Perdition Homecoming

Status
Not open for further replies.

Heck Tate

The Fleet Footed
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
250
Location
Somewhere good. You're jealous.
This is a story I've tried to rework a few times, and as a result it's kind of twisted itself out of my control. I want to do something with it but I'm torn between reworking the whole thing again to keep it under 1,000 words or expanding on it. Any thoughts on this would be greatly appreciated.

***********************************

When he reached Perdition's Pass, Invidio cut the harnesses which bound the team of horses to his nearly broken-down wagon. The team bolted back down the road from which they came, knowing better than to pass between this natural gate of mountains to the hellish landscape beyond.

All but Shade, that is. The tall mare stamped at the ground and snorted at the others as if to say “good riddance.” When he first departed, Invidio had set forth with only a quest, a week's worth of provisions, and the midnight mare. The provisions had faded quickly, and the quest had eventually been accomplished, but as always, Shade had remained his constant companion, even saving his life on a few occasions. “Thick as thieves,” was what the Greenfolk called them, but where Invidio came from the expression was “fickle as thieves.”

Shade grazed patiently on the nearby fauna as Invidio took his time packing the wagon's essentials into more portable bags. He was reminiscing all the while about the purpose of his journey, and the man he had killed.

While theft, assault, rape, and even murder were not prohibited within Perdition, escape was. It was for such a crime that Invidio had been required to hunt down and bring justice to Debeion Sint, often known as Red Deb for his anger.

Debeion had managed to survive the long, unforgiving journey across the desert, escaping into the Greenlands almost three months ago. He had fled far and fast, but he was not hard to track. He left a trail of murders and robberies that anyone could follow.

The night Deb escaped, an elderly couple had been murdered in their sleep in the cottage they owned in the woods on the green side of the mountains. Money, clothes, food, horses, all stolen, as was expected with most burglaries, but most importantly, there had not been a single drop of water left in the house. Invidio had almost caught him at the nearest town from there, but Deb had narrowly avoided him, stealing away on small river boat, while Shade chased and Invidio shot in vain.

Invidio had eventually caught up with the criminal, but it had taken many weeks, partially due to the hesitance of local authorities to cooperate with him. Authorities had eventually caught Deb trying to buy passage across the ocean on a luxury ship. He had shown up just before the ship left, dressed in rags but offering gold to board, clearly desperate. By the time Invidio had been informed Deb had been living comfortably in a local police holding cell for a full week.

He had the prisoner released into his custody and brought him to a secluded section of one of the nearby beaches. “It's fitting that you should die with sand between your toes,” Invidio told him, but Deb was clearly mad, likely due to dehydration from his desert crossing.

“Why make a desert with all this extra water,” he murmured as he stared at the waves rolling in. He stood as if in a trance, unmoving until Invidio tugged on the chain attached to the prisoner's manacles. “It's infinite,” he said when again they stopped and he had lapsed back into his hypnotic state.

“Hell is infinite,” replied Invidio before reading the judgment as he was required to do. “Debeion 'Red Deb' Sint, for refusing to serve your previously decreed sentence I hereby condemn you to death.” He drew the heavy steel six-shooter form his hip holster and aimed it at the criminal's head. “Do you have any final words?”

Debeion had been muttering to himself quietly the whole while, but at the sound of Invidio cocking the gun's hammer he seemed to regain himself for a final moment. “Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I –” he began to quote, but the gun had silenced him.

“The wicked may not speak the words of God,” he said as the Deb fell to the sand to be washed away when the tide came in.

But that was all over, and with saddlebags and rucksack stuffed full of food and water, Invidio departed the Greenlands and their soft people behind until next time duty called. He was going home.

Shade and Invidio passed through the narrow gap in the mountains which lead to the Desert of the Damned. At the end of the long path he bowed his head to the sign which arched above them, as he always did upon returning. “Abandon Hope All Ye Who Enter Here,” had been engraved in the now well-weathered, but still thick oaken boards long ago.

A new sign stood beyond this one, however. A shoddily crafted one of cheap wood which stuck in a ground at such an angle that it seemed about to collapse. Propped casually on top of this new sign was a clean though fragile looking skeleton. One of its arms lay half buried in the hot desert sand, but both hands still held the positions they had been forced in to. Both thumbs extended towards the sky and forefingers towards Shade and Invidio as they lingered at the end of the pass. All skulls grin, for they know something the living do not, and this one was no exception. Invidio's eyes locked with the skull's empty sockets and for a moment it dared him to join in the joke, but instead he glanced down at the sign itself.

Scrawled messily in what appeared to be long dried blood were the words “Welcome back Sheriff!!” The exclamation points were dotted with small X's below which was drawn a smile with its tongue sticking out. It seemed the other guards had missed him.

Invidio took a deep breath of dry desert air and smiled. “Feels good to be home,” he said aloud. Shade whinnied her agreement and the two rode off to Perdition.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Heck, the software rips out formatting such as double spacing and first line indent. Consequently, we require a clear line's space between each paragraph so we don't have a wall of text. I've gone through and edited it for you on this occasion, but please remember for next time. Thanks.


While I'm here, I'm not sure what you were intending with this. If it's a stand alone tale, I personally don't think it works -- there's no real conflict or story. If it's the beginning of a novel or a series of vignettes about this character, then it's a useful foundation. But in either case, as it stands, it seems to me to be mainly an extended flashback with a great deal of info-dumping. The character and the situation/circumstances are worth persevering with, but I do think you have to make up your mind what it is to be -- a short story or the start of something bigger.
 
Sorry about that, thanks for fixing it. I do want to keep this as a single short story, maybe just a longer one. Do you think it would work mostly as it is if I rearranged it so that it's told chronologically?
 
Heck I thought it made a nice standalone story, but there was enough there to extend it further. i enjoyed it, although I think I felt more sympathy for the guy who died than the sheriff; he fought very hard to survive.
 
As a short story, it doesn't really work as most of it is reminiscing. Also, as TJ said, there's no conflict -- deb gets caught, Invidio comes, Invidio kills him. It's all too straightforward.

In chronological order, it has a better chance of working, but I think you need to add something to the story -- a chase, a twist, some doubt about the outcome.

Apart from that, the scene is set well and it could be developed into a bigger short story.
 
I agree with alchemist -- it needs something to grip the reader, and this is all too easy. He follows the trail, finds the man in custody, takes him to a beach and kills him (as a lawyer, I'm tempted to say "murders" him since it's an extra-judicial execution). Even told in chronological order you would need more -- though frankly I don't think it would work in strict order, since the chase lasts weeks. I think you need to start at a crisis/dramatic point and work forward and flashback a little.

Hex started a thread about requirements for short stories a little while back which might be of help regarding conflict etc http://www.sffchronicles.co.uk/forum/532373-short-story-structure.html

By the way, you do realise the "Abandon hope..." misquotation isnt Biblical? It's a translation from Dante's Inferno, and might not meet with the approval of fundamentalists.
 
I'm just going to agree with everyone else, really. I liked the tone, the visual imagery and I especially liked the horse, but for this to work for me it needs a shape I can understand. It's difficult, because the flatness of the story -- the fact that there isn't a doubt about what happens, that it's all inevitable -- is part of the flavour.

It's not like Invidio is going to have a crisis about killing Deb, and overcome it (which might be one way to frame a story). So the doubt about the end may be about whether he catches him?

I'd agree that telling things in a more chronological order, without the reader knowing that Invidio is going to shoot Deb would make it more exciting. You could have the chase, and some doubt over what Invidio is going to do.

The thread TJ linked to was really helpful for me, though I found it quite tough to apply the suggestions to the story I'd written. It helped me to try to plan out a new one, before I came back to the one I'd been working on. I think the more general descriptions of structure -- that there should be some kind of tension or doubt about the ending -- worked best for me.

Edited to say: This, from William B, worked nicely in my head:

There are a lot of ways to think about it but I think it always comes back to that tension. Whether it's the tension of not knowing exactly what's happening, what the character is going to do, how it will all play out.
The reader basically wants to know "What is happening? Who is it happening to? and Why should I care?"
 
Last edited:
This is a story I've tried to rework a few times, and as a result it's kind of twisted itself out of my control. I want to do something with it but I'm torn between reworking the whole thing again to keep it under 1,000 words or expanding on it. Any thoughts on this would be greatly appreciated.
***********************************

When he reached Perdition's Pass, Invidio cut the harnesses which bound the team of horses to his nearly broken-down wagon. The team bolted back down the road from which they came, knowing better than to pass between
You tend to pass "though" a gate, rather than "between" it.
this natural gate of mountains to the hellish landscape beyond.

All but Shade, that is. The tall mare stamped at the ground and snorted at the others as if to say “good riddance.” When he first departed, Invidio had set forth with only a quest, a week's worth of provisions, and the midnight mare. The provisions had faded quickly, and the quest had eventually been accomplished, but as always, Shade had remained his constant companion, even saving his life on a few occasions. “Thick as thieves,” was what the Greenfolk called them, but where Invidio came from the expression was “fickle as thieves.”

Shade grazed patiently on the nearby fauna
"Fauna" are animals. A carnivorous horse?
as Invidio took his time packing the wagon's essentials into more portable bags. He was reminiscing all the while about the purpose of his journey, and the man he had killed.

While theft, assault, rape, and even murder were not prohibited within Perdition, escape was. It was for such a crime that Invidio
The crime of escaping seems to be associated with Invidio, rather than Debeion
had been required to hunt down and bring justice to Debeion Sint, often known as Red Deb for his anger.

Debeion had managed to survive the long, unforgiving journey across the desert, escaping into the Greenlands almost three months ago. He had fled far and fast, but he was
had not been?
not hard to track. He
had
left a trail of murders and robberies that anyone could follow.

The night Deb escaped, an elderly couple had been murdered in their sleep in the cottage they owned in the woods on the green side of the mountains. Money, clothes, food, horses, all stolen, as was expected with most burglaries, but
Comma here rather than before the "but"
most importantly, there had not been a single drop of water left in the house. Invidio had almost caught him at the nearest town from there, but Deb had narrowly avoided him, stealing away on
a
small river boat, while Shade chased and Invidio shot in vain.

Invidio had eventually caught up with the criminal, but it had taken many weeks, partially due to the hesitance
hesitancy?
of local authorities to cooperate with him. Authorities
Avoid repetition of "authorities"
had eventually caught Deb trying to buy passage across the ocean on a luxury ship. He had shown up just before the ship left, dressed in rags but offering gold to board, clearly desperate. By the time Invidio had been informed Deb had been living comfortably in a local police holding cell for a full week.

He had
had had/
the prisoner released into his custody and brought him to a secluded section of one of the nearby beaches. “It's fitting that you should die with sand between your toes,” Invidio told him, but Deb was clearly mad, likely due to dehydration from his desert crossing.

“Why make a desert with all this extra water,” he murmured as he stared at the waves rolling in. He stood as if in a trance, unmoving until Invidio tugged on the chain attached to the prisoner's manacles. “It's infinite,” he said when again they stopped and he had lapsed back into his hypnotic state.
Difficult to work out a time sequence;talking before or after relapse into trance/
“Hell is infinite,” replied Invidio
Comma
before reading the judgment as he was required to do. “Debeion 'Red Deb' Sint, for refusing to serve your previously decreed sentence I hereby condemn you to death.” He drew the heavy steel six-shooter form his hip holster and aimed it at the criminal's head. “Do you have any final words?”

Debeion had been muttering to himself quietly the whole while, but at the sound of Invidio cocking the gun's hammer he seemed to regain himself for a final moment. “Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I –” he began to quote, but the gun had silenced him.

“The wicked may not speak the words of God,” he said
Last reference for the "he" is Debeion
as the Deb fell to the sand
Comma, or it's the sand will be washed away.
to be washed away when the tide came in.

But that was all over, and with saddlebags and rucksack stuffed full of food and water, Invidio departed the Greenlands and
Left? Or perhaps instead of "departed"?
their soft people behind until next time duty called. He was going home.

Shade and Invidio passed through the narrow gap in the mountains which lead
If this is past tense, it's "led". If present, why?
to the Desert of the Damned. At the end of the long path he bowed his head to the sign which arched above them, as he always did upon returning. “Abandon Hope All Ye Who Enter Here,” had been engraved in the now well-weathered, but still thick
Comma
oaken boards long ago.

A new sign stood beyond this one, however. A shoddily crafted one of cheap wood
comma
which stuck in a
"the" rather than "a"?
ground at such an angle that it seemed about to collapse. Propped casually on top of this new sign was a clean though fragile looking skeleton. One of its arms lay half buried in the hot desert sand, but both hands still held the positions they had been forced in to
into
. Both thumbs extended towards the sky and forefingers towards Shade and Invidio as they lingered at the end of the pass. All skulls grin, for they know something the living do not, and this one was no exception. Invidio's eyes locked with the skull's empty sockets and for a moment it dared him to join in the joke, but instead he glanced down at the sign itself.

Scrawled messily in what appeared to be long dried blood were the words “Welcome back Sheriff!!” The exclamation points were dotted with small X's below which was drawn a smile with its tongue sticking out. It seemed the other guards had missed him.


Invidio took a deep breath of dry desert air and smiled. “Feels good to be home,” he said aloud. Shade whinnied her agreement and the two rode off to Perdition.



There are occasional problems with tenses, only being able to go back as far as pluperfect, even if practically the whole story is flashback, and bits of it occurred before others.
 
Thanks very much, guys, you've definitely given me a lot to think about. I know the Inferno quote isn't from the Bible, I'm not really concerned with meeting fundamentalist approval. I did not know that fauna meant animals, though. I've always seen it used with flora and assumed it meant the same. Now that I actually think about it, it makes a whole lot more sense for "flora and fauna" to mean plants and animals and not plants and plants. Kicking myself now. Again, thank you very much, everyone. I'm going to try to put some work into this during the holidays.
 
I know the Inferno quote isn't from the Bible, I'm not really concerned with meeting fundamentalist approval.
Sorry, didn't explain myself properly. I meant Invidio seems fundamentalist, with his "The wicked..." line. In which case he wouldn't be happy at the non-Biblical quote. Though, of course, I may well be misinterpreting his character on that point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top