Like Tears In Rain

Status
Not open for further replies.

reiver33

Only Forward
Supporter
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
1,982
Location
Dumfries
I've taken the liberty of duplicating this from another thread in search of more feedback.

One

I watched a couple share a last embrace, wreathed in flame.

Then a sudden rain squall swept Nelson Square, blotting out my view while the CCTV wiper struggled with a deluge it had never been designed for. Eventually the shot cleared enough to reveal two smouldering bodies on the pavement, one still moving, but both burnt beyond recognition at this distance.


I swore under my breath and set aside the paperwork I’d been working on, dumping it back into the already over-flowing tray. The switchboard managed to get me an outside line but I could tell from the background whispers that my call was being shunted over half of London; the remaining exchanges still coping, barely.

“Cleansing department.”

“Hi, this is Detective Inspector Vic Morden over at Justice.”

Acting Detective Inspector” murmured Anderson from across the desk, as he never misses a trick. I refused to scowl at his jibe and carried on, regardless.

“Look, we’ve got a couple who torched themselves in Nelson Square, Southwark, and I was wondering if you could get a crew over there before the dogs get busy.”

“They both dead then? I’m not going to send a wagon only to have some do-gooder call an ambulance instead.”

“Well, I won’t ******** you but one of them is still moving…”

I heard the sign of exasperation and decided to throw in a sweetener.

“…but, trust me, they’re way beyond medical help. Look, send a wagon and if they’re still twitching have your boys give a thumbs down to the camera; I’ll have a Paramedic swing by for an assisted termination – can’t say fairer than that?”

There was a pause, and I could hear the shuffle of paper as he consulted a clipboard.

“Yeah, OK. I’ve got a collection in SE1 just now anyway, and I’ll have them take a gander. Thumbs up if they’re stiffs then?”

“You got it, and thanks again.”

I hung up and checked the monitor; neither prone figure was moving now and the few pedestrians about were giving them a wide berth. It may sound harsh but no hospital was going to treat a severe burns victim, one who was probably going to die anyway, and if I did call in the Paramedic then at least they would be spared lying about on a trolley in an unregarded corridor for several hours.

Detective Sergeant Anderson signed off on a report and dumped it in the ‘out’ tray, placing his pen down ever-so precisely before rubbing his eyes.

“Technically speaking, someone should check the bodies for identification, so that the next of kin can be informed. Might save the state the cost of burial.”

“Burial? Didn’t you read that last directive? That’s why I called cleansing straight off.”

He gave me that slightly superior smile that I’d come to loath.

“And here was I thinking you were still the consummate professional; everything by the book, upholding the common good, even with half the planet reduced to ashes.”

“The book changed, I haven’t. Anyway, those two stepped outside society the moment they lit themselves up, and I’ve got no time for those that won’t hold on.”

The intercom buzzed before Anderson could slag me off for indifference after the fact – seemingly a heinous crime in his world view.

“I have a Major Saunders on line two for you, Inspector. He’s been passed down by Divison.”

“Yeah, thanks Heather, I’ll take it.”

I really didn’t like dealing with the Armed Forces at the best of times, but I was feeling particularly irritated by Anderson and just knew I was going to take it out on the hapless Major.

“This is DI Morden. How can I help His Majesties finest?”

“Good morning Inspector, this is Major Saunders of the Second Composite Battalion. Sorry to trouble you with what, in all probability, is the proverbial wide goose chase, but we have a situation which is more properly your preserve. Thought I’ve give you a bell while it was still under wraps, so to speak.”

At least he hadn’t started off by reminding me I was technically required to assist him under the provisions of Martial Law; I’ve found some get really riled when I point out you actually need an army for the martial bit - something clearly absent these days.

I switched to speaker so that I wouldn’t have to brief Anderson later, if need be.

“A situation, Major? What kind of situation?”

“The daughter of one of my sergeants - good man, rock solid - has been found dead. He popped home on a 48-hour pass to check up on her – the mother absented herself a while ago, you understand – and there she was. Called in our chaps, of course, even though it looked like, ah, a planned departure, and everything was fine until one of the MPs apparently blurted out he thought it was murder.”

“May I ask why your sergeant didn’t call us in straight off? I’m assuming the dead girl is a civilian, after all? It’s still our…”

“Absolutely, old chap, absolutely. It’s just we always like to have a quick look-see in cases involving dependants of active personnel, just in case it’s any kind of revenge scenario.”

“Unlikely, Major, after this time – but I take your point. Any reason why the military police think this is murder and not suicide? I mean, these days killings tend to be fairly obvious and don’t require much in the way of investigation.”

“Can’t help you there, sorry. All I know is that Sergeant Harris is most dreadfully upset at any suggestion of foul play; completely unsettled by the whole affair, apparently, and I’d be failing in my duty if I didn’t do my utmost to set his mind at ease. Bad enough the poor girl had to top herself, eh?”

“Well, it’s something we’ve all had to get used to, Major.”

“Quite. So I can leave this in your capable hands then, Inspector? My two MPs and Sergeant Harris are still in situ, so if you could have someone pop round, give the place a quick once-over and reassure him it was by her own hand, so to speak, they can give him a lift back to base.”

“A funeral at the Army’s expense then?”

“Least we can do, given the circumstances. You hear such dreadful stories these days, about cursory services and ‘body disposal’; quite dreadful. Now, the address is in south-east London, a Place called Nelson Square…”

Coincidence? Both Anderson and I glanced at the monitor, still showing two blackened bodies on the rain-swept pavement.

I don’t trust coincidence.
 
There is nothing I can think of that's wrong with this piece, absolutely nothing. I am sure the grammar experts will have their say and rightly so, however, as far as flow or construction goes, I enjoyed it. It was gripping, my interest did not falter for a moment. the conversations were concise and interesting and keeps the reader occupied.

I would love to read this book!
 
Reads like *good* Stross.

I can't say better than that !!
 
He gave me that slightly superior smile that I’d come to loath.
Take out "slightly".
– seemingly a heinous crime in his world view.
Cut out seemingly.

Love the dialogue. Though, you could break up the dialogue with brief descriptions of what is going on in the scene. Once they start talking it's like they're in a bubble. Police could arriving, the general public might need to be pushed back, heck, even the media (censored or not) might pop in.

Just personal taste here: One of the strengths of first person narrative is the ability to get directly into the character's head.
Example:
"You know what they say Mike, an apple a day and all that."
"Alright, I'll take your advice." Yeah, when hell freezes over jackass.
 
Last edited:
clippedwolf said:
He gave me that slightly superior smile that I’d come to loath.

Take out "slightly".

Actually, I'd leave it in - Anderson's a sergeant, and the narrator is an inspector, so it's unlikely that he is going to use a full-on superior smile to his boss...

Chilling, reiver - I do like the coldness of the reaction to the event, and the idea that no-one stops to even look. Is the dystopian setting going to be explained later, or would we already be aware of what had happened ? As it is, it would be good as a draw-em-in at the very start of the story.

"Cleansing Department". Brrr....
 
Thanks for the feedback everyone!

This is the off-shoot from the 'too nihilistic' thread, and thus the story setting is not merely dystopian but pre-apocalyptic; the end of the world is coming, so deal with it.

I'm a big fan of 'noir' and thus a lot of my main characters tend towards a 'pulp' feel, but (acting) DCI Morden is a bloody-minded, career policeman who defines himself, his sense of worth, by his job - hence he still comes to work, still tries to keep the justice system working, even though he and everyone on the planet is doomed.

In terms of background; half the Earth (east of the Urals and west of the US) has been seared by a solar eruption, with the resulting fires pumping billions of tons of particulate matter into the atmosphere. There has been the start of global cooling and a sharp increase in rainfall. Although 'the West' has survived intact so far, the sun has entered a period of instability, so its only a matter of time...
 
This is written very well. I didn't go through it with a fine comb or anything because the story just kept me reading! I didn't even notice if there were any mistakes or anything. I can't wait for the whole thing. I think your hook (leaving it off at the "coincidence") was perfect as it keeps readers wanting more. Good job! :)

Edit: I just thought of what this reminds me very much of: The Yiddish Policemen's Union by Michael Chabon, winner of both the Hugo and Nebula Awards for best novel. Read that if you haven't as it is somewhat similar to what you are going for: the world is ending (sort of) and a detective is trying to figure out a murder case he is working on. That's a horrible description and does complete injustice to the story lol, but read it because it is an awesome book. You can look here for a better description: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Yiddish_Policemen's_Union.
 
Can I do a grammar and spelling correction? ... ..... .... ????? :D:eek:

PS. I agree with what everyone said here. Except for Pyan... I'ven't read the Yiddish something something xD ... So no, it doesn't remind me of anything :p --- Pyan, hun, don't take me wrong, 'kay? n_n' I'm merely messing with you. :D

Edit: First correction (God, I just can't hold myself back! >_<):

He gave me that slightly superior smile that I’d come to loath.
It's loathe.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/loath

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/loathe

I hope you don't mind my little correctiong... Really! I can't help myself *she looks warily over her shoulders*

They tell me to do it... *she whispers, pointing at 'something' behind her*
 
PS. I agree with what everyone said here. Except for Pyan... I'ven't read the Yiddish something something xD ... So no, it doesn't remind me of anything :p --- Pyan, hun, don't take me wrong, 'kay? n_n' I'm merely messing with you.

:eek::mad::mad::mad::mad:

Pyar
 
No problem, Runya - any corrections will be well received! I battered away at this on a night shift from a 'cold' start, so some typos are to be expected.

Cheers,

Martin
 
My problem was in the time line.


One minute these two geezers are watching a CCTV of an incident and the next some bloke with gobstoppers in his mouth is ringing and saying things like

you understand – and there she was. Called in our chaps, of course, even though it looked like, ah, a planned departure, and everything was fine until one of the MPs apparently blurted out he thought it was murder

Now we either need a period for the coincidence to mean something or there just isn't a coincidence cos there chaps were not seen in the video looking around. Ergo linkage lost.

On an apperence point the boldness of the 'normal font' against the italicised sections seemed to me a bit jarring. I had to check that the normal stuf wasn't 'bold' font - anyway it hurt my eyes but there you go, the publisher will have his own views anyway and it does show who's talking quite well
 
Last edited:
Two different events (1) sergeant's daughter - murder or suicide - which has already taken place prior to the narrative commencing, (2) self-immolation by the couple, live, on camera. The 'coincidence' is the Location.
 
Now you tell us.

*facepalms

You know up to this moment I was in belief that what we've sawn in the footage was actually the thing sergeant was reporting.
 
Sorry for the confusion, but given the implied time-line it was 'obvious' there were two different events (the curse of the know-it-all author).

Sergeant finds daughter dead and calls his unit, unit sends in the Military Police, MP freaks out grieving father with suggestion of murder, commanding officer is alerted, CO this up the food chain, senior command pass the problem side-ways to senior civilian authorities, problem comes down and is dumped on CID...

I'll try and make this clear in the next segment, but as I'm not back on night-shift until Sunday (unless called in) and my good lady wife has a whole host of things for me to do whilst in the land of the living, this may be a couple of days.
 
WHAT!!!!!

You still have a wife!!!!!!!

Where's the dedication, where's the sense of belonging.

I tell you ctg, standards are slipping.

It was never like this in the old days.

That crash last year has a lot to answer for IMO
 

I'm so, so, so, so, so, so sorry! :eek:

_______________________________________________________________

revier33 said:
I watched a couple share a last embrace, wreathed
wreathing...? Sounds better to me.
in flames[?].

Then
What's the 'then' here for?... Suggestion: remove it.
a sudden rain squall swept Nelson Square, blotting out my view while the CCTV wiper struggled with a deluge it had never been designed for.
Eventually
comma?
the shot cleared enough to reveal two smouldering bodies on the pavement, one of them still moving, but both burnt beyond recognition at this distance.
the last bit 'but...distance,' seemed a little bit off. Didn't you already say they're burning by using the word 'smoldering'? I suggest you remove what's in red. You could add another separate sentence saying that you noticed that they both burnt beyond recognition.
I swore under my breath and set aside the paperwork I’d been working on, dumping it back into the already over-flowing tray. The switchboard managed to get me an outside line but I could tell from the background whispers that my call was being shunted over half of London; the remaining exchanges still coping, barely.
The last sentence bothers me. And when a sentence bothers me, it means it has something wrong. First, I didn't understand what you meant... Then I understood --- then... ta-daaaa... Correction: replace that semi-colon for a comma.

I also suggest situating 'barely' before 'coping.'
“Cleansing department.”

“Hi, this is Detective Inspector Vic Morden over at Justice.”

Acting Detective Inspector
comma
” murmured Anderson from across the desk, as he never misses a trick.

I refused to scowl at his jibe and carried on, regardless.

“Look, we’ve got a couple who torched themselves in Nelson Square, Southwark, and I was wondering if you could get a crew over there before the dogs get busy.”

“They both dead then? I’m not going to send a wagon only to have some do-gooder call an ambulance instead.”

“Well, I won’t ********
:eek:
you but one of them is still moving…”

I heard the sign of exasperation and decided to throw in a sweetener.

“…but, trust me, they’re way beyond medical help. Look, send a wagon and if they’re still twitching
comma
have your boys give a thumbs down to the camera;
I suggest you replace the semi-colon for a normal and boring period... lol
I’ll have a Paramedic
what's with the capital p? Is he/she a special paramedic? :D
swing by for an assisted termination – can’t say fairer than that?”

There was a pause, and I could hear the shuffle of paper as he consulted a clipboard.

“Yeah, OK. I’ve got a collection in SE1 just now anyway, and I’ll have them take a gander. Thumbs up if they’re stiffs then?”

“You got it, and thanks again.”

I hung up and checked the monitor; neither prone figure was moving now and the few pedestrians about were giving them a wide berth. It may sound harsh but no hospital was going to treat a severe burns
hyphen between severe and burns ... ? Sounds kinda awkward anyway.
victim, one who was probably going to die anyway,
Does it sound better to you if it's like...

It may sound harsh but I knew no hospital was going to treat a severely burnt person who was probably going to die anyway.

?????
and if I did call in the Paramedic then at least they would be spared lying about on a trolley in an unregarded corridor for several hours.
I suggest you use a period before 'and' instead of that comma. Just too many sentences clogged together...
Detective Sergeant Anderson signed off on a report and dumped it in the ‘out’ tray, placing his pen down ever-so precisely before rubbing his eyes.

“Technically speaking, someone should check the bodies for identification, so that the next of kin can be informed. Might save the state the cost of burial.”

“Burial? Didn’t you read that last directive? That’s why I called cleansing straight off.”

He gave me that slightly superior smile that I’d come to loathe. :D

“And here was I thinking you were still the consummate professional[; ]everything by the book, upholding the common good, even with half the planet reduced to ashes.”

“The book changed,
Period instead of a comma. That sentence is done. Over. Dead. Can't use a comma there, mister *grins*
I haven’t. Anyway, those two stepped outside society the moment they lit themselves up, and I’ve got no time for those that won’t hold on.”
Cool! They lit themselves up?? Hehehe... That's very interesting.

I wonder if they regret it...
The intercom buzzed before Anderson could slag me off for indifference after the fact – seemingly a heinous crime in his world view.

I have a Major Saunders on line two for you, Inspector. He’s been passed down by Divison.”

“Yeah, thanks Heather, I’ll take it.”
I really didn’t like dealing with the Armed Forces at the best of times, but I was feeling particularly irritated by Anderson and just knew I was going to take it out on the hapless Major.
ROFL
“This is DI
D.I. or DI? ... They're two different things in my opinion.
Morden. How can I help His Majesties finest?”

Good morning Inspector, this is Major Saunders of the Second Composite Battalion. Sorry to trouble you with what, in all probability, is the proverbial wide goose chase, but we have a situation which is more properly your preserve. Thought I’ve give you a bell while it was still under wraps, so to speak.”
After the first "Inspector" you need a period instead of a comma. "This" is Major bla bla...
At least he hadn’t started off by reminding me I was technically required to assist him under the provisions of Martial Law; I’ve found some people[?] get really riled when I point out you actually need an army for the martial bit - something clearly absent these days.

I switched to speaker so that I wouldn’t have to brief Anderson later, if need be.

“A situation, Major? What kind of situation?”

The daughter of one of my sergeants - good man, rock solid
ROFL!
- has been found dead. He popped home on a 48-hour pass to check up on her – the mother absented herself a while ago, you understand – and there she was. Called in our chaps, of course, even though it looked like, ah, a planned departure, and everything was fine until one of the MPs
M.P.s or just MPs? The second, I could pronounce out loud like 'emmepss.' While the first, may I say, I can pronounce out loud as 'Emm-Pee's.'

No naughtiness on that last word ... n_n'
apparently blurted out he thought it was murder.”
“May I ask why your sergeant didn’t call us in straight off? I’m assuming the dead girl is a civilian,
Not sure, but I think there's no need for the comma here.
after all? It’s still our…”
What happened? Did the silence reign in and silenced you? Or did the guy on the line cut your words short? If he cut your words short, I think you should use a hyphen.
Absolutely, old chap, absolutely. It’s just we always like to have a quick look-see in cases involving dependants of active personnel, just in case it’s any kind of revenge scenario.”
Repeated 'case' twice. Might reconsider that.
“Unlikely, Major, after this time – but I take your point. Any reason why the military police think this is murder and not suicide? I mean, these days killings tend to be fairly obvious and don’t require much in the way of investigation.”

Can’t help you there, sorry. All I know is that Sergeant Harris is most dreadfully upset at any suggestion of foul play; completely unsettled by the whole affair, apparently, and I’d be failing in my duty if I didn’t do my utmost to set his mind at ease. Bad enough the poor girl had to top herself, eh?

“Well, it’s something we’ve all had to get used to, Major.”

Quite. So I can leave this in your capable hands then, Inspector? My two MPs and Sergeant Harris are still in situ, so if you could have someone pop round,
I won't tighten my grip on the missing 'a' on 'round' 'cause the guy is talking and he definitely sounds like an ass in my head... Hehehe... If you made this mistake on purpose, then... Well done! If you didn't... then... ... =.='
give the place a quick once-over
IN MY OPINION, you should add a comma after 'over'
and reassure him it was by her own hand,
Period instead of a comma...???? *confused*
so to speak, they can give him a lift back to base.”
“A funeral at the Army’s expense then?”

Least we can do, given the circumstances. You hear such dreadful stories these days, about cursory services and ‘body disposal’;
hyphen insteand of semi-color... ?
quite dreadful. Now, the address is in south-east London, a Place called Nelson Square…
Coincidence? Both Anderson and I glanced at the monitor, still showing two blackened bodies on the rain-swept pavement.

I don’t trust coincidence. believe in instead of trust?
Me neither.

Woaaa.... WWOOOOOAAAAAHHHAAAAHHHOOOOAAAA....

That was awesome ^^ .

I really, really liked it.

I want to tell you, though, that at first I was somewhat confused... Well, too confused for my own good, actually, 'cause --and I quote-- you were watching a couple embrace, wreathed in flame...

Which made me think "Oh! They love each other that much!"

And then the sudden rain and the 'smoldering' bodies, of which only one was moving, confused me a bit more.

I thought that the first sentence just had nothing to do with the whole story. Just something you were doing at the time. A sentece-for-my-word-count-to-get-longer sentence. That's what I thought it was.

However, when I finally reached the end, I understood. Don't ask me why.

I might be the only one to be baffled by that first sentence, but if I were you, I'd just reconsider a little about how to word out that little scene.

IMPORTANT: All I wrote and suggested on and deleted and bla bla bla is my opinion. In no way I'm a professional. In no utterly and boring way I'm always right.

I'm no perfect writer. And hell! I'm no perfect editor.

And please, don't take any of my suggestions in the wrong way. I'm just here to help. And, after all, you posted this in the Critiques section... *grins smugly* So you just can't tell me to shut up! ... MWAHAHAHA...

~You should know I've got a little mental disorders... Like having multiple personalities, suffering from paranoia, and being a narcissist... LoL~

Oh! And I'm 33% Autist. Hahahaha, according to some freaky test on the web I am! *lmao*

If I'm wrong in any way with my suggestions, I beg you to differ with me and explain how it is correct.

Regard me kindly,

KrazyRunya

PS. Also, if I repeated any suggestion that has been made before, please forgive me.

EDIT: GOD... I need a massage... on my neck! back! shoulders! legs! butt! hair! everywhere!! this took forever! >_<
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top