Short story introduction

Status
Not open for further replies.

Vertigo

Mad Mountain Man
Supporter
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
8,763
Location
Scottish Highlands
My first time doing this so be kind!

This is the start of a short SF story. Sorry it's a bit long at 1257 words. I haven't really put a full plot together for the story but I have a couple of different possible directions it could go. However as this is my first attempt I thought I'd see what reactions I got before attempting to take it further. For the same reason I don't have a title yet.

**********

It all began over forty years ago…

"It's not fair, why should they be allowed to have babies?"

They had just finished watching a holovision documentary about life in Catholic families. And as always the presenters delighted in showing the extraordinary sight of dozens of children playing together. And as always Emma felt the need to vent her anger and frustration at the injustice of it. And as always Ian found himself producing his stock answer. "Come on, Emma, you know as well as I. They can will their lives to anyone they want and of course they are going to leave them to one of their own."

"But they have so many children, it's just not fair," she repeated.

"They forego rejuvenation for religious reasons, just like the Buddhists, so inevitably they have more deaths and consequently more children." This old argument had been repeated so many times now that Ian barely had the energy to state the obvious. Over a century ago the world governments had been forced into uniting behind the childbirth laws with the discovery of rejuvenation treatments. No one yet knows how long a life can be stretched but everyone knew the population couldn't be allowed to continue expanding as it had. One death, one birth. It was probably the most strictly enforced law since laws first began. You could leave your life to another in your will, but you had to die first. As a doctor Emma knew all this better than most but as a woman that didn't help.

"I know," she said, resigned, "but I can't help it, I want a baby. I want to feel life growing within me, I want to share the joy of my child's discovery of the world, I want to teach and guide her, lead her into the adventure of life." A pause, then; "It's all very well having rejuvenation but why can't we find a way to suppress this need?"

"There's always emigration." Again his stock answer but this time Emma didn't snap back but just looked pensive giving no answer.

This was a new twist; was she really seriously considering it, He wondered? To leave the soft civilised modern life for a colony. To be frozen for the decades it would take to reach one of the dozen or so star systems found to have habitable planets. Certainly, with Emma's vocation and his experience in the water treatment plants, they would have little trouble getting a place. But to leave everything behind just for the freedom to have children? It was a tremendous step to take with no chance of ever returning. Not quite ready for that argument yet, Ian chose to keep quiet himself.

The next morning all seemed forgotten. Cheerfully tripping over each other in the kitchen, each fixed their preferred breakfasts. Then, late as always, a fleeting kiss, before jumping into their eCars and racing off to their respective work.

When Ian got home that night, Emma was already logged onto the net. Thinking nothing of it, he pottered about in the kitchen. "Want a drink?" he shouted through whilst filling the kettle.

"Green tea, please" came the slightly distracted reply.

A couple of minutes later and a fresh, steaming mug sat beside Emma's netlink, Ian standing behind her sipping from his own. "What you looking at?" he said idly glancing at the screen and then did a double take; so it wasn't all forgotten.

"Look," she said "isn't it beautiful? No pollution. No over-population. With rejuvenation who knows what possibilities a family could create for themselves in such a place." Ah hah, a family, he thought.

Watching the slowly metamorphosing images of a slide show on the screen, he recognised them from a recent news report. They were from the first transmission just received from a new colony, so were probably only 10 years or so old. There were already fields in evidence and shots of a small, spacious town under construction. It looked like an idyllic rural scene on Earth but slightly out of kilter. Like crossing a border into a different country, everything was the same but subtly different. Ian considered what he knew about alien life in the colonies. Every compatible planet so far visited had been found to be filled with life developing along much the same lines as Earth. After all, the same evolutionary forces tended to produce similar solutions, though so far no other recognisable higher intelligence. It all looked enticingly attractive but he knew the reality; second and third wave colonists would become second and third class citizens. Unless they could afford to ship sufficient resources with them and, more importantly, guess what the most important and needed resources would be when they arrived, decades from now. "Do you really want to be a second wave colonist, Emma, maybe even third wave by now?"

"No, you've got it wrong; I'm only looking here to see what sort of standard of living the colonists can achieve after only a few years work." A couple of clicks and a new page appeared. "This is what I'm really looking at, it's a newly discovered planet and the transmissions from the first probes indicate a similar environment to Nuevo Latina." Ah yes, that was the name of the new colony. "They're already planning an arkship and will start recruiting next month…"

"You know they estimate it will take colonists over a century and half to buy back their indenture from the investors?"

"Yes of course, but we have time; with rejuvenation, as much time as we want. And a family Ian, we could have a family." The yearning in her eyes as she looked up at him, standing behind her, twisted something deep inside. And if the truth be known, he had the same longing, just better bottled up. Didn't everyone? She was right, of course, even though the limits are not yet known there have so far been no rejuvenation failures. Geoff turned seventy last year but his biological age hadn't changed from his first treatment at twenty five. They did have time.

Seeing his hesitation Emma followed up. "We could do it, Ian. We have the skills, we've enough savings. We really could do it…."

Forty three years later, with a two way communication lag of over twenty years to the nearest human government, several thousand humans established their base camp in a beautiful sheltered valley. The arkship dismantled and rebuilt into the core of a new town. Bridges truly burnt; the arkships are purposely designed to be one way tickets. It had only taken a week and everything was moving forward perfectly. Construction of the first residential houses was already starting, the first plant trials ready to start.

They had with them all the normal mix of colony survival skills; engineers, farmers, xenobiologists, doctors, teachers…

But no diplomats…

And now, silently standing just ten metres from Ian and Emma, calmly looking at them with what can only be described as open curiosity, were ten bipedal creatures that simply should not have been there. They were nowhere in any of the probes' records. Their soft mottled fur perfect camouflage for the nearby woods. Maybe that's why the probes never spotted them, or maybe they just aren't very widespread. Whatever, they stood there now and were clearly social, cooperative and organised… intelligent. And the colony had no one with diplomacy skills, no language specialists, only a few doctors like Emma had secondary psychiatry skills. They simply weren't equipped to deal with something like this.

**************

I can think of two ways I could take this. One (the original) would be to examine the problems and ethics of first contact with an alien species whilst being so far removed from any authority or expertise. I see the aliens as primitive but intelligent, maybe comparable with cro-magnon which gives scope for all kinds of ethical issues.

The other would be to drop the colony bit completely and explore the issues of childbirth with rejuvenation on Earth. In particular (inspired by one of Paolo Bacigalupi's short stories) to look at what happens when someone breaks the "one death, one birth" law or maybe a vice underground of people starting rejevenation on pre-adolescent children. Just a couple of thoughts.
 
Last edited:
I'm at work so I can't read all of this.

I'm going to start by saying that Emma is a horrific name of much vileness! :D

I think a lot of this story goes over my head really, but here are a couple of things I noticed:

"They can will their lives to anyone they want and of course they are going to leave them to one of their own."

This sentence made no sense to me. But I'm not sure if that's the fault of the sentence or my brain. Probably the latter.

Same with this sentence:

As a doctor Emma knew all this better most but as a woman that didn't help.

With this: Again his stock answer but this time Emma didn't snap back but just looked pensive giving no answer.

You already say she didn't answer by saying she's not snapped back. You don't need to repeat it.

And that's as far as I can go. For a first attempt it's pretty damn good! I'm just not a big-block-of-text type person, which you'll see from my own work! :)
 
It is a bit long and a bit of an info dump, sorry! However it seems to be a problem with a short story where you are creating a new world so to speak. I have noticed with a number of SF short stories that they tend to either leave you groping in the dark or do resort to some info dumping.

I'm going to start by saying that Emma is a horrific name of much vileness!
Yes I was unhappy with the names too! Didn't realise how hard it is to choose good names! Will have a think!

"They can will their lives to anyone they want and of course they are going to leave them to one of their own."
I wasn't too happy with the wording here but it is deliberate and sort of comes clearer a few lines down. The "will" here is referring to a last will and testament. People can leave their "life" to someone in their will so that person can then legally have a baby. Problem is that being dialogue I don't want to make it seem like a formal lecture. Which actually his next statement does rather seem to be.

As a doctor Emma knew all this better most but as a woman that didn't help
That one was a typo. No matter how many times I read it there are always more. There should have been a "than" between "better" and "more". I was just in time to edit it so have corrected that. heh heh.

With this: Again his stock answer but this time Emma didn't snap back but just looked pensive giving no answer.
I'll have to think about how to reword that. just leaving out "giving no answer" seems to leave it a bit abrupt.
 
Things that struck me while reading your work. By and large I enjoyed it (certainly enough to keep me interested in reading to the end). I would have liked to have seen more character development than what's on offer. Maybe add a bit more conflict into the mix, currently Ian seems too passive.

jumping into their eCars

eCars? Seriously?

"Look," she said "isn't it beautiful? No pollution. No over-population. With rejuvenation who knows what possibilities a family could create for themselves in such a place?"

The dialogue here sounds a bit stilted (my opinion of course). Maybe she can say it less like she's reading off a brochure?

Watching the slowly metamorphosing images of a slide show on the screen,

Despite having eCars and outer solar system travel people will still be using Powerpoint in the future?

It looked like an idyllic rural scene on Earth but slightly out of kilter. Like crossing a border into a different country, everything was the same but subtly different.

How is it different? It can't be the same and be different at the same time.

second and third wave colonists would become second and third class citizens.

Why would this be the case? It certainly isn't the case from past history of colonial experiences.

"You know they estimate it will take colonists over a century and half to buy back their indenture from the investors?"

Does this relate to the plot? Because reading this is throwing up a lot of questions for me. If these couple have been alive for so long and don't have children, why don't they have wealth to move themselves? Afterall, it states that they both have good jobs.

Didn't everyone?

No.

"We could do it, Ian. We have the skills, we've enough savings. We really could do it…."

What happened to being indentured?

the arkships are purposely designed to be one way tickets.

Present tense.

were ten bipedal creatures that simply should not have been there.

Most of your adverbs are pretty strong, except this one... and this one:

They simply weren't equipped to deal with something like this.
 
Thanks for that Luke there are some good points there.

Developing the characters, now that's something I just know I'm going to have difficulty with!

The eCars was a bit tongue in cheek, I just couldn't resist it the way everything seems to be becoming e- this that or the other. However I do hate "eco-cars" and "hybrids" and we can't keep calling them electric cars it's just too long winded. But of course if everyone has them we would certainly just call them cars :eek:.

Re second and third class. I must admit I haven't studied it but the colonies I'm thinking of here are in other star systems and I would expect there to be at least forty plus years between waves (second wave doesn't go out until first wave has reported back succcessfully) and this is what I would expect to create the disparity. By the time the second wave arrives the first will be well and truly established and have pretty much total control of local government. However I could well be wrong about that.

The "same but different" I'm trying to get across is that I do believe alien evolution will mimic our own. Over millions of years evolution on this planet has tried many different things but they all tend to be recognisable and familiar (at least once things have gotten beyond the bacteria stage). So I would expect something like grass but not quite, something like our trees but not quite. I would expect them to look similar enough but just a little disturbingly different. I know this could be argued differently but the bottom line is we really don't know until we find it.

Despite having eCars and outer solar system travel people will still be using Powerpoint in the future
No :D but I wouldn't mind betting we will still be viewing slide shows consisting of sequences of images flowed together. A little rdoing of that might be in order though - it does sound a little like a PowerPoint presentation.

I don't see the indenture business as crucial to the plot. But I do think it very very few people would have enough money to completely self finance emigration to another star system. I imagine they would have to come up with enough money to "equip" themselves but the indenture would be for the cost of the arkship which would inevitably be huge.
 
Well it's a good name, obviously, or I wouldn't have picked it (he says back peddling frantically). Actually every name I came up with seemed fine until I put them into the story and then I was unhappy. Then they all looked really prosaic. And it's not really far enough in the future to invent a whole load of new names.
 
I'm not going to comment on names as it truly doesn't matter.



This seems like it could go any number of ways, but I feel the way it should go is to please, don't make it into a cliche. The rejuvenation was a good idea and fairly original, as was the entire world uniting behind a strict childbirth law.

But with the main characters on a new world, try to keep war with an alien species as far away as possible, and if you do bring it in, use unconventional weapons. How many times do we have to put up with laser guns? :rolleyes:
 
If I go with the alien approach, then I wasn't planning on having any war at all. My vision was that they would be primitive - comparable to our cro-magnon - therefore vulnerable to predjudice and being treated like animals. Also it brings in issues of pollution of their natural development. I thought I would have them at the very top of their food chain and being peaceful hence their trusting approach (like many animals are in remote places on Earth if they have no natural predators). A bit cliche that I know, but not unreasonable if their population is still low so they are not competing for resources. What I wanted to explore is how a bunch of settlers would handle the situation with no real expertise in such things and with any such expertise literally decades away. My only problem with that is that the opening makes a big thing of the childbirth thing, which I would also like to explore, but that all becomes a bit redundant on the colony world. Except I was maybe thinking about having the doctors figure out a form of rejuvenation treatment that would work for the aliens raising the question of whether it should that be given to them. That sort of thing. It is only intended to be a short story after all.
 
First, let me say your premise is interesting, and I had no trouble staying engaged to the end. Personally, I'd like to see you keep the characters where they are and play out the tensions between biological imperatives and the "one death, one birth" laws.

Also, for the record, I didn't read "slide show" as PowerPoint. Based on some of your earlier clues, I assumed Emma watched a projection of images closer to a hologram than a PPT slide show.
 
Thanks for that Mandy - I must admit I think I'm beginning to favour sticking with the rejuve stuff on Earth. I rather suspect I've muddled things by accidentally squeezing two stories into one. It was just where my head went when I was first thinking of the idea.
 
Well, Vertigo. You continue to impress. Either you are telling gigantic porkies with your "this is my first time" or you have a good deal of natural talent.

For my taste there is too much info-dumping, but it's always difficult to get across a lot of background information of this kind. I prefer to go the slow drip-feed route, even if I'm not always successful myself, especially through dialogue but you need to avoid the "As you know, Fred" trap, which you fell into quite heavily, I'm afraid. Arguments are good for getting info across, and also good for generating conflict and interest, so personally I'd have had them rowing -- she's a woman desperately wanting a baby, she isn't going to accept his platitudes, especially when she's heard them all before. Can't you hear her saying: "Trust you to side with the bloody Catholics."?

As for the dialogue, it's not the most natural I've ever read, probably because you are so intent on trying to give information. Think yourself into these people's lives -- become Emma in her desperation for a child, feel her need and love and anger and all the rest of it.

I think my main concern, though, is because you don't know where the story is going, the whole thing is unfocussed. It would be perfectly possible to have both the idea of the restrictive birth laws and the new colony, but one or other needs to take precedence, and at the moment they are fighting. You need to resolve that before the other issues to my mind.

Coupled with that is the fact that you've opened the story at the wrong time if indeed you are taking them to the colony. This would be a moment of high drama and excitement, landing on a New World -- and this should be the opening, not a conversation they've had thirty times before over 40 years ago. A technique I use a lot is to have them at the important moment and then do a very brief flashback as to why they are there. So here it would be Ian first setting foot on the planet, the great swirl of emotion and the thought of a 40 year journey, and 20 years of childless agony before that, and all now over. Then segue into the first week's work and then the unexpected first contact.

If you decide to make the story about the birth laws, but in the absence of the colony idea, then again, I would suggest you need to show them on the brink of doing something, not just continuing an old discussion.

You also need to prune out scenes and dialogue which add nothing. This is true for all writing, but especially so for shorts where every word counts. So, for instance, the 3 paragraphs in the middle starting with "The next morning..." could all be omitted with no loss to the story.

As for grammar and punctuation, you slipped up on a few things, but I didn't see anything to make my nit-picker's hair stand on end, and I shall forbear from going through with a toothcomb, fine or otherwise.

But overall, very well done for a first attempt -- and you've got plenty of time before you start getting busy in mid-October to finish this and write lots more...!
 
Thanks for that TJ, and I promise everything I have said is true. I have only written technical manuals and training courses since I left school some 35 years ago.

I think I'm going to have to go back and have a re-think and a complete re-hash. I do agree that I have two stories jumbled up in there and the alien one really doesn't need the childbirth intro. So my inclination is to take a look at focussing on the childbirth one for now. But I think I might need to take a very different approach to it as the whole point of that first scene was to lead up to the idea of emigrating.

However this first attempt has been a great little learning experience with some excellent feedback. One interesting problem I had whilst writing was that I've read all this stuff about first person not generally being the preferred POV but I kept slipping into it and having to change it back to third person.

I still like both ideas for stories and definitely want to have a stab at them. Problem is it steals valuable reading time! :eek:
 
If it's coming to you in first person, roll with it. As Boneman will tell you, it's an invaluable way for getting inside a character's skin.

I think you're right to separate the two stories. Good luck with both of them.
 
Hello,

I enjoyed your story, and I like the idea of exploring issues of childbirth more. As TJ said, if it were about colony, you should start it right there when they land, and then explain the rest.

As to the first part of the story, I feel like there's no conflict, and it makes dialog boring and unnatural. Make them more emotional, add some drama. And if you have to show them drinking tea, or doing other routine, you could use this to show how their world is different from our own.

Keep it up, I'd like to see where you get with it :)
 
Thanks for that Kayleigh, I just know that emotion and drama are going to be difficult for me. I don't tend to be very emotional IRL. But I shall work on it. Right now I think I need to get a much clearer idea of a plot before I do anything else. So I'm just giving the old grey cells a bit of a work out now!
 
Here's a new attempt. I have dropped the colony idea to focus on the childbirth angle but it is still set in the same future. I have moved to a completely new scene for the start and the man is now the doctor. Nothing against women doctors you understand, I just don't feel up to trying to write a woman's POV that's all :eek:.

I would also add that I'm not sure I have the skills to continue this where I would have it going. Very sensitive and emotive topic!

************************

"What's the emergency?" Ian had just arrived and was observing the efficient bustle of preparatory activity.

"There's been a multi-vehicle accident near the city centre," said the A&E sister. A quiet centre to the orderly storm surrounding her. "We're expecting around fifteen casualties in the next ten minutes or so. Rooms are being prepped and we are calling in a couple of extra doctors."

"How the hell could something like that have happened?"

The sister pulled a face. "Apparently some hotshot wanted to impress his friends, hacked his cars safety system and took it out of urban auto-control. His reaction time wasn't up to it and they found themselves in the middle of an eight car pile up."

"Damn! How bad?"

"Mostly minor; cuts, bruises, shock, a few broken bones but there are a few more serious cases with possible internal injuries."

Ten minutes later and the victims started arriving in a noisy convoy of hospital trolleys. Ian's first patient was whisked into his treatment room by two paramedics.

"Closed fracture of the tibia, no apparent displacement. Some shock."

The paramedic's terse summary told Ian there was no immediate cause for alarm but his eyes widened as he took in the patient's young age.

The introduction of the first rejuvenation treatments over a century ago had forced the world's governments into uniting behind the childbirth laws. No one knew just how long a life could be stretched but everyone knew that population control was now essential. One death, one birth. It was one of the most strictly enforced laws of modern times. You could leave your life to another in your will but, with rejuvenation and modern genetic medicine, death was now much less frequent. So children were rare… very rare and this girl can't have been more than fourteen or fifteen.

His momentary pause was hidden by the paramedics gently lifting her from the trolley to the treatment couch.

"Right," he began awkwardly, he couldn't have spoken to more than two or three children in the last sixty years, "let's get you fixed up. We'll have you out of here in no time. My name's Ian," he added, cringing inwardly at how he must sound, "And what shall we call you?"

She just looked at him; distrustful, maybe even fearful.

A shrug from one the paramedics. "Hasn't spoken a word since we picked her up".

Ian raised his eyebrows, but decided to press on with the examination. Time enough to worry about that when things have calmed down. "Jenny, can you take a quick gene sample for me, while I get the scanner ready."

His nurse collected the sampler and came over to the couch taking the girl's arm. She spoke soothingly, "Don't worry it's completely painless, just a little scraping of skin…. There, all done." And to Ian, "I'll just be a minute with this, Doctor."

One of the paramedics held the door for the nurse and following her out they paused at the wave of sound from outside; shouts and doors slamming. Noticing the girl's increased anxiety, Ian called out to the departing medics, "What's with all the noise out there?"

"There's some guy storming about from room to room. Looks like he's headed this way. Want us to stick around?"

"Please." And to the girl's obvious fear, "don't worry you're completely safe. No one will harm you." But she just shook her head and then stared, wide eyed, as a big, heavily built man burst into the room. Scratches and a bruise above his right eye suggested he was one of the accident victims but he seemed otherwise unharmed.

His eyes fixed angrily on the girl. "There you are, come on get off that thing. You're coming with me. Right now!" Her face now betrayed outright terror.

As the paramedics quickly moved between the big man and the couch, Ian stepped forward; "Excuse me! This young girl is not going anywhere until her leg has been treated and we're happy she is not suffering from shock."

"I'm her father and she comes with me now!" He tried unsuccessfully to barge past the paramedics.

Ian bristled at the man's bully tactics. "Her leg is broken and if you are responsible for her, I would appreciate it if you would wait by the reception desk, where you will be informed of her progress."

He tried to pass the paramedics again but they weren't budging.

How this big thug could be any kind of relation to the slightly built young girl on the couch was beyond Ian, but even so, he was not about to tolerate this kind of behaviour. "I must ask you to leave this room immediately."

The sister, who had just marched through the door, wheeled about calling over her shoulder "I'll call security for you, Doctor".

Before he could respond the nurse returned holding a tablet. An anxious frown creasing her brow. "Doctor, could you take a look at this, please?"

"Just a minute Jenny, we really need to deal with this first." The man was still trying to get past the paramedics.

"I'm sorry, Doctor, but I really think you need to see this now."

One of the paramedics chipped in, "Don't worry; we're watching this guy and security will be along in a minute."

The arrogant scowl had vanished from the father and he was beginning to look worried, glancing back at the door. "You've no right to keep me from her." More of a complaint now than the earlier demands.

Jenny passed her tablet to Ian. "I was processing the genetic sample and… well, look for yourself."

Frowning, Ian scanned the genetic summary; it made no sense. "That's impossible! She's way too young to have had rejuvenation treatment."

"That's what I thought, Doctor, so I…"

The man was already through the door and running for the exit.
 
The paramedic's terse summary told Ian there was no immediate cause for alarm but his eyes widened as he took in the patient's young age. Children were very rare and this girl couldn't have been more than fourteen or fifteen.
( Ian remembered how)The invention of Rejuvenation treatments had forced world governments into uniting behind the childbirth laws. One death, one birth -the most strictly enforced law of modern times. Ian hadn't spoken to more than a handful of children in the last sixty years.
"Right..." he began awkwardly.

To get past that paragraph where the'infodump' happens. Maybe you also need to explain that one's life can be left to another...someone in cryogen-sleep? which is why children are so rare? Somehow it needs to seem more like Ian's quik thots, memories of the rejuvenation laws, rather than a narrator.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top