Chapter 1 The dying Wanderer part 3 of 3

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sho Pi

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
49
‘Must warn him... They’re coming for him.’ Jonndi was shocked by the wide-eyed expression on his normally level-headed friend.

‘Calm down Tairyn, you’re save now.’ Jonndi couldn’t completely hide the anguish in his voice, knowing full well that his friend wasn’t going to last through the night.

Still, his voice seemed to calm the old wanderer down almost instantly. For a moment Tairyn was staring at him as if he was seeing a ghost. Then, with a huge sigh of relieve, he finally came back to his senses.

‘Of course the Spirit would guide me well in our hour of need. I don’t know how, but I knew you were out there, far away, but just close enough. Without seeing you, I knew you were there. Without hearing me, you came.’

Jonndi frowned at his friend. He knew Wanderers had a tendency for talking in melodramatic riddles, but this was downright peculiar. Did he really say what I think he said?

Tairyn smiled warily. ‘My sceptical old friend. I didn’t believe it myself at first, but what choice did I have. I was being held captive by the Lord of the West himself; this was the only path the Spirit showed me that didn’t end in disaster for us all.'

'He has weapons, Jonndi; Algevaro has acquired terrible weapons. Not seen since the days of the Trekiir War. Weapons far too powerful to remain in the hands of ambitious men like him. He holds Dragon Weapons, the weapons of the Guardians.'

'But there is one last weapon on this continent not yet under his control. Jonndi, he must not get it, for if he does; the Spirit shows nothing but a future filled with doom for us all.'

'I know I can’t go on any further. My life’s thread has come to an end. Even though I can’t see my own life-thread like I can see others, I feel this is my final night on Meila.’

Jonndi looked pained by his friends calm words. ‘Tairyn, old friend, are you certain there is nothing that can be done. Maybe if you tell me what poison they used, I can make the right antidote. You know I have some skill with potions and elixirs.’

‘I know it is thanks to your skills that I have been given these final hours in the presence of a dear old friend. But you don’t have to comfort me, I know you’re fully aware that there is nothing more that you can do for me.’

Jonndi shook his head in denial, trying to fight back his tears. ‘Can’t you direct me to the nearest temple of Aesclia, maybe a priest of the healing goddess can still help you. If I ditch the wagon we could cover some miles quickly on Boreas’ back. I just need to figure out where I am.’ Jonndi knew that his ideas were getting more and more desperate but he couldn’t stop from offering them. ‘Can’t the Spirit direct a Ranari to come down here with a cure or a Beralin to take you to them?’

Tairyn’s smile spread to his eyes, returning some of their former sparkle. ‘You always wanted too much from the Spirit, old friend. You know full well that things don’t work like that. I am by no means important enough for any kind of special treatment. Besides, I don’t think even the Spirit can get a Ranari to come down from their jungle moon.'

'No, finding you and telling you what you need to know is the last task for me. I have done my duty and it’s nothing to be sad about. I have lived a full and wondrous life. Who else can say that throughout their entire life they were never lost, never uncertain as to their purpose on Meila and never unaware of all the good in the world?'

'You of all people know how valuable such knowledge can be. I am not the first friend you lost and I shall not be the last. Yours is a burden I don’t envy. But your days of self-imposed isolation must come to an end again. Meila needs you to finish the task that the Spirit had put upon me.’

Jonndi looked self-conscious. He had to ask the questions that had plagued him for over a century. ‘Can you see how long I will live? Will I live as long as my father?’

Tairyn looked at his friend warily. ‘Jonndi we have been over this. Yours is a life-thread unlike any I have ever seen. You have the potential to live to a great age, but you could die tomorrow from a broken neck or an errant arrow. I can’t compare, I have never seen a true Guardian. I don’t know what they’re like. Nor have I ever heard or read about a half-blood like you. The Spirit won’t show me what’s in store for you, but I’m sure that you are destined to do great things for the good of us all.’

Jonndi looked into the flames, still feeling unconvinced. ‘Everything I have done has been a failure. If I were destined to be a great protector of Meila, don’t you think my father would have taken me under his wing? He keeps me away from any real knowledge because I’m not powerful enough. My magic is useless.’

‘Stop it, Jonndi. I will not spend my final hours listening to a great man feeling sorry for himself. I’m the one who is dying here. How do you know that you’re a failure, for all you know, your life has only just begun?’

Jonndi gave an unconvinced chuckle. ‘Tairyn, I’m a hundred and ninety eight years old. I am almost three times as old as you. How can you say my life has only just begun?’

Tairyn shrugged his shoulders. ‘It’s a feeling I get when I look at you. Besides, you don’t look a day over thirty. So what does that tell you? Now, stop whining and listen, my time is running out and you must be made aware of what to do.’
 
Hi ya Sho pi, I'm sorry it didn't do it for me. The dialogue didn't seem natural, and seemed to contain a lot of information - I wondered was it a way of getting the info across. Over the three excerpts I felt told a lot and led without getting close to the characters.


" needed Must warn him... They’re coming for him.’ Jonndi was shocked by the wide-eyed expression on his normally level-headed friend.this is telling - the normally level-headed friend. And why was he shocked, he's just pollaxed him with a potion to force consciousness, I'd be wide-eyed.

‘Calm down Tairyn, you’re savesafe now.’ Jonndi couldn’t completely hide the anguish in his voice, knowing full well that his friend wasn’t going to last through the night.this doesn't get close enough to the character, you tell me he's anguished, but I'd like to feel it. Something like Jonndi took a breath, trying to steady his voice, but still it broke with anguish. Tairyn wasn't going to survive the night; the knowledge seared through him, hurting him. (only better...)

Still, his voice seemed to calm the old wanderer down almost instantly. For a moment Tairyn was staring at him as if he was seeing a ghost. Then, with a huge sigh of relieverelief, he finally came back to his senses.

‘Of course the Spirit would guide me well in our hour of need. I don’t know how, but I knew you were out there, far away, but just close enough. Without seeing you, I knew you were there. Without hearing me, you came.’

Jonndi frowned at his friend. He knew Wanderers had a tendency for talking in melodramatic riddles, but this was downright peculiar. Did he really say what I think he said?
his mate's dying in front of him - would his thoughts really be so logical?
Tairyn smiled warily. ‘My sceptical old friend. I didn’t believe it myself at first, but what choice did I have.? I was being held captive by the Lord of the West himself; this was the only path the Spirit showed me that didn’t end in disaster for us all.'remove if you're continuing into new paragraph.

'He has weapons, Jonndi; Algevaro has acquired terrible weapons. Not seen since the days of the Trekiir War. Weapons far too powerful to remain in the hands of ambitious men like him. He holds Dragon Weapons, the weapons of the Guardians.'

'But there is one last weapon on this continent not yet under his control. Jonndi, he must not get it, for if he does;comma the Spirit shows nothing but a future filled with doom for us all.'

'I know I can’t go on any further. My life’s thread has come to an end. Even though I can’t see my own life-thread like I can see others, I feel this is my final night on Meila.’
I'd drop this paragraph - we already know most of what it tells us; it's his last night, and he has special powers.
Jonndi looked pained by his friends calm words. ‘Tairyn, old friend, are you certain there is nothing that can be done.? Maybe if you tell me what poison they used, I can make the right antidote. You know I have some skill with potions and elixirs.’
This is better because you have shown us he has all his potions.
‘I know it is thanks to your skills that I have been given these final hours in the presence of a dear old friend. But you don’t have to comfort me, I know you’re fully aware that there is nothing more that you can do for me.’

Jonndi shook his head in denial, trying to fight back his tears. ‘Can’t you direct me to the nearest temple of Aesclia, maybe a priest of the healing goddess can still help you. If I ditch the wagon we could cover some miles quickly on Boreas’ back. I just need to figure out where I am.’ Jonndi knew that his ideas were getting more and more desperate but he couldn’t stop from offering them.good ‘Can’t the Spirit direct a Ranari to come down here with a cure or a Beralin to take you to them?’

Tairyn’s smile spread to his eyes, returning some of their former sparkle. ‘You always wanted too much from the Spirit, old friend. You know full well that things don’t work like that. I am by no means important enough for any kind of special treatment. Besides, I don’t think even the Spirit can get a Ranari to come down from their jungle moon.'

'No, finding you and telling you what you need to know is the last task for me. I have done my duty and it’s nothing to be sad about. I have lived a full and wondrous life. Who else can say that throughout their entire life they were never lost, never uncertain as to their purpose on Meila and never unaware of all the good in the world?'

'You of all people know how valuable such knowledge can be. I am not the first friend you lost and I shall not be the last. Yours is a burden I don’t envy. But your days of self-imposed isolation must come to an end again. Meila needs you to finish the task that the Spirit had put upon me.’this seems to be pure information giving.

Jonndi looked self-conscious. He had to ask the questions that had plagued him for over a century. ‘Can you see how long I will live? Will I live as long as my father?’

Tairyn looked at his friend warily. ‘Jonndi we have been over this. Yours is a life-thread unlike any I have ever seen. You have the potential to live to a great age, but you could die tomorrow from a broken neck or an errant arrow. I can’t compare, I have never seen a true Guardian. I don’t know what they’re like. Nor have I ever heard or read about a half-blood like you. The Spirit won’t show me what’s in store for you, but I’m sure that you are destined to do great things for the good of us all.’and again

Jonndi looked into the flames, still feeling unconvinced. ‘Everything I have done has been a failure. If I were destined to be a great protector of Meila, don’t you think my father would have taken me under his wing? He keeps me away from any real knowledge because I’m not powerful enough. My magic is useless.’

‘Stop it, Jonndi. I will not spend my final hours listening to a great man feeling sorry for himself. I’m the one who is dying here. How do you know that you’re a failure, for all you know, your life has only just begun?’

Jonndi gave an unconvinced chuckle. ‘Tairyn, I’m a hundred and ninety eight years old. I am almost three times as old as you. How can you say my life has only just begun?’

Tairyn shrugged his shoulders. ‘It’s a feeling I get when I look at you. Besides, you don’t look a day over thirty. So what does that tell you? Now, stop whining and listen, my time is running out and you must be made aware of what to do.’ the last part was a little more natural, in terms of the dialogue.
 
Last edited:
Jonndi looked pained by his friends calm words.
friend's (possessive, not plural

But you don’t have to comfort me, I know you’re fully aware that there is nothing more that you can do for me.’
Comma splice.

Can’t you direct me to the nearest temple of Aesclia, maybe a priest of the healing goddess can still help you.
You should really have a question mark in here somewhere (probably in place of the comma).

Who else can say that throughout their entire life they were never lost, never uncertain as to their purpose on Meila and never unaware of all the good in the world?'
Consider commas round "throughout their entire life". And since the next paragraph is still him talking, don't close the quotation marks.

How do you know that you’re a failure, for all you know, your life has only just begun?’
Comma splice.

Fortunately I read Springs' crit before, so didn't duplicate all her gramcors (perhaps it's time for me to retire?).

Rather than worrying about infodump, I'm more seeing this bit as a bit too clichéd. The whole "I'm dying and you're the chosen hero to save… here's your (incomplete) instruction manual…" – oh, yes, it's been used so many times because it works, but that mean we don't start to recognise it a bit early. What, suggestions for an alternative technique? I wouldn't dare.

And, for me, you hammer on the word "friend" rather too often. Not that their friendship isn't important, but it doesn't need quite so much reinforcement.
 
Fortunately I read Springs' crit before, so didn't duplicate all her gramcors (perhaps it's time for me to retire?).
QUOTE]

Except that Springs didn't, of course, find the possessive apostrophe... nor the comma splices. ;)
 
‘Must warn him... They’re coming for him.’ Jonndi was shocked by the wide-eyed expression on his normally level-headed friend.

‘Calm down Tairyn, you’re save now.’ Jonndi couldn’t completely hide the anguish in his voice, knowing full well that his friend wasn’t going to last through the night.

Still, his voice seemed to calm the old wanderer down almost instantly. For a moment Tairyn was staring at him as if he was seeing a ghost. Then, with a huge sigh of relieve, he finally came back to his senses.

‘Of course the Spirit would guide me well in our hour of need. I don’t know how, but I knew you were out there, far away, but just close enough. Without seeing you, I knew you were there. Without hearing me, you came.’
I’d rework that line, make it easier for the reader.

Jonndi frowned at his friend. He knew Wanderers had a tendency for talking in melodramatic riddles, but this was downright peculiar. Did he really say what I think he said?
I agree Jonndi, what is he on about!!

Tairyn smiled warily. ‘My sceptical old friend. I didn’t believe it myself at first, but what choice did I have. I was being held captive by the Lord of the West himself; this was the only path the Spirit showed me that didn’t end in disaster for us all.'
'He has weapons, Jonndi; Algevaro has acquired terrible weapons. Not seen since the days of the Trekiir War. Weapons far too powerful to remain in the hands of ambitious men like him. He holds Dragon Weapons, the weapons of the Guardians.'
'But there is one last weapon on this continent not yet under his control. Jonndi, he must not get it, for if he does; the Spirit shows nothing but a future filled with doom for us all.'
'I know I can’t go on any further. My life’s thread has come to an end. Even though I can’t see my own life-thread like I can see others, I feel this is my final night on Meila.’
This guy is hard to shut up once he gets going. You have told us just about everything we need to know, sadly killing the tension and suspense in the process.

Jonndi looked pained by his friends calm words. ‘Tairyn, old friend, are you certain there is nothing that can be done. Maybe if you tell me what poison they used, I can make the right antidote. You know I have some skill with potions and elixirs.’

‘I know it is thanks to your skills that I have been given these final hours in the presence of a dear old friend. But you don’t have to comfort me, I know you’re fully aware that there is nothing more that you can do for me.’

Jonndi shook his head in denial, trying to fight back his tears. ‘Can’t you direct me to the nearest temple of Aesclia, maybe a priest of the healing goddess can still help you. If I ditch the wagon we could cover some miles quickly on Boreas’ back. I just need to figure out where I am.’ Jonndi knew that his ideas were getting more and more desperate but he couldn’t stop from offering them. ‘Can’t the Spirit direct a Ranari to come down here with a cure or a Beralin to take you to them?’

Tairyn’s smile spread to his eyes, returning some of their former sparkle. ‘You always wanted too much from the Spirit, old friend. You know full well that things don’t work like that. I am by no means important enough for any kind of special treatment. Besides, I don’t think even the Spirit can get a Ranari to come down from their jungle moon.'
The last few sections were not too bad, a little tighter for flow as some of the conversation feels unnatural.

'No, finding you and telling you what you need to know is the last task for me. I have done my duty and it’s nothing to be sad about. I have lived a full and wondrous life. Who else can say that throughout their entire life they were never lost, never uncertain as to their purpose on Meila and never unaware of all the good in the world?'
Very unnatural feeling to the talking.

'You of all people know how valuable such knowledge can be. I am not the first friend you lost and I shall not be the last. Yours is a burden I don’t envy. But your days of self-imposed isolation must come to an end again. Meila needs you to finish the task that the Spirit had put upon me.’
Very unnatural feeling again.

Jonndi looked self-conscious. He had to ask the questions that had plagued him for over a century. ‘Can you see how long I will live? Will I live as long as my father?’
That’s a bit unfair, the other guy is dying after all!

Tairyn looked at his friend warily. ‘Jonndi we have been over this. Yours is a life-thread unlike any I have ever seen. You have the potential to live to a great age, but you could die tomorrow from a broken neck or an errant arrow. I can’t compare, I have never seen a true Guardian. I don’t know what they’re like. Nor have I ever heard or read about a half-blood like you. The Spirit won’t show me what’s in store for you, but I’m sure that you are destined to do great things for the good of us all.’
Very unnatural feeling again.

Jonndi looked into the flames, still feeling unconvinced. ‘Everything I have done has been a failure. If I were destined to be a great protector of Meila, don’t you think my father would have taken me under his wing? He keeps me away from any real knowledge because I’m not powerful enough. My magic is useless.’

‘Stop it, Jonndi. I will not spend my final hours listening to a great man feeling sorry for himself. I’m the one who is dying here. How do you know that you’re a failure, for all you know, your life has only just begun?’

Jonndi gave an unconvinced chuckle. ‘Tairyn, I’m a hundred and ninety eight years old. I am almost three times as old as you. How can you say my life has only just begun?’

Tairyn shrugged his shoulders. ‘It’s a feeling I get when I look at you. Besides, you don’t look a day over thirty. So what does that tell you? Now, stop whining and listen, my time is running out and you must be made aware of what to do.’

Interesting age thing going on which is nice for the plot. The conversation felt very stilted and unnatural, over running a lot as well. The greatest sin you committed here was pretty much telling me the whole plot, you laid out the up-coming quest in one go, or seemed so to me. Consider holding more back and letting the reader get to know the character more before sending them off to battles etc. This missing monkey worries me, has the monkey been killed off? To this point, and how you have currently laid out the plot, I would have stopped reading. I think your level of writing is good but you need to think about plot, flow and suspence while letting us get to know the characters more.

Sorry mate.

The start was ok, which is why I read the next two posted sections.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top