Dinner scene - 1,100 words

Status
Not open for further replies.

Esfires

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
256
This is the last part of Chapter Three of my WIP. You can find Chapter One here:
http://www.sffchronicles.co.uk/forum/536996-chapter-one-900-words.html (Check the end of the thread for a revised version)


There isn't too much you need to know for this scene as it's still early on in the book and is fairly self-explanatory. Lieutenant Mathews is part of a company of soldiers wintering in the town, and is boarding with the Gates family. We met him in Chapter Two, and established that he is a little quiet and awkward. I believe all the other characters were introduced in Chapter One.

This is the second Chapter from Elizabeth's POV. I'm trying to drop in a little exposition, particularly in the dialogue, as well as some description of the relations within the family. I want Lieutenant Mathews to be a little evasive about his time in the east, but it's not incredibly necessary that the reader pick up on that now. I just want it to be there for those who would catch that sort of thing.

After you read it, let me know if you understood what happened with the fork-dropping incident. I'm not sure if I got that across clearly.





He was still there when Elizabeth returned hours later to call him for dinner. The bag had been unpacked. The empty sack had been folded neatly on the bed and his sword leaned against the far wall, but the man himself sat just as she had left him.

She informed him that dinner was waiting. He murmured an acknowledgement and stood, brushing his already clean coat before following her down the stairs.

Simon was already in the dining room when they arrived. He trailed in Mrs. Hill’s wake, hands snaking out to sample the food as she brought it in from the kitchen.

“Hands off, you little vermin,” the housekeeper said as he tried to sneak a finger past her elbow to the large dish she carried.

Elizabeth sucked in a sharp breath as her brother nearly upended the lamp that flickered at the center of the table. “Simon, please.”

He brought a gravy-covered finger to his mouth. “I’m starving.

“Fourteen years you been eatin’ from my table,” said Mrs. Hill, “and you ain’t starved for a one of ‘em. I suspect you can manage to last a few more minutes.” Despite her chiding, the housekeeper allowed his next intrusion to slide past her defenses unopposed.

It was an old game between them, one that only persisted because both sides got a taste of victory every once in a while. Elizabeth wouldn’t change it even if she could. She took her seat along one side of the table as the silent officer sat across from her.

“Simon, seat yourself,” said her father as he entered the room, and her brother quickly took the chair next to the officer.

Her father’s eyes were red, tired. He had rolled back the sleeves of his white shirt above his hairy forearms, but it wasn’t enough to hide the dark stain on one of his elbows. Elizabeth suspected that the knees of his trousers bore similar marks and that, if she were to walk out tomorrow morning to the great oak behind the house, the winter honeysuckle growing around the base of her mother’s headstone would appear newly tended.

The meal commenced in silence. Her father was lost in his own thoughts, and from what Elizabeth had seen of the officer, he regarded conversation as a duty more than a pastime. She would probably only make him more uncomfortable if she forced him to speak.

As Mrs. Hill brought the last course to the table, her father finally emerged from his musings. “John told me some disturbing news,” he said. “About the caravans coming through the Hills.”

Elizabeth never liked talking about business, but she was grateful that her father had at least found something else to occupy his mind. “Mr. Williams is a nice man,” she said, “but he’s too gullible. He’s always being disturbed by one thing or another.”

“He seemed awfully worried this time,” her father replied. “Something about the Hillfolk tightening up the passes.”

“He probably heard it from Mr. Newcastle,” she said. “He delights in dire news, especially when he can spread it to someone like John.”

“But he hates being proven wrong,” her father pointed out as he brought his fork to his mouth. “He doesn’t spread rumors unless they have more than a little weight.”

“You sound as bad as John,” she teased. “It’s still just a rumor, isn’t it?”

“Mr. Mathews,” her father said, returning his attention to his meal. “Your Major Price tells me that you spent some time out east.”

The lieutenant dropped his fork at Elijah’s question. He bent to retrieve it before responding. “Only a little. I’ve spent most of my time in Maridon, sir, where I was born.” He prepared to stab at his food with the fork, but paused and sent a guilty glance around the table.

“Well, surely you’ve heard something about the passes,” Elijah said. “More than has come in on the barges, at least.”

Simon noisily sucked his fingers clean as her father finished speaking. Elizabeth stretched out her foot to give him a gentle kick under the table. He ignored the nudge and continued smacking at his fingers until he caught sight of her glare and discretely made use of his napkin.

She looked back at the officer. His face flushed and he quickly wiped the fallen fork with his napkin and returned it to its place on the table. Unable to finish eating without it, he simply folded his hands in his lap and said, “I wouldn’t know anything about it, sir. I was sent back to the capital nearly a year ago.”

“Still,” her father said, looking up from his plate, “you must have interacted at least a little with the Hillfolk. All of my news is second hand, at best. You’ve actually met them.”

“Only briefly,” the lieutenant said. “Most Dunlanders we came in contact with were regular army or traders, nearly all from the coast. They’re as much strangers to the Hills as we are.” He dropped his gaze to the table. “I think the Hillfolk hardly consider themselves to be Dunlanders at all, and the rest of Dunland seems to share the sentiment.”

He almost seemed embarrassed, but Elizabeth couldn’t decide if it was because he didn’t have more to tell or because he had revealed so much already. “Would they really cut off traffic through the Hills,” she asked, “when so many people rely on the passes?”

“I can’t imagine so,” he said, raising his eyes to meet hers. “They wouldn’t have anything to gain from it. The Hillfolk have a reputation for being pigheaded, but they’re not stupid. They may be protective of their mountains, but most of their coin comes from the tariffs they take from the caravans.”

“Let us hope they aren’t that stupid,” added her father. “Sending goods down through the Gap is three times as expensive. If they shut up the passes then somebody is sure to try to open them again, whether it’s us or the Dunlanders themselves.”

Simon perked up at Elijah’s statement. “Would there be a war?”

Elizabeth frowned at him. “Simon, don’t sound so hopeful.”

He turned to the officer at his side. “Could I join the army?”

“Simon,” Elijah began.

“Do you think I’m old enough?”

“Simon!” Her father extended his arm, pointing through the doorway toward the stairs leading to the second floor.

“But-”

Now,” Elijah said. There was no question of disobedience in his voice.

Elizabeth bowed her head as Simon slunk from the table. Her father resumed his meal, but the discussion was over.

The officer merely sat and stared at his plate, looking for all the world as if he wished to be anywhere else.
 
“Well, surely you’ve heard something about the passes,” Elijah said. “More than enough gossip has come in on the barges.” – A small recommendation only, I found the second part of this line unclear and when I first read the line I wondered what was missing. It’s clear enough, but not on the first read, or at least it felt that way to me.


She looked back at the officer. His face flushed and he quickly wiped the fallen fork with his napkin and returned it to its place on the table. Unable to finish eating without it, he simply folded his hands in his lap and said, “I wouldn’t know anything about it, sir. I was sent back to the capital nearly a year ago.” If he put the, now clean, fork back on the table, why can’t he use it? Or is that my poor etiquette showing me up? The fork does draw out a little extra tension and suits the style of the section posted.

I have to admit, very interesting. The pace in your writing is very gentle, or at least it is here. It suits the dinner scene very well and all the characters felt alive to me. The feeling of formal manners running just below the surface was great, which the fork adds to, while still adding tension and highlighting the political background to the story. The potential link with the officer and the girl is there, it does not feel like romance to me at the moment but I guess it could develop. I don’t read too much romance so you could be hitting me with a romance club and I would not get it! Anyway, I thought it was very nice indeed. Not to everyone’s taste I suspect, but you can’t please everyone.


Finally, if you drop your fork. I take it real good manners, would state it not be used again even after cleaning?
 
The barge line is an easy fix, and I can see how it might be confusing.

There will be a romance between Elizabeth and the officer, but that won't be for quite a while, yet. They've just met and right now both she and the readers are getting to know him. He hasn't even had a POV scene yet, and he's one of my main characters.


With the fork scene, I was trying to get across that, when Elizabeth thought she was kicking Simon's ankle, she had actually kicked the lieutenant's. He thinks she kicked him because he was about to use the fork that he had just dropped. It's a part of the scene that is hard for me to judge, because I know what is happening and I can't exactly forget that I know, no matter how long I leave it alone.


And yes, this scene does have a very gentle pace. Of the scene/sequel pairing, it's definitely a sequel, even though it does introduce some new information.
 
Only a few points, the first so nit-picky I'm quite proud of it.

“Fourteen years you been eatin’ from my table,” said Mrs. Hill, “and you ain’t starved for a one of ‘em.

The apostrophe in front of "em" is the wrong way round. Should be the same as after "eatin". This is the curse of autoformat.

More importantly, a lot of your dialogue is of the same form for several paragraphs in a row:

"[blah]," [character X] [verbed]. "[more blah]"

Once I noticed this, it became distracting. You can vary it by a character performing an action before the dialogue, or leaving out the speech indication altogether if it should be clear who's speaking. In places, it could also do with a couple of shorter lines for variety.

The pace of the conversation is very leisurely. For me, this would only work if the story has already given me a firm reason to be interested in what they're talking about. I don't know if this is the case or not.

Finally, I didn't pick up on the foot-nudging incident. Maybe you should have Elizabeth at least think the officer is behaving a bit oddly with his face flushing etc -- that way, when it is finally explained (as I expect it will be) the reader stands a better chance of remembering it.

Apart from the repetitiveness of the dialogue form, I can't really fault the prose at all. Good stuff.
 
I liked it a lot, Esfires.

The only thing that made me pause was a repeat of 'already' (which is almost on the level of nit-pickery of HareBrain's backward-facing apostrophe)

She informed him that dinner was waiting. He murmured an acknowledgement and stood, brushing his already clean coat before following her down the stairs.

Simon was already in the dining room when they arrived.

I'm afraid I didn't pick up that Elizabeth had kicked the officer (but I love him and his awkwardness -- he's wonderful).

It reminds me of Robin McKinley's YA novel, The Blue Sword, probably mainly because of the 'hillfolk', who are the native people in McKinley's rather Colonial India-like country of Damar. She has scenes like this with terribly polite meals while outside everything's going to pieces. It didn't remind me enough for it to be an issue (as I said, I think it was the use of the word 'hillfolk' that made me think of it) but you might find the book interesting.
 
Nope, I never linked the fork with the under table action. But I refer you to the romance club. As a reader I also need a big hint club, a really big one and belt me about the head with it. I know all this, because my girlfriend tells me so!

I thought he knew something about the military stuff that put him off as the father was asking him questions at the time. As I said, bit hint weapon needed.

And lastly, dropped forks, can they be re-used?
 
Last edited:
Hi, I'm in nit-picky mode...

red = suggested addition/amendment
blue = suggested deletion
purple = comment

He was still there when Elizabeth returned hours later to call him for dinner. The bag had been unpacked. The empty sack [Is the bag the same thing as the sack? If so, it's a tad confusing. I also keep wanting to shove a semi-colon there rather than a full stop, but something about the structure is then wrong] was [had been] [presumably it is still there] folded neatly on the bed [seemed a bit odd. Has he put his clothes away in the cupboards? Why leave that out and on the bed?] and his sword leaned against the far wall, but the man himself sat just as she had left him.

She informed him that dinner was waiting. He murmured an acknowledgement and stood, brushing his already clean coat before following her down the stairs.

Simon was already in the dining room when they arrived. He trailed in Mrs. Hill’s wake, hands snaking out to sample the food as she brought it in from the kitchen.

“Hands off, you little vermin,” the housekeeper said as he tried to sneak a finger past her elbow to the large dish she carried.

Elizabeth sucked in a sharp breath as her brother nearly upended the lamp that flickered at the center of the table. [I couldn't work this out, as Mrs H was still carrying the dish, she hasn't put it down, and he's trailing in her wake, so how's he got ahead of her to the middle of the table?] “Simon, please.”

He brought a gravy-covered finger to his mouth. “I’m starving.

“Fourteen years you been eatin’ from my table,” said Mrs. Hill, “and you ain’t starved for a one of ‘em. [as HB says, quote mark needs to be the other way round] I suspect [she's quite homely in her speech (that's UK homely, as in a like a homebody, not ugly!) so would she say "suspect" and not "guess" or "reckon"?] you can manage to last a few more minutes.” Despite her chiding, the housekeeper allowed his next intrusion to slide past her defenses unopposed. [hasn't she put the thing down on the table yet?]

It was an old game between them, one that only persisted because both sides got a taste of victory every once in a while. Elizabeth wouldn’t change it even if she could. [then why has she told him off with the "Simon, please"? Because of the Lieutenant? If so, is she embarrassed that he's seen it? Does she sneak a look at him to see if he's noticed? Why has she tolerated such manners all these years? This isn't just pinching food from a plate; this is dipping his rat-helping fingers into a communal dish and she's not bothered?!] She took her seat along one side of the table as the silent officer sat across from her. [how does he know where to sit? Does she show him to the chair?]

“Simon, seat yourself,” said her father as he entered the room, and her brother quickly took the chair next to the officer.

Her father’s eyes were red, tired. He had rolled back the sleeves of his white shirt above his hairy [you've a few adjectives here, so I'd drop this one as it adds nothing -- unless his hairiness is important] forearms, but it wasn’t enough to hide the dark stain on one of his elbows. Elizabeth suspected that the knees of his trousers bore similar marks [he's just walked in -- why didn't she notice then?] and that, if she were to walk out tomorrow morning to the great oak behind the house, the winter honeysuckle growing around the base of her mother’s headstone would appear newly tended.

The meal commenced in silence. Her father was lost in his own thoughts, and from what Elizabeth had seen of the officer, he regarded conversation as a duty more than a pastime. She would probably only make him more uncomfortable if she forced him to speak.[what about Simon? Isn't he interested in the soldier? Why isn't he bombarding him with questions?]

As Mrs. Hill brought the last course [tell us what it is -- that would give a flavour (ha!) of the times/social postion if we know exactly what they're eating] to the table, her father finally emerged from his musings. “John told me some disturbing news,” he said. “About the caravans coming through the Hills.” [coming immediately after "Mrs. Hill" I had visions of someone driving through her family... I suspect as he is Gates and there's Newcastle there might be deliberate intent here, but I really would change her name! Also, if it is "the Hills" then it would usually be lower case "h" and then "hillfolk" not "Hillfolk". If it's a named area it would usually be "through Hills" without the article. At present it looks very odd, so if you've a reason for doing it this way, you might need to get it out quickly]

Elizabeth never liked talking about business, [odd, it strikes me as politics rather than business] but she was grateful that her father had at least found something else to occupy his mind. “Mr. Williams is a nice man,” she said, “but he’s too gullible. He’s always being disturbed by one thing or another.”

“He seemed awfully worried this time. [,” her father replied. “] [not needed -- we expect it to be him] Something about the Hillfolk tightening up the passes.”

“He probably heard it from Mr. Newcastle. [,” she said. “] [ditto] He delights in dire news, especially when he can spread it to someone like John.” [why is he "John" now if he was "Mr Williams" when she spoke before?]

“But he [which "he"? John or Newcastle?] hates being proven wrong. [,” her father pointed out as he brought his fork to his mouth. “] [the "pointed out" is an unnecessary saidism, and if he's bringing it to his mouth as he speaks the first bit, he must have it in his mouth as he speaks the next bit, or he's having it hovering around his mouth for rather a long while which is peculiar.] He doesn’t spread rumors unless they have more than a little weight.”

“You sound as bad as John,” she teased. “It’s still just a rumor, isn’t it?”

“Mr. Mathews, ” her father said, turning to the lieutenant, [returning his attention to his meal.] [er... he never left the meal as he had a fork en route to his mouth last we heard, and he's certainly not giving it more attention!!] your Major Price tells me that you spent some time out east.” [I've given lower case "y" as if there were no interruption to me it would read "Mr Mathews, your..." not "Mr Mathews. Your..." but if you're hearing the latter then the capital is, of course, right]

The lieutenant dropped his fork at [how does she know it's "at" and not just a coincidence? Perhaps if he looks a little guilty/shifty at the question, something she might notice?] Elijah’s question. [I know you've got "He bent" afterwards but you might want to make it clearer here that it lands on the floor, not just on the table or his lap.] He bent to retrieve it before responding. “Only a little. I’ve spent most of my time in Maridon, sir, where I was born.” He prepared to stab at his food [again being specific as to what he's eating will be much better] with the fork, but paused and sent a guilty glance around the table.

“Well, surely you’ve heard something about the passes,” Elijah said. “More than has come in on the barges, at least.”

Simon noisily sucked his fingers clean [why? has he been eating with his fingers? If so, why hasn't she clouted him already as everyone else is eating dessert with a fork] as her father finished speaking. Elizabeth stretched out her foot to give him a gentle kick under the table. He ignored the nudge and continued smacking at his fingers until he caught sight [how? he's too busy licking his fingers to notice -- perhaps if she hisses at him?] of her glare and discreetely [discreet and discrete are very different words...] made use of his napkin.

She looked back at the officer. His face flushed [too long a time delay between the kick and the face beginning to flush if she's had to wait for Simon to notice her. Is it going to be important plot point that she's kicked him? If not, I'd debate its inclusion unless you make it more obvious -- ie her realising what she's done] and he quickly wiped the fallen fork with his napkin and returned it to its place on the table. [ooh... poor table manners alert... no gentlemen would put a used piece of cutlery on the table, it would go on his plate -- and if she's got manners, she should know this even if he doesn't] Unable to finish eating without it, [Simon apparently managed... but how does she know he isn't intending to finish? It's perilously close to a head-hop. And why doesn't she offer to get another one for him?] he simply folded his hands in his lap. [and said,] [the "and" makes this almost a corollary of the unable to eat. Better to keep them separate] “I wouldn’t know anything about it, sir. I was sent back to the capital nearly a year ago.”

“Still, [” her father said, looking up from his plate, “] [not needed] you must have interacted at least a little with the Hillfolk. All of my news is second hand, at best. You’ve actually met them.”

“Only briefly. [, ” the lieutenant said. “] [ditto] Most Dunlanders we came in contact with were regular army or traders, nearly all from the coast. They’re as much strangers to the Hills as we are.” He dropped his gaze to the table. “I think the Hillfolk hardly consider themselves to be Dunlanders at all, and the rest of Dunland seems to share the sentiment.”

He almost seemed embarrassed, but Elizabeth couldn’t decide if it was because he didn’t have more to tell or because he had revealed so much already. “Would they really cut off traffic through the Hills,” she asked, “when so many people rely on the passes?” [if she doesn't like talking business, why is she?]

“I can’t imagine so,” he said, raising his eyes to meet hers. “They wouldn’t have anything to gain from it. The Hillfolk have a reputation for being pigheaded, but they’re not stupid. They may be protective of their mountains, but most of their coin comes from the tariffs they take from the caravans.”

“Let us hope they aren’t that stupid,” added her father. “Sending goods down through the Gap is three times as expensive. If they shut up the passes then somebody is sure to try to open them again, whether it’s us or the Dunlanders themselves.”

Simon perked up at Elijah’s statement. “Would there be a war?”

Elizabeth frowned at him. “Simon, don’t sound so hopeful.”

He turned to the lieutenant [officer at his side]. [this makes it sound as if there are several present and he's chosen one of them] “Could I join the army?”

“Simon --” Elijah began.[I'd suggest a long dash to indicate Simon has cut him off]

“Do you think I’m old enough?”

“Simon!” Her father extended his arm, pointing through the doorway toward the stairs. [leading to the second floor.] [not needed, as we'd assume they led up not down. (And unnecessary confusion for UK readers, as it would be to the first floor, unless this is a three storey building!)]

“But-”

Now,” Elijah said. There was no question of permitting disobedience in his voice.

Elizabeth bowed her head as Simon slunk from the table. Her father resumed his meal, but the conversation [discussion] was over.

The officer merely sat and stared at his plate, looking for all the world as if he wished to be anywhere else.

Well written as everyone has said, and I didn't mind it was a little slow, though, as HB says, it might be a bit too leisurely unless we've got to know these people and we're interested in them already. I'd like a touch more of her in there, though, since the dialogue isn't the most gripping -- just a few more of her emotions might help. At present it's a touch... not flat... but, well, flattish -- we hear some of her thoughts but there's little feeling there.

With regard to the dialogue, if you want some stage business to break it up, I'd suggest adding it before or after the speech, not always in the middle, and make it something which adds to our knowledge of them eg toying with the food, separating out the plum stones with care, wolfing it down, whatever.



Bowler, when I publish my Ms Judge's Book of Table Etiquette I shall devote a whole chapter to the penalties for such social solecisms as picking one's fork from the floor and attempting to use it again, wiped on one's napkin or not.
 
I made some modifications that ought to address most of the concerns listed so far. I think I found a satisfactory solution for the kicking/fork incident, and its something that would have happened anyway if I'd really thought about it.

As for "Hillfolk," I mean for it to be capitalized. The "Hills" is a name for a mountain range at the Maridon/Dunland border, nominally in Dunland territory. The people that occupy the mountains are a bit different from the normal lowland dwellers, and will play a part later in the book. I'm trying to establish that they hold themselves separate from other populations, regardless of any lines on a map.

And Hex, The Blue Sword was one of my favorite books as a child, along with the series The Dark is Rising. I hadn't thought of either of those stories in years, and your comment brought back a flood of good memories.



Here's the corrected version:





He was still there when Elizabeth returned hours later to call him for dinner. The bag had been unpacked. The empty sack was folded neatly on the bed and his sword leaned against the far wall, but the man himself sat just as she had left him.

She informed him that dinner was waiting. He murmured an acknowledgement and stood, brushing his already clean coat before following her down the stairs.

Simon was in the dining room when they arrived. He trailed in Mrs. Hill’s wake, hands snaking out to sample the food as she brought the last of it from the kitchen. He tried to sneak a finger past her elbow to the large dish she carried.

“Hands off, you little vermin,” the housekeeper said as she set the dish on the table.

Elizabeth sucked in a sharp breath as her brother nearly upended the lamp that flickered at the center of the table. She glanced at the lieutenant, but he didn’t appear to have taken notice. “Simon, please.”

He brought a gravy-covered finger to his mouth. “I’m starving.

“Fourteen years you been eatin’ from my table,” said Mrs. Hill, “and you ain’t starved for a one of 'em. I figure you can manage to last a few more minutes.” Despite her chiding, the housekeeper allowed his next intrusion to slide past her defenses unopposed.

It was an old game between them, one that only persisted because both sides got a taste of victory every once in a while. Elizabeth wouldn’t change it even if she could, but she wished her brother would control himself when there was a guest in the house. She showed the silent officer to his seat and took her own across from him as her father entered the room.

“Simon, seat yourself,” Elijah said, and her brother quickly took the chair next to the officer.

Her father’s eyes were red, tired. He had rolled back the sleeves of his white shirt above his forearms, but it wasn’t enough to hide the dark stain on one of his elbows. Elizabeth suspected that the knees of his trousers bore similar marks and that, if she were to walk out tomorrow morning to the great oak behind the house, the winter honeysuckle growing around the base of her mother’s headstone would appear newly tended.

The meal commenced in silence. Her father was lost in his own thoughts, and from what Elizabeth had seen of the officer, he regarded conversation as a duty more than a pastime. She would probably only make him more uncomfortable if she forced him to speak. Even Simon seemed to sense the mood.

As Mrs. Hill brought the last course to the table, her father finally emerged from his musings. “John told me some disturbing news,” he said. “About the caravans coming through the Hills.”

Elizabeth never liked talking about business, but she supposed she should be grateful that her father had at least found something else to occupy his mind. “Mr. Williams is a nice man,” she said, “but he’s too gullible. He’s always being disturbed by one thing or another.”

“He seemed awfully worried this time. Something about the Hillfolk tightening up the passes.”

“He probably heard it from Mr. Newcastle. He delights in dire news, especially when he can spread it to someone like John.”

“But he hates being proven wrong,” her father pointed out. He frowned down at his food as he pushed it around on his plate. “He doesn’t spread rumors unless they have more than a little weight.”

“You sound as bad as John,” she teased. “It’s still just a rumor, isn’t it?”

“Mr. Mathews,” her father said, pushing his plate away, “your Major Price tells me that you spent some time out east.”

The lieutenant dropped his fork at Elijah’s question and it tumbled to the floor. He bent to retrieve it before responding. “Only a little. I’ve spent most of my time in Maridon, sir, where I was born.” He prepared to stab at his food with the fork, but paused and sent a hesitant glance around the table.

“Well, surely you’ve heard something about the passes,” Elijah said. “More information than has come in on the barges, at least.”

Simon sucked his fingers clean as her father finished speaking. Elizabeth stretched out her foot to give him a gentle kick under the table, but instead of his ankle her toes struck the hard leather of a boot.

Her brother continued smacking at his fingers, but the officer stiffened. Elizabeth tried to keep the color from rising to her face as he shot her a guilty look and quickly wiped the fallen fork with his napkin before returning it to its place on the table. Unable to finish eating without it, he simply folded his hands in his lap. “I wouldn’t know anything about it, sir. I was sent back to the capital nearly a year ago.”

“Still, you must have interacted at least a little with the Hillfolk. All of my news is second hand, at best. You’ve actually met them.”

“Only briefly,” the officer said. “Most Dunlanders we came in contact with were regular army or traders, nearly all from the coast. They’re as much strangers to the Hills as we are.” He dropped his gaze to the table. “I think the Hillfolk hardly consider themselves to be Dunlanders at all, and the rest of Dunland seems to share the sentiment.”

He almost seemed embarrassed, but Elizabeth couldn’t decide if it was because he didn’t have more to tell or because he had revealed so much already. “Would they really cut off traffic through the Hills,” she prodded, “when so many people rely on the passes?”

“I can’t imagine so,” he said, raising his eyes to meet hers. “They wouldn’t have anything to gain from it. The Hillfolk have a reputation for being pigheaded, but they’re not stupid. They may be protective of their mountains, but most of their coin comes from the tariffs they take from the caravans.”

“Let us hope they aren’t that stupid,” added her father. “Sending goods down through the Gap is three times as expensive. If they shut up the passes then somebody is sure to try to open them again, whether it’s us or the Dunlanders themselves.”

Simon perked up at Elijah’s statement. “Would there be a war?”

Elizabeth frowned at him. “Simon, don’t sound so hopeful.”

He turned to the officer. “Could I join the army?”

“Simon,” Elijah began.

“Do you think I’m old enough?”

“Simon!” Her father extended his arm, pointing through the doorway toward the stairs.

“But-”

Now,” Elijah said. There was no question of disobedience in his voice.

Elizabeth bowed her head as Simon slunk from the table. Her father resumed his meal, but the conversation was over.

The officer merely sat and stared at his plate, looking for all the world as if he wished to be anywhere else.
 
I've been told you should always say what's being eaten when you have a meal scene. Readers will forgive much if you just make them hungry and strangely, sometimes even more if you make them sick. :)

I still didn't quite pick up on Elizabeth kicking the wrong person though I did at least notice it this time. You need to point out WHOSE boot, (some of us just aren't subtle, it seems)

Touching rats, putting their fingers into food...given the apparent time and level of culture I will accept that all, but then would a dropped fork bother them? And while the fork was known and even common in many places it wasn't widely used in Europe until the 18th century, according to Wiki, so it seems out of place to emphasise one in the setting I've thought you've been trying to establish.

Very well written generally, though, and I want to know more about these Hill people,...uh...the ones closing the passes, not the family.
 
I've been told you should always say what's being eaten when you have a meal scene. Readers will forgive much if you just make them hungry and strangely, sometimes even more if you make them sick. :)

I still didn't quite pick up on Elizabeth kicking the wrong person though I did at least notice it this time. You need to point out WHOSE boot, (some of us just aren't subtle, it seems)

Touching rats, putting their fingers into food...given the apparent time and level of culture I will accept that all, but then would a dropped fork bother them? And while the fork was known and even common in many places it wasn't widely used in Europe until the 18th century, according to Wiki, so it seems out of place to emphasise one in the setting I've thought you've been trying to establish.

Very well written generally, though, and I want to know more about these Hill people,...uh...the ones closing the passes, not the family.


Thomas is the only one that would be wearing boots in the first place. And I took the rat-touching part out of the first chapter :)

Part of the point of the fork-dropping is that nobody really did care or take notice of it. Thomas just thought they did, because Elizabeth kicked him. I'm trying to show is awkwardness in social situations.

The Hillfolk will get their time. They get about a third of the book, actually.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top