The Scar by China Mieville

[Werthead]

The Scar

Fleeing from New Crobuzon for reasons she prefers to keep to herself, Bellis Coldwine is heading for Nova Esperium, a colony located thousands of miles away across the Swollen Ocean, to lay low. Unfortunately, her ship is intercepted by the enigmatic pirates of the floating city of Armada and she is pressganged into Armada's service...as a librarian.

Armada is a city like no other, even on the baroque and weird world of Bas-Lag. Ruled over by the passion-fuelled Lovers, defended by Uther Doul and his unique sword, funded by piracy across half a dozen seas, Armada is a city of boats and decks and intrigue. But after centuries of wandering, Armada now has a mission and a purpose: to chain a creature of myth and to use it to find an ancient and great treasure. In the process Bellis will visit the island of the mosquito-women, will uncover a vast threat to New Crobuzon itself and be used and become an important chess-piece in the struggle for supremacy in the floating city.

China Mieville has written many good novels over the years, books which combine fine prose with wonderfully strange ideas, but often the elements of his books are out of balance. Perdido Street Station, for example, features wonderful worldbuilding and powerfully effective prose, but the actual story is somewhat mundane and the book overlong. The City and the City has a clever story and efficient, stripped-back writing but the premise doesn't convince (or at least the reactions of the outside world to it). Un Lun Dun is brilliant fun but lacks the darkness that lies at the heart of much of Mieville's work. And so forth.

The Scar, on the other hand, has all of Mieville's strengths working in tandem with one another. The world is vivid, the story engrossing, the writing intelligent but also compulsively page-turning, whilst the book has arguably Mieville's finest collection of characters.
Breaking free from the metropolis of New Crobuzon (which was fairly well-explored in Perdido Street Station), The Scar takes us across the oceans and islands of Bas-Lag, showing more locations and hinting at grander vistas lying beyond the horizon. It's a dizzying travelogue of invention and weirdness and works excellently.

The characters are an interesting bunch, from cold and remote Bellis Coldwine, our main protagonist, to Uther Doul, the city's resident badass warrior with a philosophical streak and a mighty sword (if The Scar had come out a bit later, I'd have suspected Anomander Rake as an inspiration). Even the secondary cast is superb, such as Tanner Sack, a Remade slave in New Crobuzon who becomes a respected and worthy citizen of Armada, and Shekel the cabin boy, a potential cliche who becomes a compelling character in his own right. Even barely-seen characters like the Brucolac, Hedrigall the lookout and the steamborg Angevine hint at tantalising depths. Mieville also continues his tradition of giving good monster, with the mosquito-women in particular being memorably horrific.

The Scar (*****) may be China Mieville's masterpiece, a rich and captivating weird novel of the fantastic. It is available now in the UK and USA.

 

[Ursa major]

While I'd recommend it as a good read, I'm not as enthusiastic about The Scar as you seem to be.

I can't really put my finger on it, but I didn't find this book as all-consuming a read as Perdido Street Station. (Yes, that book has its flaws, but I felt more engaged with its characters than I do with The Scar's.) Perhaps my (slight) disappointment comes from my belief that The Scar should have entranced me, but didn't quite manage it.

 

[Stephen Palmer]

Great review of his finest book so far.

 

[digs]

You nailed it Werthead. By far my favourite Mieville book, though I do love Perdido Street Station and Iron Council too. So many awesome and crazily inventive elements that somehow weave together to make a really compelling story.

 

[Fried Egg]

Hmm...I've been toying with the idea of reading this one next but I wasn't sure. You may well have convinced me!

 

[Foxbat]

I loved Perdido Street Station but couldn't get into Iron Council. From what you've said in the review, maybe it's time to give The Scar a try?

 

[Stephen Palmer]

I loved Perdido Street Station but couldn't get into Iron Council. From what you've said in the review, maybe it's time to give The Scar a try?

I satruggled with Iron Council as well. It's not bad, but to me there seemed to be a Bas-Lag-by-numbers feel to it.

 

[gully_foyle]

The Scar is definitely a much richer and enjoyable book than Iron Council, but I don't think it comes close to PSS myself. The characters in PSS were way more complex and interesting.