Troy: Fall of Kings Question

kgdl120201

New Member
Joined
May 11, 2009
Messages
2
Hello everyone, I just finished the last of the Troy series. All three books were amazing, but I did have one nagging question. Towards the end of Fall of Kings, Kalkheus was stabbed by a Mykene warrior outside of Troy. As he was dying, he saw a huge man coming toward him with light seemingly radiating from him. The man was also described as having a limp. Maybe I am not seeing the forest for the trees, but who is this man?

Thanks for your help....
 
Kalkheus was the smith right? Can't think who the man with the limp was but its been a while since i read Troy series, maybe it was one of the gods?
 
Yes, Kalkheus was the smith.

I thought that at first it was the god Hephaistos since he was the smith to the gods, but I have two issues with that theory.

-First of all, I believe Hephaistos was completely lame and could not walk at all (if my memory serves me correctly)
-Second, Gemmell never really acknowledges the gods as being real. He doesn't have them directly involved in the story like Homer had them. In fact at various points thoughout the series, he even implies that the gods were just made up by the Greek people as a way of coping with life by giving them a reason for random things that would happen.

These reason make me doubt that it was any of the gods, but I can't think of anyone else it could be either.
 
I can remember that Kallides had a limb but im not sure if it was him. I think it said that Kalkheus thought it was Apollo Lord of the silver bow or maybe it was the god of war as Kalkheus created the ultimate weapon.
 
Remember Gershom, the renegade Egyptian prince who eventually became captain of Aeneas's ship, the Xanthos, the Burner Ship? His real name was Prince Ahmose. He had a younger brother, Prince Thutmose. He fled to Kretos to escape the wrath of his grandfather, the Pharaoh, after he had slain two Egyptian royal guards when they attacked a Jewish slave woman.

Kassandra, youngest daughter of Priam, who could see the future, foretold Gershom's (Ahmose's) future return to Egypt, in the process also making Gershom (Ahmose) recall his earliest memories of his young childhood in Egypt. You see, he never knew that he was an adopted Jewish child, until the prophecy session with Kassandra. He had always thought that he was of the Pharaoh's own flesh n blood.

Now, my first read of Troy I, II n III have led me to conclude that Gershom/Ahmose was Moses himself. But the prophet who Gershom/Ahmose had brought with him from the Egyptian quarter of Troy, to treat a dying Aeneas with maggot therapy, was an older prophet, preceding Moses.

The chronology may not have fitted in perfectly, though, between the proposed time of the Trojan War n the estimated time of Moses's existence. But it was close enough, in the vast time frame of ancient history. Many scholars say that Troy occurred anywhere around 1250 to 1400 BC. While the time of Moses was ca 1300 to 1450 BC. Well, something like that.

Anyway, it's just fiction, isnt it? Written for our entertainment most of all. But all credit to David. What he had done was craft in an appearance - more than a cameo appearance - for Moses in his Troy story. Which is absolutely fantastic, I think.

David also involved his Hector in the famous Battle of Kadesh between the Egyptians n the Hittites, said to be the first big war in history. Another piece of brilliant inspiration.

Could the huge guy with the halo, who walked with a limp, whom Khalkeus the Egyptian swordsmith saw in his dying moments, have been Moses himself? I have to read Troy again to reconfirm this first assessment.
 
Last edited:
Yes, I've re-checked it. David's Gershom, a.k.a. Prince Ahmose, was definitely Moses.
 
I think it is made clear that the lame man is Hephaestus, the Greek god of smiths. I find that somewhat ironic. Hephastus was the husband of Aphrodite. She was the one who could be said to have started the Trojan War in mythology, as she was the one who gave Helen to Paris.
 

Back
Top