My
December 2016 Asimov's review is up on
Tangent.
Recommended: "They Have All One Breath" by Karl Bunker
(Almost that exact thing can be read as the frist psot of my shiny new blog (which being an early adopter enabled me to name
Featured Futures).)
Starting reviews of this collection (1970 reprint of 1960 original)
Because I'm here and a Sturgeon nut and was actually able to find it and there were several interesting resonances (and a dissonance or two) between our comments, here are my notes on the collection from when I read it in April 2000. This wasn't intended for posting, so I've edited out the spoilers and fixed some vagueness and so on but otherwise left it alone. And I don't know I'd have the same reactions on a re-read but here it is, FWIW:
Finished Sturgeon's
Beyond. This was a good collection. Interestingly, it opens and closes with 1960 pieces but the middle four are all 40s pieces. To be such early pieces, and so good, one wonders why it took so long to collect them. [Actually, he was collecting great 40s and 50s pieces on into the 70s.]
First, from 60, we have "Need" which is quite a captivating story of excellently idiosyncratic characters and deals with, among other things, a guy who is psychically attuned to other peoples' needs. The only oddity is the rather callous treatment of heroin addicts. Maybe you don't want to give them what they need, but why not give them what they need [in order] not to need? That quibble aside, it's an excellent story, though there is one more quibble in that it feels "climactic" about ten pages before it ends. It still manages to end okay, but it might have been better to tighten the ending or flatten out the part near the end so it doesn't feel climactic until the end. I dunno.
"Abreaction" is about a guy who slips dimensional streams but vividly captures some of the occasional effects of LSD rather brilliantly. [Sturgeon really did drive bulldozers in WWII, by the way. The story might have been inspired by incipient heatstroke or something.]
"Nightmare Island" has problems in its narrative device as I found myself continuously asking how a) the narrator could know what he described in such detail especially if b) the protagonist seems so unlikely to be one who could articulate it even at first hand. Also, [the alcoholism] seems pretty exaggerated even before it slips into fantasy - or SF (this was actually published in
Astounding while
Unknown existed) - but, these two points aside, it's a very absorbing, entertaining tale - that is quite evocative of a seaman's life, too.
I suppose some might criticize "Largo" for some reason or other and I have a quibble in that I don't know about "fingers flying" over a violin during a
largo - [especially one] that is "about an hour" long. But I don't care about hypothetical general criticisms [no offense intended now that yours is not hypothetical, VS
] or my quibble - this tale of a musician, his inspiration, his revenge, his great performance of his masterpiece - this is just a
really excellent one.
--Oops. I forgot to specify that "Island" was about a shipwrecked sailor getting drunk on coconuts and serving as God of the Big Worms and [what is probably a spoiler deleted] of the Really Big Worm.
Then, "The Bones" reads like a Padgett story with a pinch of brutality as a whacked-out inventor tries to make a directional FM radio and ends up mak[ing] a bone-telepathy-projector that reveals the reason for a death and for all deaths, and is used for [another probable spoiler deleted]. Kind of silly, kind of cool.
Then we have an odd close in that it's the only story I didn't much care for and wouldn't really like to re-read. I'd have dropped it and moved "Largo" to the end. It's an overwrought piece that is sort of a gag-tale as it deals with human beings almost extinguished by a disease, with the survivors creating a corpus of Human Wisdom for their projected successors, the otters, [and spoilers about its anti-climax deleted]. This one
wasn't published in
Astounding, but that isn't really my problem with it. It's just, as I say, an overwrought tale that has no payoff and only touches semi-comically on a theme that is not original and [is] better and more seriously traversed elsewhere.
That one aside, this is a spiffy collection. In order, I guess I'd go "Largo," "Need," "Abreaction" in a very good/excellent class; "Nightmare Island," "The Bones" in a good class, and "Like Young" as indifferent/poor.
[Then it wraps up with excessive words about how my only real complaint about the collection is that it only has 6 stories and is only 150 pages long. But, otherwise, I'd really recommend it.]