LotR - A Reader's Companion

It's quite interesting in some of the annotations, Ace, and has some nice trivia: for instance, the "voice" (Hroom, hroom) of Treebeard was apparently suggested by the booming tones of C.S.Lewis.
 
Something like this can always be improved by the addition of new information brought to light since the earlier edition. Might well be worth looking into....
 
It does fall into the habit that a lot of these seem to, though - it's not too sure of where to pitch its explanations, so to speak.

For example, one note may be explaining a tricky piece of chronology, tying up several points from other chapters - but next it feels it has to tell you what "uplands" and a "parapet" are.
 
Frankly, Pyan, that's because with something like this, given the popularity of the films (and, consequently, the books, where people who wouldn't normally have read them are concerned), like so many secondary tomes, whether it be of scholarship or whatever, it has become necessary to explain terms such as this because fewer and fewer people really do know these terms (amazing as that may seem); so adding these is an attempt to bridge that gap -- sometimes successfully, often not; but necessary to avoid alienating a rather large percentage of their potential buyers -- a larger percentage than would find such a practice annoying, I'm afraid.....
 
It looks like there's some interesting stuff... but sometimes I feel like the information the author gave in the book was all he or she wanted you to know. I don't know, I definitely eat up all the extra Harry Potter stuff I can get. It doesn't look bad to me, but I don't know that I'm going to go out and buy it.
 

Back
Top