Moving too quickly!

Status
Not open for further replies.

allmywires

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2012
Messages
1,672
Location
London
I'm having a bit of trouble with this section. His assault on the guard feels as if it's coming too quickly, but I can't think of how to slow it down. Any thoughts?

###

'Hello?' he called out, hoping that he had a sympathetic guard on duty.
'Anyone out there? I might be willing to reconsider my opinion on what is and isn't legal in this city-'

The food flap on his cell door opened, and a voice barked, 'Shut it, deSabella, or no rations for you.'

Alberto settled back against the wall, affronted. Usually he was only chucked in here for an afternoon, a whole night at best, before being given a friendly slap on the wrists and making a promise not to be a bad boy again, which he rarely kept. Come to think of it, this was a smaller cell than he was used to, and it was a lot quieter as well: normally the yells and catcalls of other prisoners could be easily discerned, as well as the chatter of the guards, who rather enjoyed their sojourns in the Bowels from all Alberto could tell.

'Any chance you want to tell me what's going on, my lord?'

Silence from the flap. Alberto took a deep breath, knowing that this was quite possibly a bad idea, and attempted to enter the guard's mind.

He had been right. He was exhausted, and the hangover from his last foray hadn't entirely worn off; his movements were heavy and sluggish, and he could barely feel the mind outside his door, even less try and penetrate its many layers and complications. He gave up and collapsed onto his rock-hard bed, his head thumping, feeling decidedly nauseous. Closing his eyes, he tried to ward off the sickness, but his mouth was pappy from thirst and he hadn't eaten for gods knew how long.

Sitting up gingerly, his head swimming, he banged on the stone walls.

'Water!' he called.

Nothing. The churning in his head and stomach intensified, and he rested his head on his knees, concentrating on breathing.

'I need water!' he tried again. 'Perhaps I might be feeling the after-effects of some watch brutality-'

The flap snapped open. 'If you're messing with me, deSabella-'

'I promise you,' Alberto said, raising his aching head as much as his nausea would allow, 'I feel awful.'

He almost collapsed on the floor with relief when a tray of water was shoved through the flap. He drunk it too quickly, and then almost immediately threw it up; while he was still retching on his hands and knees, he heard the turn of a key in the lock, and the door opened an inch.

'deSabella?'

'Yes,' Alberto groaned, careful to keep his head down.

'Do you need a healer?'

'Do you know,' he said, bracing himself, 'I'm feeling a lot-'

He leapt to his feet, planning to jump the guard and escape; however, the sudden change of position was too much for his head, which caused stars to burst in his vision and for him to lose balance and collapse to his knees again.

'-better,' he finished weakly, as the guard rolled him over with his steel-
capped boot.

'Trying to get the jump on me, eh?' the Orian sneered. 'Right, I warned you. No rations for you. And no water for a few hours, either, for trying to trick me into believing you was sickly.'

'Brilliant,' Alberto murmured at the ceiling, as the door was locked and bolted firmly in front of him. He'd been a fool. Now he was going to pay.
 
Hmm. First of all, yay Alberto! Secondly, oooh powers.

Thirdly, yes, a little quick. I'd probably have him finish his dialogue, struggle to his feet and swing an awkward punch before the momentum did him in.
 
I'd second Mouse's suggestion, and add that I rather like the writing style.
 
I second Victoria. I didn't see it as a problem the first time, and when I re-read it, I still didn't. It conveys to me that he's impulsive and doesn't always think it through. If that's not him, it might need to be changed.
 
I third alchemist...

Maybe ( I know you didn't ask for nitpicks, but as it's a New Year, can I suggest just one?) remove these words: which he rarely kept. because he's back inside, we know that.

I liked the style, and it flows very well. Is this the opening? If it is, it's working well because I want to read more...:) Besides, if you move it slower, you lose an important characteristic of your hero. Sudden thought: do you mean the narrative is too fast or the hero moves too fast? Either way, I still say Nay. I like him already...
 
I think it's the fact that he pukes and then 'leaps' to his feet that jars with me. That's why I suggested struggle. I know I'm not very speedy after I've just chundered.
 
Leave it alone. The fact that he was too fast trying is the very reason it fails and this implies he may still get out if he tries it right later, or not. Whatever, you've revealed character and given him humanity without reducing his options. This is a really masterful hook, you've not only given the reader good reason to want more, you've pulled him into the story, most couldn't leave now if they wanted to.
 
Thanks all, glad it's got you hooked! It's not the first scene of the book but it's close enough. There's a bit before that explains how he got himself arrested.

I think it's the fact that he pukes and then 'leaps' to his feet that jars with me. That's why I suggested struggle. I know I'm not very speedy after I've just chundered.

That was my problem with it as well, funnily enough, so I've tweaked it just a bit: (very rough, so ignore any flow/sentence structure problems!)

edit: And Boneman, I realised after I'd written it that it comes across that he's faking, when he really isn't. He's just a pantser who sees a chance to escape (hopefully explained better here).


'I promise you,' Alberto said, raising his aching head as much as his nausea would allow, 'I feel awful.'

He almost collapsed on the floor with relief when a tray of water was shoved through the flap. He drunk it too quickly, and then almost immediately threw it up; while he was still retching on his hands and knees, he heard the turn of a key in the lock, and the door opened an inch.

'deSabella?'

'Yes,' Alberto groaned, careful to keep his head down.

'Do you need a healer?'

Did he? Absolutely not, there was a danger they would find out what had caused his ill humour. Especially as, much as he had come to expect, the vomiting had cleared his head well enough – though he wouldn't dare try and infiltrate anyone's mind for a day or two unless he wanted to black out and wake up in his own vomit, which in the circumstances didn't really seem worth it.

On the other hand, he could always use the situation to his advantage...

'deSabella, what's going on in there?'

There was the telltale creak of the cell door, and Alberto braced himself.

'Do you know,' he said, leaping to his feet, 'I'm feeling a lot-'

He was cut short, however, as the sudden change of position was too much for his head; stars burst in his vision and caused him to lose balance and collapse to his knees again.

'-better,' he finished weakly, as the guard rolled him over with his steel-capped boot.
 
Seems mostly fine - isn't "retch" when the stomach is empty, though? Would have thought him convincingly ill at the end so not sure why the guard doesn't notice that, but unfair treatment hardly goes down badly with the reader. :)
 
I much prefer the original. :)

I've enjoyed reading it - makes me want to know what happens next.

To make it clearer, I think you could just add something like this - but much better:

He leapt to his feet, a sudden flash of inspiration, to jump the guard and escape.
 
Seems mostly fine - isn't "retch" when the stomach is empty, though? Would have thought him convincingly ill at the end so not sure why the guard doesn't notice that, but unfair treatment hardly goes down badly with the reader. :)

I had a thread about this once, for much the same reason, and we got it down to retching was the action of being sick, whether or not you brought anything up. So you retch up vomit, or you retch up bile, or you retch up nothing. Nice. Right before brunch. :(

AMW, I liked it, I liked him. there were a couple of places where I'd have liked it a little tighter, but he moved okay for me, and I have been in that hungover place where such a movement just... isn't... possible. Not for a long time, mind, but with you being a student, I'll bow to your knowledge. :p :)
 
That was my problem with it as well, funnily enough...

edit: And Boneman, I realised after I'd written it that it comes across that he's faking, when he really isn't.

I got that. It's like we share a brain.
 
Thanks again everyone! I think it might need to be clearer what he's planning, just a little indicator as crystal haven suggested, I reckon I'll work that in.

I had a thread about this once, for much the same reason, and we got it down to retching was the action of being sick, whether or not you brought anything up. So you retch up vomit, or you retch up bile, or you retch up nothing. Nice. Right before brunch. :(

Yeah, that was my impression as well. Unfortunately I've just had my lunch...

I have been in that hungover place where such a movement just... isn't... possible. Not for a long time, mind, but with you being a student, I'll bow to your knowledge. :p :)

It has its uses. :p

I got that. It's like we share a brain.

:cool:
 
Late this party, I know, but. I like both of them. The first did not seem rushed and was nice and pacey (for want of a less circumspect word)... but what made me stop for a bit was:-

Absolutely not, there was a danger they would find out what had caused his ill humour.

When humour is used in the sense of mood (as opposed to sense of humour) is it not spelt 'humor'? I looked it up but can only find an American version so the 'u' is naturally dropped anyway.

pH
 
Not sure - when I Googled it, it came up as the English way of spelling. Thanks for the feedback :)
 
I always thought the four humours were spelt the same way as the comedy concept.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top