J-Sun
⚡
- Joined
- Oct 23, 2008
- Messages
- 5,324
I came across this item on Conversations with Dead Science Fiction Writers and thought it might make an interesting thread. There's not a person on this guy's list who wouldn't rank highly on mine but I decided to limit myself to a half-dozen as he did, in which case there's only a couple of people I had to overlap on.
I think I have an answer to his Campbell question, though: "If I could have met Campbell late in his life, I'd ask him why he gave up writing to become an editor. Clearly he was talented at both. As a writer myself, it is hard to imagine ever giving it up. So why did Campbell decide to do it?" I think the answer is that Campbell didn't give up writing - he just wrote dozens of times more material by proxy than he could have by himself. Not everything was like this, but Campbell definitely got a lot of people to write a lot of his ideas, sometimes more than once.
Anyway, to my list:
Isaac Asimov. He's simply my favorite writer and his thirst for all knowledge and devotion to writing is fascinating. The only thing is that he was so dedicated to it that I'd hate to take away from his writing time.
Algis Budrys. There's just something about this guy that I find fascinating. He seems like a very deep guy without being faux-philosophical/pretentious. He also had an interesting life, starting in Lithuania, witnessing the Hitler madness as a tiny kid, and ending up in America and becoming an extraordinary writer.
Robert A. Heinlein. I'd especially like to be able to personally/privately discuss all the religion and politics and economics issues that are most controversial. I'd also like to discuss with him how he saw his earlier and later books since, while his late books still have their values, I so much prefer the earlier ones.
Henry Kuttner and C.L. Moore. I count them as one because they were married and often wrote as one and, in this hypothetical, why would I corner one alone rather than meet both, right? In addition to general discussions, the thing I'd most like to know is more detail about how they collaborated and who wrote what. Also what it was like for them being Weird Tales people who could sell to Campbell and to more general magazines like Argosy or whatever. That's an extraordinary aspect of their work.
Fritz Leiber. Another extremely versatile author with a varied life, experiences in the stage, an interesting family, etc. This is actually the last non-alphabetical slot I filled and he was in competition with Kornbluth and Sturgeon and others, but I think I'll give him the edge.
Jack Williamson. From covered wagons to blackberrys - the guy lived a long and extraordinary life and had seen it all. He was there from the first issues of Amazing to just recently. How could you not listen to this guy indefinitely and soak up the experiences?
Who'd be on your list?
I think I have an answer to his Campbell question, though: "If I could have met Campbell late in his life, I'd ask him why he gave up writing to become an editor. Clearly he was talented at both. As a writer myself, it is hard to imagine ever giving it up. So why did Campbell decide to do it?" I think the answer is that Campbell didn't give up writing - he just wrote dozens of times more material by proxy than he could have by himself. Not everything was like this, but Campbell definitely got a lot of people to write a lot of his ideas, sometimes more than once.
Anyway, to my list:
Isaac Asimov. He's simply my favorite writer and his thirst for all knowledge and devotion to writing is fascinating. The only thing is that he was so dedicated to it that I'd hate to take away from his writing time.
Algis Budrys. There's just something about this guy that I find fascinating. He seems like a very deep guy without being faux-philosophical/pretentious. He also had an interesting life, starting in Lithuania, witnessing the Hitler madness as a tiny kid, and ending up in America and becoming an extraordinary writer.
Robert A. Heinlein. I'd especially like to be able to personally/privately discuss all the religion and politics and economics issues that are most controversial. I'd also like to discuss with him how he saw his earlier and later books since, while his late books still have their values, I so much prefer the earlier ones.
Henry Kuttner and C.L. Moore. I count them as one because they were married and often wrote as one and, in this hypothetical, why would I corner one alone rather than meet both, right? In addition to general discussions, the thing I'd most like to know is more detail about how they collaborated and who wrote what. Also what it was like for them being Weird Tales people who could sell to Campbell and to more general magazines like Argosy or whatever. That's an extraordinary aspect of their work.
Fritz Leiber. Another extremely versatile author with a varied life, experiences in the stage, an interesting family, etc. This is actually the last non-alphabetical slot I filled and he was in competition with Kornbluth and Sturgeon and others, but I think I'll give him the edge.
Jack Williamson. From covered wagons to blackberrys - the guy lived a long and extraordinary life and had seen it all. He was there from the first issues of Amazing to just recently. How could you not listen to this guy indefinitely and soak up the experiences?
Who'd be on your list?