Mining v Giant Cuttlefish

Rosemary

The Wicked Sword Maiden
Joined
Jun 14, 2005
Messages
3,447
Science & Nature | The Australian, Weekend Australian, newspaper, Australia | The Australian


Port development could scuttle giant cuttlefish - by Andrew Faulkner

A vulnerable and genetically distinct population of giant cuttlefish stands in the way of the mining industry's bid for a deep-sea port in South Australia's Spencer Gulf.

The shallows off Port Bonython, 25km northeast of the steel city of Whyalla, are the world's largest breeding ground for the giant Australian cuttlefish, which, at up to 1.5m long, are the largest of their kind.


But the mining industry is eyeing this spot for a deep-sea port to take its billions of dollars of uranium, copper, gold and other minerals to the world. The state Government has shown its hand by buying land for "future developments" at the site, putting mining wealth and conservation on a collision course in this narrow stretch of water 220km north of Adelaide. Marine biologists, fishers and environment groups are gravely concerned for the cuttlefish's future if Port Bonython is expanded.


The expansion and associated dredging could kill off the cuttlefish, which, according to Adelaide University marine biologist Bronwyn Gillanders, is a species all of its own.


After being nearly fished out 10years ago, a moratorium has allowed stocks to recover - but the cuttlefish faces an uncertain future as it breeds only once in its one-to-two-year lifetime, so any change in its environment could be fatal.


I would have thought that with the vast amount of coastline Australia has, there would be no need to build in this particular area. Also our mining industry more often than not, gets the final say in the matter.
 
Tricky one this. They need to really think about the benefits that will come with mining the minerals against the welfare and the lives of the cuttlefish. But as you say Rosie, Australia has got a vast coastline but maybe not the minerals that are around. They could relocate the cuttlefish but that would cost millions of pounds.
 
I'm not sure how successful relocation would be, though hopefully it's at least tried if these developments go ahead. The cuttlefish is a suprisingly intelligent animal so whether they would accept an alternative breeding ground is anyones guess.

The ex-fisherman raises a good point towards the end of the article in that on top of the port, dredging and possible desalination plant there will also be the ongoing hazard of marine life like algae, starfish etc being brought in on the hulls of ships and taking over the local ecology.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top