Titles, I suppose, are a very subjective thing. Every author wants a title that grabs the reader. How the grab is achieved is the thing. Some are lyrical, some evocative, some punchy, but a good title must pique the interest of the reader.
I agree, the hackneyed and cliched will turn me off.
The real difficulty is summing up a book of hundreds of pages in two or three words. The series get to cheat a little, as they can use two titles:
A Game of Thrones, Book 1 of
A SONG OF ICE AND FIRE, or
The Ships of Merior, Book 2 of
THE WARS OF LIGHT AND SHADOW.
Steven Erikson I think has great titles, because they all finish with "
A Tale of the Malazan Book of the Fallen". The series name just evokes death, honour, deceit, betrayal, loyalty... it is really wonderful.
I think that balanced titles work well, such as
The Object of A Place (The Ships of Merior) or A thing of Something Else (A Game of Thrones) or
A Person of Something (The Lord of the Rings) Speaking the words aloud gives you the idea. The title has a cadence, or even a lilt.
I have always thought that
The Dragonbone Chair was a great title.
Titles are perhaps some of the most difficult things to come up with. However, some authors know their titles in advance of writing the book (probably because they have planned out what they intend to write). Janny Wurts, for example, has the next two books of
The Wars of Light and Shadow already named, and she is only part way through the first of those. She also names the story arcs in the series (e.g.
Initiate's Trial, Book 1 of
Sword of the Canon, (book 9 of
The Wars of Light and Shadow)), which, if the publisher is not on the ball, can cause confusion. GRRM knew the title of
A Dance With Dragons a couple of years ago, and it is set to be released this fall (AS IF!
).
For me, titles are the hardest things to create. I have only written one semi-fictional piece, and coming up with a title was the hardest part, and I mean that literally. I eventually submitted myself to a committee to name the darn thing (and I am still unsatisfied).