Um, had she never seen piccies of the Gulf or California during the oil boom ? With derricks & donkey pumps, oily puddles, pipe-lines, mud and burn-offs to the horizon ?? IIRC, part of the Lake Baikal area is still like that. And strip-mining coal ain't pretty, either...
FWIW, nuclear power may be 'clean' at power station, but the mining and residuals are just as messy as coal and, statistically, less radioactive....
Has anyone forgotten where the raw materials for solar panels or wind-farms come from ? And dam --or tidal barrage-- building takes a heap of stuff you gotta haul from some-where...
What really bugs me is that this tar-sand oil will flow straight into a culture that still pays a few bucks per gallon for gasoline, considers a 3-litre Saturn Aura sedan to be an 'economy' car...