"Reef" (1st part of 1st scene, 1000 words)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Victoria Silverwolf

Vegetarian Werewolf
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
9,746
Location
Chattanooga, Tennessee, USA
[Here is the first part of the opening scene of a work in progress. I am aware that it ends suddenly, but I did not want to violate the guidelines for the length of an excerpt to be critiqued. The entire opening scene is about 1800 words; I'll post the second half after I get some feedback on this part.]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

REEF

Like a ghostly pearl larger than a human head, the holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of Curiosity's guidance chamber. Slarik lifted one massive arm above the projection. The dozens of delicate tendrils that served the Vrax as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.

"Oxygen," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Water. No life."

Sorensen moved closer to the image, careful not to stumble in the low-g conditions of the guidance chamber. He blinked in the scarlet glare of the illumination panels which simulated the light of Slarik's homeworld. The chamber was hot, dry, and full of the oddly astrigent scent of Vrax.

"As far as we can tell from here," he said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Hiroki leaned back and folded her hands. She seemed perfectly at ease working in an environment designed for hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs.

"True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock covered with empty seas. Common enough, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. That's a mystery."

Thrin shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly turning image. Anxiety? Excitement? It was difficult to tell.

"Probes wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at the grammatical confusion of his companion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple cases for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of Standard Simplified European might suggest.

"Bad," Slarik noted. "Much cost, little return." It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain.

Sorensen didn't understand all the intricacies of Vrax sociology, with its mixture of clan loyalty, religious faith, and rigid code of business ethics. It was obvious, however, that Slarik seriously disapproved of throwing good money after idle speculation.

Curiosity was a typical scout ship, designed to do a quick survey of a solar system after emerging from the disorienting chaos of flatspace. Carrying fully equiped probes would have been a foolish luxury, given the scarcity of planets that were more than stone or gas.

"So we go down and take a look." Hiroki passed her hand through the ghostly image. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds. She smiled slightly, as if daring the planet to hide its secrets from her.

"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the chamber without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. "Promising. Dangerous." Instead of simply walking backwards out of the chamber, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image -- a challenging task for a six-limbed creature twice as heavy as a human. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Hiroki left the chamber, walking briskly toward her station. Sorensen wondered why a experienced flatspace navigator had chosen to work aboard a small scout ship, when her skills would have been welcomed anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a sense of adventure, the willingness to wait years for a discovery that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

We are all aliens to each other. Sorensen made his way to his own station. He welcomed the change of light from blazing red to the cool yellow-white of Earth. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's familiar voice -- somehow gentler than Slarik's -- seemed to be coming from all around. Sorenson thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Jen?" The playfulness in Hiroki's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole planet seems to be nothing but one big beach. Shallow oceans and countless tiny islands."

"Wet," Slarik said. "Like Earth."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light of Epsilon Eridani, a shade more orange than the light of Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Clouds hid much of the planet from view. Beneath them he could see flocks of islands scattered throughout the sparkling water. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

A giant hand smashed into Curiosity. Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bit deeply.

"Who is harmed?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Hiroki, report."

'I'm here," she said weakly. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."
 
Forgive the pickyness

Here goes :-

[Here is the first part of the opening scene of a work in progress. I am aware that it ends suddenly, but I did not want to violate the guidelines for the length of an excerpt to be critiqued. The entire opening scene is about 1800 words; I'll post the second half after I get some feedback on this part.]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The impression from early on is that they arte looing at Earth (I may be wrong but that's how it comes across to me). Sorenson and his obvious none Vraxinan description, sounds too English to be anything other than from Earth and this jars a bit: especially as an opening.

REEF

Like a ghostly pearl larger than a human head, the holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of Curiosity's guidance chamber. Slarik lifted one massive arm above the projection. The dozens of delicate tendrils that served the Vrax as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.

"Oxygen," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Water. No life."

Sorensen moved closer to the image, careful not to stumble in the low-g conditions of the guidance chamber. He blinked in the scarlet glare of the illumination panels which simulated the light of Slarik's homeworld. The chamber was hot, dry, and full of the oddly astrigent scent of Vrax.

"As far as we can tell from here," he said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Hiroki leaned back and folded her hands. She seemed perfectly at ease working in an environment designed for hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs.

"True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock covered with empty seas. Common enough, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. That's a mystery."

Thrin shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly turning image. Anxiety? Excitement? It was difficult to tell.

"Probes wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at the grammatical confusion of his companion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple cases for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of Standard Simplified European might suggest. (Again this causes confusion - If this isn't Earth then the Earthlings would be very interested in the place. Since the Vrax are obvioulsy joint venturers in this craft they would sure recognise the potential of the place as an asset.)

"Bad," Slarik noted. "Much cost, little return." It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain.

Sorensen didn't understand all the intricacies of Vrax sociology, with its mixture of clan loyalty, religious faith, and rigid code of business ethics. It was obvious, however, that Slarik seriously disapproved of throwing good money after idle speculation.

Curiosity was a typical scout ship, designed to do a quick survey of a solar system after emerging from the disorienting chaos of flatspace. (nice concept. It tells us that there is a 'ftl' space and we can fill in the gaps. I wish I had thought of it. Excellent) Carrying fully equiped probes would have been a foolish luxury, (however this makes no sense- a specially designed survey ship with no surveying equipement??) given the scarcity of planets that were more than stone or gas.

"So we go down and take a look." Hiroki passed her hand through the ghostly image. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds. She smiled slightly, as if daring the planet to hide its secrets from her. (jars again - they've just decided that there was no point in doing anything with this waste of space so why expend effort confirming it - You need to give a reason say the possibility of some rare "only found on Oxygen infested planets" stuff that the Vrax need)

Sorry I'm called away (Mrs Tein). If you wish I will return to do the rest.

"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the chamber without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. "Promising. Dangerous." Instead of simply walking backwards out of the chamber, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image -- a challenging task for a six-limbed creature twice as heavy as a human. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Hiroki left the chamber, walking briskly toward her station. Sorensen wondered why a experienced flatspace navigator had chosen to work aboard a small scout ship, when her skills would have been welcomed anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a sense of adventure, the willingness to wait years for a discovery that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

We are all aliens to each other. Sorensen made his way to his own station. He welcomed the change of light from blazing red to the cool yellow-white of Earth. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's familiar voice -- somehow gentler than Slarik's -- seemed to be coming from all around. Sorenson thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Jen?" The playfulness in Hiroki's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole planet seems to be nothing but one big beach. Shallow oceans and countless tiny islands."

"Wet," Slarik said. "Like Earth."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light of Epsilon Eridani, a shade more orange than the light of Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Clouds hid much of the planet from view. Beneath them he could see flocks of islands scattered throughout the sparkling water. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

A giant hand smashed into Curiosity. Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bit deeply.

"Who is harmed?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Hiroki, report."

'I'm here," she said weakly. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."


Sorry I had to stop early.

Hope I helped.

TEiN
 
REEF

Like a ghostly pearl larger than a human headas a first line, I don't like the image. I can't really say why, except it makes me wonder if there weren't better descriptors. It also doesn't ground me in a pov, as I'm not sure if its a human - why would they think of it as a human head, and not just a head - or an alien?, the holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of Curiosity's guidance chamber. Slarik lifted one massive arm above the projection. The dozens of delicate tendrils that served the Vrax as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.But I like the last line.

"Oxygen," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Water. No life."

Sorensen moved closer to the image, careful not to stumble in the low-g conditions of the guidance chamber. He blinked in the scarlet glare of the illumination panels which simulated the light of Slarik's homeworld. The chamber was hot, dry, and full of the oddly astrigent scent of Vrax.

"As far as we can tell from here," he said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Hiroki leaned back and folded her hands. She seemed perfectly at ease working in an environment designed for hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaursThis confused me. If she is one of the centaurs, why mention it? If she isn't, who is? Sorenson? Some other alien we haven't met?

"True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock covered with empty seas. Common enough, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. That's a mystery."

Thrin shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly turning image. Anxiety? Excitement? It was difficult to tell.

"Probes wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at the grammatical confusion of his companion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple cases for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of Standard Simplified European might suggest.

"Bad," Slarik noted. "Much cost, little return." It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain.

Sorensen didn't understand all the intricacies of Vrax sociology, with its mixture of clan loyalty, religious faith, and rigid code of business ethics. It was obvious, however, that Slarik seriously disapproved of throwing good money after idle speculation.

Curiosity was a typical scout ship, designed to do a quick survey of a solar system after emerging from the disorienting chaos of flatspace. Carrying fully equiped probes would have been a foolish luxury, given the scarcity of planets that were more than stone or gas.Hmm, here I'm a bit lost. Firstly, aren't they looking for planets that are worth exploring, so surely the equipment should have been brought? Otherwise why the expense of a space ship?

"So we go down and take a look."should this be a question, since he indicated above that he wasn't sure. Hiroki passed her hand through the ghostly image. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds. She smiled slightly, as if daring the planet to hide its secrets from her.

"Agreed."He gave in pretty easily. Slarik backed out of the chamber without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.So, then why back down? I'm getting really confused, sorry. It might be caffeine requirement.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. "Promising. Dangerous." Instead of simply walking backwards out of the chamber, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image -- a challenging task for a six-limbed creature twice as heavy as a humannice. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"Theywho? don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Hiroki left the chamber, walking briskly toward her station. Sorensen wondered why a experienced flatspace navigator had chosen to work aboard a small scout ship, when her skills would have been welcomed anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a sense of adventure, the willingness to wait years for a discovery that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

We are all aliens to each other. Sorensen made his way to his own station. He welcomed the change of light from blazing red to the cool yellow-white of Earth. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was confortingcomforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's familiar voice -- somehow gentler than Slarik's -- seemed to be coming from all around. Sorenson thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Jen?" The playfulness in Hiroki's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole planet seems to be nothing but one big beach. Shallow oceans and countless tiny islands."

"Wet," Slarik said. "Like Earth."

Sorensen watched the planet approachnot sure about this. the planet isn't approaching, they are? on his viewscreen. The light of Epsilon Eridaniis this the planet, if so wasn't it unnamed before., a shade more orange than the light of Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Clouds hid much of the planet from view. Beneath them - drop? he could see flocks of islands scattered throughout the sparkling water. Could this truly be a world which had never lived? So, there are clouds, yet they can see the islands, and they've been able to make a pretty detailed assessment from space?

The image suddenly seemed - this reads a little week, the adverb followed by the veil, how about the image blurred? It's a little more active and just as immediate? to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

A giant hand smashed into Curiosity. Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bit deeply.

"Who is harmed?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Hiroki, report."

'I'm here," she said weakly. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."[/QUOTE]

In general, I liked it. I enjoyed the concept. Inconsistencies, like the clouds against the detailled observations, kept pulling me out. I also couldn't understand, at first, why I wasn't fully engaged, and I think (not that I'm an expert, it's one of my weaknesses) that it is too passive. There are a lot of seems, a fair few adverbs, some felts and it's all removing me from the action and making it feel a little slower than I think it actually is. (I'm not sure that made any sense, sorry.)

But overall, I'm intrigued. I'd read on for a bit.
 
[Here is the first part of the opening scene of a work in progress. I am aware that it ends suddenly, Not necessarily a problem, unless you are worried about the plot-line but I did not want to violate the guidelines for the length of an excerpt to be critiqued. The entire opening scene is about 1800 words; I'll post the second half after I get some feedback on this part.]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

REEF

Like a ghostly pearl larger than a human head, Not a terrible simile, but not great either the holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of Curiosity's guidance chamber. Slarik lifted one massive arm above the projection. The dozens of delicate tendrils that served the Vrax as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.

"Oxygen," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Water. No life."

Sorensen moved closer to the image, careful not to stumble in the low-g conditions of the guidance chamber. He blinked in the scarlet glare of the illumination panels which simulated the light of Slarik's homeworld. The chamber was hot, dry, and full of the oddly astrigent scent of Vrax.
Obviously a human character here
"As far as we can tell from here," he said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Hiroki leaned back and folded her hands. She seemed perfectly at ease working in an environment designed for hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs. Now I'm starting to feel unsure. Is this a 3rd race? Are the HPRC actually present, or did they just build the ship? Have we just met one of the HPRC in para 1?

"True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock covered with empty seas. Common enough, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. That's a mystery." Human English diction

Thrin shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly turning image. Anxiety? Excitement? It was difficult to tell.

"Probes wished for," it said. Obviously a alien - fine

Sorensen tried not to smile at the grammatical confusion of his companion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple cases for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of Standard Simplified European might suggest.

"Bad," Slarik noted. "Much cost, little return." It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain. I've forgotten which race this speaker is already

Sorensen didn't understand all the intricacies of Vrax sociology, with its mixture of clan loyalty, religious faith, and rigid code of business ethics. It was obvious, however, that Slarik seriously disapproved of throwing good money after idle speculation. I've forgotten already what the Vrax look like

Curiosity was a typical scout ship, designed to do a quick survey of a solar system after emerging from the disorienting chaos of flatspace. Carrying fully equiped probes would have been a foolish luxury, Sending a multi-racial scout ship around interstellar space comes under a different budget? given the scarcity of planets that were more than stone or gas.

"So we go down and take a look." Hiroki passed her hand through the ghostly image. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds. She smiled slightly, as if daring the planet to hide its secrets from her.

"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the chamber without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. "Promising. Dangerous." Instead of simply walking backwards out of the chamber, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image -- a challenging task for a six-limbed creature twice as heavy as a human. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.
Good
"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Hiroki left the chamber, walking briskly toward her station. Sorensen wondered why a experienced flatspace navigator had chosen to work aboard a small scout ship, when her skills would have been welcomed anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a sense of adventure, the willingness to wait years for a discovery that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly. good

We are all aliens to each other. Sorensen made his way to his own station. He welcomed the change of light from blazing red to the cool yellow-white of Earth. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends. Good

"Approach begins." Thrin's familiar voice -- somehow gentler than Slarik's -- seemed to be coming from all around. Sorenson thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Jen?" The playfulness in Hiroki's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole planet seems to be nothing but one big beach. Shallow oceans and countless tiny islands."

"Wet," Slarik said. "Like Earth."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light of Epsilon Eridani, I'm sure this is a star known to us today, but other readers may not know that. a shade more orange than the light of Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Clouds hid much of the planet from view. Beneath them he could see flocks of islands scattered throughout the sparkling water. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

A giant hand smashed into Curiosity. Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bit deeply.

"Who is harmed?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Hiroki, report."
The ship appears to have collided with something far above the surface that wasn't supposed to be there, but clearly not at re-entry speed, otherwise they'd all be in small bits.
'I'm here," she said weakly. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."

I should perhaps declare a certain ennui with interstellar space fiction - after a few moonwalks and forty years of nothing it seems like a bad joke. Also, earlier this year I saw the Japanese anime "Bodacious Space Pirates" which with its ultra-modern depiction of space warfare as a form of cyber-hacking, underlined just how old-fashioned a lot of SF is.
Here, it seems illogical that they don't want to expend probes to explore the planet, but are willing to take their spacecraft down to its surface, which looks like a more expensive and riskier operation. (To put this in context, with our y2012 technology, we could land a sensor probe on an earth-sized planet, but we definitely can't land a manned spacecraft on an earth-sized world and get it off again, because we cannot yet store and deploy the amount of energy that would be required.) Can you imagine what far-future probes might be like, given we already have ones that drive around, take video and dig up and test samples? They'd be fantastic.
In this piece I lost track of how many different races were present (four?) - there seemed to be too many descriptions and unfamiliar names presented in rapid succession.
Apart from that, it reads quite well, and it's fairly clear what is going on.
Overall, not bad.
 
What keeps tripping me up in this piece are the constant attempts to throw in explanations and unnecessary descriptions.

It makes the piece read not as a natural POV (which appears to be Sorensen's) but instead A Series Of Explanations For The Benefit Of The Reader.

I think the standard practice would be to mention Slavik and only mention aspects relating to his being and race in passing, or until necessary. For example, when looking at the planet, would Sorensen's first natural reaction be to consider the nature of Vrax physiology, use of language, and sociology? Save such details for when necessary, as otherwise all you are doing is distracting from what you have already set out to be your focus at the beginning - the nature of the planet, and the events that follow.

I think once you stop trying to explain everything for the benefit of the reader, and simply immerse us in the POV experience, the piece will read as a much stronger start.

Just my 2c.
 
What keeps tripping me up in this piece are the constant attempts to throw in explanations and unnecessary descriptions.

It makes the piece read not as a natural POV (which appears to be Sorensen's) but instead A Series Of Explanations For The Benefit Of The Reader.


Just my 2c.

I agree with Brian. I think that the writing has a lot of great potential if you cut some of the unnecessary words. Below I make a few nit-pick edits that may help... or not. Please take it with a grain of salt... opinion and all that.:eek:



[Like a ghostly]delete A pearl [larger than a human head, the holographic image of the unnamed planet]delete floated in the middle of [Curiosity's] THE guidance chamber[.] ; a ghostly… holographic image of the planet. Slarik lifted [one]DELETE his massive arm above the projection. [The d] Dozens of [delicate]delete tendrils [that served the Vrax as fingers] delete wriggled over the planet, [as if they could] trying to brush away its mysteries.
"Oxygen," Slarik lamented [said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like]DELETE with distant thunder in his voice, "Water. No life."
Sorensen moved closer to the image, careful not to stumble in the low-g [conditions of the guidance chamber] delete. He blinked in the scarlet glare of the illumination panels [which simulated the light of Slarik's homeworld.] delete [The] he felt the chamber [was]delete hot[,] and dry[,]; was not exactly the same as [and full of] the oddly astrigent scent of Vrax.

"[As]delete far as we can tell from here… [," he said. "S] sensors don't tell the whole story."
Serenely, Hiroki leaned back and folded her hands; [. She seemed perfectly at ease working in an]DELETE the environment designed for [hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs.] another race didn't bother her.
"True enough, [" she said. "S] DELETE still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data [are ] is consistent with bare rock covered with empty seas. Common enough, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. [That's a mystery.]delete"
Thrin shuffled [its front legs as it] and examined the slow[ly], turning image. Anxiety? Excitement? It was difficult to tell.
"Probes wished for," it said.
Sorensen [tried not to smile] smirked at the grammatical confusion of his companion. [Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any] delete Vrax language, [most of which had] with bewildering multiple cases for past, present, and future ; was hard for a human. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their [stumbling use of Standard] DELETE Simplified European might suggest.

"Bad," Slarik noted. "Much cost, little return." It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain.
Sorensen didn't understand [all the intricacies of] DELETE Vrax sociology[,]; with its mixture of clan loyalty, religious faith, and rigid code of business ethics. [It was obvious, however, that] It's obvious Slarik [seriously] DELETE disapproved of throwing good money after idle speculation.

Curiosity, [was] a typical scout ship, [designed to do a quick survey of] surveyed [a] DELETE solar systems [after] when emerging from [the disorienting]delete chaos of flatspace. [Carrying fully equiped probes would have been a foolish luxury, g] Given the scarcity of planets [that were] DELETE more than stone or gas, they did not carry fully equipped probes.
 
Others have commented on the nitty-gritty, so I'll add only one thing to that. I didn't know if the "giant hand" was a metaphor or literal.

Overall, it's very good but I think you're introducing too diverse a cast too early. Like others, I lost track of who was who and who was what. It may be better to just state they're all from different species early on, and then introduce their characteristics in separate scenes.

But in general, I could see myself reading more of this. Good job.
 
I really like this and welcome the explanations. I don't see the planet as Earth, nor Hiroki as anything other than human. Just a few minor points.

Like a ghostly pearl [larger than a human head] delete - surely they are used to seeing planets onscreen, where size depends on magnification, the holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of }Curiosity's guidance chamber. Slarik lifted one massive arm above the projection. The dozens of delicate tendrils that served the Vrax as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.

"Oxygen," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Water. No life."

Sorensen moved closer to the image, careful not to stumble in the low-g conditions of the guidance chamber. He blinked in the scarlet glare of the illumination panels which simulated the light of Slarik's homeworld. The chamber was hot, dry, and full of the oddly astrigent scent of Vrax.

"As far as we can tell from here," he said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Hiroki leaned back and folded her hands. She seemed perfectly at ease working in an environment designed for hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs.

"True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock covered with empty seas. Common enough, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. That's a mystery."

Thrin shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly turning image. Anxiety? Excitement? It was difficult to tell.

"Probes wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at the grammatical confusion of his companion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple cases for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of Standard Simplified European might suggest.

"Bad," Slarik noted. "Much cost, little return." It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain.

Sorensen didn't understand all the intricacies of Vrax sociology, with its mixture of clan loyalty, religious faith, and rigid code of business ethics. It was obvious, however, that Slarik seriously disapproved of throwing good money after idle speculation.

Curiosity was a typical scout ship, designed to do a quick survey of a solar system after emerging from the disorienting chaos of flatspace. Carrying fully equiped probes would have been a foolish luxury, given the scarcity of planets that were more than stone or gas.

"So we go down and take a look." I agree this doesn't make sense, probes ought to be a cheaper and safer option than a "manned" landing Hiroki passed her hand through the ghostly image. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds. She smiled slightly, as if daring the planet to hide its secrets from her.

"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the chamber without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. "Promising. Dangerous." [Instead of simply walking backwards out of the chamber, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image -- a challenging task for a six-limbed creature twice as heavy as a human.] I would have thought a pseudo-reptilian centaur would find it easier to turn round than walk backwards. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Hiroki left the chamber, walking briskly toward her station. Sorensen wondered why a experienced flatspace navigator had chosen to work aboard a small scout ship, when her skills would have been welcomed anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a sense of adventure, the willingness to wait years for a discovery that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

We are all aliens to each other. Sorensen made his way to his own station. He welcomed the change of light from blazing red to the cool yellow-white of Earth. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's familiar voice -- somehow gentler than Slarik's -- seemed to be coming from all around. Sorenson thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Jen?" The playfulness in Hiroki's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole planet seems to be nothing but one big beach. Shallow oceans and countless tiny islands."

"Wet," Slarik said. "Like Earth."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light of Epsilon Eridani, a shade more orange than the light of Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Clouds hid much of the planet from view. Beneath them he could see flocks of islands scattered throughout the sparkling water. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

It was as if a giant hand had smashed into Curiosity. Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bit deeply.

"Who is harmed?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Hiroki, report."

'I'm here," she said weakly. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."
 
Hi Victoria
This is my sort of thing. I like this. I liked the first sentence as a hook, and it went on from there. Only a few small things to pick up on. They're just my take on it, though, so please take them with a pinch of salt.

Like a ghostly pearl larger than a human head, the holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of Curiosity's guidance chamber.

I liked this first sentence, but it did clunk slightly. It was the comparison with the human head. I wonder if something like this would work for you:
Like a huge ghostly pearl, the holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of Curiosity's guidance chamber.
If you wanted to work in the exact size, perhaps later on would work.

*​

The phrase 'Standard Simplified European' didn't quite ring true for me. Sorry. If languages coalesce, as has happened in the past and probably will in the future, I wonder if it would simply be a European language. Considering the numbers, I suspect it would include a wider spectrum.

Perhaps, though, it could be solved by giving the language a simple, possibly one word, name. With a name that trips off the tongue, I'd probably think less about the meanings - cf. horseless carriage and car

*​
A giant hand smashed into Curiosity.
I like this, but it did read quite literally, rather than as a metaphor, which is what I thought it was.


Definitely something I'd like to read more of. Please keep on with it. :)
 
Hi Victoria. This is an interesting piece and I found myself hooked on the concept of the planet being the Vrax homeworld yet clearly something strange has happened to it. But unfortunately I found the first half too distanced. You need to get us right into Sorensen's head in the first paragraph, otherwise people are going to get confused and think the PoV is from Slarik instead - which makes for a whole lot more confusion as you can see from the comments I made until I figured out that the PoV was from the human captain, Sorensen. Like thinking the ship was a Vrax vessel, and wondering at the use of 'it'.

REEF

Like a ghostly pearl larger than a human head, the holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of Curiosity's -Interesting name for an alien ship. I wonder if the name is a bit too human though? Considering the name of their species is hardly human-like- guidance chamber. Slarik lifted one massive arm above the projection. The dozens of delicate tendrils that served the Vrax as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries. -I wonder about this last sentence. It might just be me, but I'm kind of looking for the possessive here that makes the reader know they are Slarik's tendrils-

"Oxygen," Slarik said. Its -Would they really refer to themselves as 'It'? Do they not have genders?- voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Water. No life." -Seems strange to have a planet with oxygen and water yet no life at all. Not even animals?-

Sorensen moved closer to the image, careful not to stumble in the low-g conditions of the guidance chamber. -Don't really need to repeat the mention of guidance chamber. We know where they are- He blinked in the scarlet glare of the illumination panels which simulated the light of Slarik's homeworld. -Homeworld? I thought it was an unknown planet? But at least I'm very curious now to know what happened to all the life if it is supposed to be his home. Good hook- The chamber was hot, dry, and full of the oddly -Would it really be odd to them? I'd have thought the smell would be normal?- astrigent scent of Vrax.

"As far as we can tell from here," he said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Hiroki leaned back and folded her hands. She seemed perfectly at ease working in an environment designed for hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs. -Starting to add so many characters here, yet we haven't seen a thought from any of them yet. Unless it's omncisent then we need to get into the head of one of the characters right in the first paragraph. I'd assumed it was Slarik but now wonder if it is supposed to be Hiroki, which would explain the use of It instead of gender for the Vrax, but the seemed is only used when not in a character's head, so I'm confused here about PoV-

"True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are is consistent with bare rock covered with by empty seas. Common enough, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. That's a mystery." -Some little grammar issues there I think-

Thrin shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly turning image. Anxiety? Excitement? It was difficult to tell. -So many different characters just being thrown at us unexpectedly without any prior knowledge to how many could possibly be in the room. Perhaps at the beginning of the scene get right into a characters head and reference the different people around them?-

"Probes wished for," it said. -Don't understand this dialogue. The use of it again; not natural unless the PoV is from that of a human character-

Sorensen tried not to smile at the grammatical confusion of his companion. -Oh, ic. No wonder I didn't understand it, because that was deliberate- Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple cases for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of Standard Simplified European might suggest. -This is the first glimpse inside a character's head by implying Sorensen is narrating the mini info-dump. If we are seeing everything from Sorensen's PoV then he/she needs to be the first character we are introduced to, and we need to see some of his/her thoughts before this point. It's too shallow-

"Bad," Slarik noted. "Much cost, little return." It touched the jeweled jewelled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain.

Sorensen didn't understand all the intricacies of Vrax sociology, with its mixture of clan loyalty, religious faith, and rigid code of business ethics. It was obvious, however, that Slarik seriously disapproved of throwing good money after idle speculation. -Now we are starting to get inside the character's head-

Curiosity was a typical scout ship, designed to do a quick survey of a solar system after emerging from the disorienting chaos of flatspace. Carrying fully equiped probes would have been a foolish luxury, given the scarcity of planets that were more than stone or gas. -But this paragraph is disjointed from Sorensen's thoughts. It's a distanced info-dump without any necessary triggers to make Sorensen think about the ship-

"So we go down and take a look." Hiroki passed her hand through the ghostly image. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds. She smiled slightly, as if daring the planet to hide its secrets from her.

"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the chamber without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of funding made the elder Vrax first among equals. -More distanced info-dumping. Need to word it from Sorensen's perspective and make it more personal voice for him-

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible for Sorensen to read. -That's a basic example of how you could make the PoV closer to Sorensen and not feel so distanced-

"Anomaly," it said. "Promising. Dangerous." Instead of simply walking backwards out of the chamber, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image -- a challenging task for a six-limbed creature twice as heavy as a human. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture. -Good, this part is closer to the PoV, replicate it elsewhere-

"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Hiroki left the chamber, walking briskly toward her station. Sorensen wondered why an experienced flatspace navigator had chosen to work aboard a small scout ship, -no comma here- when her skills would have been welcomed anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a sense of adventure, the willingness to wait years for a discovery that would could make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

We are all aliens to each other. Sorensen made his way to his own station. He welcomed the change of light from blazing red to the cool yellow-white of Earth. -Nice, this is the depth of PoV that was needed earlier- The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's familiar voice -- somehow gentler than Slarik's -- seemed to be coming from all around. Sorenson thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Jen?" -Jen? That sounds like a female name, yet you're using 'his' in the next sentence-The playfulness in Hiroki's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole planet seems to be nothing but one big beach. Shallow oceans and countless tiny islands."

"Wet," Slarik said. "Like Earth."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light of Epsilon Eridani, a shade more orange than the light of Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Clouds hid much of the planet from view. Beneath them he could see flocks of islands scattered throughout the sparkling water. Could this truly be a world which had never lived? -I don't understand how it can be a world that 'never lived' yet be Slarik's homeworld?-

The image suddenly seemed -Seemed is a bit uncertain here. If the image is blurring, Sorensen would know for sure, so there wouldn't be any 'seemed' about it. Cut the word out- started to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something's strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

A giant hand smashed into Curiosity. -Giant hand? I think this needs more description please, or to be reworded differently for the sake of clarification. I'm with everyone else on this. I didn't know if you were being literal or figurative- Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still. -If they actually crashed from the impact, then I'd expect a bit more description of what happened, otherwise it's a bit underwhelming-

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. -Why did they baffle him?- He winced as he moved out of removed his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bit deeply.

"Who is harmed?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Hiroki, report."

'I'm here," she said weakly. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."
 
Sorensen moved closer, careful not to stumble in the low-g conditions of the guidance chamber. He blinked in the scarlet glare. The chamber was hot and full of the oddly astrigent scent of Vrax.

Like a big holographic ghostly pearl larger than a human head, the a football sized holographic image of the unnamed planet floated in the middle of Curiosity's guidance chamber the room.

"Oxygen," Slarik said, lifting one massive arm above the projection. Its voice was like distant thunder. "Water. No life."

"But sensors never tell the whole story," Sorensen said.

"True," said Hiroki. She seemed perfectly at ease in an environment designed for hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs.

"Still," she said, "the evidence seems convincing."

"Bad," Slarik noted, the dozens of delicate tendrils that served the Vrax as fingers wiggling around, touching the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain.


Slarik lifted one massive arm above the projection.The dozens of delicate tendrils that served the Vrax as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.

"Oxygen," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Water. No life."

Sorensen moved closer to the image, careful not to stumble in the low-g conditions of the guidance chamber. He blinked in the scarlet glare of the illumination panels which simulated the light of Slarik's homeworld. The chamber was hot, dry, and full of the oddly astrigent scent of Vrax.

"As far as we can tell from here," he said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Hiroki leaned back and folded her hands. She seemed perfectly at ease working in an environment designed for hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs.

"True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock covered with empty seas. Common enough, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. That's a mystery."

Thrin shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly turning image. Anxiety? Excitement? It was difficult to tell.

"Probes wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at the grammatical confusion of his companion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple cases for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of Standard Simplified European might suggest.

"Bad," Slarik noted. "Much cost, little return." It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain.


Sorensen didn't understand all the intricacies of Vrax sociology. with its mixture of clan loyalty, religious faith, and rigid code of business ethics. It was obvious, however, that Slarik seriously disapproved of throwing good money after idle speculation.

"So we go down and take a look?" Hiroki passed her hand through the ghostly image. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds.

Curiosity was a typical scout ship, designed to do a quick survey of a solar system after emerging from the disorienting chaos of flatspace, and carrying only basic probes Carrying fully equiped probes would have been a foolish luxury, given the scarcity of planets that were more than stone or gas.

"So we go down and take a look." Hiroki passed her hand through the ghostly image. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds. She smiled slightly, as if daring the planet to hide its secrets from her.

"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the chamber without further discussion.

Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the The fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of funding for Curiosity's mission, made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin, the fourth member of the Curiosity's rough democracy, now continued to study the image, its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. "Promising. Dangerous." Instead of simply walking backwards out of the chamber, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image -- a challenging task for a six-limbed creature twice as heavy as a human. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"They don't fool around," heSorensen said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Hiroki left the chamber, walking briskly toward her station.

Sorensen wondered why a experienced flatspace navigator like Hiroki had chosen to work aboard a small scout ship, when her skills would have been welcomed anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia? A sense of adventure? The willingness to wait years for a discovery that would make her filthy rich? None of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

We are all aliens to each other. (No need tosay this. It's obvious by now?) Sorensen made his way to his own station. He welcomed the change of light from blazing red to the cool yellow-white of Earth, and the slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity was comforting to him, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's familiar, gentle voice -- somehow gentler than Slarik's -- seemed to be coming from all around. Sorenson thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Jen?" The playfulness in Hiroki's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole planet seems seemed to be nothing but one big beach: shallow oceans and countless tiny islands."

"Wet," Slarik said. "Like Earth."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light of Epsilon Eridani, a shade more orange than the light of Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it.

As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Clouds hid much of the planet from view. Beneath them he could see saw flocks strings of islands scattered throughout the on sparkling waters. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly now seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to it didn't seem to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, "Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

A giant hand smashed into Curiosity. Sorensen's words were cut off and his body was slammed into his restraints as a giant hand seemed to smash into Curiosity. He Sorenson felt as if he were inside a monstrous bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by jangled with monstrous sound. The ship seemed to shuddered for an endlessly moment, then stood, and then was still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bit deeply.

"Who is harmed?" Slarik's voice. seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said. "Movement difficult," Thrin said.

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Hiroki, report."

'I'm here,""Damn," she said weakly. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go to Thrin."

Red: add
Blue: cut

Sorry Victoria, for all the ink. But you're trying to cram a lot of information and four strange characters into a very compressed space here. No need to explain everything at once. Just hit the main points, then expand at leisure as you go along.


Please excuse any errors in my attempted edit. There's never enough time ...
 
Last edited:
Sorry, these paragraphs will read like nonsense without the correction ...

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. The whole planet seems seemed to be nothing but one big beach: shallow oceans and countless tiny islands.

...

A giant hand smashed into Curiosity. Sorensen's words were cut off and his body was slammed into his restraints as a giant hand seemed to smash into Curiosity. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by jangled with monstrous sound. The ship seemed to shuddered for an endlessly, moment, then stood, and then was still.

Something like that, anyway.
Thanks Victoria. And happy Christmas
:)
 
Last edited:
I liked it, it was clear to me and very interesting. I especially liked the way you obliquely noted that oxygen without life would be somewhat mysterious.

Also liked how you put a bit of character into the aliens. Many authors get all detailed about the physical oddities and forget they will have culture.

Definitely want to read more

I do share the crits about going down to look being cheaper than probes. I'd make them unworkable in some other way
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top