Alien Jam - 1000 post critique

Status
Not open for further replies.

Moonbat

Chuckle Churner
Joined
Jul 18, 2007
Messages
2,238
Location
Devon
Well it has been a while, I've been at 999 posts for a few days, I know (or at least I think it is the order of the day) that I'm expected to create a post for critique on my 1000 post. so here it is. :rolleyes:

It started off as an idea for a screenplay (this is the opening scene), I've been leaning towards making it a graphic novel, but here it is as a plain old story. The title is only a working title. Obviously I'd like to know what you guys think, and I'm sure there are grammatical errors, the formatting is designed to make it easier to read. I hope you enjoy. :)


Alien Jam

On the cold, damp and dingy bridge Ludackm’s crew busied themselves behind him. He could feel their eyes on him, he felt as though he could lean back on the wall of tension directed at him. He was deep in contemplation, transfixed to the main viewer which displayed an enhanced image of a still distant planet. He studied the planet, hoping to draw some conclusions that would not be revealed to his crew through their numerous instrument panels. Sometimes, when they approached a planet, he felt like he had a kind of telepathy and that he could communicate with the planet itself; learn some of its secrets before the cold hard facts were presented.

He had taken an enormous risk and this trip had been a failure. They had travelled a long way and, as of yet, only procured a tiny percentage of their quota. He might return home ruined, with colossal debts, disowned by his family and no hope of living free. His wife would dismiss him (if she hadn’t already) the best he could hope for was that his children inherited his debt and worked to pay it off for him. He had decided, after the calamity that was Plompstop, that they take a huge (and very costly) detour in an attempt to recoup some of his losses. This was that detour right now, they were travelling ever closer to the planet that would either plunge them all into the lowest echelons of society, let them break even, or propel them into the comfortable life of a veteran.

Malkick coughed, Ludackm ignored him and the crew grew increasingly worried that the captain was ruining all of their lives. It occurred to Ludackm that the planet he was looking at was unnaturally beautiful. Maybe it was the promise of reward and his vicinity to possible redemption that colouring his thinking, polluting his thoughts and cajoling him into thinking it was more than your average life sustaining planet. He had to admit that the blue was striking and the dance of clouds across the atmosphere was hypnotic, but deep down he knew that in all likelihood this planet was no different from the others. But that in itself was a lie, there was a reason he had diverted them light years to this backwater planet, there was history here, a history of monsters.

Malkick inhaled.

“Don’t bother Malkick. The air is moist enough without a handful of your phlegm lubricating it.” The captain said. Some of the crew relaxed, others laughed inwardly, Malkick lowered his hand.

“Yes Sir.”

“It looks delicate, but it isn’t. We once believed that planets supported precariously balanced eco-systems and that if we upset the balance we could accidentally kill the planet. Imagine that, kill a planet. Sometimes we over estimate our power. There is nothing that can kill a planet. We can destroy one with enough errant energy but that would just leave a scattering of dust and debris orbiting where once a planet was. That doesn’t destroy the planet permanently only temporarily, over time gravity will reform the planet. But to actually kill a planet, no one can do that.”

Malkick knew better that to change subject when his superior officer talked about something so intangible, he had learned (over many years) that the best option was to encourage the conversation, preferably with a slightly opposing view, though never too contrary.

“What about Semphora?”

The captain flashed Malkick a wry smile and began. “Ah, Yes very good. But then Semphora was only killed in one sense, the planet still exists, no life as we know it does, but over time life will rise again on that devastated planet. It is possible that it will remain bereft of life for eons, we know that the lickto-spore count is still incredibly high, the atmosphere is still corrosive and that there are no signs of life, but I still hold to my original point, the planet isn’t dead. Life will find a way, it may be unimaginably different from what once flew there, but it will find a way, it always does.”

Ludackm looked at the small planet and thought about the menagerie. He felt powerful as he realised that ultimately everything he did was for death, he was a harbinger of death. He would seek out new life forms, but only so his people could watch them die.

“Yet Death is inevitable.” The Captain smiled to himself and then turned to his crew.
“Ok. I’ve kept you waiting long enough. What do we have?”

Malkick gathered his thoughts, he was an efficient officer and prided himself on explaining the situation clearly and concisely.
“Chatter, lots of it. Video, Audio, even binary data.”

The captain was astonished, but quickly regained his composure.
“Chatter Really? Then they have evolved.” He turned back to the view screen with a desirous look upon his maw, and spoke softly, mainly to himself.

“They have evolved into sentient creatures. I hope they haven’t lost their instincts. Sentient monsters would make this trip worth while.” The captain continued his reverie.
“What devastation has evolution plagued upon the monsters, will they talk? I hope they don’t have art. Binary data, they have machines, what machines would the mind of a monster create. Video?”
Malkick motioned to his transmissions officer to be prepared, he knew what the next order would be.

“I want the video on screen now. Let’s see what has become of our monsters.”

The screen changed, and with it the mood on the bridge went from one of hope and excitement to one of severe disappointment.

“What the hell is that? Change the image.” The captain ordered. The Image changed. Malkick motioned to the transmission officer to keep changing the picture because he knew what the Captain wanted to see. But every image showed the same tiny soft skinned biped.

“What is happening Malkick, is that all there is?”

“I’m afraid so sir, these are live news results. Everything else is dramatisation.”

“Where are my monsters?” The captain demanded.

Malkick turned his glare upon the officer responsible for picking up transmissions. But he had nothing. The officer smiled at Malkick and swapped the image. Malkick turned back to the screen, his heart fell. He saw the monsters but he could tell instantly they weren’t real.

“Please tell me you are joking, even I know that is fake. Find me my monsters. Real ones!” The captain was becoming frustrated. Malkick turned to the transmissions officer and asked him directly for a response.

“Mockpam, is that all you can find?”

Mockpam swallowed nervously and pulled himself up to his impressive height. The Captain turned and faced him directly, Mockpam wilted.

“I’m afraid so, it is all dramatisation, we have nothing real. The best we can find are some wild animals, but they aren’t in control. That is the dominant species.”

Mockpam gestured to the screen, a single image covered the screen. The captain roared in frustration, some of the junior officers shrunk into their seats, afraid to get into the captain’s sights. Ludackm approached the screen and addressed the picture.

“What are you? What have you done to my monsters? Right, everyone to their stations, prepare a full invasion, let’s capture or kill these pathetic monster killers, we need something from this disastrous trip. Malkick take over”

“Yes sir” Malkick began ordering the teams to prepare for invasion, the ground troops and the aerial support. “Loptick, take us into orbit.”

The huge intergalactic craft moved easily across the solar system, thousands of armed troops prepared themselves for the issued capture or kill command, whilst Captain Ludackm Frack stood staring at the image on the viewing screen; an image of a human.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
IF this is going to be a screenplay or a stageplay or script for a comic, then this is completely in wrong format. So if you are going to go down that road, then you need to change this ASAP, because this is good stuff. Something that could probably be interesting in the eyes of Hollywood Executives.
 
Ah, I changed it from Screenplay format to a story with internal dialogue for this post. It also helps me with the characterisation. But thanks for the compliment. :)
 
Hi, Moonbat! Congratulations on the 1,000th post!

The formatting went a little awry, and the first three paras weren't properly separated, so I've edited and put in line spaces to break it up a little. You've also got a few breaks where the same person was speaking, so I wasn't sure if they were meant to be complete para breaks, so I've left them for the moment -- if you do want an extra line in there, let me know.

No time for a proper critique now, but for my taste it was a touch info-dumpy at the beginning if you're turning it into a story and there's a jump into Malkick's POV that jarred a bit with me after you've been so deep in the Captain's. Is it meant to be a comedy, by the way? The names read as essentially humorous to my eye/ear, so if it's deadly serious it might be an idea to make them a bit nastier.

Nit-picky wise, the first para is very inelegant with the frequent repetition of planet, and you need to pay a bit more attention to punctuation throughout, particularly commas. If it's staying as a story, as opposed to a script/graphic novel, you need to smooth it a bit, especially the beginning narrative, I think. But that final paragraph is definitely going to work as a good visual -- a really punchy image!

A good dramatic opening -- so I hope you're planning to take it further.
 
Hi Moonbat,

aaah, the dreaded 1,000 post... I've been deliberately slowing down, knowing 2,000 would get here soon, so congratulations, in the first place, and well done for posting this piece, in the second. I'd echo The Judge, and hope it would go further... I was uncertain if the crew were humanoids, but atomatically assumed they were, so well done, either way!

I'll nitpick and comment as I go through, and hope it helps. All my own opinions, as usual...

Well it has been a while, I've been at 999 posts for a few days, I know (or at least I think it is the order of the day) that I'm expected to create a post for critique on my 1000 post. so here it is. :rolleyes:

It started off as an idea for a screenplay (this is the opening scene), I've been leaning towards making it a graphic novel, but here it is as a plain old story. The title is only a working title. Obviously I'd like to know what you guys think, and I'm sure there are grammatical errors, the formatting is designed to make it easier to read. I hope you enjoy. :)


Alien Jam

On the cold, damp and dingy bridge Ludackm’s crew busied themselves behind him. I immediately pictured a bridge over a river, because of the cold damp and dingy. Took me a little while to realise they were on a starship...He could feel their eyes on him, he felt repetitionof feel/felt as though he could lean back on the wall of tension directed at him. He was deep in contemplation, so how did he feel their eyes on him? transfixed to the main viewer which displayed an enhanced image of a still distant planet. He studied the planet,'he studied it' would avoid the close repetition hoping to draw some conclusions that would not be revealed to his crew through their numerous instrument panels. Conclusions aren't revealed, they're arrived at, so maybe 'hoping to draw his own conclusions before the crew picked anything up'? Don't think we need 'the numerous instrument panels'. Sometimes, when they approached a planet, he felt likefeeling again... he had a kind of telepathy and that he could communicate with the planet itself; learn some of its secrets before the cold hard facts were presented.

He had taken an enormous risk and this trip had been a failure. They had travelled a long way and, as of yet, only procured a tiny percentage of their quota. He might return home ruined, with colossal debts, disowned by his family and no hope of living free. His wife would dismiss him (if she hadn’t already) the best he could hope for was that his children inherited his debt and worked to pay it off for him. Up to here is okay as an infodumpHe had decided, after the calamity that was Plompstop, that they take a huge (and very costly) detour in an attempt to recoup some of his losses. This was that detour right now, they were travelling ever closer to the planet that would either plunge them all into the lowest echelons of society, let them break even, or propel them into the comfortable life of a veteran. That bit isn't... I think by leaving it out, you give us enough info to draw our own conclusions. And the cough by the crewmate speaks volumes...

Malkick coughed, Ludackm ignored him and the crew grew increasingly worried that the captain was ruining all of their lives.POV change here, to the crew. Maybe: Ludackm knew he was close to ruining all their lives, and ignored Malkick's cough. It occurred to Ludackm that the planet he was looking at was unnaturally beautiful. Maybe it was the promise of reward and his vicinity to possible redemption that colouringcloured his thinking, pollutingpolluted his thoughts and cajolingcajoled him into thinking it was more than your average life-sustaining planet. He had to admit that the blue was striking and the dance of clouds across the atmosphere was hypnotic, but deep down he knew that in all likelihood this planet was no different from the others. But that in itself was a lie, there was a reason he had diverted them light years to this backwater planet, there was history here, a history of monsters. Erm... you lead us down the path that it's no different, knowing all along it's a lie. Maybe, following on from the previous thought about ruin, and the cough, you could do something like: 'The blue was striking and the dance of clouds across the atmosphere was hypnotic. Deep down he knew the crew thought this planet was no different from the others. But there was a reason he had diverted them light years to this backwater planet, a reason he hadn't divulged. There was history here. A history of monsters'

Malkick inhaled.

“Don’t bother Malkick. The air is moist enough without a handful of your phlegm lubricating it.” The captain said. Some of the crew relaxed, others laughed inwardly, Malkick lowered his hand.He's got his back to the crew, how does he see the hand?

“Yes Sir.”

“It looks delicate, but it isn’t. We once believed that planets supported precariously balanced eco-systems and that if we upset the balance we could accidentally kill the planet. Imagine that, kill a planet. Sometimes we over estimate our power. There is nothing that can kill a planet. We can destroy one with enough errant energy but that would just leave a scattering of dust and debris orbiting where once a planet was. That doesn’t destroy the planet permanently only temporarily, over time gravity will reform the planet. But to actually kill a planet, no one can do that.”Erm, don't really like this infodump. The crew know all this, don't they? They've been startrekking across the universe, it must be second nature to them. But because you want to bring in Semphora, then what if the captain is interpreting Malkirks expectoration as concern? So it would go like this:
"Yes Sir."

"Stop worrying. We've never destroyed a planet yet."

"What about Semphora?"

"The planet's still exists, Malkick. Life will return, it always does."

This way, we think 'ooh, what did they do? It may be this crew did do it, or it may be that they're talking about the planet being done by someone else, but it focuses our attention quite sharply. And if we think they're capable of destroying all life (no need to tell us how, or why) our imaginations will run wild, especially when the last sentence hits us. Then start with the para 'Kudackm looked at the small planet' and the reinforcing message about death will have even more impact.

Malkick knew better that to change subject or to change pov...when his superior officer talked about something so intangible, he had learned (over many years) that the best option was to encourage the conversation, preferably with a slightly opposing view, though never too contrary.

“What about Semphora?”

The captain flashed Malkick a wry smile and began. “Ah, Yes very good. But then Semphora was only killed in one sense, the planet still exists, no life as we know it does, but over time life will rise again on that devastated planet. It is possible that it will remain bereft of life for eons, we know that the lickto-spore count is still incredibly high, the atmosphere is still corrosive and that there are no signs of life, but I still hold to my original point, the planet isn’t dead. Life will find a way, it may be unimaginably different from what once flew there, but it will find a way, it always does.”

Ludackm looked at the small planet and thought about the menagerie. He felt powerful as he realised that ultimately everything he did was for death, he was a harbinger of death. He would seek out new life forms, but only so his people could watch them die.

“Yet Death is inevitable.” The Captain smiled to himself and then turned to his crew.
“Ok. I’ve kept you waiting long enough. What do we have?”

Malkick gathered his thoughts, he was an efficient officer and prided himself on explaining the situation clearly and concisely.
“Chatter, lots of it. Video, Audio, even binary data.”

The captain was astonished, but quickly regained his composure.
“Chatter Really? Then they have evolved.”

He turned back to the view screen with a desirous look upon his maw, That's the first clue they're not human, but not sure about the 'desirous look'...and spoke softly, mainly to himself.

“They have evolved into sentient creatures.delete this first sentence as an infodump. So much more powerful to start with 'I hope etc' I hope they haven’t lost their instincts. Sentient monsters would make this trip worth while.” The captain continued his reverie.
“What devastation has evolution plagued upon the monsters, will they talk? I hope they don’t have art. Binary data, they have machines, what machines would the mind of a monster create. Video?” Again, it's the captain talking to himself to give us info, but I'm not surer we need it, and it rather jolts us from the here and now, the story in hand.
Malkick motioned to his transmissions officer to be prepared, he knew what the next order would be.Delete this sentence, it's unnecessary.

“I want the video on screen now. Let’s see what has become of our monsters.” Which makes me think they seeded the planet some time ago, and the last line becomes even better...

The screen changed, and with it the mood on the bridge went from one of hope and excitement to one of severe disappointment.

“What the hell Hell? A human invention...is that? Change the image.comma ” The the captain ordered. The Image image changed. Malkick motioned to the transmission officer to keep changing the picture because he knew what the Captain wanted to see. But every image showed the same tiny soft skinned biped.

“What is happeningQuestion Mark Malkick, is that all there is?”

“I’m afraid so sir, these are live news results. Everything else is dramatisation.”

“Where are my monsters?” The captain demanded.

Malkick turned his glare upon the officer responsible for picking up transmissions. But he had nothing. The officer smiled at Malkick and swapped the image. Malkick turned back to the screen, his heart fell. He saw the monsters but he could tell instantly they weren’t real.

“Please tell me you are joking, even I know that is fake. Find me my monsters. Real ones!” The captain was becoming frustrated. Malkick turned to the transmissions officer and asked him directly for a response.

“Mockpam, is that all you can find?”

Mockpam swallowed nervously and pulled himself up to his impressive height. The Captain turned and faced him directly, Mockpam wilted.

“I’m afraid so, it is all dramatisation, we have nothing real. The best we can find are some wild animals, but they aren’t in control. That is the dominant species.”

Mockpam gestured to the screen, a single image covered the screen. The captain roared in frustration, some of the junior officers shrunk into their seats, afraid to get into the captain’s sights. Ludackm approached the screen and addressed the picture.

“What are you? What have you done to my monsters? Right, everyone to their stations, prepare a full invasion, let’s capture or kill these pathetic monster killers, we need something from this disastrous trip. Malkick take over”

“Yes sir” Malkick began ordering the teams to prepare for invasion, the ground troops and the aerial support. “Loptick, take us into orbit.”

The huge intergalactic craft moved easily across the solar system,Full stop thousands Thousands of armed troops prepared themselves for the issued delete 'the issued' capture or kill command, whilst Captain Ludackm Frack stood staring at the image on the viewing screen; an image of a human.

Excellent kicker at the end, you lead us down the path so well... I think by leaving out some of what you say, what you don't say becomes much more powerful. A clever piece, and enjoyable to read. Hope what I've said helps...:eek:
 
Boneman, Judge, thank you for your comments.
I thought the formatting was a bit off, but on-line things look better with extra line spaces rather than just carriage returns (a bit of typing jargon) it makes it easier to tell who is saying what. I think I had more lines between the captain's speech so that is probably why I seperated some of his lines.

Thanks for all the nitpicks Boneman, I know people call them nitpicks but they are what makes this critique section so awesome. I know that conclusions are drawn but I worded it wrong, I like alot of what you have said I will take it all on board.
Thanks again for the comments. :)
 
Hey Moonbat.
I haven't got time for a proper critique I'm afraid; it's late and I have to work tomorrow.
It's certainly a colourful piece of writing and there's a nice comedy edge to it.
My own thoughts (reiterating what's already been said) is that there's a lot of information where perhaps you might think about cutting it/being a bit more economical.
From a reader's point of view, I found it a little difficult to find the important bits of information which hook a reader from the get go. I think this is a real priority when composing a bit of fiction, especially in the opening 1000 words... an ability to get it right really sorts the sheep from the lambs and the men from the boys.
Just a few lines that made me think:


"He had taken an enormous risk and this trip had been a failure. They had travelled a long way and, as of yet, only procured a tiny percentage of their quota. He might return home ruined, with colossal debts, disowned by his family and no hope of living free. His wife would dismiss him (if she hadn’t already) the best he could hope for was that his children inherited his debt and worked to pay it off for him. He had decided, after the calamity that was Plompstop, that they take a huge (and very costly) detour in an attempt to recoup some of his losses." This is too dense I think. Perhaps you could drip feed some of this later and just throw in one or two allusions to his personal life now?


But then Semphora was only killed in one sense, the planet still exists, no life as we know it does, but over time life will rise again on that devastated planet. (I would get rid of this extra clause here... it works for comedic effect possibly but it clouds a really important plot hook)

an image of a human. This is a great hanger. If the lead up could be a tadge more punchy and economical it would be a great opening scene with this as the final flourish so to speak.

A nice bit of writing all in all. Double check for punctuation, but I didn't spot anything wrong with the grammar (it is late though)

Cheers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top