Mixed genres

allmywires

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2012
Messages
1,672
Location
London
Does anyone here write anything other than sci-fi or fantasy? Are agents or publishers discouraged if you don't work solely in one genre? I realise it sounds a bit stupid, but since sci-fi/fantasy seems to be quite an exclusive genre, I wondered if it's hugely important.
 
I have it from the horse's mouth (well, a horse...) that they're not overhappy if you write SF and fantasy until you're well established. The rationale is that if the publishers are going to invest money in you, they want to build up a following by marketing a brand. Crossing genres can be an obstacle to that branding, unless you write under a pseudonym.

It isn't impossible -- obviously Iain (M) Banks does it, among others, as does our Ian Whates, but from what I've been told it isn't encouraged.
 
I write scifi and fantasy and I also write crime. But I've not got anything published, nor likely to have, so I guess it doesn't affect anything.

Ideas surface and I write them down. Or try to ;)

If you have any crime/thrillers you want someone to help review - I could do that.
 
Most of my short stories are horror. Does that count? One of my short stories is in a literary anthology, even. Can you believe that?
 
Well...what I'm writing at the moment as an aside to my main trilogy is what you would probably call literary fiction. (Goodness me that sounds poncey). So basically it's as different from my lovely fantasy epic as you can be. I may yet shelve it though since it's in the no-mans-land between short story and full novel.
 
Heh heh! I did make a comment along those lines before deciding to delete it! (If you needa reada...) ;)
 
I can think of quite a few established authors who write both fantasy and sf: David Weber, Elizabeth Moon, Richard Morgan, Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle wrote a couple of historical fantasy books, I think Charles Stross has as well, and I'm sure there are many others.

Much less common I suspect is writing mainstream or "literary" fiction as well as speculative. As the Judge says, Iain (M) Banks is one and possibly Michael Crichton. I can't think of any others off the top of my head though I am sure there are many more.

However all of the ones I can think of are established authors. I know Iain Banks had always wanted to write sf but didn't actually do it until after he was reasonably well established as a mainstream author (his first sf book was in 1987 I think and he had already published 3, possibly 4, mainstream books by then).
 
If anything, there seems to be a resurgence in writers publishing under pseudonyms for different genres and even sub-genres. Mark Barrowcliffe writes (or wrote) mainstream fiction under his own name, and writes fantasy as M D Lachlan - and his new series, which is still fantasy but different in tone to his Wolfsangel series, is coming out under yet another pseudonym (Mark Alder). I know other writers (some of whom I can't name, since I was told in confidence) in similar situations, so this isn't a one-off.

The publishers have to balance the benefits of an existing brand against the likelihood (or lack) of a crossover in readership. They want to prevent the casual reader from having wrong expectations when picking up a book, probably even more than they want to exploit a known brand, especially if that brand isn't mega-famous. If you're not JKR or Stephen King, most likely you'll be expected to use pseudonyms.

I think you'd have trouble selling one SF book and then a fantasy, for example, but get a trilogy under your belt and genre-switching is more of an option, particularly if your first books sold only modest amounts. A poor track record of sales can be a serious disadvantage in today's computerised ordering systems, and a new pseudonym can get you round that!

As for agents...it depends. Some agents are very genre-specific (John Jarrold, for example), others are a bit more eclectic - some authors have multiple agents for different genres, for that reason.
 
So far as I understand it, you stick to one genre. Or else use a pseudonym for a second genre if you're established enough.

Even with his commercial success, Iain Banks still had to publish as Iain M Banks for his sci-fi.

Publishers, booksellers, readers, appear to want a sense of consistency.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top