Nineteen Eighty-Four, by George Orwell

Omphalos

הדרךקפיצת
Joined
Oct 24, 2007
Messages
777



If you ask me (and for the record, nobody ever does, even if I prompt them with a question like that) there is a little bit of overlap among the lists of best SF books ever written, and the best novels ever written, probably by five or six books. I'm sure that a few out there will find that a shocking idea, hopefully not everyone, but I really believe that a few novels - nothing written recently, mind you, except maybe for The Road - managed to achieve something stellar, something worthy of serious praise outside of SF circles. I will be the first one to admit that I occasionally sing the praises of some SF that other people find abhorrent. Consider my fetish for zombie literature as a case in point. But I have been reading and writing about SF for long enough now that I think I am capable of differentiating the stinkers and the nuggets of gold either by using good old fashioned community standards, or with a critical method. Unfortunately there is one factor that makes my job of spreading the Word about these novels as tough as neutronium nails: Many of them, as you soon shall see, were not marketed as SF to begin with, and since "SF" is not only a sub-genre of literature, but also a marketing category, I have sometimes had a hard time getting others to accept obvious SF novels as SF for the mere fact that they were distributed through the mainstream system. This week's selection happens to be a book that is in fact generally acknowledged as a masterpiece of twentieth century literature. It is so obvious to me that it is SF also that I personally cannot fathom the reaction I get from some quarters when I mention that fact, but nevertheless, get that reaction I do. The book is George Orwell's magnificent tale of repression, love, sex and torture, Nineteen Eighty-Four, published in 1949. I'm sure that most of you read this book in high school, including even that one user from Myanmar who turns up at the book review site from time to time so I will not waste too much time getting into the nitty-gritty. Instead Ill just give the basics of the plot, discuss the efficacy of Orwell's world-building and characterization, then wrap up with some comments on the work as a whole...Please click here, or on the book cover above, to be taken to the complete review..
 
Unlike most others, I didn't read this at school and only read it for the first time a couple of years ago. I was blown away by it. So much so that I'm glad I didn't get forced to read it school because that might have impaired by appreciation of it. This must surely be one of the greatest, if not the greatest SF books of all time. I can honestly not think of a single bad thing to say about it. There was not a bit of it I didn't love.

Oh, Orwells grasp of some economic principles is found wanting in places (such as his belief that over production is a problem for capitalism which will necessitate the need for perpetual war in order to sustain demand for all that is produced and to sustain full employment. This is belied by Orwell himself when he shows reveals that ever increasing shortages are prevalent and rations become stricter. War impoverishes, it does not enrich (unless you're an arms dealer).
 
Still a book I've yet to read. Not because its not my choice of reading matter(i like Space opera type SF) but because I fear books like this are going to be very cerebral,and there's going to be some Important Message in there that I will miss completely.
I will give it a read sometime tho!
 
Still a book I've yet to read. Not because its not my choice of reading matter(i like Space opera type SF) but because I fear books like this are going to be very cerebral,and there's going to be some Important Message in there that I will miss completely.
I will give it a read sometime tho!
It is deeply thought provoking but I don't think you need to worry about not getting it. Afterall, they give it to school children to read! ;)
 
I always imagine it to be like Huxley's Brave New World which I've not read but my other half has.
It's not really anything like "Brave New World". As it happens, I read "Brave New World" immediately after reading "1984" and it's nowhere near as good. There's a lot of interesting ideas in there but the story is not nearly as engrossing as it is in "1984".
 
I enjoyed the book, but I think I view it with the same suspicion that many anarchists and socialists view Das Kapital - that it has been diverted from its original purpose and is, in fact, a textbook for fledgling despots. ;)
 
I enjoyed the book, but I think I view it with the same suspicion that many anarchists and socialists view Das Kapital - that it has been diverted from its original purpose and is, in fact, a textbook for fledgling despots. ;)
Oh my, if a wanna-be despot ever got their hands on a copy of "1984", we'd be in trouble... :eek:;)
 

Similar threads


Back
Top