told the name of his visitor does he recollect anything about him.
“Gandalf, Gandalf! Good gracious me! Not the wandering wizard that gave Old Took a pair of magic diamond studs that fastened themselves and never came undone till ordered?
Hobbit, Ch1, An Unexpected Party.
 
Hmmm..

Why might a member of the Aztec pantheon feel an affinity to one of the Powers of Arda?

A reference and a separate quote, please.
 
Been gone for a couple weeks.... as for the nameless things under the mountains, I think that this is a bit of Tolkien having Frodo write like Bilbo. Bilbo is much more of a poet than Frodo and he revels in the wonder of Middle-earth and promotes is inscrutability to the hobbits. There are only a few moments of The Lord of the Rings when a hobbit is not present. The story is told from their perspective... and I assume that comments about older things than Sauron are Gandalf's way of saying, "This is dangerous and beyond your understanding. I love you, but it would be best if hobbits hold this as a terrifying superstition and never pursue it." I find this out of character for Frodo's writing. He was not trying to write a fairy tale or a fantastic adventure for young hobbits. Frodo's purpose was to set down as true an account as he could. Considering the dangers of the Old Forest, the Dead Marshes, Dunland, Mordor, and knowing the terrors of the Barrow Downs, Dol Guldur, Minas Ithil, and Barad-dur, I find it peculiar how Gandalf does not open up about the nameless creatures. But then I also know that Tolkien did not want to fully explain everything. The man loved enigmas.... in order to keep that sense of wonder and mystery.

Anyway... I know nothing about the Aztec pantheon. I suppose the jobs (areas of expertise) of the Valar are fairly applicable to all pantheons. I suppose that one of them had the exact name as one of the Valar. That's not a guess, just thinking.
 
Clue?

You could almost say it was a matter of conscience...
 

Similar threads


Back
Top