You can take comfort in the fact that you’ve playtested it for me and I’ll give it a miss.So, Man O'War ought to be great fun but isn't. Everything about it is cumbersome and awkward: not just sailing a ship (you'd expect some awkwardness there!) but trading, paying your crew, equipping your men, boarding the enemy, exploring, even looking at the map. It's full of good ideas and execution that would have seemed clunky in 2005. It's so awkward, coupled with the difficulty of "standard" mode, that there's very little incentive to do anything at all, really. You might as well play something else. Doesn't somebody playtest these games? Or am I just unusual in wanting them to be enjoyable to play?
I have a copy of its predecessor (Command: Modern Air and Naval Operations.I don't play too many games, but I do spend a bit of time playing and writing scenarios for COMMAND: MODERN OPERATIONS. It's probably one of the best war games (emphasis on naval and air operations, but some ground warfare elements, too) available right now.
I have a copy of its predecessor (Command: Modern Air and Naval Operations.
It’s a game I want to love so much but it is just too much for me. I wasn’t surprised when the military started using it because it’s so detailed. Needless to say I won’t be buying Command: Modern Operations.
I have found Rule The Waves 3 much more to my liking.
Sadly that was my view, it feels like an early access game that the developers never finished. A pity as it had potential.So, Man O'War ought to be great fun but isn't. Everything about it is cumbersome and awkward: not just sailing a ship (you'd expect some awkwardness there!) but trading, paying your crew, equipping your men, boarding the enemy, exploring, even looking at the map. It's full of good ideas and execution that would have seemed clunky in 2005. It's so awkward, coupled with the difficulty of "standard" mode, that there's very little incentive to do anything at all, really. You might as well play something else. Doesn't somebody playtest these games? Or am I just unusual in wanting them to be enjoyable to play?