The Trials of Jason Kingsley

Status
Not open for further replies.

hooteh

New Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2009
Messages
2
Hi all,
Apologies for posting a critique request as my first ever post here but the only reviews i'm getting is from my wife and she's not the hugest sci-fi fan! This is a story I've been looking to write for a while, I've written 10k words so far and it's looking like it might be something I get to novel length in the end. Any critique is gratefully accepted :D


Introduction

As rumors go, it wasn’t a bad one. People were missing, taken from the town by monsters. It spread through the township of Sheaf Field like ivy, climbing and winding, touching everything it found with a little fear and doubt. It was started by the wife of one of the Marshalls. Her husband Jared had been out searching in the pastures out past the deep nothing and had seen something that meant he had drunk a whole bottle of Jastor’s best potato brew. He slurred on and on about some sort of beast that walked on cloven hooves and carried a weapon that fired long, cruel arrows. It had apparently nearly killed his partner trying to drag him away to who knows where and had just vanished into nothing. He collapsed into a drunk, crying heap soon after that. She couldn’t sleep that night for thinking her husband was crazy and was so tired the next day that she accidentally let the story slip to the locksmith. He has always had a loose tongue so the rumor didn’t take long to find strong roots after that. By the time it was proved true, there were fifteen people missing.


‘How could you keep this from us?’ shouted the man from the front of the room.
The town meeting had been called when a group had tried to break into the Marshalls office to find out the truth and things had gotten out of hand.
‘Simply put Roger, we did not want to spread fear across the town. It seems our fears were well founded’, the town’s magister said reasonably.
‘How are we supposed to gather the harvest for the cold times?’, said Eoin, one of the farmers. ‘I’ve heard that most people were taken from out in the wastelands, the only good land for miles is out near there so how can we risk more people?’ At this everyone stood up and started shouting out opinions and complaints.
The magister stood up with his palms held out to quiet the meeting down.
‘We are putting plans in place to ensure each harvest patrol is accompanied by at least two Marshalls. It is our main concern to ensure that the township has enough food to last the winter so please try not to worry.’
‘How long has it been since someone went missing?’ one woman asked from the back of the room.
The Chief Marshall, an old weathered man called Josiah Grey who had very tired looking eyes and a pink ruddy complexion stood.
‘Jason Kingsley, the young boy who lived with his mother at the edge of town went missing seven days ago. He was playing with some other boys on the edge of the deep nothing… apologies… the wasteland and he went missing. No one saw anything apart from a couple of his friends and they haven’t given us anything useful’. He sat down heavily, looking down at the ground. Everyone gasped, his mother was well liked and no one had seen her in a while.


‘When are we going to get our damn people back!?’ shouted a man from the back of the room.
Everyone turned around. A wiry man with black and grey hair sat at the back of the room wringing his hands.
‘Sam, we’ve talked about this. There’s no evidence that any of the people out there are still alive. If we find any then we will send the Marshalls out straight away. Until then I’m not going to risk any more of our people and that’s the end of it.’ The man got up and looked around the room with a furious expression on his face.
‘I tell you now, any real human being would just get out there and comb every inch of wasteland they could find, whether or not it’s dangerous! I’m going first light, anyone who wants in can come see me at the tavern.’ he shoved his chair back and stormed out of the room.
The magister turned aside and whispered something to Josiah.
One man put his hand up. ‘Yes John?’
‘Magister, there are roughly 1100 people living here. Are there any plans to make sure no one else goes missing?’
‘Yes, we are putting in place a census check and some other security measures to protect us all from what has happened.’ The magister sat down and folded his hands on his lap before addressing the meeting again.
‘Please everyone; trust me when I say we meant no harm in not allowing this to get out. Now trust usto protect you as we always have done. Go home and you will see that no more people go missing and we can put this all behind us.’


A few people looked satisfied at what the magister had said and stood up to head for the door of the grouping hall. The meeting broke up after that as people began heading home. It was dark and raining outside, the track outside the hall was beginning to turn into a river of mud and the first people to leave hunkered down against the rain before heading into the darkness. Some folk from around town liked to stick around after the meetings to gossip with their friends and rub shoulders with the town leaders so they mingled in the centre of the large hall talking animatedly.


Suddenly, bell started ringing from the direction of the town gate. Josiah Gray ran out of the hall, followed by a stream of other people. When they reached the gate, Claire Atikins, the young Marshall who was left on guard duty was stood at the top of the tower gesturing frantically over the gate.
‘What is it, Atikins!?’ the Chief Marshall shouted, wiping rain water out of his eyes as he struggled to see the Marshall at the top of the tower.
‘There’s someone out there Josiah!’
Josiah raced to the ladder and climbed quickly up. The people on the floor heard the two Marshalls having a heated conversation and saw them pointing out over the gate.
‘Just open it!’, the Chief shouted and slid down the ladder, thudding into the mud at the bottom with a grunt. Everyone heard the steam engine let out a hiss of hot air and Josiah threw back a large metal switch next to the tower. The large metal gate that covered the entrance to the town gave a squeal of protest and started to slowly rise. It was very heavy because it was made from the thickest metals that could be scavenged from the wastelands. Everyone looked out up the track that led down to the township and saw a tall, thin figure staggering down towards the gate.


As the figure reached the pools of light cast by the guard tower, they could see that it was Jason Kingsley, the boy that had been taken seven days ago. He staggered towards the group behind the gate who moved back from him as he approached. Now they could take in all the details of the teenager. He was tall, thin and roughly 5 foot 7 tall. His black hair was lank and plastered to his head and the side of his face by the rain. He was also covered head to toe in rough splashes and gouts of blood with rips and tears all over his clothes. In one hand he held a long, cruel looking sword with blood stains all along the blade. In the other hand he held the head of a brutal looking man. It was swaying back and forth from long brown hair that was tangled in the boy's bruised and bloody fingers. As the group looked at the head they realized it was just wrong. The face was a little too long, the mouth was too wide and too feral. As Jason came to a halt he dropped it on the floor and everyone saw as the head rolled to a stop that it had two horns sprouting from just above the forehead.


Josiah looked at Anne and said, ‘Get down to Thorpe Hall Road and fetch his mother, she lives behind the Medicae’s lodgings. Anne ran off with a swish of her leather cloak and Josiah stepped forward to grab Jason by the shoulders.
‘Jason! What happened to you, where have you been? What the hell is that thing on the floor?’ The young boy looked back at him vaguely and slurred, ‘I, I don’t know… I don’t remember.’ He shook his head, as though a fly was bothering him, then his eyes rolled back and he collapsed.
 
Last edited:
Greetings, and welcome to SFFC ^.^ I'm still fairly a newbie, too, but I wanna say hi. Now, before I begin, I'm gonna state that when I edit, I am using American publishing standards, so please don't beat me up if something I say/correct is fine wherever you live. ^.^ Here we go.

~Her husband Jared had been out searching in the pastures out past the deep nothing and had seen something that meant he had drunk a whole bottle of Jastor’s best potato brew.~
Two of the word "out" far too close together. In fact, the second one could be omitted. And if he was drunk, what was could he possibly be searching for to take him so far out of town? I don't know much about drunks, but I'd think he'd have passed out before he either got there to see this creature or back to talk about it.

~
He collapsed into a drunk, crying heap soon after that. She couldn’t sleep that night...~
Before this, you were mostly talking about Jared, then suddenly you have "She" jump in. I think a name would fit better here.

~
He has always had a loose tongue so the rumor didn’t take long to find strong roots after that. By the time it was proved true, there were fifteen people missing.~
A few odd changes here. Try "His had always been a loose tongue/He had always had a loose tongue, so the rumor didn't take long to find strong roots after that. By the time it was proven true, there were fifteen people missing."

~Marshall's office.

~I'm thinking the right word Magistrate, not Magister.

~
‘Simply put Roger, we did not want to spread fear across the town. It seems our fears were well founded’, the town’s magister said reasonably.~
Again, the ford "fear" is used twice, too close together. Just sounds repetitive. Maybe replace the first one with "panic" or something else. Also, this seems to be missing something.... Hmm.... "..spread fear across the town until we were certain of any danger." Not sure, but it's about in that area after "spread" that something of that sort seems missing.

~
‘I’ve heard that most people were taken from out in the wastelands, the only good land for miles is out near there so how can we risk more people?~
Period or semicolon after wastelands, and start a new sentence; otherwise it's a run-on. Now, the first sentence is confusing. The wastelands are sounding like the place to be at first, then made out to be bad. Might want to adjust it. I'm not sure precisely what you're meaning here, so I don't have a suggestion.

~
The Chief Marshall, an old weathered man called Josiah Grey who had very tired looking eyes and a pink ruddy complexion stood.~
Use either pink or ruddy, not both, and comma after "complexion."

~This seems like a small town where everyone knows everything about everyone else. This kid's been gone a week, and they're only now realizing it?

~
‘When are we going to get our damn people back!?’ shouted a man from the back of the room. Everyone turned around. A wiry man with black and grey hair sat at the back of the room wringing his hands~
Another double, only a whole phrase this time. Maybe instead of "the back of the room" for the second one, use "standing/sitting near the door/entrance." Also, his outcry is originally a question, so I think it should be "?!"

~I have a thing about numbers in text, and it's personal preference, but I'd just type out "eleven hundred."

~...
was stood at the top of the tower gesturing frantically over the gate.~
"...was standing at the top of the tower, gesturing frantically over the gate."

~
‘What is it, Atikins!?’~
Again with the "?!" switch. And so far, everyone's been being called by their first name, but suddenly she's called by her last. It just seems a little out of place.

~...
a large metal switch next to the tower. The large metal gate...~
I'm seeing a pattern, hahaha.

~
‘Just open it!’, the Chief shouted... The large metal gate that covered the entrance to the town gave a squeal of protest and started to slowly rise.~
Okay, now, this is a little contradictory in my mind. If you're going to open this kind of door [I'm seeing a drawbridge after saying it's rising], you would lower it to allow entry.


~
It was very heavy because it was made from the thickest metals that could be scavenged from the wastelands.~
Now, this I think could be relayed a little better, or even omitted. A gate like this to close or open a town to the world is already going to be big.

~
Now they could take in all the details of the teenager. He was tall, thin and roughly 5 foot 7 tall.~
Saying tall, then 5'7'' is a little repetitive. I'd just get rid of the 5' 7'', use a different measurement [like, "nearly six feet/two meters in height], or try to compare it to something else.

~
As Jason came to a halt he dropped it on the floor...~
Floor or ground? I find there is a distinct visual difference in my own mind. Floor assumes that a person is inside [but it can't very well rain indoors, unless there's a leak, haha], while ground is most definitely outside.

~
‘Get down to Thorpe Hall Road and fetch his mother, she lives behind the Medicae’s lodgings.~
Period after mother. And since this is such a small town, I think that Anne would already know where the boy's mother lives. Also you missed the apostrophe/quote after lodgings.

~
‘Jason! What happened to you, where have you been? What the hell is that thing on the floor?~
Try
"Jason! What happened to you? Where have you been? What the hell is that thing on the ground?"

Mks, now for some other stuff I missed. After you have a quote, and it ends with a question mark ["words?"] you don't need a comma afterward [I've seen " 'words?', "]

Now, to me it feels odd having quotes surrounded by just the apostrophes. Too used to seeing the "...words..." But it still works. I can understand that people are speaking.

Too many names starting with "J"! Way confusing trying to remember which "J"-name belonged to whom.

Maybe vary up the policing system. Instead of all Marshalls [which gets a tad confusing], you have your Chief Marshall, one regular Marshall, and perhaps a Sheriff or Deputy.

Overall a neat story [And I really liked this simile:
"It spread through the township of Sheaf Field like ivy, climbing and winding, touching everything it found with a little fear and doubt."]. I'd be interested to know how this boy killed this ogre/demon creature and then not remember.
 
Agreeing with what Misting Wolf said, while hunting out some others (if I duplicate, apologies)

Her husband Jared had been out searching in the pastures out past the deep nothing and had seen something that meant he had drunk a whole bottle of Jastor’s best potato brew.
It is not clear that what he saw made him go and drink; indeed, MW has assumed he saw it because he had already imbibed

We are putting plans in place to ensure each harvest patrol is accompanied by at least two Marshalls.
"patrol" sounds very military; wouldn't the harvesters who needed protection be more in work gangs?

I’m going first light, anyone who wants in can come see me at the tavern.’
semicolon rather than comma.

‘Magister, there are roughly 1100 people living here. Are there any plans to make sure no one else goes missing?’
Why would he mention how many people they were, a fact presumably common knowledge? That feels awfully like infodump.

Claire Atikins, the young Marshall who was left on guard duty
had been left?

Suddenly, bell started ringing from the direction of the town gate.
a bell

It was dark and raining outside, the track outside the hall was beginning to turn into a river of mud
semicolon instead of comma

Everyone heard the steam engine let out a hiss of hot air
Seeing that it's a steam engine, the 'hiss' would be steam, wouldn't it? And leaving the engine hot all night? (you don't just light a steam engine and expect it to start) Hadn't they heard of counterweights?


He staggered towards the group behind the gate who moved back from him as he approached.
comma after "gate"

He was also covered head to toe in rough splashes and gouts of blood with rips and tears all over his clothes.
comma after "blood"

everyone saw as the head rolled to a stop that it had two horns sprouting from just above the forehead.
commas round "as the head rolled to a stop"

, ‘Get down to Thorpe Hall Road and fetch his mother, she lives behind the Medicae’s lodgings.
close quotation marks after "lodgings"

Please read the formatting 'sticky at the head of critiques; there are several paragraph breaks not marked by line spaces.
 
Thank you for the comments, I'm going to redraft and apply what you've said through the other chapters I've written. Also apologies for the piece not fitting into the forum guidelines, will make sure anything I post in future does so :)
 
[FONT=&quot]Hi hooteh, Welcome to the Chrons. You'll find a great community here and I'm sure you will fit right in. For future reference please refer to this thread on how to properly format submissions for critiques: http://www.sffchronicles.co.uk/forum/40133-if-you-ignore-this-your-post-may-be.html.

I'll try to help you out with your piece now. :) (Sorry if I repeat anything someone else has said.)

As rumors go, it wasn’t a bad one. People were missing, taken from the town by monsters.
I'm not sure why you are putting "missing" and "monsters" in italics. It seems like an unnecessary emphasis.
It spread through the township of Sheaf Field like ivy, climbing and winding, touching everything it found with a little fear and doubt.
I would think gramatically this sentence should be "It spread through the township of Sheaf Field like ivy; climbing, winding and touching everything it found with a little fear and doubt." As a side note I think it should be everybody or everyone, not everythign.
It was started by the wife of one of the Marshalls.
Is "Marshalls" capitalized because it is the proper name of several men that live in the town (John Marshall, Chris Marshall, etc.) or are you refering the title/job of marshall? If you are refering to the latter then I would think it doesn't need to be capitalized.
Her husband Jared had been out searching in the pastures out past the deep nothing and had seen something that meant he had drunk a whole bottle of Jastor’s best potato brew.
This sentence is just very confusing to me. I know that the 'her husband' is refering to the 'wife' in the previous sentence, but I don't think the wording is right. It might sound better like this: "Her husband, Jared, had been out searching in the pastures past the deep nothing. And based on what he said he saw, he must have drunk a whole bottle of Jastor's best potato brew." I may be confused here though, did he drink the alcohol and then "see" something in his drunkenness or did he see something and because he was scared or whatever get drunk afterwards?
He slurred on and on about some sort of beast that walked on cloven hooves and carried a weapon that fired long, cruel arrows.
Ooo, I love this description.
It had apparently nearly killed his partner trying to drag him away to who knows where and had just vanished into nothing.
"Apparently, It had nearly killed his partner while trying to drag him away to who knows where and then had jsut vanished into nothing." That sounds a little better I think.
He collapsed into a drunk, crying heap soon after that. She couldn’t sleep that night for thinking her husband was crazy and was so tired the next day that she accidentally let the story slip to the locksmith.
”She couldn’t sleep that night, all she could think about was her husband’s crazy story and if he had lost his mind. She was so tired the next day that she accidentally let the story slip to the locksmith.” The second sentence is the same, I just changed the second half of the first sentence. Please take it as you want to, I don’t want to come across as writing your story for you! :p[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
He has always had a loose tongue so the rumor didn’t take long to find strong roots after that. By the time it was proved true, there were fifteen people missing.
Maybe “He’s always had…” instead of “He has always had”. “proved” should be “proven” and there shouldn’t be a comma after ‘true’.
‘How could you keep this from us?’ shouted the man from the front of the room.
There isn’t any transition! The scene switched so quickly. Maybe you should put something other than a space to indicate the change in scene?
The town meeting had been called when a group had tried to break into the Marshalls office to find out the truth and things had gotten out of hand.
‘Simply put Roger, we did not want to spread fear across the town. It seems our fears were well founded’, the town’s magister said reasonably.
I don’t think you need to put ‘reasonably’, it is very unnecessary.
‘How are we supposed to gather the harvest for the cold times?’, said Eoin, one of the farmers. ‘I’ve heard that most people were taken from out in the wastelands, the only good land for miles is out near there so how can we risk more people?’
Comma after ‘farmers’, not period.
At this everyone stood up and started shouting out opinions and complaints.
No need to say “At this”, it is understood that everyone stands up after he says that.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
The magister stood up with his palms held out to quiet the meeting down.
The magister wasn’t standing before when he spoke?
‘We are putting plans in place to ensure each harvest patrol is accompanied by at least two Marshalls. It is our main concern to ensure that the township has enough food to last the winter so please try not to worry.’
Did you mean harvest patrol? Or did you mean the farmers? I think you can get rid of “It is” and say “Our main concern is to ensure…”[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
‘How long has it been since someone went missing?’ one woman asked from the back of the room.
It should be “A woman asked” not “one” in my opinion.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
The Chief Marshall, an old weathered man called Josiah Grey who had very tired looking eyes and a pink ruddy complexion stood.
You are missing commas. “The Chief Marshall, an old, weathered man called Josiah Grey who had very tired looking eyes and a pink, ruddy complexion, stood.”[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
‘Jason Kingsley, the young boy who lived with his mother at the edge of town went missing seven days ago. He was playing with some other boys on the edge of the deep nothing… apologies… the wasteland and he went missing. No one saw anything apart from a couple of his friends and they haven’t given us anything useful’. He sat down heavily, looking down at the ground. Everyone gasped, his mother was well liked and no one had seen her in a while.
I’m not sure why everyone gasps here, his statement doesn’t seem that dramatic.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
‘When are we going to get our damn people back!?’ shouted a man from the back of the room.
Everyone turned around. A wiry man with black and grey hair sat at the back of the room wringing his hands.
‘Sam, we’ve talked about this. There’s no evidence that any of the people out there are still alive. If we find any then we will send the Marshalls out straight away. Until then I’m not going to risk any more of our people and that’s the end of it.’ The man got up and looked around the room with a furious expression on his face.
Which man got up? The man in the back of the room or the marshall?
‘I tell you now, any real human being would just get out there and comb every inch of wasteland they could find, whether or not it’s dangerous! I’m going first light, anyone who wants in can come see me at the tavern.’ he shoved his chair back and stormed out of the room.
The magister turned aside and whispered something to Josiah.
One man put his hand up. ‘Yes John?’
Who is this speaking here?
‘Magister, there are roughly 1100 people living here. Are there any plans to make sure no one else goes missing?’
‘Yes, we are putting in place a census check and some other security measures to protect us all from what has happened.’ The magister sat down and folded his hands on his lap before addressing the meeting again.
Would someone really be sitting when they address a crowd that big?
‘Please everyone; trust me when I say we meant no harm in not allowing this to get out. Now trust usto protect you as we always have done. Go home and you will see that no more people go missing and we can put this all behind us.’
I don’t understand why you have the semicolon in there.
A few people looked satisfied at what the magister had said and stood up to head for the door of the grouping hall. The meeting broke up after that as people began heading home. It was dark and raining outside, the track outside the hall was beginning to turn into a river of mud and the first people to leave hunkered down against the rain before heading into the darkness. Some folk from around town liked to stick around after the meetings to gossip with their friends and rub shoulders with the town leaders so they mingled in the centre of the large hall talking animatedly.
You can get rid of the second sentence I think. This is a lot of telling here, and not much showing. Its like we have been watching this scene from a distance. I couldn’t relate to any of the characters. :eek: Maybe you were intending for that?
Suddenly, bell started ringing from the direction of the town gate. Josiah Gray ran out of the hall, followed by a stream of other people.
I thought most of the people had already left the buildy?[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
When they reached the gate, Claire Atikins, the young Marshall who was left on guard duty was stood at the top of the tower gesturing frantically over the gate.
‘What is it, Atikins!?’ the Chief Marshall shouted, wiping rain water out of his eyes as he struggled to see the Marshall at the top of the tower.
‘There’s someone out there Josiah!’
Josiah raced to the ladder and climbed quickly up. The people on the floor heard the two Marshalls having a heated conversation and saw them pointing out over the gate.
‘floor’ should be ‘ground’[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
‘Just open it!’, the Chief shouted and slid down the ladder, thudding into the mud at the bottom with a grunt.
Wouldn’t you sink into mud?[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
Everyone heard the steam engine let out a hiss of hot air and Josiah threw back a large metal switch next to the tower.
Wow, I didn’t realize there was any mechanics in this world until this point, maybe you want to hint at it before hand somehow?[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
The large metal gate that covered the entrance to the town gave a squeal of protest and started to slowly rise. It was very heavy because it was made from the thickest metals that could be scavenged from the wastelands. Everyone looked out up the track that led down to the township and saw a tall, thin figure staggering down towards the gate.
Shouldn’t it be “led from the township”?
As the figure reached the pools of light cast by the guard tower, they could see that it was Jason Kingsley, the boy that had been taken seven days ago.
How was there any light, if it was raining?[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
He staggered towards the group behind the gate who moved back from him as he approached. Now they could take in all the details of the teenager. He was tall, thin and roughly 5 foot 7 tall.
There’s no need to give his exact height since that information really makes virtually no difference whatsoever to the story. Unless later on only 5 foot 7 people get taken away. :eek:[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
His black hair was lank and plastered to his head and the side of his face by the rain. He was also covered head to toe in rough splashes and gouts of blood with rips and tears all over his clothes. In one hand he held a long, cruel looking sword with blood stains all along the blade.
I don’t think there can be “blood stains” on metal, maybe just say “blood all along the sword” or “the remnants of blood”. But anyway, shouldn’t have the blood been washed off the sword in the rain?[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
In the other hand he held the head of a brutal looking man. It was swaying back and forth from long brown hair that was tangled in the boy's bruised and bloody fingers. As the group looked at the head they realized it was just wrong. The face was a little too long, the mouth was too wide and too feral. As Jason came to a halt he dropped it on the floor and everyone saw as the head rolled to a stop that it had two horns sprouting from just above the forehead.
I love the description of the head, very menacing.
Josiah looked at Anne and said, ‘Get down to Thorpe Hall Road and fetch his mother, she lives behind the Medicae’s lodgings. Anne ran off with a swish of her leather cloak and Josiah stepped forward to grab Jason by the shoulders.
Who is Anne??
‘Jason! What happened to you, where have you been? What the hell is that thing on the floor?’ The young boy looked back at him vaguely and slurred, ‘I, I don’t know… I don’t remember.’ He shook his head, as though a fly was bothering him, then his eyes rolled back and he collapsed.
Omg very freaky![/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]I loved your story, I think you have some work to do though. I want to keep reading so that is very good sign. Usually I don’t read fantasy either so this really drew me in. Take my criticisms with a grain of salt though and use only what you think is right. :)
[/FONT]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top