Casting the Scar

[polymorphikos]

Inspired by the GRR Martin one, because I can actually remember this book and it seems as though, properly-approached, the only hurdle to accurately realising it would be money and three hours of screen time. Namely, who would you cast for a film of The Scar.

I reckon on Kate Ashfield from Shaun of the Dead as Bellis Coldwine.

 

[rune]

This thread is such a puzzlier we're all stumped as to who to put forward


Well I've had a think I feel Ralph Fiennes would take a good Uthor Doul. He is a very good actor, takes a sinster part well too and I can imagine he could pull off some of the strangeness of this character

 

[Rane Longfox]

I have difficulty in imagining any actor pulling off most of the characters in The Scar particularly well... though the guy who did Gimli in the LotR films might dop good as the cactus bloke. As the voice, I mean... I'm not too good on names either

 

[vurtperson]

I'm picturing Cate Blanchett as Bellis while reading the book. But she's described as having dark hair so she probably wouldn't be right for the role.
Someone really scary should play Uther Doul. Ralph Fiennes who was mentioned would probably be better as Silas. He could also play the Lover with Rachel Weisz playing his wife.

 

[Totem Hokum]

I reckon Claudia Black would be perfect for Bellis.

 

[ravenus]

Bob Hoskins was who I had in mind for the Tanner Sack character, although he might be rather old for this now. Yeah, Ralph Fiennes for the male Lover. Malcolm MacDowell for Johannes Tearfly. And Viggo Mortensen for Doul, it'd make a nicely different knight character for him

 

[ravenus]

I'm picturing Cate Blanchett as Bellis while reading the book. But she's described as having dark hair so she probably wouldn't be right for the role.

Um...you haven't heard of hair dye? And I would not call dark hair as the defining element of a character. Morgan Freeman's character from Shawshank Redemption was originally an Irishman called Red for his red hair.

 

[speedingslug]

Halle Berry for Bellis
Edward Norton as Doul ?

 

[kaelcarp]

China himself gave a cast list for this in an interview at Del Rey.

It was:
Bellis: Carrie-Anne Moss
Tanner Sack: Sean Bean
Uther Doul: Russell Crowe
Silas: Ralph Fiennes
The Lovers: Timothy Dalton and Angelica Houston
Brucolac: Laurence Fishburne
Tearfly: Malcolm McDowell

Others (unspecified) would be played by Fairuza Balk, Don Cheadle, and Demitri Goritsas.

This is old, so I wonder if he'd still cast it that way today.

 

[Hedrigall]

China himself gave a cast list for this in an interview at Del Rey.

It was:
Bellis: Carrie-Anne Moss
Tanner Sack: Sean Bean
Uther Doul: Russell Crowe
Silas: Ralph Fiennes
The Lovers: Timothy Dalton and Angelica Houston
Brucolac: Laurence Fishburne
Tearfly: Malcolm McDowell

Others (unspecified) would be played by Fairuza Balk, Don Cheadle, and Demitri Goritsas.

This is old, so I wonder if he'd still cast it that way today.

Ooh, did he do the same for Perdido Street Station?

 

[speedingslug]

Uther Doul: Russell Crowe?

Nah.

 

[kaelcarp]

Ooh, did he do the same for Perdido Street Station?

Not that I know of, but I seem to recall reading Laurence Fishburne (again) as Isaac. Don't know if that was Mieville's idea.

I actually read the cast list before reading the book, which may or may not have been a good idea because I actually pictured all those people in their roles.

 

[tori_bingham]

Laurence Fishbourne as Isaac? NEVER!

 

[jojajihisc]

I think the Scar would be a good candidate for an R-rated animated feature. But if it were to be made into a live action movie here are some I think might fit.

Uther Doul - Ian McShane
Bellis - Tilda Swinton
Tanner Sack - Timothy Olyphant
Brucolac - Michael Wincott

 

[Dagny]

i would be in absolute heaven if they made a movie out of this book. so long as Keanu Reeves and Angelina Jolie are kept FAR AWAY.