Malessar's Curse - yes, it's another lump...

Status
Not open for further replies.

chopper

Steven Poore - Epic Fantasist & SFSF Socialist
Joined
Feb 4, 2005
Messages
2,269
Location
Sheffield, SoYo
Ey up peeps

i'm struggling somewhat with a chapter near the front of the book - i'm wanting to lead readers to think one thing while something else is actually happening, and also to introduce a part of the main plot, without info-dumping. just let me know what you reckon to this bit.

Rashenbaum had begun to describe his journey up from the plains of Hallea to Hetch. “Of course, much of the land is cultivated now, with the Empire having been at peace for so long. Hallea must feed its own, you see, and there are vast tracts of wheat and corn, stretching away from the road for as far as the eye can see. It can be very boring when there is nothing but fields from one day to the next, as I’m sure your brother might agree if he was here. It is quite unfortunate from my point of view - so much has been disturbed and ploughed over, lost to posterity.”

Hetch frowned. “Do you mean things like old battlefields, sir?”

Rashenbaum nodded. “Yes, and abandoned farms and villages that stood in the way of progress, their populations dispersed for miles around. You might see some old shrines dotted across the landscape, but they have mostly been plundered and left to ruin. You would be surprised at how relatively undisturbed such monuments are in this region, where the Empire’s influence is not so old.”

“There are many shrines to Pyraete,” Meredith observed slowly. It was the first time he had spoken, and even Attis raised his head a little to regard him. “I have not seen their like before.”

“The Emperor commands our respect, naturally,” Rann Almoul pointed out evenly, meeting Meredith’s gaze as if daring him to disagree. The irony, Cassia thought, was that Rann bore no love at all for the Empire in that it seemed to exist only to interfere with his business. Even Vescar’s high position in the Factor’s legion had been a move calculated to make some form of profit. But Rann could never come out and voice his opinions in the open - however much he might dislike it, the fact remained that the Empire could still crush him without a thought.

“Oh, naturally,” Rashenbaum agreed. “I’m sure that Meredith never meant to suggest otherwise. He meant only that you still retain a strong sense of your own worth and identity as true men of the north. And, as such, that the good people of Keskor are closely connected to their past.”

The table was quiet for a moment. Rann seemed deep in thought, weighing the historian’s words with care. There were deep currents here, Cassia realised, and she knew that she was already out of her depth.

“Our ancestors and our past are important to us,” Rann allowed at last, gesturing toward the carved wooden rail that ran, chest high, along the length of the walls of his house. “That tells the story of Pyraete’s realm: of the first men to scale His great mountains; the kingdoms that rose and fell under His gaze. Emperors will come and go, sir, but the mountains will remain, and our hearts with them.”

Cassia blinked, the bowl of fruit now completely forgotten. She had never heard Rann say anything so incendiary before, even in private - in public, it would have been enough to see him stripped of all his property and set to work in the mines. Hetch and Tarves looked as shocked as she thought she did herself; indeed, Tarves’ ruddy complexion had paled alarmingly.

The historian appeared not to have noticed. He nodded as though he had expected such a reply, wiping his bowl with a crust of bread. “Yes, an exquisite piece of work, that rail,” he commented. “Very rare to see one so complete. There are drawings, of course, in Kalakhadze, but they hardly compare to the real thing.”

He looked up and around the table, and a tone of amusement entered his voice. “Breathe, gentlemen, please! I have no intention of outing your ambitions to the Factor. That would do nobody any good at all, not least myself.”

Rann leaned forward, his gaze locked upon the historian. “Then what is it that you want?”

Clearly he was done with dancing around the subject of tonight’s dinner. Cassia bit her lip nervously as a stray thought crossed her mind: had Rann forgotten that she and her father were still here? Why on earth would he want any witnesses to such a conversation, least of all a storyteller notorious for his lack of tact?

What kind of danger are we in?

Belatedly she realised that both Meredith and Tarves had come to the table under arms: each man had a long knife sheathed at his side, and Cassia did not doubt that they were prepared to use them. She suppressed the urge to flee from the yard with a cold shiver, hoping that her father had already reached the same conclusions.

“I want the same thing that you do, sir,” Rashenbaum said quietly. “I want to return these lands to their former glories - to free them from the Imperial yoke. For now Keskor is no more than a provincial town, always sending taxes and tributes to Hellea, while you give your sons to the legions and receive nothing in return. You know as well as I that it was not always so.”

“And what makes you believe that this can be changed?” Rann asked bluntly. “What can a mere scholar achieve that the rest of us may not?”
 
I like it, for the most part. It doesn't seem too much like info-dumping to me, more like a heated conversation that borders on possible violence.

I do have some issues, though:

They're at a table eating a supper of some sort, yes? Are they indoors or outside? Is this made clear before-hand? If not, I found myself thinking they were outside regarding the landscape at first and then suddenly they were at a table in a dining room of sorts.

On that note, if you want to spice up the interaction some more, make it more obvious that they are eating or at least doing something other than delivering their lines; the one line where he scrapes the bowl with a bit of bread is neat, but seems awfully lonely.

Rashenbaum nodded. “Yes, and abandoned farms and villages that stood in the way of progress, their populations dispersed for miles around. You might see some old shrines dotted across the landscape, but they have mostly been plundered and left to ruin. You would be surprised at how relatively undisturbed such monuments are in this region, where the Empire’s influence is not so old.”

Contradictory statements unless you happened to leave out some detail about region specific shrines or similar.

What kind of danger are we in?

Present-tense in a past-tense entry.

===

Well that's my two cents, but other than those snippets, I like it, and continue to desire seeing more of this story.
 
Also, now that the critiquing is out of the way, on to the idea of the scene :

MY take on this is that this particular group of characters is talking about what the Empire has done to the Northlands. Now these people are obviously very proud and stubborn (also steeped in history, historical battlefield seem to be very important) and it's probably well-known that they do not enjoy this oppression they are being forced into. So you have a group of people who seem to have the same goals - liberation of the northland - while at the same time they don't trust each other any further than any one of them could throw a pack mule. Obviously one of them has some sort of scheme, most likely complex and extremely cunning, with which he plans on destroying the Empire's power in the north. Aside from that, it remains to be seen how many of the people actually feel this way, and how many are either there as spies or just out of curiosity.

I, just like the main POV character, wonder what the heck she and her father are doing there. How the heck did they get themselves wrapped up in this mess?
 
you know you've arrived when you get a two-part critique :D

thanks for taking so much time on it, pc, let's see now...

yep, it's set in an enclosed yard, which is clearer earlier on ( always a puzzle how much story & info to give in context...)
Contradictory statements
again, possibly not clear enough that he's comparing northern shrines to those on the plains nearer Hellea. Fair enough. Tweaking reqd....
What kind of danger are we in?
is Cassia's thought. Formatting error.
Aside from that, it remains to be seen how many of the people actually feel this way, and how many are either there as spies or just out of curiosity.
interesting you should say that....
How the heck did they get themselves wrapped up in this mess?
Again, i don't want to give the entire story away.....but this ain't a real mess yet....
 
It's difficult to judge without knowing what your real intentions are from this short excerpt. However, I do get the feeling of an argument if that was your intention. Another funny point was the use of story teller, was it intentional? Is talking about you or the historian?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top