A little help with some emotion, please!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Noah Phoenix

Occasional Idiot
Joined
Apr 24, 2009
Messages
140
Location
Terry Pratchett is king of observational wit. Did
I'm not sure if I've got the emotion right here, is there any way that it could be worded better? A little backstory: Noah and Ethan are brothers. Their father died in the last great war, Noah hates his father for leaving, Ethan idolized him. They love each other dearly. Noah didn't want Ethan to come on their journey as he's too rash and doesn't have much skill with a sword. As they attempt to flee Endershall to stop Vandaal, they are attacked by orcs and trolls, lead by Vandaals servant, Imrand. I'm still working on spelling and such, its just the feel I'd like help with...



Noah looked to his left as he fought off three orcs; Ethan was doing better than he had done before. He was flowing nicely, and took his time as he engaged his enemies one by one. He even took a few swings at a passing troll as it lumbered by, seeking Noah out. As it trailed its enormous club behind it, Noah readied himself for the troll.

‘Time to go, boys!’ shouted Aggie from behind him. She slammed her fists into the ground, which shook everything within sight, shattering windows and pushing over a couple of the barricades in front of Noah. The troll look confused, and looked like it might panic. That wouldn’t be good this close, thought Noah, it’ll most likely panic all over my head. He swiped two orcs down that attempted to catch him off guard, and then watched the troll as it looked at him, eyes wide with fear.

‘What are you doing, Aggie?’ shouted Ethan as he backed away from the orcs, towards the steps of the house.

‘Making my exit! Gotta be wi some style, me boy! Get up ere, all of e!’
Noah began to step backwards as the troll looked like it might turn to run. From out of the corner of his eye, a blur of motion caught his attention. It was Imrand, incensed and full of rage, wildly swinging a short-bladed sword tinged with green.

Noah parried the first few blows, but they were so fast he was beaten back a couple of steps. Regaining his footing, Noah dodged two more swings of Imrand's blade, and took the opportunity to take a pot shot at the flailing orc. He was swearing madly and screaming in orcish, and there seemed no end to his attacks.

‘Come on, Noah,’ shouted Ethan from the steps, ‘we gotta go!’

Noah couldn’t find a way through Imrand's attacks; he was barely dodging the blows, and never had time for a single attack back. Aggie slammed the ground twice more, and the ground began to give way. He could hear the mansion behind him breaking up as the ground beneath it began to slide towards the Edge. Aggie was taking the house off the Edge, the same way as she had done with the lake. The barricades, the orcs and trolls were going with it, including Noah, Ethan, Anath and Aggie.

‘What are you doing? The house!’ Ethan shouted.

‘Like I said, makin me exit look good. Dunt worry bout me, boy, go help yer brother! Anath, you go help Oz and Aldebert get that thing outa the shed! Quick!’

Ethan jumped three steps at a time and hurtled towards Noah, as Anath headed back in through the now almost fully destroyed front door towards the back of the house, and the shed.

Ethan reached Noah just as he’d beaten Imrand back, and followed up Noah’s attack with a carefully timed blow, which struck him full in the face. Noah then leaped forward and thrust his sword deep into Imrand’s chest as he staggered backwards. Noah drove the hilt in as far as it would go, and spoke into Imrand’s ear as he neared his face, ‘Tell your master you failed to kill me when you meet him in hell!’

Imrand’s body fell limply to the ground, and Noah turned to Ethan, ‘Thank you, brother.’

‘No problem; it’s about time I saved you. Come on lets get out of here!’
Ethan followed Noah up the stairs, and as Noah turned to him to help him up the last few steps, Ethan stopped suddenly and looked right into Noah’s eyes as a wave of shock swept over his face.

‘Ethan?’

Ethan didn’t answer; instead he dropped to his knees, hanging his head as he did so.

‘Ethan! No! What the…?’ Noah dropped to his knees beside Ethan, and as he threw his arms around him, he felt the long, cold blade of a knife mix with the feeling of warm blood. He looked behind Ethan to see Imrand sink to the ground, his arm outstretched towards them.

‘Ethan, hang on!’ The tears were already bursting forth from Noah’s eyes as he tried desperately to get Ethan to stand. He grasped Ethan’s head within his hands as he laid him down on the steps again, just as Aggie reached his side, ‘Ethan,’ Noah said softly, ‘just hold on, you’re doing really well, come on, just a little longer…’

‘Noah, e’s gone, come on, we ave t go,’ said Aggie softly.

‘I’m not leaving him here!’ Noah screamed as the first of the orcs realized what was going on and began making their way towards them. The house was also gaining momentum, slipping now yard by yard rather than inch by inch.

‘Come on, boy, we’re goin now! Leave him here; he’s dead!’
[FONT=&quot]
Noah looked up into her eyes. They were steel grey and full of determination. He hated her for being so insensitive, but he knew she was right. She was so cold and uncaring, but as he looked into her eyes, what was that flicker deep down there somewhere? There was definitely something; perhaps it was a flicker of doubt, perhaps it was a flicker of compassion, perhaps sadness. Whatever it was, it was gone and no more than a memory. But it snapped Noah into action. He sheathed his sword, grabbed Ethan and heaved him onto his shoulder. Aggie sprinted up the steps after him, obviously deciding not to argue. They hurried through the house and came out into the yard behind it in front of the shed. The ground beneath them was constantly shaking now and slipping away slowly. Oz, Aldebert and Anath were pulling the gigantic shape of the rocket out from the shed, and proceeded to turn it to face the Edge.
[/FONT]
 
Most of this seems to be concerned with describing action rather than emotion. You might like to think about cutting down the 'as's that you've over-used throughout. Also, the numbers and minute directions grate:
'Noah looked to his LEFT as he fought off THREE orcs...'
This amount of detail slows the pace and is unnatural, you're describing like a police witness, not someone who is feeling the emotion of the moment.

Coming to the more emotional bit at the end, it's a bit curt. There's drama, but no real human feeling (even if the characters aren't fully human, don't know what kind of fantasy this is, the reader IS human and needs emotion described accordingly). The expression 'hanging his head' gives the connotation of shame, so gives the reader the wrong impression even if it's a subconscious collocation thing. Imo you could have more description of the brothers embracing each other at the end, and he dies a bit suddenly if you're wanting to bring out emotion. Just a personal view, obviously.


 
I agree with kadife.

Also, your guy's been fighting quite a while without, apparently, breaking a sweat.

Physical sensations can be a good way of communicating a POV character's emotions to the reader. The stomach clenches, the hand trembles, mouth goes dry, etc. If readers "feel" what a character feels, they can identify the emotion without being told.
 
This was what I was worried I'd done. This scene does have alot of action before this and it carries on after this piece, as it's the finale. I didn't want to break that up too much with an over the top cliched death. I wanted it to be quick and a little bit of a shock as this is the end of book one and Ethan is a main character.

I see what you mean about the numbers grating, it's too much precise information, I'm leaving little to the imagination. I never saw it till now...

A little more attention to emotional detail is required, and a little more flow with the action, less of the 'police statement' which was a spot on comment, kadife.

Thanks to the both of you!
 
OK, so if this is the end of book one and the readers have known this character for most or all of the story at this point, and really care about him, his death will have plenty of emotional impact as it is.

So you have to handle it carefully and with a certain amount of subtlety, finding a middle course between, on the one hand, the danger of dismissing his death too lightly, and, on the other, getting in the way of what your readers should already be feeling all by themselves, by either falsifying Noah's emotions or over-dramatizing them.
 
OMG I freakin know....No one ever told me it was this hard....I just want my brain back! It hurts, oh it hurts!
I've re-written the piece, but I'm still not sure about it....The as's were a pain to get rid of, but crikey were there loads...
Why can't I see what you guys see when I read it through?

I kind of went for the feeling that the reader will care about his death, and there will be time for Noah to grieve soon enough. I added in Ethan being scared and asking Noah to help as he's dying, which goes with Ethan being the younger brother, and Noah always looking after him. Noah still has the same reaction, as this isn't Noah's limelight. I also added in Ethan telling Noah their father loved him, but he dies before he can tell Noah he does as well.

Hopefully it will do the trick....I hope....
 
There has to be more action and description of Noah's shock and feelings when Ethan is stabbed. There is simply too little emotion there. I am unable to connect with Noah and hurt with him.

Aggie is too quick to decide Ethan is dead. She is experienced and she stands by her team so asking Noah to leave Ethan is too quick. If its her idea to leave Ethan behind for some reason (she sends him after Noah), then though there is a trace of a hint, the reader should get the idea a little more clearly.

Well...those are my impressions, hope I've been of help!


I'm not sure if I've got the emotion right here, is there any way that it could be worded better? A little backstory: Noah and Ethan are brothers. Their father died in the last great war, Noah hates his father for leaving, Ethan idolized him. They love each other dearly. Noah didn't want Ethan to come on their journey as he's too rash and doesn't have much skill with a sword. As they attempt to flee Endershall to stop Vandaal, they are attacked by orcs and trolls, lead by Vandaals servant, Imrand. I'm still working on spelling and such, its just the feel I'd like help with...



Noah looked to his left as he fought off three orcs; Ethan was doing better than he had done before. He was flowing nicely, and took his time as he engaged his enemies one by one. He even took a few swings at a passing troll as it lumbered by, seeking Noah out. As it trailed its enormous club behind it, Noah readied himself for the troll.

‘Time to go, boys!’ shouted Aggie from behind him. She slammed her fists into the ground, which shook everything within sight, shattering windows and pushing over a couple of the barricades in front of Noah. The troll look confused, and looked like it might panic. That wouldn’t be good this close, thought Noah, it’ll most likely panic all over my head. He swiped two orcs down that attempted to catch him off guard, and then watched the troll as it looked at him, eyes wide with fear.

‘What are you doing, Aggie?’ shouted Ethan as he backed away from the orcs, towards the steps of the house.

‘Making my exit! Gotta be wi some style, me boy! Get up ere, all of e!’
Noah began to step backwards as the troll looked like it might turn to run. From out of the corner of his eye, a blur of motion caught his attention. It was Imrand, incensed and full of rage, wildly swinging a short-bladed sword tinged with green.

Noah parried the first few blows, but they were so fast he was beaten back a couple of steps. Regaining his footing, Noah dodged two more swings of Imrand's blade, and took the opportunity to take a pot shot at the flailing orc. He was swearing madly and screaming in orcish, and there seemed no end to his attacks.

‘Come on, Noah,’ shouted Ethan from the steps, ‘we gotta go!’

Noah couldn’t find a way through Imrand's attacks; he was barely dodging the blows, and never had time for a single attack back. Aggie slammed the ground twice more, and the ground began to give way. He could hear the mansion behind him breaking up as the ground beneath it began to slide towards the Edge. Aggie was taking the house off the Edge, the same way as she had done with the lake. The barricades, the orcs and trolls were going with it, including Noah, Ethan, Anath and Aggie.

‘What are you doing? The house!’ Ethan shouted.

‘Like I said, makin me exit look good. Dunt worry bout me, boy, go help yer brother! Anath, you go help Oz and Aldebert get that thing outa the shed! Quick!’

Ethan jumped three steps at a time and hurtled towards Noah, as Anath headed back in through the now almost fully destroyed front door towards the back of the house, and the shed.

Ethan reached Noah just as he’d beaten Imrand back, and followed up Noah’s attack with a carefully timed blow, which struck him full in the face. Noah then leaped forward and thrust his sword deep into Imrand’s chest as he staggered backwards. Noah drove the hilt in as far as it would go, and spoke into Imrand’s ear as he neared his face, ‘Tell your master you failed to kill me when you meet him in hell!’

Imrand’s body fell limply to the ground, and Noah turned to Ethan, ‘Thank you, brother.’

‘No problem; it’s about time I saved you. Come on lets get out of here!’
Ethan followed Noah up the stairs, and as Noah turned to him to help him up the last few steps, Ethan stopped suddenly and looked right into Noah’s eyes as a wave of shock swept over his face.

‘Ethan?’

Ethan didn’t answer; instead he dropped to his knees, hanging his head as he did so.

‘Ethan! No! What the…?’ Noah dropped to his knees beside Ethan, and as he threw his arms around him, he felt the long, cold blade of a knife mix with the feeling of warm blood. He looked behind Ethan to see Imrand sink to the ground, his arm outstretched towards them.

‘Ethan, hang on!’ The tears were already bursting forth from Noah’s eyes as he tried desperately to get Ethan to stand. He grasped Ethan’s head within his hands as he laid him down on the steps again, just as Aggie reached his side, ‘Ethan,’ Noah said softly, ‘just hold on, you’re doing really well, come on, just a little longer…’

‘Noah, e’s gone, come on, we ave t go,’ said Aggie softly.

‘I’m not leaving him here!’ Noah screamed as the first of the orcs realized what was going on and began making their way towards them. The house was also gaining momentum, slipping now yard by yard rather than inch by inch.

‘Come on, boy, we’re goin now! Leave him here; he’s dead!’
[FONT=&quot]
Noah looked up into her eyes. They were steel grey and full of determination. He hated her for being so insensitive, but he knew she was right. She was so cold and uncaring, but as he looked into her eyes, what was that flicker deep down there somewhere? There was definitely something; perhaps it was a flicker of doubt, perhaps it was a flicker of compassion, perhaps sadness. Whatever it was, it was gone and no more than a memory. But it snapped Noah into action. He sheathed his sword, grabbed Ethan and heaved him onto his shoulder. Aggie sprinted up the steps after him, obviously deciding not to argue. They hurried through the house and came out into the yard behind it in front of the shed. The ground beneath them was constantly shaking now and slipping away slowly. Oz, Aldebert and Anath were pulling the gigantic shape of the rocket out from the shed, and proceeded to turn it to face the Edge.
[/FONT]
 
One thing I didn't mention is that Aggie has seen most of all this happen already in her vision. Although Noah doesn't remember it right now and she never gives anything away. The reader knows this, so they will get the impression that she sent Ethan after Noah because she knew he would save him, but would die in the process. This will be explored later.
 
Here's what I did with it....

Noah scanned the area around him, fighting off more orcs. Ethan was doing better than he had done before. He was flowing nicely, and took his time as he engaged his enemies one by one. He even took a few swings at a passing troll lumbering by, obviously seeking Noah out. As it trailed its enormous club behind it, Noah readied himself for the troll.

‘Time to go, boys!’ shouted Aggie from behind him. She slammed her fists into the ground, which shook everything within sight, shattering windows and pushing over a couple of the barricades in front of Noah. The troll look confused, and looked like it might panic. That wouldn’t be good this close, thought Noah, it’ll most likely panic all over my head. He swiped two orcs down that attempted to catch him off guard, and then watched the troll, its eyes wide with fear.

‘What are you doing, Aggie?’ shouted Ethan backing away from the orcs, towards the steps of the house.

‘Making my exit! Gotta be wi some style, me boy! Get up ere, all of e!’
Noah began to step backwards as the troll looked like it might turn to run. From out of the corner of his eye, a blur of motion caught his attention. It was Imrand, incensed and full of rage, wildly swinging a short-bladed sword tinged with green.

Noah parried the first few blows, but they were so fast he was beaten back. He was now sweating profusely, and the last of his energy was being sapped by Imrand’s ferocity. Regaining his footing, Noah dodged more swings of Imrand's blade, and took the opportunity to take a pot shot at the flailing orc; he was swearing madly and screaming in orcish, and there seemed no end to his attacks.

‘Come on, Noah,’ shouted Ethan from behind him, ‘we gotta go!’

Noah couldn’t find a way through Imrand's attacks; he was barely dodging the blows, and never had time for a single attack back. Aggie slammed the ground twice more, and the ground began to give way. He could hear the mansion behind him breaking up and the ground beneath it began to slide towards the Edge. Aggie was taking the house off the Edge. The barricades, the orcs and trolls were going with it, including Noah, Ethan, Anath and Aggie.

‘What are you doing? The house!’ Ethan shouted.

‘Like I said, makin me exit look good. Dunt worry bout me, boy, go help yer brother! Anath, you go help Oz and Aldebert get that thing outa the shed! Quick!’

Ethan jumped several steps at a time and hurtled towards Noah and Anath headed back in through the now almost fully destroyed front door towards the back of the house.

Ethan reached Noah just as he’d beaten Imrand back, and followed up Noah’s attack with a carefully timed blow, which struck him full in the face. Noah then leaped forward and thrust his sword deep into Imrand’s chest. Noah drove the hilt in as far as it would go, and whispered into Imrand’s ear, ‘Tell your master you failed to kill me when you meet him in hell!’

Imrand’s body fell limply to the ground, and Noah turned to Ethan, ‘Thank you, brother.’

‘No problem; it’s about time I saved you. Come on lets get out of here!’

Ethan began to follow Noah but stopped suddenly and looked right into Noah’s eyes, who had stopped to help him up the last step, as a wave of shock swept over his face.

‘Ethan?’

Ethan didn’t answer; instead he dropped to his knees.

‘Ethan! No! What the…?’ Noah dropped to his knees beside Ethan, and as he threw his arms around him, he felt the long, cold blade of a knife mix with the feeling of warm blood. He looked behind Ethan to see Imrand sink to the ground, his arm outstretched towards them. Ethan looked up into Noah’s eyes, and pawed at his shoulders while Noah got a grip on him.

‘Ethan, hang on!’ The tears were already bursting forth from Noah’s eyes as he tried desperately to get Ethan to stand.

‘Put me down…please….Noah….’ Ethan stammered gasping for air, his hands shaking wildly. He embraced his brother with all the strength he could manage. Noah, meanwhile, slowly pulled the knife from Ethan’s back and held him.

Ethan raised his head to Noah’s ear, ‘I’m scared, Noah….help me….please….’

Noah looked again into the eyes of his brother, ‘I’m sorry, Ethan….I…I love you….’

Ethan smiled, again gasping and fighting for breath, ‘Father…he loved you…I….I….’

Noah grasped Ethan’s head within his hands as he laid him down on the steps again, ‘Ethan,’ he said softly. ‘Just hold on, you’re doing really well, come on, just a little longer…’

‘Noah, e’s gone, come on, we ave t go,’ came Aggies soft tones from close behind him.

‘I’m not leaving him here!’ Noah screamed.

The first of the orcs were beginning to realize what was going on and began making their way towards them. The house was also gaining momentum, slipping now yard by yard rather than inch by inch.

‘Come on, boy, we’re goin now! Leave him here; he’s dead!’

Noah looked up into her eyes. They were steel grey and full of determination. He hated her for being so insensitive, but he knew she was right. She was so cold and uncaring, but as he looked into her eyes, what was that flicker deep down there somewhere? There was definitely something; perhaps it was a flicker of doubt, perhaps it was a flicker of compassion, perhaps sadness. Whatever it was, it was gone and no more than a memory. But it snapped Noah into action. He sheathed his sword, grabbed Ethan and heaved him onto his shoulder. Aggie sprinted up the steps after him, obviously deciding not to argue. They hurried through the house and came out into the yard behind it in front of the shed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top