Short rewritten prologue

Status
Not open for further replies.

Damiynn

Fantasy Author
Joined
May 1, 2005
Messages
290
Location
I am a fantasy author, who has traveled the world.
If you have been here for a while you know I have finished my first book, and have used the crits to finish my second book, the prolouges from both have told a different story than the actuall books, and some of you have been helping me with that. Well this is the third prolouge to go with the other two.

Prologue

The dank rank smell of old sweat and blood clung to everything in the lower levels of the holding pits. Lord Richard couldn’t keep the smell from permeating his nostrils, it was everywhere, but it was a small price to pay. If I am right. The worried thought cut through him like a worm through an apple.

The fighting slave’s owner carried a long pole. It was pointed on one end and he jabbed it in between the bars of a cell. “Get ye up! Go on get off your lazy ass, behave yourself, someone is here to see you.”

Through the bars of the cell door, Lord Richard saw a tall figure stand, bald headed, scarred and bloody. Although his wrists were manacled and all he wore was a burlap shift that could only barely be called clothes, the smell of death still surrounded him. He looked like a death shadow moving, a killer with no conscious and no morals other than to survive.

Dried blood covered his face, neck and chest and to Richard’s eyes at first he looked nothing like the man Richard remembered him being, but it was him.

“Raise your damn head so that the good lord can see you.” The stick shot out but just before it caught the bald headed man in the chin, his voice rasped out in a snarl, “If you touch me with that thing again, you will never touch anyone again.”

The long stick stopped inches from the slave’s chin. It hung in the air for a few moments, then it began quavering and fell to the floor.

Lord Richard watched the exchange, he still had the air of command he remembered, for that he was grateful, it spoke a lot about his spirit. You might be able to take the man out of a leader’s role, but you would find it hard to take the leader out of a man.

“Please raise your head,” Lord Richard asked, his voice also carrying the tone of command but not enough to offend.”

A haunted mask of a face lifted to meet his eyes. It was a haggard shattered remnant of the one that he knew it to be. One thing was still the same, the eyes that met his. In spite of their haunted look, that made them appear as if they had seen every specter in a graveyard, it was still him.

“How long will you fight for, no matter how long it is you can never atone for what happened, and if you haven’t by now, I’m sure the gods don’t want you to.”

“What are you talking about?” growled the man behind the cell door. “You couldn’t understand!”

“I know why you are fighting.” Stated Lord Richard gently, his voice even and calm, “If you agree and stop doing it here, I promise I will give you a reason to live again someday. A reason you will need to fight for.”

“All I fight for is dead,” stated the fighting slave behind the cell door.

“Yes I know, they all died that night, of that almost all are certain,” returned Lord Richard.

Suddenly bloody hands shot out and grasped the bars on the cell door, turning white knuckled hot, they squeezed. “Almost all are certain, what do you mean,” a harsh voice growled. “None lived, except me!”

“And you can’t die here.” Lord Richard solemnly said. The eyes behind the cell door met his, dark brown ones that stared into his steel grey.

“I know you have tried. It won’t happen. Come with me, live with me, swear oaths to me and I promise you with all my heart that someday I will give you a reason to want to live again. A reason I am certain of.” Lord Richard allowed his voice to trail off and there was a noticeable silence in the holding pits, a quiet sort of tension that seemed to grip the room in a tight fist.

Finally the hands holding the bars released them, and slip slowly back inside of the cell. Richard saw the head lower and heard a voice say, “You have my oath I will follow you till you give me a reason to want to live again.”

Lord Richard turned and eyed the holding slave’s keeper. “Free him, get him out of those rags, give him a sword, and tell him to meet me out front.”

The holding cells keeper, bowed his head quickly, saying, “As you wish my lord, so shall it be immediately.”

Lord Richard turned away from the beaten battered fighting slave who had once been protector to the king and queen and walked outside, hoping that he could keep all this and everything else secret until the proper time came.
 
Intriguing. On the whole I enjoyed it. I felt it did what a Prologue should, pulling me in, giving me hints of detail, and making me want to know more. I would definitely read on to see where this goes.

The only issues I saw (and as I always say, I'm no expert) were mostly small details, just little things that made my eyebrow arch when I saw them. These are some of them.

The worried thought cut through him like a worm through an apple.
I would change "cut" to "bored" or "drilled", as when I think of a worm through an apple, "cutting" seems way to quick. Small detail, I know, but it struck me as odd.

There were a few sentences that seemed to run on when they shouldn't. For example, Lord Richard watched the exchange, he still had the air of command he remembered, for that he was grateful, it spoke a lot about his spirit.I believe it should be Lord Richard watched the exchange. He still had the air of command he remembered, and for that he was grateful. It spoke a lot about his spirit.

Another fragment that stuck out at me was this.
In spite of their haunted look, that made them appear as if they had seen every specter in a graveyard, it was still him.
The highlighted bit just felt unnecessary, and personally it was a bit distracting. I would suggest maybe, Despite their haunted look, they were his. or something similar.


“How long will you fight for, no matter how long it is you can never atone for what happened, and if you haven’t by now, I’m sure the gods don’t want you to.”
I'm far from being an expert in the field of punctuation, but I had to read the sentence twice before realizing what the character was saying. "How long will you fight for?"

Yet that second sentence felt redundant, when Lord Richard says, "No matter how long it is, you can never atone for what happened," why would he then suggest the possibility that he had? "If you haven't by now, I'm sure the gods don't want you to." just felt kind of pointless to me.

Again, I'm no expert, and if something I pointed out is indeed the way it should be, then someone please correct me. As I said, just small things I thought were odd. Overall, though, very nice. I look forward to reading more at some point in the future. Hope you found this helpful!
 
Just cut out and switched little bits here and there, take what you can use. A prologue should probably, usually be as concise as you can make it.

The rank smell of old sweat and blood (permeated) the lower levels of the holding pits. Lord Richard couldn’t keep the smell from clinging to his clothing, but it was a small price to pay - If I am right, he thought. Worry gnawed at him like a worm burrowing inside an apple.

The fighting slave’s owner carried a long pole, needle-sharp on one end, and he jabbed it between the bars of the cell.

“Get ye up! Go on get off your lazy ass, behave yourself, someone is here to see you."
A tall figure stood inside the cell, bald headed, scarred and bloody. Although his wrists were manacled and all that he wore was a burlap shift, which could scarcely be called clothing, an aura of death still surrounded him. He looked like a dead shadow moving, a killer with no conscious and no morals. ( other than to survive.

Dried blood covered his face, neck and chest, and to Richard, he looked nothing like the man he remembered, but it was he. (?) Or him? Look it up:)
 
The fighting slave’s owner carried a long pole. It was pointed on one end and he jabbed it in between the bars of a cell.

The fighting slave's owner carried a long pointed pole and he jabbed it between the bars of a cell.

You might want to consider dropping "fighting" and letting the audience figure that out on their own. You could detail some of the scarring to reinforce that he is a fighting slave.
 
Hi, just a few observations. Usual caveats; who am I to tell you etc.

First things, the length is good. Goldilocks and the three bears - just about right. I tend to ignore prologues, but having said that, I wonder what the point of a prologue is if it's not about the book - Hey but it works for you so...

If you have been here for a while you know I have finished my first book, and have used the crits to finish my second book, the prolouges from both have told a different story than the actuall books, and some of you have been helping me with that. Well this is the third prolouge to go with the other two.

Prologue

The dank rank (stank I'd lose the poetical rhyming and just leave it at dank. Plus in my experience such places have much stronger smells than sweat - p*ss and s**t spring to mind. IMO not to include those cloud the true mental picture) smell of old sweat and blood clung to everything in the lower levels of the holding pits. Lord Richard couldn’t keep the smell (too many smells) odour, taste might be included too) from permeating his nostrils, it was everywhere (covered that) , but it was a small price to pay (it's not really a price more a discomfort). If I am right. The worried ("If I'm right" is more an optimistic thought rather than a worried one - unless he wants to wrong of course) . thought cut through him like a worm through an apple.

The fighting slave’s owner carried a long pole. It was pointed on one end and he jabbed it in between the bars of a cell (Not realistic IMO. Slave owners - especially of fighting slaves - would not risk damaging the good with a sharp point. A badly placed jab could sever an artery or tendon. Not worth the risk Plus this is a fighting slave. He could easily turn on his owner and take the 'pole' and have a handy javelin with which to seek redress on the owner. Common or garden staff would be enough to rouse a tardy slave. They both work within limits of behavior). “Get ye up! Go on get off your lazy ass, behave yourself, someone is here to see you.” (the behave yourself isn't required. The accent seems to be dropped half way through)

Through the bars of the cell door, Lord Richard saw a tall figure stand, bald headed, scarred and bloody (again a valuable fighting slave wouldn't be left to fester with open wounds. Since he won his last bout (he's alive) he would have his wounds dressed and possibly even be given a 'companion' not just left to rot). Although his wrists were manacled and all he wore was a burlap shift that could only barely be called clothes that hardly covered his modesty, the smell of death still surrounded him. (No, you've said it was everywhere so you couldn't attach it to this one person now) He looked like a death shadow moving, a killer with no conscious and no morals, his only concern was to survive other than to survive. (Er... didn't get that at all)

Dried blood covered his face, neck and chest and to Richard’s eyes at first he looked nothing like the man Richard remembered him being (too many Richards), but it was him.

“Raise your damn head so that the good lord can see you.” The stick (? it's a spear) shot out but just before it caught the bald headed man in the chin, his voice rasped out in a snarl, “If you touch me with that thing again, you will never touch anyone again.” (as I remarked above plus too much touching)

The long stick (what is it? a pole, stick or long stick. why not just call it a spear) stopped inches from the slave’s chin. It hung in the air for a few moments, then it began quavering and fell to the floor (the owner considered, he needed to save face but he knew the man next to him was interested in the slave. He would punish the outburst later, for now he thought better of it and withdrew).

Lord Richard watched the exchange, The man he still had the air of command he remembered, for that he was grateful, it spoke a lot about his spirit. You might be able to take the man out of a leader’s role, but you would find it hard to take the leader out of a man. (a bit cliche ish)

“Please raise your head,” Lord Richard asked, his voice also carrying the tone of command but not enough to offend.” (please does not suggest command "Raise your head" is sufficient)

A haunted mask of a face lifted to meet his eyes. It was a haggard shattered remnant of the one that he knew it to be (whoa; a minute ago he was the spirited defiant leader person. now he's a haggard remnant bag of bones - which would hardly make for a fighting slave). One thing was still the same, the eyes that met his. In spite of their haunted look, that made them appear as if they had seen every specter in a graveyard, it was still him. (the two things don't connect IMO either his eyes were haunted and completely unlike the other person or it was the same guy because his eyes were the same)

How long will you fight for, no matter how long it is you can never atone for what happened, and if you haven’t by now, I’m sure the gods don’t want you to.”

“What are you talking about?” growled the man behind the cell door. “You couldn’t understand!” (neither did I:))

“I know why you fight are fighting.” stated Lord Richard gently, his voice even and calm, “If you agree and stop doing it here, I promise I will give you a reason to live again someday. A reason you will need to fight for.” (stop fighting so you can fight ?)

“All I fight for is dead,” stated the fighting slave behind the cell door.

“Yes I know, they all died that night, of that almost all are certain,” returned Lord Richard. (I would have thought there should be some recognition from the slave by now I would have thought. It should at least be mentioned even if the slave is choosing to ignore it.)

Suddenly bloody hands shot out and grasped the bars on the cell door, turning white knuckled hot, they squeezed. “Almost all are certain, what do you mean,” a harsh voice growled. “None lived, except me!” (shot out again)

“And you can’t die here.” Lord Richard solemnly said. The eyes behind the cell door met his, dark brown ones that stared into his steel grey.

“I know you have tried. It won’t happen. Come with me, live with me, (sounds a bit dodgy:)) swear oaths to me and I promise you with all my heart that someday I will give you a reason to want to live again. A reason I am certain of.” Lord Richard allowed his voice to trail off and there was a noticeable silence in the holding pits, a quiet sort of tension that seemed to grip the room in a tight fist.

Finally the hands holding the bars released them, and slipped slowly back inside of the cell. Richard saw the head lower and heard a voice say, “You have my oath I will follow you till if you give me a reason to want to live again.”


Lord Richard turned and eyed the holding slave’s keeper. “Free him, give him a bath clothes get him out of those rags (it was a loincloth above), give him a sword, (he just wouldn't too dangerous - this man now has a protector of rank and if there was anything between them then the owner wouldn't risk it) and tell him to meet me out front.” (He would say it to the man, the owner is out of it now as far as ordering the slave about. as in:- When you are ready I will be in the 'The Tridents Cast' tavern, across the road )
The holding cells keeper, (demoted ? owner) bowed his head quickly, saying, “As you wish my lord, so shall it be immediately.”


Lord Richard turned away from the beaten battered fighting slave who had once been protector to the king and queen and walked outside, hoping that he could keep all this and everything else secret until the proper time came.

OK more than a few comments. It's engaging. However, if I read this and then bought the book only to find that was the end of it. I would be more than a little miffed. It would be the last book of yours I bought. You've set up the book well and now I want the rest of story. I don't want to read about a roman like society in the prologue only to find I've really bought a bodice ripping tale of lost romantic love and domestic life. Though again you say you've done this before successfully so who am I etc.

Hope I helped

TEiN
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top