Death's Gambit Chapter 1 - Conflict

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dom.com

New Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2009
Messages
4
Hey guys. This is my first ever forum post but about the 5th version of my chapter. Ive only put the beggining in but please have a read through and give me some advice on where i can improve. Any comments welcome XD Cheers



Marcus woke with a jolt. Bear stood in the doorway, the moonlight pouring in through the open door.
“It is time” he said. Marcus swiftly rose, collecting his dagger and bow from the back of his room. He followed Bear out into the moonlight and breathed in the crisp, night air. From his rooftop shack, Marcus looked into the night sky and prayed to whatever gods kept him safe to watch over him tonight. He looked to the North towards the wall around Cerdas’ middle class housing and markets. The silence of the night would soon be broken. Bear slid down the ladder to the ground. Marcus followed quickly and was immediately hit by the stench of the slums open sewers and rotting landscape. Bear led him uphill towards the wall and to the edge of a small courtyard by the gate. Marcus could see others now. More and more men hiding in the shadows and around street corners, waiting for the signal. Marcus drew his bow and knocked an arrow.
A few minutes later, a large man strode out of the shadows and headed towards the gate. In his hand he held a long sword. Immediately the guards drew their weapons and prepared to defend themselves. The man tapped his long sword on the ground three times and all hell broke loose. Marcus fired his arrow, along with many others who then charged through the gate and into the city. Marcus drew his dagger and followed. He was almost surprised by how many men had come. He knew the White Dogs clan was big but this was nearly a thousand men! Bandit, the leader of the White Dogs, had done a good job of convincing people to join them in their conquest for Cerdas. Bandit, the man with the long sword, shouted orders and directions for different groups of men. Marcus was about to follow the closest group to him but as he turned to follow them, a strong hand gripped his shoulder. He turned to see Bandit grinning at him.
“Now boy, how good is your aim?”
* * *
Wolf smiled a wolfish grin. The chaos caused by the White Dogs uprising was extremely entertaining. In the few hours since their attack had started, they had taken the middle class section and were on their way to attack the Governor’s house in the centre of Cerdas. The large mansion had high walls and only one entrance for the Dogs. Inside was a large courtyard where the available town’s guards had positioned themselves. Wolf had perched on a roof just by the walls and had a perfect view of the scene below. From within the darkness of the streets, a man shouted the charge and the Dogs poured into the courtyard. The Dogs crashed into the Guards line and brutal conflict began. Slowly the Dogs pushed forward but they paid heavily for each step they took. As the guard’s line reached the steps to the front entrance of the Mansion, the door opened and a robed man stepped out. The doors closed eerily behind him. In the chaos, a Dog fired an arrow above the guards and it flew straight towards the robed man. Instead of ripping through the man’s flesh, the arrow halted in midair just in front of the man. The fighting stopped and the Dogs took a step back. The robed man pulled back his hood and smiled arrogantly. Wolf sensed an unnatural disturbance in the air. All of a sudden, fire exploded from the robed man, flying directly into the awestruck Dogs. Panic resumed as some Dogs ran and others charged. The addition of a Mage to the Guards defences had shaken the Dogs’ morale. However, Wolf could tell the mage was a weak one. After his initial outburst, the Mage had backed down, reducing his attacks to one or two feeble fireballs every few minutes and deflecting incoming arrows with a shield.
Then Wolf spotted what he’d been looking for all along. Bandit raised his sword high and shouted a battle cry. The Dogs immediately rallied to his call and took up the charge. The guards were pushed back a little more until the Mage released another outburst of fire, killing many Dogs and regaining their lost ground in seconds. Wolf picked up his bow and readied an arrow. Before Wolf could fire, Bandit raised his sword and pointed to the rooftop opposite Wolf. Puzzled, Wolf glanced over and spotted a boy, slim build with dark hair, no more than seventeen, crouching on the rooftop with a bow. He was aiming at the Mage! Wolf almost laughed aloud at the feeble attempt. Wolf returned his aim to Bandit but as he did silence crept over the chaotic scene. Wolf looked towards the Mage and gasped. An arrow was protruding from his chest. Wolf looked back towards the rooftop with the boy on but there was no one there. The Mage slumped to the ground and the Dogs let out a cheer. However, instead of pressing forward, Bandit shouted orders to pull back. Swiftly the Dogs fled into the streets and alleyways outside the mansion and Wolf lost sight of Bandit. He cursed, picked up his gear and began to pursue the retreating Dogs. However, all he could think about was how the boy had managed to get his shot through the mage’s shield. Something wasn’t right here and Wolf was sure he’d get to the bottom of it.
 
Hi and Welcome to Chrons. What took you so long?

Listen before you lose the ability to edit your post go back in and put some line breaks bewteen paragrapghs. It makes it easier to read and you'll get more replies. Also read the stickies on formatting at the top of the critiques section and then you'll get some good advice from a great bunch of guys.:)
 
You can't now. You've left it too late. You see the blue oval box at the bottom right corner of your post which says 'Quote'? If you are inside the time allowed for editing, another box appears alongside it with 'Edit' on it - press that, and it brings up your post again and you can make the changes you need.

Gary is right. It's a little difficult to read work in this format so it will put people off from replying. Go up and read the stickies, inwardly digest, and then come back and try again. Meantime, have a look around and contribute to other threads. We don't begrudge critiquing anyone's work, but we're only human -- we prefer it if people are here for the pleasure of our company rather than to use us as unpaid editors. Reading through other critiques and giving your thoughts will also help you improve your own writing. And, yes, I have to say there is room for improvement.

J

PS Welcome to the Chronicles!
 
Dont be put off Dom.com, almost everybody makes mistakes on their first post, I'm still making them now!!

Give it a day or two and put it back up leaving spaces between paragraphs. If you dont know what I mean have a look at my meagre offering in critiques.

You'll find the old magnets of critiques will be attracted to your post, mark my words.

It's hard to read a wall of text and most critiquers just turn off and move on to the next:)
 
QUOTE] By Gary
It's hard to read a wall of text and most critiquers just turn off and move on to the next:)
[/QUOTE]

But not all.... Welcome to the chrons Dom - that's a prophylactic if ever I heard one!

I'll give it a go - all my personal opinions, and you must feel free to ignore anything that you don't agree with. You will find other critiquers often agree and disagree with each other, quite happily, but in the end it's your story, your creation and it's up to you alone to decide. Don't slavishly change things just because one person says so...


Marcus woke with a jolt. Bear stood in the doorway, the moonlight pouring in through the open door. I think you could lose the repetition of 'door'. Maybe 'Bear stood in the doorway, framed by the moonlight'. (If he stood in the doorway, it would have to be open...)

“It is time” he said. Marcus swiftly rose,(rose swiftly?) collecting his dagger and bow from the back of his room. Just a small suggestion this one - maybe he just collects his 'weapons' from the back of THE room (avoids repetition of 'his' and you're going to tell us which weapons he has later, anyway. He followed Bear out into the moonlight and breathed in the crisp, night air. Erm, a little cliched this - nothing wrong with it, but would: 'He followed Bear out into the moonlight and the cold night air wrapped around him,' sound a little better? From his rooftop shack, Marcus looked into the night sky and prayed to whatever gods kept him safe to watch over him tonight. Erm, 'prayed to whatever Gods kept him safe' is a little unwieldy. Maybe: 'Marcus looked up into the night sky and prayed to the Gods to watch over him.'He looked to the North towards the wall around Cerdas’ middle class housing and markets. I'd consider dropping this sentence altogether - i know you want to tell us the difference between the slums and the middle classes, but your next descriptions show it so much better...

The silence of the night would soon be broken. I like that. Bear slid down the ladder to the ground. Marcus followed quickly and was immediately hit by the stench of the slums open sewers and rotting landscape. Erm, presumably he smells this every time he's on the ground? 'Immediately hit' sounds like it's the first time, or a new sensation...P'raps 'Marcus followed quickly and the familiar stench of the open sewers and rotting landscape enveloped him. (Gives a nice contrast to the crisp night air btw, good one!) Bear led him uphill towards the wall and to the edge of a small courtyard by the gate. Marcus could see others now. More and more men hiding in the shadows and around street corners, waiting for the signal. Marcus drew his bow and knocked an arrow. I think that should be 'nocked'...

A few minutes later, what did they do during those few minutes? If it's a planned operation, wouldn't a few seconds be better? Or deleted altogether and the sentence starts with A large man....etc. a large man strode out of the shadows and headed towards the gate. In his hand he held a long sword. where else would he hold it? It's my own opinion, but would 'He held a long sword that gleamed dully in the darkness' be more evocative? It's almost as though your narrator is recounting the scene without giving any of the danger, intrigue, passion to it. Immediately the guards drew their weapons and prepared to defend themselves. Erm, presumably he's the only one the guards can see? And it's a major shock when the arrows fly out? I think you're overlooking a chance to ramp up some tension, to add some good storytelling - it's your narrator again, he's too dispassionate. Wouldn't it be better if there was a shout from the guards, a challenge, and the big man stops and looks at them with a sneer, maybe one or two of them edge forward and then he taps the swordThe man tapped his long sword on the ground three times and all hell broke loose. Marcus fired his arrow, along with many others who then charged through the gate and into the city.P'raps some description of a fight? Or did they all drop under the hail of arrows? Did some flee to raise the alarm? Was a bell rung , or was the surprise total and no alarm given to the city? Again, you could show us a bit more, the blood, the sweat, the danger, the excitement even. Marcus drew his dagger and followed. He was almost surprised by how many men had come. He knew the White Dogs clan was big but this was nearly a thousand men! This is the first time you've used any emphasis, it's Marcus' thoughts and it's about how many men there are - surely we could have had some of Marcus' adrenaline thoughts along the way - or better, show the nervous sweat cooling on him, his heart beating etc etc.

Bandit, the leader of the White Dogs,erm, delete 'the leader of the white dogs'? It's not truly relevant and it's telling had done a good job of convincing people to join them in their conquest for Cerdas. Bandit, the man with the long sword,you're trying to tell us this, but it's an unwieldy way of doing it - two sentences, both starting 'Bandit,'. Either name Bandit the first time we see him, int he previous paragraph, or drop the 'the man with the long sword' in this section. shouted orders and directions for different groups of men. Marcus was about to follow the closest group to him but as he turned to follow them, a strong hand gripped his shoulder. Repetition of 'follow'.Erm..., 'Marcus moved to follow the closest group, but a hand gripped his shoulder, turning him. He saw Bandit grinning at him'?. He turned to see Bandit grinning at him.
“Now boy, how good is your aim?” I like this, sets us up nicely, we're interested to see what's about to happen.


* * *


Wolf smiled a wolfish grin. Oh, come on....he either smiles a smile or grins a grin, and using 'wolfish' is just going too far. I'd expect a character called fox to smile a foxy grin later, and so on. 'Wolf smiled to himself 'would be enough. The chaos caused by the White Dogs uprising was extremely entertaining. In the few hours since their attack had started, they had taken the middle class section see? here you've mentioned it, it shouldn't be necessary to include it in the rooftop scene at the beginning. and were on their way on their way? No tension in that, sounds like a day trip.... Aren't they fighting their way? Clawing their way? smashing their way? Gouging their way? Rampaging their way? Anything would be better to add some tension. And it's been hours since they started out, there must have been pitched battles all the way? Where's the smoke the flames, the blood and guts in the street? to attack the Governor’s house in the centre of Cerdas. The large mansion had high walls and only one entrance for the Dogs.which by now would be barricaded, and there would be archers on the high walls - at least make it a bit difficult for the dogs to get in! Inside was a large courtyard where the available town’s guardsavailable town's guards?? Doesn't the governor have his own? had positioned themselves. Wolf had perched on a roof just by the walls and had a perfect view of the scene below. From within the darkness of the streets, a man shouted the charge and the Dogs poured into the courtyard. No they didn't, he watched as they smashed into the barricade, men falling from the arrows, firing back at them, fighting past the barricade with axes, fire, blood and guts everywhere!!!The Dogs crashed into the Guards line and brutal conflict began.That's it? Brutal conflict began? Slowly the Dogs pushed forward but they paid heavily for each step they took. How much? £5 a foot? That's £10 per man, unless someone has lost a foot on the way... sorry, wandered off there.. but I'm wondering why you don't want to describe the scene? Is it that you don't think you can write battle scenes? Or is it (as I suspect) that you're focusing too much on what is going to be important - Marcus killing the mage - and are trying to get there too quickly?

As the guard’s line(there's only one guard??? Sorry, did this in edit, won't let me use red...) reached the steps to the front entrance of the Mansion, They didn't 'reach' the steps, they were drive back slowly, with weapons clashing, steel flashing, disembowelling, shields smashing and so on. the door opened and a robed man stepped out. The doors closed eerily Sorry, what? There's a battle we're watching from Wolf's pov, there's screaming, yelling, weapons clashing, dying people, flames, blood and gore all over, but someone somewhere thinks the door closes eerily... behind him. In the chaos, hah! What chaos? According to you, there isn't any...a Dog fired an arrow above the guards and it flew straight towards the robed man. Instead of ripping through the man’s flesh, the arrow halted in midair just in front of the man. The fighting stopped and the Dogs took a step back. in which case the guards will slash at them and kill as many of them as they can... If you want the battle to cease, you'll have to do better than that, not a single one fighting in the front line will have seen it, they're fighting for their lives! The robed man pulled back his hood and smiled arrogantly. Wolf sensed an unnatural disturbance in the air. wouldn't it be better if the unnatural disturbance in the air happens when the mage comes out of the mansion - and they all instinctively know? That way the tension can be ramped up enormously, and the reader will feel it, as well.

All of a sudden, No... this is a cliche too far. Just start with 'fire exploded...etc' fire exploded from the robed man, flying directly into the awestruck Dogs. The fire stuck, it burnt flesh, it tore through them, it melted their eyeballs... which?? Panic resumed as some Dogs ran and others charged. The addition of a Mage to the Guards defences had shaken the Dogs’ morale. However, Wolf could tell the mage was a weak one. After his initial outburst, the Mage had backed down, reducing his attacks to one or two feeble fireballs every few minutes and deflecting incoming arrows with a shield. Okay, I'm going to stop telling you to ramp up the tension/danger, and accept that you get my point...

Then Wolf spotted what he’d been looking for all along. Bandit raised his sword high and shouted a battle cry. The Dogs immediately rallied to his call and took up the charge. The guards were pushed back a little more until the Mage released another outburst of fire, killing many Dogs and regaining their lost ground in seconds. Wolf picked up his bow and readied an arrow. Before Wolf could fire, Bandit raised his sword and pointed to the rooftop opposite Wolf. Isn't that giving the game away to the enemy? Wouldn't it be better if the bandit paused, and gave an unusual hand signal, that draws wolf's attentionPuzzled, Wolf glanced over and spotted a boy, slim build with dark hair, no more than seventeen, crouching on the rooftop with a bow. He was aiming at the Mage! Wolf almost laughed aloud at the feeble attempt. Wolf returned his aim to Bandit but as he did silence crept over the chaotic scene. Wolf looked towards the Mage and gasped. An arrow was protruding from his chest. Wolf looked back towards the rooftop with the boy on but there was no one there. The Mage slumped to the ground and the Dogs let out a cheer. However, instead of pressing forward, Bandit shouted orders to pull back. Swiftly the Dogs fled into the streets and alleyways outside the mansion and Wolf lost sight of Bandit. He cursed, picked up his gear and began to pursue the retreating Dogs. However, all he could think about was how the boy had managed to get his shot through the mage’s shield. Something wasn’t right here and Wolf was sure he’d get to the bottom of itneeded to get to the bottom of it?

Okay, that's your baptism of fire, and I hope it didn't hurt too much. Interestingly, I'm normally saying people put too much in, but in your case I want more!! You can't have a battle of this magnitude and not show us any of it... unless you just focus on Marcus being kept safe, and escorted through the streets to the mansion, and the battle can be heard but not seen as he crouches on the roof, waiting for his moment of glory. You'll still have to describe the assault on the mansion in order to bring the mage out, though. And Wolf's part in it all. Up to you.

I suggest you read some of your favourite battle scenes from your favourite books and see how it is done, if you feel you need more realistic showing of the chaos that's happening. But chaos is not what comes over to me at all, it's just too dispassionate. I'd like to see and feel more of what Marcus is going through- even if you leave it as it is, I think it would be great to have some of his emotions shown - I have no idea if he's nervous, frightened, exhilarated, confident, arrogant etc...

But there looks to be a good story in here, keep at it, and keep posting, and reading others' work and making a comment or two, even if it's just to say 'I like it because...'

Good luck
 
Last edited:
Thanks Boneman. This has been a massive help to me. I guess you were right in saying i havent written a good battle scene. I guess its just intimidating to try and portray everything i want to. Ill post again in a few days I think with an updated and continued version XD Thanks though, this has been really helpful XD
 
Hey guys. This is my first ever forum post but about the 5th version of my chapter. Ive only put the beggining in but please have a read through and give me some advice on where i can improve. Any comments welcome XD Cheers
Hi Dom. A sword and sorcery trip. You've been reading/raiding the Conan paperbacks, haven't you? LOL.

Seriously though, I like it. You've got the makings of a fairly decent story, I think. Just keep tweaking, sharpening and polishing it up further. Paragraphing, punctuation (a comma is important where there should be one), spelling (e.g. 'nock' instead of 'knock') etc. Then run with it.

Yes, round things off with a bit of graphic close-up hand to hand fighting, with dagger, sword, spear. Even just fist, elbow, knee, foot or head. Or anything else one could lay one's hand on. Enroll in a martial arts class, boxing, archery or even swordfighting, if it's possible. Not to be a champion, but just for the heck of it. Then watch plenty of fight movies, Van Damme, whoever.

Besides giving you some basic profiency that would obviously help you in your storytelling, it also provides a nice distraction for when you need a break from writing. Plus, you get the close networking with the real experts in the field, whom you could turn to for advice when you need to.

You'd be surprised how a little fighting scene, written expertly, could transform a decent chapter into an awesome one. Gives it a quantum lift, if you like. At least for me, it does.
 
Last edited:
Just one small point since others have given it a fair going over and they may even have addressed this point which it:

I'm having trouble with the whole dogs, dogs' and men thing.

would it be possible to reference them some other way. Unless I've got it completely wrong and they are actually dogs.

If they are men then it confuses the hell out of me (fair enough not difficult:))

Cheers

Tein
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top