Fantasy Prologue for series of novels

Status
Not open for further replies.

Oxman

Thread Killer
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
127
Location
Birmingham, England
Hello everybody,

Here's around the first 800 words of my prologue for the first in a series of fantasy novels that have been rattling around in my head for the last couple of years. I usually write in a much more contemporary (and familiar) setting, so any feedback on the style and substance would be massively appreciated. I hope the excerpt is not too large.

Thanks in advance!



Prologue


Arrows rained down out of the sky. Elric remained perfectly still, even when one whistled by a little too close for comfort, the barbed, bronze head embedding in the mud less than a stride away from him. The group of mercenaries exchanged glances, a mixture of confusion and incredulity, before loosening off a second volley. Seeing that two or three were likely to find their mark this time, Elric bared his teeth and tightened his grip on the hilt of his sword. He waited - just for a heartbeat - then swung, the gleaming blade cutting a swathe through the air, snapping the shafts of the projectiles and knocking them scattering. He returned his gaze to his adversaries and flashed them a smile, mustering up the wickedest grin he could manage.

It was enough to discourage the majority of his foes. They turned their mounts and spurred them on, galloping a hasty retreat, leaving their leader alone to face Elric. Clad partly in worn plate armour, partly in chainmail, the mercenary sat astride a grey stallion, gently kneading the reins to keep the mount still and calm. Judging by his armour and well-fed horse, Elric supposed the man had been a knight once, who had perhaps since disgraced himself somehow or fallen upon hard times. It mattered little.

Slowly, the knight drew a lengthy blade from a decorative scabbard and urged his steed in Elric’s direction, armour clanking and rattling as the horse gathered momentum.

Elric was at a disadvantage. His sword would not reach his mounted enemy before he had been cut to ribbons. Reluctantly sheathing it, he moved his hands around to his back, his fingers working swiftly to unbuckle the strap that held a weighty halberd in place. He planted his feet into the muddy ground and gripped the halberd with both hands, reassured by the jagged point at its tip. He awaited the knight’s charge.

The stallion was upon him sooner than he expected. Elric pulled to the side at the last possible moment, close enough to feel a warm gust of horse breath flow across his face and to catch the faint scent of damp straw. The sweeping arc of the knight’s blade missed his head by inches. In response, Elric drove the halberd up with all his strength. The point found its way under the arm of the knight and, without the protection offered by plate armour, continued to move upward, parting the more vulnerable rings of chainmail before coming to a sudden stop in the man’s shoulder socket with a crack and a wet squelch.

An anguished cry echoed from the helm of the knight. He was held in place while his stallion continued to gallop forward. Tumbling from the saddle, all that stopped him crashing to the ground was one stirrup, which stubbornly twisted around the knight’s foot and held him there, hanging. The leather footrest creaked and groaned, trying to bear weight that was not intended for it and, with the squirming of the flailing man contributing to the strain, the stirrup gave way, snapping in two and sending the knight sprawling onto his back.

Weighed down by his armour, the knight found it impossible to get to his feet, though he tried, first by pushing to the left, then to the right, then by trying to sit straight up. The battle scarred plates of metal forged to protect their wearer now hindered him in the cruellest of ways. In the fall, the knight’s breast plate had become unbuckled and hung loosely to the side, revealing a burgundy tunic of what once must have been the finest silk until it had became sullied and torn. The grounded man stopped squirming when he felt the cold point of Elric’s halberd pressed against his exposed chest.

“Yield,” said Elric, his voice quite steady and calm. The knight lifted a hand to his helm, raised it and struggled against his cumbersome apparel in an attempt to lean close to Elric. His eyes were dark, his cheeks were muddy and he sported a bushy, black beard. The knight spat, a great gob full of stringy phlegm aimed for Elric. Instead, it caught on the bristles of his beard and splattered onto the Knight’s own stomach. Elric sighed and pushed his weapon into the soft flesh of his fallen foe.

“Crookedmouth!”

Elric Stayle snapped out of his dreamworld. His mail hauberk was replaced by the humble, muddy attire of a twelve year old stableboy. The halberd he had been wielding so expertly had been switched for a simple pitchfork and on the pointy end, where he had imagined the still beating heart of his enemy to be, there sat a near perfectly spherical ball of horse ****.
 
First the font is a bit hard on the eye and to me there's a bit too much over complicated description. projectiles for arrows as an example.

Red remove
Blue comments in general
Green possible improvements

IMO

Hello everybody,

Here's around the first 800 words of my prologue for the first in a series of fantasy novels that have been rattling around in my head for the last couple of years. I usually write in a much more contemporary (and familiar) setting, so any feedback on the style and substance would be massively appreciated. I hope the excerpt is not too large.

Thanks in advance!



Prologue


Arrows rained down out of the sky (given that the adversaries are close enough to see each other raining down from the sky seems a little odd. He presumably saw them flirt into the sky in the first place, so why start with the downward path In any case it seems a little cumbersome Arrows rained around him is what is actually happening, down is a given for rain). Elric remained perfectly still, even when one whistled by a little too close for comfort, the barbed, bronze head embedding in the mud less than a stride away from him. The group of mercenaries exchanged glances, a mixture of confusion and incredulity., before loosening They loosed off a second volley. Seeing that two or three were likely to find their mark this time, (Why? The same number of arrows? in fact to be sure of hitting just one man with a volley of arrows I suspect there would need to be hundreds. In an case this form of attack wouldn't be used against one man - it's only effective against large ranks or bunches of men. If the can see him they would be aim for his body, horizontally) Elric bared his teeth and tightened his grip on the hilt of his sword. He waited - just for a heartbeat - then swung, the gleaming blade cutting a swathe through the air, snapping the shafts of the projectiles (hard to believe) and knocking them scattering. He returned his gaze to his adversaries and flashed them a smile, mustering up the wickedest grin he could manage. (Again the grin would be useless, a war cry maybe, but at a distance where arrows are flirting about you can't see facial expressions and certainly not grins)

It was enough to discourage the majority of his foes. They turned their mounts and spurred them on,(into a) galloping a hasty retreat, leaving their leader alone to face Elric (unlikely, men on horse would be perfectly able to handle one man on foot unless he's got more than a cheeky grin especially if they have bows. They just keep a distance and aim at him till he's dead or run him down in close combat - He would need cover, (trees) or a thousand men at his back to make them run so easily - after he had killed a dozen or so they may see the do a runner but not because there's a bloke with a big sword -He has to take them down with a bow of his own or up close and personal where arrows are difficult to fire at one individual). Clad partly in worn plate armour, partly in chainmail, the mercenary sat astride a grey stallion, gently kneading the reins to keep the mount still and calm. Judging by his armour and well-fed horse, Elric supposed the man had been a knight once, who had perhaps since disgraced himself somehow or fallen upon hard times. It mattered little.

Slowly, the knight drew a lengthy blade from a decorative scabbard and urged his steed in Elric’s direction, armour clanking and rattling as the horse gathered momentum.

Elric was at a disadvantage. His sword would not reach his mounted enemy before he had been cut to ribbons. Reluctantly sheathing it, he moved his hands around to his back, his fingers working swiftly to unbuckle the strap that held a weighty halberd in place (so he's got a axe like weapon with six foot of pole hanging on his back sticking up in the air?). He planted his feet into the muddy ground and gripped the halberd with both hands, reassured by the jagged point at its tip. He awaited the knight’s charge.

The stallion was upon him sooner than he expected. Elric pulled to the side at the last possible moment (feet planted in mud?), close enough to feel a warm gust of horse breath flow across his face and to catch the faint scent of damp straw. (Er no, that is too close, the horse would be trampling him by then) The sweeping arc of the knight’s blade missed his head by inches. In response, Elric drove the halberd up with all his strength. The point found its way under the arm of the knight and, without the protection offered by plate armour, continued to move upward, parting the more vulnerable rings of chainmail before coming to a sudden stop in the man’s shoulder socket with a crack and a wet squelch. (Again this would be difficult. He would need to be standing to do this in which case the sword would hit him and if he did succeed then the momentum of the rider would do him dame too. He'd be unlikely to maintain his upright position in any case I don't think this weapon was used against charging horses although I will stand corrected. If it was so used a man on horse back is unlikely to charge against it given all his advantages)

An anguished cry echoed from the helm of the knight. He was held in place while his stallion continued to gallop forward. Tumbling from the saddle, all that stopped him crashing to the ground was one stirrup, which stubbornly twisted around the knight’s foot and held him there, hanging. The leather footrest creaked and groaned, trying to bear weight that was not intended for it and, with the squirming of the flailing man contributing to the strain, the stirrup gave way, snapping in two and sending the knight sprawling onto his back. (The horse is still moving forward no ones going to be dangling around)

Weighed down by his armour, the knight found it impossible to get to his feet, though he tried, first by pushing to the left, then to the right, then by trying to sit straight up. The battle scarred plates of metal forged to protect their wearer now hindered him in the cruellest of ways. In the fall, the knight’s breast plate had become unbuckled and hung loosely to the side, revealing a burgundy tunic of what once must have been the finest silk until it had became sullied and torn. The grounded man stopped squirming when he felt the cold point of Elric’s halberd pressed against his exposed chest.

“Yield,” said Elric, his voice quite steady and calm. The knight lifted a hand to his helm, raised it and struggled against his cumbersome apparel in an attempt to lean close to Elric. His eyes were dark, his cheeks were muddy and he sported a bushy, black beard. The knight spat, a great gob full of stringy phlegm aimed for Elric. Instead, it caught on the bristles of his beard and splattered onto the Knight’s own stomach. Elric sighed and pushed his weapon into the soft flesh of his fallen foe.

“Crookedmouth!” (Who? and is it meant to be relavent)

Elric Stayle snapped out of his dreamworld. His mail hauberk was replaced by the humble, muddy attire of a twelve year old stableboy. The halberd he had been wielding so expertly had been switched for a simple pitchfork and on the pointy end, where he had imagined the still beating heart of his enemy to be, there sat a near perfectly spherical ball of horse ****.

It has potential and I didn't see the end coming. It's possible that due to his age my points about the exchange could be ignored since the boy wouldn't know the niceties. However to keep the reader fooled I think the fight scene has to be realistic.

Hope I helped.


TEiN
 
This is the first time I have offered my opinion, so, I will go lightly and just offer a small section first. See how we go.

Arrows rained down out of the sky. Arrows rained down... Has more punch and I think from the sky is obvious.
Elric remained perfectly still, even when one whistled by (take out the ,by,) a little too close for comfort, the barbed, bronze head embedding (hit the mud) in the mud less than a stride away. (take out, from him.) The group of mercenaries exchanged glances, a mixture of confusion and incredulity, before loosening off a second volley. Seeing that two or three were likely to find their mark, (take out, this time,) Elric bared his teeth and tightened his grip on the hilt of his sword. (Elric bared his teeth, tightened his grip on the sword, and waited)(out, He waited - just for) A heartbeat - then he swung, the gleaming blade cutting a swathe through the air, (snapping the shafts, broken pieces falling at his feet) (out, snapping the shafts of the projectiles and knocking them scattering.) He returned his gaze to his adversaries and flashed them a smile, mustering up the wickedest grin he could manage. (Mustering a wicked grin, he glanced at his adversaries)

Just my humble opinion, I think this speeds it up a tad and avoids stating the obvious.

Steve;)
 
My thoughts are that, while I was impressed by how meticulously choreographed and detailed this sequence was, it lacked context and emotion. Should I be rooting for Elric or the knight, and why? Despite all the action, I didn't feel a white-knuckled sense of urgency.

Then I got to the last couple of lines and thought, "D'oh!" :D Fooled me. The fight sequence might be a little too long for a mere daydream.
 
The subject is nice I like it!

But are you an equestrian? I am as fickle as Chris is on spelling and grammer when it comes to things like this.

For instance horses do not smell of straw when they gallop past and kneading reins what is that ( but I know what you were sriving at) ?
Lastly leathers do not twist round a foot could slip through an Iron but ( even in a fantasy realm) these were usually cupped to prevent that. They would be made of Iron or steel, leather would be no use at all ( for the reason you stated).

sorry but on equestrian matters ... I do know where I am at

Skill-at-Arms introduction on Vimeo

As a constructive finish - feel free to ask me anything about mounted combat!
 
Thanks for the comments.

The general consensus seems to be to make this a bit punchier and perhaps less clinical sounding in places.

TEIN: You have hit the nail on the head with what was my major concern about this piece: That a reader might start to look at this, get a few paragraphs down and stop reading in disgust upon finding such an unrealistic battle scene!
What I’ve tried to do is to write a heavily glamorised version of a battle as seen in the head of a twelve year old with no real experience of war. I know that the mercenaries wouldn’t waste all their clout-shooting practice on a singular target, nor would they flee so easily, but in Elric’s head he allows himself this fantasy. He has (unrealistic) aspirations of becoming a knight; such a hero that he could conceivably cut arrows out of the air. Needless to say, when the prologue ends and the first chapter begins several years later, Elric is more of a veteran of war and knows full well the harsh realities of it!
So I’m torn between making the battle too realistic, even at the expense of fooling the reader. Perhaps some sort of compromise? Add a degree of realism and shorten the scene somewhat perhaps. You’ve given me food for thought!

2ndchance: Thanks, I take it you’re agreeing that a lot of this piece needs trimming down and made more streamlined. I’ll work on that.

Pelagic Argosy: You’ve made me think of putting more of Elric’s feelings and thoughts during the battle scene, even though it’s a daydream where he’s invincible. More character conflict I guess. The urgency is something I’ll work on in the rewrite. It’s an important point, thank you.

Cavalry: I see why you have your username! I’m not an equestrian; I used to do a small amount of riding years ago when I was a boy, but it’s been a while, I have to admit.
The smelling of straw bit was an attempt at showing rather than just telling, ie “the horse galloped past”. It obviously failed! If it is a distraction rather than a contribution it might need to be trimmed out.

As for the leathers, my idea was based on the metal stirrups I’d used as a youth. I’d envisioned a foot slipping out of one stirrup even though cupped, but the other foot becoming trapped. Would the strap holding the stirrup not be leather though? This is what I’d had breaking in the story, not the stirrup itself. I probably didn’t write that clearly enough.
Nice video too by the way!



I’m wondering whether to post the other part of the prologue and then work on the whole thing en masse, or to tidy and trim the battle scene first. What do you guys suggest?
 
As far as critiquing goes, I think everyone else pointed out everything that needed to be fixed, I agree that you should come to a degree of compromise with how realistic the battle seen is, just enough glamour and fiction to hint at a boy imagination but not so much that the reader starts looking at the book as unrealistic. Other than that I really enjoyed this excerpt, by all means edit this little bit and post the whole prologue; I'm looking forward to reading about this daydreaming stable boy becoming a down-to-earth soldier.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top