Quinn's First Assignment

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jake Reynolds

Wordslinger
Joined
Sep 24, 2010
Messages
638
Hi folks, thought it was about time that I posted some stuff of my own here to be torn to shreds. This is the first mini-chapter of a short story that features one of the secondary characters from my novels, set in his younger days. Any thoughts or opinions greatly appreciated.

Quinn's First Assignment

1
Barrow, Taradea Province, 2nd Day of Azdoch, 1828

Barrow, like most small towns, had secrets.

It was like many in the forested Hills of the Veil, so named for the mist that would often reach down from the Vaston Range like claws seeking to reclaim the land that man had taken. It was a place of old spirits and superstition, a place where the southern pioneers had not quite overcome what had been there before.

The thatched rooftops may have seemed homely, the snaking arms of smoke twirling upward promising warmth by a fire and perhaps a bowl for travellers. To Martyn Quinn, the muddy streets and rickety animal pens suggested that an outsider asking questions could expect a cold reception.

Not that he required warmth. Quinn was the sharp edge of the Tower of Scripture, a man who was expected to get things done. That his first assignment should take him to a place all but forgotten by the world was no surprise. In the southern hills the darkness of woods still held mysteries for those who cared little for lines on maps.

He dismounted, preferring to lead Shinsu in on foot, for if he rode in upon the young mare it might give the wrong impression. As it was he would be mistrusted as an outsider, but if he came charging in arrogantly he would get nowhere.

He saw movement on the streets as he reached the low wall that marked Barrow’s boundary, snow still clinging to its uneven rocks. People darted to and fro, no doubt hurrying about their business so that they to could return to their fires. Though it was warming further south, the snow of the hills desperately clung to every surface it could.

As he led Shinsu he caught the gaze of all that he passed. Those he saw out of doors merely lowered their gazes and barrelled forward on their way, unwilling to greet him. He expected it. These were people who ran Barrow as Barrow was run; a church officer from Havegard had little business there.

Everything he had with him marked him a city man; his long grey woollen coat and scarf, his black leather gloves and tricorn hat, his shirt and vest, his expensive boots. Owning a horse wasn’t so out of place here, though the saddle likely was. He might have received some kind of approval for the battered bedroll, marking him as a man that slept outdoors, but that would be all.

The goodwife hurrying past with her baskets, the two farmhands who narrowed their eyes and the old man that stood from his porch rocker and went inside at the sight of him, all of them told him more effectively than words that he was unwelcome.

He reached the town square, where eight buildings- one of them the church- faced a clay statue of a man with an axe, no doubt some kind of town founder. Most of the villages and towns at the base of the Vastons had such decoration, the southern provinces still proud of their pioneer spirit. To his right he saw half a dozen people deep in discussion in the entranceway of what seemed to be a council hall, unmindful of the cold winter’s evening. At sight of him one of the men stopped speaking and gestured to the others, all six of them going indoors silently.

‘Might have to break my promise, Shin,’ he told her as he rolled the ride from his shoulders, ‘not sure if you can find a warm stable tonight.’

‘After a stable?’

The voice had pipped from behind him, and he turned to see a boy of perhaps ten years, so rugged up against that cold that he couldn’t rest his arms at his side.

‘Could be,’ Quinn said. ‘There an inn here?’

‘Mem’s Place.’ The boy tried to point, but had to move his whole body sideways to do so, indicating a slightly larger building on the other side of the square, one of the few that had light stronger than a candle. ‘Got a stable there. Best get inside quick,’ he added. ‘We’re all supposed to be inside after dark.’

‘Why is that?’

The boy looked up at him as if he were dense. ‘Because the Widow Wind can freeze a man in ten steps, ‘specially in a winter like this.’

Quinn had the impression that the boy was repeating something another had said, likely his father’s words. ‘I'd best get inside then, yes?’

The boy shrugged and waddled away without another word, though Quinn thought he heard him singing to himself. Clucking to Shinsu, he led her toward the building opposite the council hall, tying her to the hitching post before slinging his saddlebags across one shoulder and heading toward the doors.

Before he had even put a foot on the bottom step the doors burst outward and a man staggered through them, stumbling down the three steps to sprawl in the hard, half-frozen mud. He was pursued by the biggest woman Quinn had ever seen. She wore an apron that he could have used as a blanket, a huge cudgel in her hands as she rolled from the building, blocking most of the light.

She was about to speak when she saw Quinn, and then sniffed as if she could smell the city on him, ignoring the spluttering man who also fell silent as he realised that an outsider stood there. The woman looked him up and down, her tongue poking out one of her cheeks as she assessed him.

‘Room and stable?’ she asked eventually, her voice matching her fierce demeanour.

‘Please, and a hot meal if you’ve one on the fire.’

‘We can rustle something up if you can pay for it.’

‘Not a problem.’

After a grunt, she paused only long enough to fork two of her fingers toward the man in the dirt, who tapped his chin twice and pointed at her in his silent rage. Quinn ignored their tiny superstitions, starting up the stairs and into the common room, thinking his arrival in Barrow was much as he expected.

The common room was similar to his welcome; both were as he had assumed they would be. A blazing fire scorched the room from the far wall, a main set of stairs leading upward to his right, and a corridor presumably leading to the stableyard where patrons might also relieve themselves if there was an outhouse. He caught sight of the immense woman passing through the archway, presumably to the kitchens beyond.
There were only six four-seater tables, and besides a man hunched over near the fire with his back to him, Quinn saw nobody else. The bar, situated further than usual from the bottle wall, ran the length of the place to his left, behind which a wiry barman cleaned tankards with a dirty rag.

‘Quiet night,’ Quinn observed, receiving only a shrug from the barman and no movement at all from the man by the fire.

He shrugged off his saddlebags and coat, ignoring the barman’s eyes upon him as he revealed the Najarim blade that was sheathed upside down on his back, the three foot long weapon easily hidden beneath the heavy wool. He draped his coat over the back of his chair before unslinging the weapon his teacher had given him, the runes upon the scabbard marking it as foreign even more than the gentle curve of blade and handle did. It was not a sword used by those from the Empire.

Leaving it upon the table by his hat, he walked over to the bar and leant upon it, his height perhaps half a foot more than the barman, though he chose a less intimidating stance. ‘Any of the stout in stock?’

‘Not so as city folk can stomach it,’ the barman replied, earning a shifting of the shoulders of the man by the fire.

‘Well, there’s a difference between coming from a city and being from a city.’ Quinn spun a copper gild on the bar.

The barman nodded, ‘Fair enough. Just the one?’

‘For now.’ Quinn spent the time waiting leaning back on the bar with his elbows upon it, looking at the various decorations. There was a stag’s head over the fire and a few flags, but not much else. ‘I’ve a horse outside,’ he started when the barman returned.

‘Taken care of. Baskin will be back soon enough. He’s never scared of Mem for long.’

‘Mem?’

‘You can’t be telling me you missed her.’

‘I see.’ Quinn smiled, settling over his ale. ‘Boy outside mentioned the Widow Wind,’ he said quietly.

The barman’s eyes narrowed as if he were some character in campfire tale. ‘Folk story. Just a name for the wind off the mountains. They say she used to stalk into town after dark, taking husbands away from their wives. Freezing it is, especially in a winter this late. Wait until a few more hours after dark.’

He held out his hand. ‘Martyn Quinn.’
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Dubrech, the upper limit for word count for the Critiques forum is 1500. I can appreciate you wanted to get to the end of the chapter, but the total came in well over that. Rather than lock the thread, this time I've simply lopped the end off the piece. Another time, however...

What you've given is plenty enough for us to see your writing skills, anyway. I'm in a rush at the moment, but I'll try and get back later and see if there's anything which needs nitpicking
 
Sorry boss, understood- thought I might sneak it in just to reach the end- nay bother.
 
Hello Dubrech, so ill mostly be focusing on the overall impression I got from this excerpt and gut reactions. I'm sure those vastly more qualified than i will be along for the structural/gramatic/nip picky stuff.

Right off the bat I can tell you I felt the opening was a bit wordy and awkward. Line one mentions Barrow having secrets, then that train of thought is completely abandoned. Later, you go into extensive detail about how outsiders are not welcome, i think it might be good to tie that back into Barrow having secrets. The second line did not work for me; it just seemed to run on and on, ending up kind of confusing. I think removing "It was like many" would help to clean that up. Overall I enjoyed the tone and vivid, detailed descriptions of the atmosphere and the town of Barrow, but felt we get too little introduction to Martyn Quinn, there are bits throughout and we are left to scrape up and piece them together on our own (if this is a prologue or some such, ignore that.) I think clear, basic intro to main characters makes it easier to visualize and gives reader an anchor of sorts.

Also, as a reader I started to loose interest somewhere around "Everything he had with him..."(Side note-the first three items you lump together are clothing items, so you could probably get away with 'Everything he wore' or 'The he was clothed') and didn't recapture attention until the little boy showed up. From then on out this turned into a novel I wanted to finish reading as soon as possible. Character interactions are a definite strength of yours!

Dont know how much help it was, but those are my gut reactions as a reader.

Keep up the good work!
 
You don't need what I do; grammar, punctuation and homophones (the easy stuff, I know.), you've got that down.

The bar, situated further than usual from the bottle wall, ran the length of the place to his left, behind which a wiry barman cleaned tankards with a dirty rag.
I'll point out one incorrect referent; the barman is behind the bar, not the place to his left.

The barman’s eyes narrowed as if he were some character in campfire tale.
"a" (or "some") campfire tale.
 
Hello Dubrech. In my humble opinion:

( ) = consider dropping.

(?) = consider another word or phrase.

Suggested changes in bold.

Firstly, I have to say that you've got some writing chops on you. I think you've done this critter thing before. Anyhoo...


Quinn's First Assignment

1
Barrow, Taradea Province, 2nd Day of Azdoch, 1828

Barrow, like most small towns, had secrets.

It was like many in the forested Hills of the Veil, Perhaps: a place of old... then move the following description to the end. so named for the mist that would often reach down from the Vaston Range like claws (?) seeking to reclaim the land that man had taken. It was a place of old spirits and superstition, a place where the southern pioneers had not quite overcome what had been there before.

Big opening sentence. Consider reconstruction. I did not relate mist and claws.

(The thatched rooftops may have seemed homely, the snaking arms of smoke twirling upward promising warmth by a fire and perhaps a bowl for travellers.) To Martyn Quinn, the muddy streets and homely thatched rooftops (rickety animal pens) spoke of a cloistered parochialism [FONT=&quot][/FONT]that would not be welcoming to outsiders. (suggested that an outsider asking questions could expect a cold reception.)

(Not that he required warmth.) Quinn was the sharp edge of the Tower of Scripture, a man who was expected to get things done. That his first assignment should take him to a place all but forgotten by the world was no surprise. In the southern hills the darkness of woods still held mysteries for those who cared little for lines on maps.

He dismounted, preferring to lead Shinsu in on foot, for if he rode in upon the young mare it might give the wrong impression. As it was he would be mistrusted as an outsider, but if he came charging in arrogantly he would get nowhere.

He saw movement on the streets as he reached the low wall that marked Barrow’s boundary, snow still clinging to its uneven rocks. People darted to and fro, no doubt hurrying about their business so that they to could return to their fires. Though it was (warming) the warmth had begun to return further south, the snow of the hills desperately clung to every surface (it could).

As he led Shinsu he caught the gaze of all that he passed. Those he saw out of doors merely lowered their gazes and barrelled (?) forward on their way, unwilling to greet him. He expected it. These were people who ran Barrow as Barrow was run; a church officer from Havegard had little business there.

Everything he had with him marked him a city man; his long grey woollen coat and scarf, his black leather gloves and tricorn hat, his shirt and vest, his expensive boots. Owning a horse wasn’t so out of place here, though the saddle would likely stand out (likely was). He might have received some kind of approval for the battered bedroll, marking him as a man that slept outdoors, but that would be all.

The goodwife hurrying past with her baskets, the two farmhands who narrowed their eyes and the old man that stood from his porch rocker and went inside at the sight of him, all of them told him more effectively than words that he was unwelcome. Hmmm, not sure. Haven't you made this point already?

He reached the town square, where eight buildings- one of them the church- faced a clay statue of a man with an axe, no doubt some kind of town founder. Most of the villages and towns at the base of the Vastons had such decoration, the southern provinces still proud of their pioneer spirit. To his right he saw half a dozen people deep in discussion in the entranceway of what seemed to be a council hall, unmindful of the cold winter’s evening. At sight of him one of the men stopped speaking and gestured to the others, all six of them silently retreating indoors (going indoors silently.)

‘Might have to break my promise, Shin,’ he told her as he rolled the ride from his shoulders, (ah, what?) ‘not sure if you can find a warm stable tonight.’

‘After a stable?’

The voice had pipped (?) from behind him, and he turned to see a boy of perhaps ten years, so rugged up against that cold that he couldn’t rest his arms at his side.

‘Could be,’ Quinn said. ‘There an inn here?’

‘Mem’s Place.’ The boy tried to point, but had to move his whole body sideways to do so, indicating a slightly larger building on the other side of the square, one of the few that had light stronger than a candle. ‘Got a stable there. Best get inside quick,’ he added. ‘We’re all supposed to be inside after dark.’

‘Why is that?’

The boy looked up at him as if he were dense. ‘Because the Widow Wind can freeze a man in ten steps, ‘specially in a winter like this.’

Quinn had the impression that the boy was repeating something another had said, likely his father’s words. ‘I'd best get inside then, (yes?)

The boy shrugged and waddled away without another word, though Quinn thought he heard him singing to himself. Clucking to Shinsu, he led her toward the building opposite the council hall, tying her to the hitching post before slinging his saddlebags across one shoulder and heading toward the doors.

Before he had even put a foot on the bottom step the doors burst outward and a man staggered through them, stumbling down the three steps to sprawl in the hard, half-frozen mud. He was pursued by the biggest woman Quinn had ever seen. She wore an apron that he could have used as a blanket, a huge cudgel in her hands as she rolled from the building, blocking most of the light.

She was about to speak when she saw Quinn, and then sniffed as if she could smell the city on him, nice ignoring the spluttering man who also fell silent as he realised that an outsider stood there. The woman looked him up and down, her tongue poking out one of her cheeks as she assessed him.

‘Room and stable?’ she asked eventually, her voice matching her fierce demeanour.

‘Please, and a hot meal if you’ve one on the fire.’

‘We can rustle something up if you can pay for it.’

‘Not a problem.’

After a grunt, she paused only long enough to fork two of her fingers toward the man in the dirt, who tapped his chin twice and pointed at her in his silent rage. Quinn ignored their tiny superstitions, starting up the stairs and into the common room, thinking his arrival in Barrow was much as he expected.

(The common room was similar to his welcome; both were as he had assumed they would be.) A blazing fire scorched the room from the far wall, a main set of stairs leading upward to his right, and a corridor presumably leading to the stableyard where patrons might also relieve themselves if there was an outhouse. He caught sight of the immense woman passing through the archway, presumably to the kitchens beyond.
There were only six four-seater tables, and besides (?) a man hunched over near the fire with his back to him, Quinn saw nobody else. The bar, situated further than usual from the bottle wall, ran the length of the place to his left, behind which a wiry barman cleaned tankards with a dirty rag.

‘Quiet night,’ Quinn observed, receiving only a shrug from the barman and no movement at all from the man by the fire.

He shrugged off his saddlebags and coat, ignoring the barman’s eyes upon him as he revealed the Najarim blade that was sheathed upside down on his back, the three foot long weapon easily hidden beneath the heavy wool. He draped his coat over the back of his chair before unslinging the weapon his teacher had given him, the runes upon the scabbard marking it as foreign even more than the gentle curve of blade and handle did. It was not a sword used by those from the Empire. Okay, if he's by the fire, then say so.

Leaving it upon the table by his hat, he walked over to the bar and leant upon it, his height perhaps half a foot more than the barman, though he slouched so as to present (chose) a less intimidating stance. ‘Any of the stout in stock?’

‘Not so as city folk can stomach it,’ the barman replied, earning a shifting of the shoulders of the man by the fire.

‘Well, there’s a difference between coming from a city and being from a city.’ Quinn spun a copper gild (?) on the bar.

The barman nodded, ‘Fair enough. Just the one?’

‘For now.’ Quinn spent the time waiting leaning back on the bar with his elbows upon it, looking at the various decorations. There was a stag’s head over the fire and a few flags, but not much else. ‘I’ve a horse outside,’ he started when the barman returned.

‘Taken care of. Baskin will be back soon enough. He’s never scared of Mem for long.’

‘Mem?’

‘You can’t be telling me you missed her.’

‘I see.’ Quinn smiled, settling over his ale. ‘Boy outside mentioned the Widow Wind,’ he said quietly.

The barman’s eyes narrowed as if he were some character in campfire tale. ‘Folk story. Just a name for the wind off the mountains. They say she used to stalk into town after dark, taking husbands away from their wives. Freezing it is, especially in a winter this late. Wait until a few more hours after dark.’

He held out his hand. ‘Martyn Quinn.’

Nice start, good flow, great descriptions. It's a little wordy here and there but nothing you won't catch on edit. A good sound piece of writing. Well done.

Hope that my comments are of some small value to you. But remember: take the good, leave the rest.


 
Hi,

Usual caveats
R Remove
G Possible suggestions
B Comments/queries

All only opinions

Hi folks, thought it was about time that I posted some stuff of my own here to be torn to shreds. This is the first mini-chapter of a short story that features one of the secondary characters from my novels, set in his younger days. Any thoughts or opinions greatly appreciated.

Quinn's First Assignment

1
Barrow, Taradea Province, 2nd Day of Azdoch, 1828

Barrow, like most small towns, had secrets.

It was like many in the forested Hills of the Veil, so named for the mist that would often reach down from the Vaston Range like claws seeking to reclaim the land that man had taken. It was a place of old spirits and superstition, a place where the southern pioneers had not quite overcome what had been there before.

Immediately I'm thinking black hills of Dakota. I'm not sure if I've walked into the SF or Western section. OK Azdock is a clue but for all I know such a date exists in some god forsaken country on Earth. It's also a bit passive and hasn't grabbed me by the throat. I could easily put this book on the shelf and move on by now.

Although I will say it's excellent description, which you seem to have a knack for in the rest of the piece; as others have said it could be moved to later.

The thatched rooftops may have seemed homely, the snaking arms of smoke twirling upward promising warmth by a fire and perhaps a bowl for travellers. To Martyn Quinn, the muddy streets and rickety animal pens suggested that an outsider asking questions could expect a cold reception.

Not that he required warmth. Quinn was the sharp edge of the Tower of Scripture, a man who was expected to get things done. (There's no justification for this claim - this is his first mission apparently so he could fail miserably. As for being the sharp edge of some force for order wouldn't he have some kind of insignia to advertise his status. If not then he's the soft edge, undercover, sneak about in the dark type of agent. The sharp edge would be the jack booted, gun ho kill everything on sight, squaddies) That his first assignment should take him to a place all but forgotten by the world was no surprise. In the southern hills the darkness of woods still held mysteries for those who cared little for lines on maps.

He dismounted, preferring to lead Shinsu in on foot, for if he rode in upon the young mare it might give the wrong impression (why? in most situations in every genre riding a horse creature into town would be perfectly expected - walking in would seem odd if not perverse. As to the sex of the beast?). As it was he would be mistrusted as an outsider, but if he came charging in arrogantly he would get nowhere. (now if he came in a whooping and a hollering and blasting away with his shotgun that may be true but quietly walking your horse into town?)

He saw movement on the streets as he reached the low wall that marked Barrow’s boundary, snow still clinging to its uneven rocks. People darted to and fro, no doubt hurrying about their business so that they to could get out of the cold and return to their fires. Though it was warming further south, the snow of the hills desperately clung to every surface it could. (Technically the snow of the hills is on the hills)

As he led Shinsu he caught the gaze of all that he passed. (probably wondering -wonder why he ain't riding that horse:)) Those he saw out of doors merely lowered their gazes and barrelled forward on their way, unwilling to greet him. He expected it. These were people who ran Barrow as Barrow was run(?); a church officer from Havegard had little business there. (I don't quite get this - do they know somehow what he is and are avoiding him as a result)

Everything he had with him marked him a city man; his long grey woollen coat and scarf, his black leather gloves and tricorn hat, his shirt and vest, his expensive boots. Owning a horse wasn’t so out of place here, though the saddle likely was (why?). He might have received some kind of approval for the battered bedroll, marking him as a man that slept outdoors, but that would be all.

The goodwife woman hurrying past with her baskets, the two farmhands who narrowed their eyes and the old man that stood from his porch rocker and went inside at the sight of him (do old people sit in rockers in the freezing cold), all of them told him more effectively than words that he was unwelcome.

He reached the town square, where eight buildings- one of them the church- faced a clay statue of a man with an axe, no doubt some kind of town founder (I would think he would know - he would have been briefed who the town founders were and all about what was known). Most of the villages and towns at the base of the Vastons had such decoration, the southern provinces still proud of their pioneer spirit. To his right he saw half a dozen people deep in discussion in the entranceway of what seemed to be a council hall, unmindful of the cold winter’s evening. At sight of him one of the men stopped speaking and gestured to the others, all six of them going indoors silently.

‘Might have to break my promise, Shin,’ he told her as he rolled the ride from his shoulders (rolled the ride?), ‘not sure if you can find a warm stable tonight.’

‘After a stable?’

The voice had pipped from behind him, and he turned to see a boy of perhaps ten years, so rugged up against that cold that he couldn’t rest his arms at his side.

‘Could be,’ Quinn said. ‘There an inn here (town)?’

‘Mem’s Place.’ The boy tried to point, but had to move his whole body sideways to do so, indicating a slightly larger building on the other side of the square, one of the few that had light stronger than a candle. ‘Got a stable there. Best get inside quick,’ he added. ‘We’re all supposed to be inside after dark.’

‘Why is that?’

The boy looked up at him as if he were dense. ‘Because the Widow Wind can freeze a man in ten steps, ‘specially in a winter like this.’

Quinn had the impression that the boy was repeating something another had said, likely his father’s words. ‘I'd best get inside then, yes?’

The boy shrugged and waddled (everybody else is scurrying to get out of the cold) away without another word, though Quinn thought he heard him singing to himself. Clucking to Shinsu, he led her toward the building opposite the council hall, tying her to the hitching post before slinging his saddlebags across one shoulder and heading toward the doors.

Before he had even put a foot on the bottom step the doors burst outward and a man staggered through them, stumbling down the three steps to sprawl in the hard, half-frozen mud. He was pursued by the biggest woman Quinn had ever seen. She wore an apron that he could have used as a blanket, a huge cudgel in her hands as she rolled from the building, blocking most of the light.

She was about to speak when she saw Quinn, and then sniffed as if she could smell the city on him, ignoring the spluttering man who also fell silent as he realised that an outsider stood there. The woman looked him up and down, her tongue poking out one of her cheeks as she assessed him.

‘Room and stable?’ she asked eventually, her voice matching her fierce demeanour.

‘Please, and a hot meal if you’ve one on the fire.’

‘We can rustle something up if you can pay for it.’ (I would've expect a little colloquialism rather than this standard English tone out here in the sticks. not too much else it become unreadable like Huckleberry Finn but just the odd dropped consonant)

‘Not a problem.’

After a grunt, she paused only long enough to fork two of her fingers toward the man in the dirt, who tapped his chin twice and pointed at her in his silent rage. Quinn ignored their tiny superstitions, starting up the stairs and into the common room, thinking his arrival in Barrow was much as he expected.

(Slight problem here with the way a horse culture works. I always thought the golden rule was see to your horse first. He's just been told the cold is bitter, his horse is warm from presumably a long ride. Would he leave it out in the street to freeze while he has a cup of warm cocoa and big fat steak?)

The common room was similar to his welcome; both were as he had assumed they would be. A blazing fire scorched the room from the far wall, a main set of stairs leading upward to his right, and a corridor presumably leading to the stableyard where patrons might also relieve themselves if there was an outhouse. He caught sight of the immense woman passing through the archway, presumably to the kitchens beyond.
There were only six four-seater tables, and besides a man hunched over near the fire with his back to him, Quinn saw nobody else. The bar, situated further than usual from the bottle wall, ran the length of the place to his left, behind which a wiry barman cleaned tankards with a dirty rag.

‘Quiet night,’ Quinn observed, receiving only a shrug from the barman and no movement at all from the man by the fire.

He shrugged off his saddlebags and coat, ignoring the barman’s eyes upon him as he revealed the Najarim blade that was sheathed upside down on his back (not very pratical. On a horse for instance it would be nigh impossible to draw and under a long woolen coat what would be the point - Oh could you just hold my coat while I get ready for your attack.:) However, upright with the handle sticking out of the collar gives easy access and protects the back and neck from behind), the three foot long weapon easily hidden beneath the heavy wool. He draped his coat over the back of his chair before unslinging the weapon his teacher had given him, the runes upon the scabbard marking it as foreign even more than the gentle curve of blade and handle did. It was not a sword used by those from the Empire.

Leaving it upon the table by his hat, (he would never do this. Strange town, unknown situation anything could be brewing and he's six feet from his weapon of choice. He'd be more likely to sit down and indicate to the barman he wanted some service) he walked over to the bar and leant upon it, his height perhaps half a foot more than the barman, though he chose a less intimidating stance. ‘Any of the stout in stock?’

‘Not so as city folk can stomach it,’ the barman replied, earning a shifting of the shoulders of the man by the fire.

‘Well, there’s a difference between coming from a city and being from a city.’ Quinn spun a copper gild on the bar.

The barman nodded, ‘Fair enough. Just the one?’

‘For now.’ Quinn spent the time waiting leaning back on the bar with his elbows upon it, looking at the various decorations. There was a stag’s head over the fire and a few flags, but not much else. ‘I’ve a horse outside,’ he started when the barman returned.

‘Taken care of. Baskin will be back soon enough. He’s never scared of Mem for long.’

‘Mem?’

‘You can’t be telling me you missed her.’

‘I see.’ Quinn smiled, settling over his ale. ‘Boy outside mentioned the Widow Wind,’ he said quietly.

The barman’s eyes narrowed as if he were some character in campfire tale. ‘Folk story. Just a name for the wind off the mountains. They say she used to stalk into town after dark, taking husbands away from their wives. Freezing it is, especially in a winter this late. Wait until a few more hours after dark.’

He held out his hand. ‘Martyn Quinn.’

After the initial lack of action I'm warming to the situation. I think you could work some incident in prior to his arrival at the outskirts of the town. Something with some action that will establish his ability and introduce the rapport between him and the horse. We will get an idea this isn't some bookkeeper with and old nag and it will set up the reason for the cautious approach.

Hope I helped

TEiN
 
Thanks guys, great points. It's amazing what you overlook when you're doing it yourself! I few face palms there...
 
Just a quick one. I would lose most of the description. It's a fairly generic setting so far -- nothing wrong with that, but it means we can picture it with a minimum of cues from the writer. I would also be tempted to start with the character rather than the setting, maybe here:

That [Quinn's] first assignment should take him to a place all but forgotten by the world was no surprise.

It's unusual for fantasy that he's wearing a tricorn hat etc, but if you want us to know what he's wearing, try having him do something with it rather than just describing it to us. The tone of the first half is one of you trying to paint the scene so you can then get on with the story that's happening within it. My advice would be, don't -- start the story straight away and fill in what we need to see of the scene around it. After halfway or so, it improves and relaxes into the story more.
 
I'll pick and choose some bits...

It was like many in the forested Hills of the Veil, so named for the mist that would often reach down from the Vaston Range like claws seeking to reclaim the land that man had taken. it's a bit rambly. I'd change it.



He dismounted, preferring to lead Shinsu in on foot, for if he rode in upon the young mare it might give the wrong impression. As it was he would be mistrusted as an outsider, but if he came charging in arrogantly he would get nowhere. why would riding in be regarded as aggressive?


As he led Shinsu we already know he's leading her he caught the gaze of all that he passed. Those he saw out of doors merely lowered their gazes and barrelled forward on their way, unwilling to greet him. He expected it. These were people who ran Barrow as Barrow was run; a church officer from Havegard had little business there.


The goodwife hurrying past with her baskets, the two farmhands who narrowed their eyes and the old man that stood from his porch rocker and went inside at the sight of him, semicolon, perhaps? or a rewording all of them told him more effectively than words that he was unwelcome.


‘Mem’s Place.’ The boy tried to point, but had to move his whole body sideways to do so, are you telling us he's disabled? neatly done indicating a slightly larger building on the other side of the square, one of the few that had light stronger than a candle. ‘Got a stable there. Best get inside quick,’ he added. ‘We’re all supposed to be inside after dark.’



After a grunt, she paused only long enough to fork two of her fingers toward the man in the dirt, who tapped his chin twice and pointed at her in his silent rage. Quinn ignored their tiny superstitions, starting up the stairs and into the common room, thinking his arrival in Barrow was much as he expected.
the preceding and succeeding sentences are too similar
The common room was similar to his welcome; both were as he had assumed they would be. A blazing fire scorched the room from the far ...

If this is part of a short story, it feels like it's quite a long short story.
I'd also agree there's probably too much description.
One other thing is that Quinn seems pretty confident for a first assignment. Should he be a bit more nervous?
It's good stuff, though. I'm interested enough to find out what happens, and what the background is.
 
Hey, other much more qualified done all the nitpicking so ill just make some general points. Firstly, liked it. I think this is a story I would read if it was i the first chapter of a book. So with that in mind, a couple of caveats - keep in mind i have not put any of my own stuff up here for reviewing (maybe later ;) ) so I could just be talking out my... well, to carry on.

The visual stuff - claws from the mountains, the fancy saddle (presuming it was fancy - it might have been pink), tower of scripture etc. all need expanding out. they feel awakward otherwise, like youre at the beginning of a story which is just left there, hanging... I realise this is meant to be a short story which is why i am concerned they would not get filled out more. I think it would work better as the beginning of a book or build on these sentences to fluff out what your poiint was, rather than presuming thats job done.

there are also multiple references to being unwelcome 'an outsider asking questions could expect a cold reception...he would be mistrusted as an outsider...unwilling to greet him. He expected it...told him more effectively than words that he was unwelcome....not sure if you can find a warm stable tonight' - when actually, the visualisation you are doing already makes that point clear. You could just do the townsfolk scurrying, perhaps make a point about a shiny saddle being stared at and then leave it to the reader to firm it all up when Quinn talks to his horse. No need to keep pointing it out.

Another point is the name - this is very much a personal preference and theres nothing wrong with martyn, in fact i know one. Its just that you always think 'ooooh thats an unusual way to spell martin' or 'haha hes spelled it wrong', both of which you dont want the reader doing early in the story. Maybe its just me! I think Quinn is a good name, vaguely religious, adequate for a character. Thats just IMHO.

Otherwise I like the dialogue with the barman. I thought it came across as natural and quickly established a relationship beyond idle banter. Perhaps this barman was going to come up with more useful info? I didnt so much like the boy - unless he reappears later on as either a demented werewolf or the barman were to say 'what boy? theres been no boy here since 1274..." tadaaa! You get what I mean. If thats the last we see of the boy it seems a lot of characterisation for no purpose.

Finally (yay) I totally commiserate with you about length. My first part of my first chapter is 2,200 words and keeps growing. Im going to have to cut it off early too!

Good work.

Regards.

S.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top