Salvelinus
Member
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2008
- Messages
- 7
I see Stross is nominated for a hugo yet again with his latest novel.
The only work I've read by him was "Singularity Sky" and was extremely disappointed after reading all the raving reviews. His characters were poorly developed and uninteresting. The plotline was slow and predictable. The battle scenes and miliatry drama were a chore to read through. The social commentary was cliched (yes, we all agree, opression of the proletariat = bad). Finally, his complicated scientific ideas are explained poorly in most instances. True masters of sci-fi, such as Clarke are able to explain the science behind thier fiction with extreme clarity and without resorting to lay terminology that alienates their audience. Stross was definitely inconsistant at best in this regard.
Nevertheless, the book had many incredibly original, fantastic ideas in it with some occasional beautifully articulated descriptions of a far-future galaxy.
I know he's been quite prolific since this debut novel. Has his writing improved? I'd like to give him another shot, but not if he's writing in the same way. Anyone read his more recent stuff like Glasshouse and Halting State?
The only work I've read by him was "Singularity Sky" and was extremely disappointed after reading all the raving reviews. His characters were poorly developed and uninteresting. The plotline was slow and predictable. The battle scenes and miliatry drama were a chore to read through. The social commentary was cliched (yes, we all agree, opression of the proletariat = bad). Finally, his complicated scientific ideas are explained poorly in most instances. True masters of sci-fi, such as Clarke are able to explain the science behind thier fiction with extreme clarity and without resorting to lay terminology that alienates their audience. Stross was definitely inconsistant at best in this regard.
Nevertheless, the book had many incredibly original, fantastic ideas in it with some occasional beautifully articulated descriptions of a far-future galaxy.
I know he's been quite prolific since this debut novel. Has his writing improved? I'd like to give him another shot, but not if he's writing in the same way. Anyone read his more recent stuff like Glasshouse and Halting State?