The Sword in the Dark

Status
Not open for further replies.

DB Tempest

Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2009
Messages
5
hey,
I was hoping for critique on whether this prologue works
any ideas, points or well anything you have to say about it will be amazing.
Thanks
 
Prologue

The Arch-Mage stared out over the town spread before him. The order of it all pleased him; each street ran in perfect lines from the base of the tower where he stood to the outer wall; over a mile away. The tower in which he stood was over a mile high and he stood in the highest room, but the tower was easily dwarfed by the slab of rock that stood behind it at four times the height of the room in which he stood. The sun rose over the fields that lay to three sides of the city. A grimace passed over his usually unmoving features as his thoughts strayed to the day ahead.

Slowly his hands started to run up his robes; stopping when they reached the stitched symbol on the lapels. It showed a dark circle with a bright white sword thrust through it; his face returned to supreme stillness as he contemplated the sign. It was the symbol of the Paladins. They were the defence of humans against the dark, who were the white sword defending against the dark world.

He dropped his hands away from his robes in disgust with himself. How dare he show such a weakness, letting himself show his nervousness in his actions? He returned his gaze to the outer lands; the flat fields outside his city; it was his city no matter what anyone said. He flashed his eyes over the thousands of armed soldiers that trained on those fields, Calvary, infantry and battle mages all pushing themselves to their limits readying themselves for their next challenge.

A light knock roused him from his thoughts and he turned to his ornate office before speaking in his gravelly voice, “…Enter”. Three people strode in the room, each wearing robes as stark as those the Arch-Mage himself wore, his deep black was contrasted the bright white, of the new peoples. Each of the new entrants bowed to him in turn and waited for him to speak.

The Arch-Mage greeted each. “General, Healer, Scholar.” Each nodded as they heard their own title, and solemnly lifted back their hoods. Between the four of them they made up the ruling Council of the Paladins.

The General was a big man, at least seven foot tall with strength radiating from him. However time had placed a burden upon his once proud shoulders, wrinkles lined his face and his eyes showed the many years of hard fighting he had endured. He shook his head lightly in a way of an old lion, and looked at the Arch-Mage, “Terrible way to start a day” he said gruffly.

The Healer looked up at his words, her long black hair falling down over her shoulders and spilling out her robes, like a dark shadow falling on untouched white snow. She merely shook her head with sadness obvious in her eyes. The Scholar looked up last and his face looked drawn, it was a face used to a smile and jolliness, not the sadness of the day. He spoke softly and quietly almost as if he did not wish to say the words “We should go; this needs to be done…” He looked down again after the word, as if studying the floor intensely.

The other members of the council said not a word as they looked at him and slowly turned to Arch-Mage. He nodded sharply and strided to the door pushing it open on well oiled hinges and pacing though, closely followed by the rest of the Council. They moved though the tower as if every single step was forced upon them, every person they met bowing deeply to them and moving swiftly aside noting the expressions they shared, all but Arch-Mage whose face was completely blank.

They reached an elaborate set of double wooden doors and slowly the Arch-Mage waved his hand in front of them. They swung open slowly and without creaking. The council filed in and filled the seats around the circumference of the room. The doors eased closed after them

Moments later the four turned to watch the doors opening again. A figure was dragged in by two burly guards who deposited their burden in the centre of the room before leaving. The man they left was gaunt, his clothes in shreds, and chains holding his wrists and legs together. But he managed to look more regal and stately than the entire council. The light in his eyes showed defiance and internal strength shone though his outwardly wasted appearance, giving him the look of a proud warrior surrounded by men he commanded, not a prisoner in chains. The man on the ground rose to his feet, his chains clanking with each movement. His light hair fell lankly in front of his eyes and he moved his head smoothly to shift it. He clasped his hands together and started to study each member of the council before stopping and staring at the Arch-Mage deeply.

Each person around the room visibly shifted in their seats as his gaze fell on them their eyes unable to hold his. Slowly the Arch-mage rose to speak, his words leaving his mouth with a bitter sneer. “Damien Wolfsbane, last defender of Falco, first sword of the council of Paladins, high captain of the western armies, you are hereby charged with the gravest crime any man on this world can commit, CONSORTING WITH DEMONS!” the Arch-Mages Voice had rose until the last past of his speech had left his mouth as a roar.

Damien seemed to consider the Arch-Mage, speaking not a word but allowing a knowing smile to spread across his face as the words flowed over him. He seemed to be drinking in every word that was said and his eyes changed to show he hated the taste of each and every one of them. Yet he still did not speak, he just continued his inspection of the Arch-Mage

Again the Arch-Mage secretly berated himself over his loss of control, and started to speak, forcing his voice back to its normal pitch and tone. “No man may become, or try to become, immortal. You knew this and yet you went against our laws trying to bargain with demons to achieve your aims in the path.”

He didn’t even think before his next words passed over his lips, his eyes held no remorse or mercy for the man that stood before him. “I banish you from all civilised land, this city, The Sacred Hold, is closed to you for ever more. To return is to die.”

Damien looked up at his judge and slowly opened his mouth, but delayed before speaking as if weighing each word, “Father…Father, I shall return, and when I do, it will be to cut your blind head from your shoulders.” He pronounced this with out ever changing his expression from a knowing smile.

The General almost leapt to his feet, all traces of an old lion now replaced by that of a young panther in the height of its charge. He raised his hand in a clawed thrusting motion towards Damien while solemnly proclaiming “You are banished!” A light flooded the courtroom making it brighter than any midsummer’s day. The council, who had all been rising from their seats, fell back, blinded and clawing at their own eyes. Slowly the light faded and it revealed Damien was gone; and all that was left was the chains he had been held with.
 
What a title, that is really something, but when I look prose it doesn't come out as magnificent. You need to start working on this.

Prologue

The Arch-Mage stared out over the town spread before him. The order of it all pleased him; each street ran in perfect lines from the base of the tower where he stood to the outer wall; over a mile away. The tower in which he stood was over a mile high and he stood in the highest room, but the tower was easily dwarfed by the slab of rock that stood behind it at four times the height of the room in which he stood. The sun rose over the fields that lay to three sides of the city. A grimace passed over his usually unmoving features as his thoughts strayed to the day ahead.

Start from the first sentence. At the moment, it's a good start but you need to edit it, like for example: The Arch-Mage stared out to town spreading at before him. The order of it pleased him. ....

The next thing you need to is checking out the repetition. For example you're using word stood way too many times. Use it only once, and try to give us just a simple image. This is way too much information. The tower in which he stood was over a mile high and he stood in the highest room, but the tower was easily dwarfed by the slab of rock that stood behind it at four times the height of the room in which he stood.

The reason. I got the image of tower from first sentence.

Slowly his hands started to run up his robes; stopping when they reached the stitched symbol on the lapels. It showed a dark circle with a bright white sword thrust through it; his face returned to supreme stillness as he contemplated the sign. It was the symbol of the Paladins. They were the defence of humans against the dark, who were the white sword defending against the dark world.

He dropped his hands away from his robes in disgust with himself. How dare he show such a weakness, letting himself show his nervousness in his actions? He returned his gaze to the outer lands; the flat fields outside his city; it was his city no matter what anyone said. He flashed his eyes over the thousands of armed soldiers that trained on those fields, Calvary, infantry and battle mages all pushing themselves to their limits readying themselves for their next challenge.

Would you as a person talk in thoughts in third person or would use first person?

I would rewrite the whole paragraph, and only show what I need to show. Therefore I would try to move out the exposition of battle-mages and warriors training at the field and write them in one sentence. He returned his gaze to the flat land opening beyond the city walls. Leave it there and continue from next chapter.

A light knock roused him from his thoughts and he turned to his ornate office before speaking in his gravelly voice, “…Enter”. Three people strode in the room, each wearing robes as stark as those the Arch-Mage himself wore, his deep black was contrasted the bright white, of the new peoples. Each of the new entrants bowed to him in turn and waited for him to speak.

You get the image wrong. The arch-mage is in his thoughts, he gets interrupted. He allows people to enter the room, but then you don't make them and your readers to wait, as they are expecting the people speaking their mind. Not bowing and doing other manouvers.

The Arch-Mage greeted each. “General, Healer, Scholar.” Each nodded as they heard their own title, and solemnly lifted back their hoods. Between the four of them they made up the ruling Council of the Paladins.

The General was a big man, at least seven foot tall with strength radiating from him. However time had placed a burden upon his once proud shoulders, wrinkles lined his face and his eyes showed the many years of hard fighting he had endured. He shook his head lightly in a way of an old lion, and looked at the Arch-Mage, “Terrible way to start a day” he said gruffly.

The Healer looked up at his words, her long black hair falling down over her shoulders and spilling out her robes, like a dark shadow falling on untouched white snow. She merely shook her head with sadness obvious in her eyes. The Scholar looked up last and his face looked drawn, it was a face used to a smile and jolliness, not the sadness of the day. He spoke softly and quietly almost as if he did not wish to say the words “We should go; this needs to be done…” He looked down again after the word, as if studying the floor intensely.

The other members of the council said not a word as they looked at him and slowly turned to Arch-Mage. He nodded sharply and strided to the door pushing it open on well oiled hinges and pacing though, closely followed by the rest of the Council. They moved though the tower as if every single step was forced upon them, every person they met bowing deeply to them and moving swiftly aside noting the expressions they shared, all but Arch-Mage whose face was completely blank.

They reached an elaborate set of double wooden doors and slowly the Arch-Mage waved his hand in front of them. They swung open slowly and without creaking. The council filed in and filled the seats around the circumference of the room. The doors eased closed after them

Moments later the four turned to watch the doors opening again. A figure was dragged in by two burly guards who deposited their burden in the centre of the room before leaving. The man they left was gaunt, his clothes in shreds, and chains holding his wrists and legs together. But he managed to look more regal and stately than the entire council. The light in his eyes showed defiance and internal strength shone though his outwardly wasted appearance, giving him the look of a proud warrior surrounded by men he commanded, not a prisoner in chains. The man on the ground rose to his feet, his chains clanking with each movement. His light hair fell lankly in front of his eyes and he moved his head smoothly to shift it. He clasped his hands together and started to study each member of the council before stopping and staring at the Arch-Mage deeply.

To me this is all bit too much of info dumpy. You build the image, but you don't get to the action. In your shoes I would rewrite the important members entering in the arch-mage study differently. I would move straight away to the dialogue. Try to hook the reader with the message. Build the momentum and then move them to the execution.

Each person around the room visibly shifted in their seats as his gaze fell on them their eyes unable to hold his. Slowly the Arch-mage rose to speak, his words leaving his mouth with a bitter sneer. “Damien Wolfsbane, last defender of Falco, first sword of the council of Paladins, high captain of the western armies, you are hereby charged with the gravest crime any man on this world can commit, CONSORTING WITH DEMONS!” the Arch-Mages Voice had rose until the last past of his speech had left his mouth as a roar.

Does he need to give out whole litany of pompeus titles if he's going to condamn the man for consorting with the demons? Man obviously is a traitor.

"Damien Wolsbane," the arch-mage boomed. He looked down at the beaten man chained on the floor, trying to understand why he was standing in honour when he had committed such a terrible crime. "We are gathered here to ..."

Damien seemed to consider the Arch-Mage, speaking not a word but allowing a knowing smile to spread across his face as the words flowed over him. He seemed to be drinking in every word that was said and his eyes changed to show he hated the taste of each and every one of them. Yet he still did not speak, he just continued his inspection of the Arch-Mage

Why to hop in his head? Stick with the Arch-mage.
Again the Arch-Mage secretly berated himself over his loss of control, and started to speak, forcing his voice back to its normal pitch and tone. “No man may become, or try to become, immortal. You knew this and yet you went against our laws trying to bargain with demons to achieve your aims in the path.”

He didn’t even think before his next words passed over his lips, his eyes held no remorse or mercy for the man that stood before him. “I banish you from all civilised land, this city, The Sacred Hold, is closed to you for ever more. To return is to die.”

Shucked out from the city for doing such a terrible crime... not a great punishment, imho.

Damien looked up at his judge and slowly opened his mouth, but delayed before speaking as if weighing each word, “Father…Father, I shall return, and when I do, it will be to cut your blind head from your shoulders.” He pronounced this with out ever changing his expression from a knowing smile.

The General almost leapt to his feet, all traces of an old lion now replaced by that of a young panther in the height of its charge. He raised his hand in a clawed thrusting motion towards Damien while solemnly proclaiming “You are banished!” A light flooded the courtroom making it brighter than any midsummer’s day. The council, who had all been rising from their seats, fell back, blinded and clawing at their own eyes. Slowly the light faded and it revealed Damien was gone; and all that was left was the chains he had been held with.


Hmmm, I think you have the skill of doing better. Read your prologue and think about it. Would you buy it?
 
I think you have just opened my eyes a little bit, I've just looked at my own worked and I'm now seriously considering scrapping this and starting again....:p
only joking, i don't give up on a project that easily
but thanks for the amazing advice.
To the pen and paper!!!
 
[/quote]
Prologue

The Arch-Mage stared out over the town spread before him. The order of it all pleased him; each street
each street is singular, so it "ran in a perfect line"
ran in perfect lines from the base of the tower where he stood to the outer wall;
comma, not semicolon (you don't want two in a sentence)
over a mile away. The tower in which he stood was over a mile high and he stood in the highest room, but the tower was easily dwarfed by the slab of rock that stood behind it at four times the height of the room in which he stood.
The repetitions of "tower", "high", "stood" and "over a mile" have been commented upon
The sun rose over the fields that lay to three sides of the city.
That last sentence is hardly really part of that paragraph.
A grimace passed over his usually unmoving features as his thoughts strayed to the day ahead.

Slowly his hands started to run up his robes;
just a comma; and consider inverting "symbol" and "stitched"
stopping when they reached the stitched symbol on the lapels. It showed a dark circle with a bright white sword thrust through it; his face returned to supreme stillness as he contemplated the sign. It was the symbol of the Paladins. They were the defence of humans against the dark, who were the white sword defending against the dark world.
this states that it is thedark who are the defenders. I'm aware of what it's supposed to say.
He dropped his hands away from his robes in disgust with himself. How dare he show such a weakness, letting himself show his nervousness in his actions? He returned his gaze to the outer lands;
comma instead of semicolon
the flat fields outside his city; it was his city no matter what anyone said. He flashed his eyes over the thousands of armed soldiers that trained on those fields, Calvary, infantry and battle mages all pushing themselves to their limits
comma
readying themselves for their next challenge.

A light knock roused him from his thoughts and he turned to his ornate office before speaking in his gravelly voice, “…Enter”. Three people strode in the room, each wearing robes as stark as those the Arch-Mage himself wore,
full stop
his deep black was contrasted
to? with?
the bright white,
no comma
of the new peoples. Each of the new entrants bowed to him in turn and waited for him to speak.

The Arch-Mage greeted each. “General, Healer, Scholar.” Each nodded as they heard their own title, and solemnly lifted back their hoods. Between the four of them they made up the ruling Council of the Paladins.

The General was a big man, at least seven foot tall with strength radiating from him. However
comma
time had placed a burden upon his once proud shoulders, wrinkles lined his face and his eyes showed the many years of hard fighting he had endured. He shook his head lightly in a way of an old lion, and looked at the Arch-Mage, “Terrible way to start a day” he said gruffly.

The Healer looked up at his words, her long black hair falling down over her shoulders and spilling out
on?
her robes, like a dark shadow falling on untouched white snow. She merely shook her head with sadness obvious in her eyes. The Scholar looked up last and his face looked drawn,
full stop
it was a face used to a smile and jolliness, not the sadness of the day. He spoke softly and quietly almost as if he did not wish to say the words “We should go; this needs to be done…” He looked down again after the word, as if studying the floor intensely.

The other members of the council said not a word as they looked at him and slowly turned to
the
Arch-Mage. He nodded sharply and strided
strode
to the door
comma
pushing it open on well oiled hinges and pacing though, closely followed by the rest of the Council. They moved though the tower as if every single step was forced upon them, every person they met bowing deeply to them and moving swiftly aside
comma
noting the expressions they shared, all but Arch-Mage whose face was completely blank.

They reached an elaborate set of double wooden doors and slowly the Arch-Mage waved his hand in front of them. They swung open slowly and without creaking. The council filed in and filled the seats around the circumference of the room. The doors eased closed after them

Moments later the four turned to watch the doors opening again. A figure was dragged in by two burly guards who deposited their burden in the centre of the room before leaving. The man they left was gaunt, his clothes in shreds, and chains holding his wrists and legs together. But he managed to look more regal and stately than the entire council. The light in his eyes showed defiance and internal strength shone though his outwardly wasted appearance, giving him the look of a proud warrior surrounded by men he commanded, not a prisoner in chains. The man on the ground rose to his feet, his chains clanking with each movement. His light hair fell lankly in front of his eyes and he moved his head smoothly to shift it. He clasped his hands together and started to study each member of the council before stopping and staring at the Arch-Mage deeply.

Each person around the room visibly shifted in their seats
"each" is singular. I will accept that "their" has now been accepted to denote 'singular of unknown gender', but it's still "seat", not "seats"
as his gaze fell on them
comma
their eyes unable to hold his. Slowly the Arch-mage rose to speak, his words leaving his mouth with a bitter sneer. “Damien Wolfsbane, last defender of Falco, first sword of the council of Paladins, high captain of the western armies, you are hereby charged with the gravest crime any man on this world can commit, CONSORTING WITH DEMONS!” the Arch-Mages
Arch-Mage's
Voice had rose
risen
until the last past
part?
of his speech had left his mouth as a roar.

Damien seemed to consider the Arch-Mage, speaking not a word but allowing a knowing smile to spread across his face as the words flowed over him. He seemed to be drinking in every word that was said and his eyes changed to show he hated the taste of each and every one of them. Yet he still did not speak, he just continued his inspection of the Arch-Mage

Again the Arch-Mage secretly berated himself over his loss of control, and started to speak, forcing his voice back to its normal pitch and tone. “No man may become, or try to become, immortal. You knew this and yet you went against our laws
comma
trying to bargain with demons to achieve your aims in the path.”

He didn’t even think before his next words passed over his lips, his eyes held
holding
no remorse or mercy for the man that stood before him. “I banish you from all civilised land,
full stop
this city, The Sacred Hold, is closed to you for ever more. To return is to die.”

Damien looked up at his judge and slowly opened his mouth, but delayed before speaking as if weighing each word, “Father…Father, I shall return, and when I do, it will be to cut your blind head from your shoulders.” He pronounced this with out ever changing his expression from a knowing smile.

The General almost leapt to his feet, all traces of an old lion now replaced by that of a young panther in the height of its charge. He raised his hand in a clawed thrusting motion towards Damien while solemnly proclaiming “You are banished!” A light flooded the courtroom making it brighter than any midsummer’s day. The council, who had all been rising from their seats, fell back, blinded and clawing at their own eyes. Slowly the light faded and it revealed Damien was gone; and all that was left was the chains he had been held with.

Although if you're going to do all the corrections ctg suggested, my little grammar details are somewhat irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
It's taken me so long to do this, that some of the points have already been covered, but here's my sixpennyworth....

Welcome to the Chronicles: interesting concept, and although I have some nitpicks, I did like the slow build of tension, although I was confused at times: so........

The Arch-Mage stared out over the town spread before him. The order of it all pleased him; each street ran in perfect lines from the base of the tower where he stood to the outer wall; over a mile away. The tower in which he stood was over a mile high and he stood in the highest room, but the tower was easily dwarfed by the slab of rock that stood behind it at four times the height of the room in which he stood. The sun rose over the fields that lay to three sides of the city. A grimace passed over his usually unmoving features as his thoughts strayed to the day ahead.

Repetitious, use of 'the tower where he stood' and 'the tower in which he stood'. Even worse you have four 'stood' in one sentence, and it runs out of meaning... I can't stand it........

Why were his features usually unmoving?Does he have Parkinson's disease? How do we know they are usually unmoving? Is it relevant? Nope. it's the narrator overdoing it. Rein him in a bit, and the story will flow much easier....

Slowly his hands started to run up his robes; stopping when they reached the stitched symbol on the lapels.

Not sure about the semi-colon, or the change of tenses. Perhaps: Slowly his hands started to run up his robes. They stopped when they reached the stitched symbol on the lapels. ?

It showed a dark circle with a bright white sword thrust through it; his face returned to supreme stillness as he contemplated the sign.

Again not sure about the semi-colon....I think a full stop (period) is better, but I really don't like 'supreme' stillness. Narrator again.

It was the symbol of the Paladins. They were the defence of humans against the dark, who were the white sword defending against the dark world.

Now I am confused.... it looks as though the Paladins are the defence against the dark, but then says that the dark were the white sword against the dark world. Probably better if: It was the symbol of the Paladins. They were humankind's defence against the dark: the white sword defending against the dark world.

There's a repetition of 'dark' there, I'll leave you and luke skywalker to find an alternative.

He dropped his hands away from his robes in disgust with himself. How dare he show such a weakness, letting himself show his nervousness in his actions?
Who exactly is he asking this question to? I realise it's his thoughts spilling over, but you then go immediately back to your narrator to continue the story. Wouldn't it be better to let us make our minds up, by showing us, rather than telling us? ie: He sighed and dropped his hands away from his robe. That's it, nothing more... then move on to your next sentence.

He returned his gaze to the outer lands; the flat fields outside his city; it was his city no matter what anyone said.

That's two semi-colons I'm not sure about, and his thoughts have come back in again. That's three changes in pov in two sentences, wait till ctg sees it.......

He flashed his eyes over the thousands of armed soldiers that trained on those fields, Calvary, infantry and battle mages all pushing themselves to their limits readying themselves for their next challenge.

A moment ago he was gazing, why are his eyes flashing now? Oh, and Calvary was where Christ was crucified, Cavalry are those guys on horses. Why the change in tenses again? 'Flashed' 'trained' and then 'pushing' and 'readying' You need to stick to one...

A light knock roused him from his thoughts and he turned to his ornate office before speaking in his gravelly voice, “…Enter”.

Changing tenses again.... and trying to tell us he's got an ornate office and a gravelly voice. Gravelly? Is that in the English language? Ah, this is fantasy, you made it up!

Three people strode in the room, each wearing robes as stark as those the Arch-Mage himself wore, his deep black was contrasted the bright white, of the new peoples. Each of the new entrants bowed to him in turn and waited for him to speak.

"contrasted by' I think you'll find. And they've turned from 'people' into 'new peoples' Unless they're the band, I think that's probably incorrect. Try this: Three people strode into the room. The robes they wore were brilliant white, a stark contrast to his own. As one, they bowed and waited.

Just a thought, but it does read better....

The Arch-Mage greeted each. “General, Healer, Scholar.” Each nodded as they heard their own title, and solemnly lifted back their hoods. Between the four of them they made up the ruling Council of the Paladins.

Do you know Allan Ahlberg's 'Each peach pear plum book? That's what sprang to mind here with the repetition of 'each'. And you're telling again. I think you could do this: The Arch mage greeted them. And leave it at that, allowing the narrator to fill us in with the descriptions.

The General was a big man, at least seven foot tall with strength radiating from him. However time had placed a burden upon his once proud shoulders, wrinkles lined his face and his eyes showed the many years of hard fighting he had endured. He shook his head lightly in a way of an old lion, and looked at the Arch-Mage, “Terrible way to start a day” he said gruffly.

Hmm, I don't recal seeing Lions shaking their heads lightly in a way that springs to mind. And isn't he already looking at the Archmage? Surely the last line should be: He shook his head lightly. “Terrible way to start a day,” he said gruffly.

The Healer looked up at his words, her long black hair falling down over her shoulders and spilling out her robes, like a dark shadow falling on untouched white snow. that spread out across the peaks of the distant mountains that gleamed in the morning sun, a purity that sparkled with a tall shadow of a peak running through it.........?

C,mon these guys are equals aren't they? She wouldn't be looking down, and the description of her hair belongs in a romantic novel, not a fantasy/SciFi book. So it could just be:
The healer shook her head sadly. She was a.....what? Gorgeous, sexy, old, young, wizened, wise? You described the General, what have you got against women?

Then:

The last of them spoke. He was an elderly man etc. “We should go; this needs to be done…” The Scholar's face looked drawn.

I hope you're seeing what I'm getting at? Less is more, let's have some mystery, let's wonder what they're up to, we know it's going to end in tears, but at least we're more likely to be intruiged....

The other members of the council said not a word as they looked at him and slowly turned to Arch-Mage. He nodded sharply and strided to the door pushing it open on well oiled hinges and pacing though, closely followed by the rest of the Council. They moved though the tower as if every single step was forced upon them, every person they met bowing deeply to them and moving swiftly aside noting the expressions they shared, all but Arch-Mage whose face was completely blank.

Now we're drowning in unnecessary information, and kid, let me tell you, there ain't no such word as 'strided'. And you keep mixing tenses all over the place.... Try this: The Arch-Mage nodded and strode to the door, followed by the others. As they made their way through the Tower, people stepped swiftly aside.

The rest is irrelevant, and adds little to the story.

They reached an elaborate set of double wooden doors and slowly the Arch-Mage waved his hand in front of them. They swung open slowly and without creaking. The council filed in and filled the seats around the circumference of the room. The doors eased closed after them

Ditto. Repeating 'slowly' and why would he wave his hand slowly? Aren't these guys purposeful, striding to destiny?

They made their way to the council chambers and took their seats. The prisoner in chains raised his head and looked at each of them in turn, then climbed painfully to his feet. He stood proudly, waiting.

And that's the whole of the next paragraph dealt with. It's enough to know he's in chains, and he's gonna get it, we don't need all the florid descriptions that just distract us from the action. You've got a thing about hair haven't you?

Moments later the four turned to watch the doors opening again. A figure was dragged in by two burly guards who deposited their burden in the centre of the room before leaving. The man they left was gaunt, his clothes in shreds, and chains holding his wrists and legs together. But he managed to look more regal and stately than the entire council. The light in his eyes showed defiance and internal strength shone though his outwardly wasted appearance, giving him the look of a proud warrior surrounded by men he commanded, not a prisoner in chains. The man on the ground rose to his feet, his chains clanking with each movement. His light hair fell lankly in front of his eyes and he moved his head smoothly to shift it. He clasped his hands together and started to study each member of the council before stopping and staring at the Arch-Mage deeply.

Honest, try it: your paragraph against mine, see what it looks like and then show both to a friend and ask whcih one they prefer. No cheating and telling them which is yours and which is mine.....


Each person around the room visibly shifted in their seats as his gaze fell on them their eyes unable to hold his. Slowly the Arch-mage rose to speak, his words leaving his mouth with a bitter sneer. “Damien Wolfsbane, last defender of Falco, first sword of the council of Paladins, high captain of the western armies, you are hereby charged with the gravest crime any man on this world can commit, CONSORTING WITH DEMONS!” the Arch-Mages Voice had rose until the last past of his speech had left his mouth as a roar.

Now I'm sorry, but you don't get to be Arch-mage on a whim! You start out as an apprentice mage, you spend years and years studying all the arcane law before they even let you out to work supervised, and then you continue to study the higher laws and work your way up the MUCK (Mages United for Country and King) council, until you have earned the respect of all your peers, and they elect you Arch-Mage. So guess what? You don't lose your temper the first time you speak!! You knew what's coming you probably did it loads of times before, this bit is a complete nonsense. I figure you're trying to show that Damien is a cool piece and it rankles them, but this just doesn't work, doesn't work at all.

I'm kinda assuming that he's been accused falsely (or not) but that he'll return someday, but the top men, the council of Paladins are acting like spoiled brats. So, let's put the power where it should belong:

The Arch-mage rose to his feet and stared at the prisoner. “Damien Wolfsbane, last defender of Falco, first sword of the council of Paladins, high captain of the western armies, you are hereby charged with the gravest crime any man on this world can commit, consorting with demons.

Damien stared back at the Arch-mage. There was a moment's silence and the Arch-mage continued.

“No man may become, or try to become, immortal. You knew this and yet you went against our laws trying to bargain with demons to achieve your aims in the path.”

“I banish you from all civilised land. This city, The Sacred Hold, is closed to you for ever more. To return is to die.”

Damien stared directly at his Judge. “I shall return, Father and when I do, it will be to cut your blind head from your shoulders.”

The General leapt to his feet, and thrust out his hand. " You are banished!" he roared. Incandescent light flooded the room blinding them all. As their sight returned, all that was left were the chains that had bound the prisoner.

And that's it, none of the other stuff. Whatjer reckon? I am confused whether the bright light was done by the general and Damien was hurled into exile (ie they expected it) or whether it was a complete surprise to them, a result of damien's dealings with demons. You gave me no clue in your story as to which it was...... I've left the other stuff in, below this lot so you can see how much unnecessary(okay, in my opinion) wordage you have. Good luck with the story, I'll look out for what you think....



Damien seemed to consider the Arch-Mage, speaking not a word but allowing a knowing smile to spread across his face as the words flowed over him. He seemed to be drinking in every word that was said and his eyes changed to show he hated the taste of each and every one of them. Yet he still did not speak, he just continued his inspection of the Arch-Mage

Again the Arch-Mage secretly berated himself over his loss of control, and started to speak, forcing his voice back to its normal pitch and tone. “No man may become, or try to become, immortal. You knew this and yet you went against our laws trying to bargain with demons to achieve your aims in the path.”

He didn’t even think before his next words passed over his lips, his eyes held no remorse or mercy for the man that stood before him. “I banish you from all civilised land, this city, The Sacred Hold, is closed to you for ever more. To return is to die.”

Damien looked up at his judge and slowly opened his mouth, but delayed before speaking as if weighing each word, “Father…Father, I shall return, and when I do, it will be to cut your blind head from your shoulders.” He pronounced this with out ever changing his expression from a knowing smile.

The General almost leapt to his feet, all traces of an old lion now replaced by that of a young panther in the height of its charge. He raised his hand in a clawed thrusting motion towards Damien while solemnly proclaiming “You are banished!” A light flooded the courtroom making it brighter than any midsummer’s day. The council, who had all been rising from their seats, fell back, blinded and clawing at their own eyes. Slowly the light faded and it revealed Damien was gone; and all that was left was the chains he had been held with.

 
First things first I want to thank you all for completely ripping this to shreds, and I really mean that, I was fed up of asking for honest opinions off people and getting back, "It's amazing why aren't you published??"

I've just re-read my own first paragraph and I'm kicking myself, its seriously the worst thing I have ever seen written and I plan to destroy every copy of it. :p

chrispenycate thanks for all the grammar advice, I am always useless with true grammar and spelling. I probably shouldn't admit this but..when do you use a comma and when do you use a semi-colon? I don't know which is better to use when.

Boneman, your advice is completely right. Lots of my work is over done. and I really have to edit out a large amount of that description. However in my own opinion I think maybe your suggestions cut out to much, maybe a happy medium would be the best move.

What do you think?


Again thanks for reading my work, I'm really sorry for putting you though that. :D
 
A comma is the minimalist pause, just a breath when you're reading out loud. It separates segments of an idea from each other, so yout eye doesn't just run on and think that the next word is automatically conceptually continuous with the one before.

A full stop says that one concept is closed, an idea totally laid out. It denotes a complete sentence with subject, verb and frequently object (and with me, more than often, subordinate clauses and parenthetical interventions) is tied up in rbbon ready for delivery.

A semicolon frequently sticks together two things which are grammatically sentences, but conceptually parts of a whole. This job's frequently given to a conjunction (and or but) reinforcing or contrasting the first half of a sentence with the second. It is not reccomended to use two successive semicolons in a sentence. (it's not recommended to use the passive mode, either, but I enjoy stretching the laws; this is much easier if you know them in the first place. Do you see how the semicolon could have been replaced by an "and" there?)

As an enjoyable way of bashing this into your skull I do reccomend "Eats, shoots and leaves" (Lynne Truss). That is, it was enjoyable for me, as a pedant. I'm not sure about the rest of society but, having seen it as a best seller in the airport bookshop, I suspect I'm not unique (in this, at any rate).

But reading it out loud is the trick.
 
DB, I recognise me in you. You got the same quick temper. Please don't think this your prose was so bad, because it wasn't. You definitely have the skills, so use them to make your piece better. That is the only way. :)
 
By DB Tempest
Boneman, your advice is completely right. Lots of my work is over done. and I really have to edit out a large amount of that description. However in my own opinion I think maybe your suggestions cut out to much, maybe a happy medium would be the best move.

Absolutely right, DB. I wrote those corrections on the hoof, and they were very stringent. I wanted to do the whole thing, so I was rushing it a bit at the end, and as I look back at it, I agree with you, too much has been taken out. There's a very famous writer (so famous I can't remember his name, but he sold milions around the world) and he said "I'm not a very good writer, but I'm an excellent re-writer".

I was exactly the same as you when I started out, over describing, over-flowery, waxing on for ages about deep emotions being expressed through thought, word and deed, and like you, loads of friends said it was really good...... When I showed them a much revised version they said things like: "Yeah, I never liked that bit....etc". I've learnt not to ask friends because they will lie so as not to hurt you, which doesn't help at all. My friends on the chronicles do no such thing, they tell the truth, and that's what improves the work. Where I agree with them, I make changes, where I don't agree, I either tweak it and see how it looks, or leave it exactly as it is. When my agent and publisher tell me the same as my friends on the chronicles, then maybe I will change it..... All I have to do is get an agent and publisher!!!

In the words of the aliens in Galaxy Quest, "never give up, never surrender" - brilliant movie.......:D

Again thanks for reading my work, I'm really sorry for putting you though that. :D

That's what the critique section is for..... probably we get a perverse pleasure out of it. But definitely, we learn from doing it, because we're focusing on writing, looking at it from different angles, and we're not so close to it (as we are with our own writing) that we can't see things that aren't working. It's all subjective. So comment on someone else's work, even if only to say 'I really liked it', and say what didn't work and why. You might think 'what do I know, I'm just starting out' but you are a potential reader/buyer of my book, and your opinion can help shape it into something better, no matter how small your comment.

Oh, and you're already doing something right, you're acknowledging the time and effort others have put in, so thank you for that. There is nothing worse than spending ages trying to help someone and get a big fat zero back from them, not a comment, not a thank-you-but-I-disagree even. There are one or two posters who I won't bother with now, it's as though they just want a free edit, and that's it. It's common courtesy to get back to the people who've helped, and you did it without thinking. Good on you.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top