aspiring writer who desperately needs critiqing. untitled story.

Status
Not open for further replies.

McLain

New Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2005
Messages
2
hey, i am new to this forum and have never posted here before. anyway i am an aspiring writer and have been working on a current project and need to be critiqued so i am posting the first chapter here. please, hit me with everything you got. i have no idea if i completely suck or am better than tolkien, lewis, etc. So grammer errors, storyline, main character, vividness, attention to detaiil, spelling i mean everything. i will gladly except and appreciate any and all ideas,opinions,constructive critisism, flat out critisism or anything else you want to add. my thanks ahead of time. anyway here it is.

P.S it is to long to post on one so i am goingt to post it and then reply with the second half.



General Humal woke from his private quarters with a start. He was dreaming of actually getting to fight in an epic battle. Instead now he had to go to a boring council meeting. He yearned for action but all he ever got to do was run drills and fill out status reports.
“General Homal.” Said one of the kings messengers who had just entered the room. “The king sends word that the council meeting will start in an hour.”

“I know I got yesterdays dispatch.” He replied heavily.

“Yes, but the king just wants to make sure you are not late like the last four.”

Humal just stared still half asleep.

He dragged himself out of bed and started to get into his uniform. He had been dreading this all week, as he had done every other council meeting. He knew this month, just like every other month he and his men would be put on guard duty, guarding the treasuries of the great city of Baylik while the other generals got to fend off raiders or at the very least run Recon missions. The only person the treasuries really needed guarding from anyway was the king himself. noeone was stupid enough to try to steal anything from the armies of Baylik. The king however practicily lived down there. he was a very greedy man who humal hated. in his opinion he had no honor, self dignity, or any loyalty to his country what soever. anytrhing he did he did for himself, and expanding his already enormuos supply of wealth. the only reason humal handnt left yet was that Baylik was were his family had grown up for centuries and all of his forefathers had served as a general in the once proud baylik army. and the fact that he liked his supreme commader. The supreme commander,the commander of all armed forces, was second to none besides the king himself. He was known as commander Hepkin,noeone knowing his first name, and he was half elf all though you couldnt tell it from looking at him. He was also the only one from keeping the king from banning humal into exile. Humal liked him because although he was somewhat greedy like the king, he had a sense of honor, and self respect. Commader Hepkin had five generals, one of which was humal, and each general had a lieutenant.


On his way to the council meeting General humal ran into his first liutenant, lieutenant Vexon. his name descended from his ancestors on his fathers side who were lizardmen, a race that is now extinct except for a few such as Vexon who had a little of their ancestors blood left in them. He looked mostly human except that he did have a somewhat green skin to him that made him look deathly sick to anyone that did not know his of his origion.
"lieutenant" Humal said returning the salute that vexon had given him. "prepare the men at the second courtyard. after getting back from the council meeting i will instruct them on what there orders are for the month. not that it will be anything new i just feel like giving them false hope for action is better than giving them no hope at all. My men grow tiresome from sitting around playing dice games while trying to stay awake for their guard duty. they grow out of shape and our rusty from lack of combat."

"I know what you mean." said vexon. he did not usually say sir or general like he was supposed to because he and humal had a good relationship and thought more of each other as friends then mere colleagues.

"Maybe Hepkin will put in a good word for you."

"im sure he would but it would do no good. the king hates me and my men and it is all hepkin can do just to persuade him not to throw us out."

"Well as you said, false hope is better than no hope at all. Vexon said walking away. Humal continued down the great hall toward the council meeting.



The great hall was magnificently decorated with rare and priceless tapestries. the floor was dark marble with golden specks that humal knew cost more than most kings had. the place was adorned with dark green and silver checkered banners which was the Baylik knights standard. As he walked through the huge hall he felt a sense of pride for what he had, always washed away by a feeling of guilt for those they had taken it from. most were vile creatures such as the ogre tribes or dark elves which were elves that had abandoned their homeland to learn the black magics and to raid trade caravans and such. but some were just inocent little fishing villages and towns who had lost everything that was theres.
 
heres the second half,




He snapped back to reality as the great clock in the center of the hall struck one. he rushed into the meeting just as everyone was taking thier seats.

"I see your late again general humal." said the king. " at least you didnt miss anything like you usually do. Now have a seat."

"sorry, Lord Kimren." He said cursing under his breath. as he took his assinged seat he noticed that three of the other generals were gone and that it was only him, commandor Hepkin,the great mage Gilroc responsible for mainting the magic that protected Baylik which Humal knew nothing about,The king, the kings advisor, and the other General.

"As you probably all have noticed." said the king beggining the council. "Some of the other Generals will not be joining us today. We got reports a couple days ago of our mnining city, Caliph, being overrun by unkown bandits. We have confirmed the reports

and have sent a large force to defend, or if it is already lost, tke back the city. There is no need to worry about that as i have already handled the situation. There is one thing I do think we need to concentrate on though. as you know, Caliph is where we get our supply of gold from the gold mining operations there. Even though i am certain we will get the city back under our control, the city is running out of gold anyway so we have to begin construction of a new mining site. scouts have informed me that a gold mine has been located in the barren area to the south west known as the Takhir region. The mine does border the Kanashi Forest however, so their is chance of light resistance from renagades taking shelter in the forest,but nothing an old farmer with a pitchfork could'nt handle. Now i have instructed General Delphi to take up guard at our borders just in case the bandits attacking Caliph decide to head for our Capitol city. Now i was going to order Commander Hepkin to begin this new mining operation as General Humal took his regular postion of guarding my treasury." He said with a slight smile. He enjoyed displeasing humal. "But Commander Hepkin has informed me prior to the meeting that his men are very weak and dreary and it would do them good to take up guard duty at the treasury for a while and that they would not be able to handle such a task in thier current condition. So unfortunatly, with much displeasure i have to announce that General Humal will be in charge of setting up this gold operation."Humal coughed so hard he almost fell out of his chair. he couldn’t believe that he actually got to do something besides sit around all day and sleep.

“Thank you, my Lord.” he said and it was the first time he actually meant it.

“I’ll assume everyone else knows what there orders are. Any questions?” noone said anything. “Alright well, meeting adjourned.

Humal, you stay behind with commander Hepkin who will instruct you further.” he said as he was walking out the door with the others. “Oh and humal” he whispered up close to him. “ if you mess this up you will be my personal slave who has to wash my feet every night.”

“Trust me sir, I wouldn’t want to do that.” Humal said half chuckling.

The king just glared at him and walked on by.

“You better watch what you say.” Hepkin said smiling. “You don’t want to mess this up.”

“By the way I want to thank you. I know your men aren’t tired. Anything you want or need you just holler. I really appreciate this.”

“Well I didn’t just do it for you.” Hepkin replied “I also did it for your men. Their starting to grow an ale gut, and there beards are getting as long as dwarves.” they both laughed. “ well lets start this shall we.” he pulled out a map of all of Elbadorn and a wooden pointer. “Take seven or eight-hundred of your best men as that should be more than you need. I will personally look after the rest of them here and give them work to do. The gold mine, as the king has stated, is in the Takhir region so you will have to cut through Billirds

pass that runs between the Tal’Elbore mountain range and the Mars Plateau.” he said illustrating with the map. “Now even though this is a gold mining operation looking at how it is situated it would also be a good defensive position guarding the pass if we ever got attacked even though we wouldn’t get attacked through there. It should take less than a days travel to get there and if you leave after this meeting you should get there tomorrow just before nightfall. Once you arrive at the destination and find the gold mine you should immediately scout out the area for any dangers but don’t get your hopes up. Once you have found an appropriate position start construction on the base and send a messenger to let us know. We will be expecting him in about three days time so don’t be late. You don’t want to make the king wait or he will kick you off this operation so fast it will make your head spin. Your really on his last straw. Anyway once you get the mine up and running establish trade caravans to run periodically with the gold. Take care of all enemy threat if there is any and setup a local garrison. Once you have the gold, a trade route, and a good defense, you can return here leaving a small number of your forces behind to man the garrison. Appoint someone else in command and instruct him to send you weekly reports, and all you have to do is sit here and review your reports as the gold comes in.” He finally finished.

“Sounds easy enough.”

“It is an easy assignment, but keep in mind it’s a very important one. Don’t screw this up. If you mess up, your gone for good and there’s nothing I can say or do, to change his mind. Well, ill let you get to it then.”

“Thank you again commander. Trust me, I wont mess up.” He said leaving the meeting.

Humal walked out of the great hall into the crisp clean air of the courtyard. He walked to the left into a smaller second courtyard where he say his men lining up in formation and lieutenant Vexon barking orders left in right as confused men scrambled about. They were definitely out of practice. But, this assignment would be just the kind of thing they needed. Not to dangerous, but just enough to get their sword dirty.

“Vexon” he shouted as he came into hearing distance. “I want eight-hundred of our best men outside the west gate in ten minutes. Tell the rest to wait in the barracks for commander Hepkins orders. Looks like were finally getting some action around here. Ill explain on the way.”

“Yes, sir” Vexon said with a pleased look on his face. He went back to shouting orders while Humal found some servants to fetch rations and camping equipment and load them on supply wagons.

After he had gotten all the equipment ready, and gotten on his steed, he rode out of the west gate where he saw some supply wagons, Vexon, and eight hundred pleased faces awaiting for his arrival.

“AWW” he thought to himself. “ The fresh smell of command”




well there you have it. i tried to break it up as best i could so i hope noeone strained there eyes. i realize that from the first chapter you cannot tell much of the storyline so i will try to give a quick summary for you if it helps.

humal goes and starts the mining operation only to find that it is in a ogre cheiftans territory and it gradually turns into a full scale war. meanwhile the raid on Caliph was just a disrraction to a much bigger plan to take the capitol city while there forces were away and divided. anyway i wont tell you who attacks them or why because i dont want to give it away but that pretty much somes it up with a few twists and turns.
like i said i appreciate any and alll critiquing and thank you ahead of time. sorry for the length.
 
McLain said:
General Humal woke from his private quarters with a start.

“General Homal.” Said one of the kings messengers who had just entered the room.

Continuity error or intended slight ?

I think you have some good ideas, the part lizardman officer for example. But you have a lot of spelling/grammer errors.
 
Yes, you do have a lot of spelling and grammatical errors, which need to be cleaned up before posting for critiquing. However, I love how you open with the general waking up, yearning for some action but just getting to go to boring council meetings. Sounds almost like my day job. ;) I think the reader can immediately identify with the general.

[“Yes, but the king just wants to make sure you are not late like the last four.”

Humal just stared still half asleep.] LOL! Loved that bit.

In the council meeting, you mentioned that Humal was the only general, then you mentioned another general. Check your continuity.

You've introduced a lot of characters, and I think you need to flesh them out a bit more later on. Why is the king so greedy? What adventures did Humal and his general/commander friend have in common? Why did the commander have to tell Humal how to set up the gold operation, even though Humal is a general? What is Humal's perception of elves and dwarves and other manner of fanstasy beings in the story?

Good cutting insult about Humal's men having ale guts and beards longer than elves. :D

I think you have good ideas, but your writing needs to be tighter, with fewer errors. Read it over, fix the errors, flesh it out a bit more. Keep the humor! Makes it interesting. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top