"Reef" (rewritten opening)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Victoria Silverwolf

Vegetarian Werewolf
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
9,698
Location
Chattanooga, Tennessee, USA
[Many thanks to those of you kind enough to do so much hard work helping me with this story. I have tried to improve the most obvious flaws with the first version of the opening scene. In particular, I have tried to stay with one viewpoint character; I have removed confusing metaphors; I have removed the plot hole almost everyone pointed out; and I have have tried to make it it clearer who the characters are. I hope this is a little better.]

[P.S. Please disregard the strange change in typeface shown below. I don't how I messed this up, or how to correct it.]

_____________________________________________________________

Niels Sorensen entered Curiosity's control center as quietly as possible. The three other crew members stood around a holographic image of the unnamed planet the ship orbited. Scattered clouds floated over countless small islands. The planet's ocean was a deep, inviting blue.

Akimi Haruna lifted a hand in greeting. "Nice of you to join us." A quick wink took some of the sting out of her words, but Sorensen felt himself blushing. It wasn't always easy being the newcomer aboard a small scout ship.

"I was using the cycler when I got your message." Sorensen moved closer to the image. It looked like a ghostly pearl half a meter in diameter. "What have we got here?"

Haruna stood between the two Vrax aboard Curiosity. She seemed perfectly at ease working with hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs twice her mass. One of the Vrax -- Sorensen thought it was Slarik, the elder of the two -- lifted a massive arm over the projection. Dozens of the long, delicate tendrils that served it as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.

"Water," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Oxygen. No life."

"As far as we can tell from here," Sorensen said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Haruna leaned forward a bit and folded her hands together. She was tall and slender, and the gesture reminded Sorensen of a long-limbed water bird seeking its prey. "True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock and empty oceans. Not uncommon, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. Without something similar to photosynthesis, that's a puzzle."

Thrin, the other Vrax aboard , shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly spinning image. It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain. Anxiety? Excitement? It was impossible to tell. "More information wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at Thrin's grammatical confusion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple tenses for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of human speech might suggest.
 
"So we go down and take a look." Haruna waved a hand through the hologram. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds.


"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the control center without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of the funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. " Promising. Dangerous." Instead of walking backwards like Slarik, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Haruna left the control center, walking briskly toward her station. Once again Sorensen wondered why she had chosen to work aboard a scout ship, when she had the skills to be valued as a flatspace navigator anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a youthful sense of adventure, the willingness to waste years for the chance to make one of the rare discoveries that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

Sorensen made his way to his own station. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's voice, somehow gentler than Slarik's, seemed to be coming from everywhere. Sorensen thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Niles?" The playfulness in Haruna's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole place seems to be nothing but one big beach."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light from its primary, a shade more orange than Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints, as if a giant hand had grabbed Curiosity. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous church bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bitten deeply.

"Who survives?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said weakly. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Haruna, report."

'I'm here," she said. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."


 
Hi, Victoria. The PoV is much better with this rewrite. We get who's head it is in from the very first paragraph and it sticks all the way. Good work! The issues which confused me about the ship and planet appear to be taken care of as well, which is good.

I'm wondering though how exactly his screens got damaged? Physically? And if so, how? Or were they just not operating properly, like lose connections/wiring or something?

I also wondered why he was sneaking into the room quietly. There didn't seem to be a logical reason for bothering to do so since she sees him anyway.


Overall, much improved.
 
Much better and it shows off the quality of your writing well. A couple of quick points.

_____________________________________________________________

Niels Sorensen entered Curiosity's control center as quietly as possible. The three other crew members stood around a holographic image of the unnamed planet the ship orbited I know we try to avoid continuous verbs, but I think you should change one or both verbs here, especially the second, to "...ship was orbiting". Scattered clouds floated over countless small islands. The planet's ocean was a deep, inviting blue.

Akimi Haruna lifted a hand in greeting. "Nice of you to join us." A quick wink took some of the sting out of her words, but Sorensen felt himself blushing. It wasn't always easy being the newcomer aboard a small scout ship.

"I was using the cycler when I got your message." Sorensen moved closer to the image. It looked like a ghostly pearl half a meter in diameter. "What have we got here?"

Haruna stood between the two Vrax aboard Curiosity. She seemed perfectly at ease working with hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs twice her mass. One of the Vrax -- Sorensen thought it was Slarik, the elder of the two not needed-- lifted a massive arm over the projection. Dozens of the long, delicate tendrils that served it as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries nice.

"Water," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Oxygen. No life."

"As far as we can tell from here," Sorensen said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Haruna leaned forward a bit and folded her hands together. She was tall and slender, and the gesture reminded Sorensen of a long-limbed water bird seeking its prey. "True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock and empty oceans. Not uncommon, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. Without something similar to photosynthesis, that's a puzzle."

Thrin, the other Vrax aboard not needed, shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly spinning image. It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain. Anxiety? Excitement? It was impossible to tell. "More information wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at Thrin's grammatical confusion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple tenses for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of human speech might suggest.
 
"So we go down and take a look." Haruna waved a hand through the hologram. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds.


"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the control center without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of the funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. " Promising. Dangerous." Instead of walking backwards like Slarik, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Haruna left the control center, walking briskly toward her station. Once again Sorensen wondered why she had chosen to work aboard a scout ship, when she had the skills to be valued as a flatspace navigator anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a youthful sense of adventure, the willingness to waste years for the chance to make one of the rare discoveries that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

Sorensen made his way to his own station. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's voice, somehow gentler than Slarik's, seemed to be coming from everywhere. Sorensen thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Niles?" The playfulness in Haruna's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole place seems to be nothing but one big beach."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light from its primary, a shade more orange than Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints, as if a giant hand had grabbed Curiosity. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous church bell, the first simile in this para is fine but two stands out a little too much. You also used one just before this paragraph swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment "moment" suggests it's very short-lived, but given the damage and injuries, I think you want to suggest it goes on for longer , then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bitten deeply.

"Who survives?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said weakly. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Haruna, report."

'I'm here," she said. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."



But, very good. You dealt with the previous issues effectively.
 

Niels Sorensen entered Curiosity's control center as quietly as possible. The three other crew members stood around a holographic image of the unnamed planet the ship orbited. Scattered clouds floated over countless small islands. The planet's ocean was a deep, inviting blue.

Akimi Haruna lifted a hand in greeting. "Nice of you to join us." A quick wink took some of the sting out of her words, but Sorensen felt himself blushing. It wasn't always easy being the newcomer aboard a small scout ship.
Please read carefully the two paragraphs as in the first one you introduce Mister Sorensen as the main PoV, but as soon as you get to the second, you do an immediate jump from Niels to Akima. So I would recommend you to rewrite the highlighted sentences from Niels perspective.
"I was using the cycler when I got your message." Sorensen moved closer to the image. It looked like a ghostly pearl half a meter in diameter. "What have we got here?"
I know few who like their last name more then their first names, so for the sake of the clarity I would recommend you to stick with Niels. But I'd also advice you to stick to your guns and tell me to sod off, because this is your prose and you made the decision to stick with the last name.
His eyes locked first to Haruna, who stood between the two Vrax aboard Curiosity. She seemed perfectly at ease working with hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs twice her mass. One of the Vrax -- Sorensen thought it was Slarik, the elder of the two -- lifted a massive arm over the projection. Dozens of the long, delicate tendrils that served it as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.
There is not much that you'll need to do to zoom in. So look what I did and try to apply it in your own writing as much as possible.
"Water," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Oxygen. No life."

"As far as we can tell from here," Sorensen said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Haruna leaned forward a bit and folded her hands together. She was tall and slender, and the gesture reminded Sorensen of a long-limbed water bird seeking its prey. "True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data are consistent with bare rock and empty oceans. Not uncommon, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. Without something similar to photosynthesis, that's a puzzle."
The highlighted bit breaks the flow. I'd advice rewriting it or chopping it off completely.
Thrin, the other Vrax aboard, shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly spinning image. It touched the jewelled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain. Anxiety? Excitement? It was impossible to tell. "More information wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at Thrin's grammatical confusion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple tenses for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of human speech might suggest.
You are distancing yourself from the MC in these two paragraph when you should try your best to get closer. Try using HE instead of Sorensen and see if it gives alters the perspective.
"So we go down and take a look." Haruna waved a hand through the hologram. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds.

"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the control center without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of the funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. " Promising. Dangerous." Instead of walking backwards like Slarik, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Haruna left the control center, walking briskly toward her station. Once again Sorensen wondered why she had chosen to work aboard a scout ship, when she had the skills to be valued as a flatspace navigator anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a youthful sense of adventure, the willingness to waste years for the chance to make one of the rare discoveries that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.
A slight shift in the PoV.
Sorensen made his way to his own station. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was conforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's voice, somehow gentler than Slarik's, seemed to be coming from everywhere. Sorensen thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Niles?" The playfulness in Haruna's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole place seems to be nothing but one big beach."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light from its primary, a shade more orange than Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints, as if a giant hand had grabbed Curiosity. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous church bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bitten deeply.

There a slight jump in time between last two paras. Let your inner narrator to dictate the flow as you don't need to write much to get it perfect.
"Who survives?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said weakly. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Haruna, report."

'I'm here," she said. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."
This is very engaging piece, and it intrigues me as you don't try to dictate the prose from technology prespective, but you rather try to use drama and tension as much as you can. But I'd like it better if it would come from slightly closer perspective.
 
I think it's well-written and reads very well. A couple of random thoughts:

Personally, I disagree with some of the points about POV. Just because a sentence begins with someone else doing something, we're not leaving Sorensen's POV, especially since when Haruna does something, it is often quickly followed by Sorensen's thoughts on what she has just done. I should add that I am not as strict as a reader on POV as others, but I don't think it's moving much here.

Technically, English has a range of confusing tenses for past, present and future (future present, pluperfect etc) so I think I'd find another way to express this.

But I liked it. It made me think of Banks and Mass Effect.
 
Very, very good. I was wondering about how you would handle the probes question and I'd really not noticed that the early statement 'Sensors don't tell the whole story' actually already had, so you could just drop them entirely.

I'd actually put one of your earlier statements, where you mention how one or another of the alien's cultures involves "strict business ethics" et al back in. So few of these stories involve any mention of alien cultures at all and it lends a great deal of versimilitude IMO. OTOH this is tighter and smoother, as has been said, so maybe you could save that for later.

The only crit I can see now is that after what is obviously a big disturbance everybody reports on their own condition, but nobody says one word about the ship. And the first to report on that should be Sorensen, if his screens are damaged, as they relate directly to their survival.
 
Last edited:
Like the others, I thought this very good and much better than the first draft (which I don't think I commented on, sorry). Just some nitpicks.

Haruna stood between the two Vrax aboard Curiosity[We know they're aboard Curiosity, so you don't need to tell us again, and it reads as though you're at pains to point out that they're not the only two Vrax in existence, which I found a bit distracting.]. She seemed perfectly at ease working with hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs twice her mass. One of the Vrax -- Sorensen thought it was Slarik, the elder of the two -- lifted a massive arm over the projection. Dozens of the long, delicate tendrils that served it as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.

Thrin, the other Vrax aboard [see above], shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly spinning image. It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain. Anxiety? Excitement? It was impossible to tell. "More information wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at Thrin's grammatical confusion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple tenses for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of human speech might suggest.[This feels rather patronising, but keep it in if it's in his character]

Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints, as if a giant hand had grabbed Curiosity. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous church bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. [This reads like the narrator's choice of simile, not Sorensen's, especially in such a stressed situation. Depends how close you want his POV]The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.


That's all. Good stuff.
 


Yup, much better. Couple words here and there maybe make it read a tad easier.

Niels Sorensen entered Curiosity's control center as quietly as possible. The three other crew members stood around a holographic image of the unnamed planet the ship currently orbited. Scattered clouds floated over countless small islands. The planet's ocean was a deep, inviting blue.

Akimi Haruna lifted a hand in greeting. "Nice of you to join us." A quick wink took some of the sting out of her words, but Sorensen felt himself blushing. It wasn't always easy being the newcomer aboard a small scout ship.


"I was using the cycler when I got your message." Sorensen moved closer to the image of the planet. It looked like a ghostly pearl half a meter in diameter. "What have we got here?"

Haruna stood between the two Vrax. (aboard Curiosity) She seemed perfectly at ease working with hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs twice her mass. One of the Vrax - Sorensen thought it was Slarik, the elder of the two - lifted a massive arm over the projection. Dozens of the long, delicate tendrils that served it as fingers wriggled over the image, as if they could brush away its mysteries.
 
You've done a good job of revising this - much better and clearer all round.
However I hope you explain at some point how the ship "stood still" when it is apparently still outside the planet's atmosphere and moving over the surface at near-orbital speed.
 
I haven't had much practice giving critiques to other people's writings, but I'll give it a try.

First, I found it interesting and I want to know what happens, and why the planet has no life and why they crashed.

I felt like you did a good job keeping the scene in Sorensen's PoV. However, there were a few things that came to mind as I was reading. I found it interesting that he referred to the Vrax as "it." I know they don't have the same genders as humans, being hermaphrodites they're not male or female but both. Even so, for a human working with intelligent beings who have personalities I feel like if I were in that situation I'd find my self thinking of them as "he" or "she" even though it's not accurate. By saying "it" it makes me feel like he's uneasy around them, doesn't trust them, or think they're equal to humans.

Also, there was one simile you used, "He felt as if he were inside a monstrous church bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound." I get what you're saying because I've seen big church bells, but I wonder if Sorensen has, and if that's what he'd compare it too. Are there still big churches and church bells on Earth at the time of the story? Has he spent lots of time on Earth, or has he spent most of his time in space on various ships?

Anyway, I hope these help you in some way. I figure it's always good to see how others respond to your story and characters so you can tell if you're telling your story the way you want. And again, I also am interested to see what happens next which I think is the more important thing here anyway.
 
I am impressed. This prose is a lot better than the first time. The last edit made a big difference.

Niels Sorensen entered Curiosity's control center as [quietly] [as possible.]

(Opinion), I think an adverb in action prose takes away the power of your writing. I feel, while writing in a passive aggressive way would help parlay a passive aggressive character, or help in a description. You are doing neither here.

If you use the “quetly” I think you don’t need the “as possible. ”
You could avoid the entire mess by simply stating, Sorensen entered the Curiosity’s control center with surreptitiousness /OR ANY SYNONYM



[The]DELETE three [other]DELETE crew members stood around [a]DELETE holographic image[]s of the unnamed planet the ship orbited. Scattered clouds floated over countless [small]DELETE islands. The planet's ocean, [was]DELETE a deep, inviting blue.

Akimi Haruna lifted a hand in greeting. "Nice of you to join us." A quick wink took some of the sting out of her words, but Sorensen felt himself blush[ing]DELETE. It wasn't [always]DELETE easy being the newcomer aboard a small scout ship.

"I was using the cycler when I got your message." Sorensen moved closer to the image[. It looked like]DELETE of a ghostly pearl half a meter in diameter. "What have we got here?"

Haruna stood between [the]DELETE two Vrax [aboard Curiosity]DELETE. She seemed perfectly at ease working with hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs[ twice her mass]DELETE. One of the Vrax [--], THAT Sorensen thought [it was] DELETE Slarik, [the elder of the two --]DELETE lifted a massive arm over the projection. Dozens of [the]DELETE long[,]DELETE AND delicate tendrils[], that served it as fingers[], wriggled over the planet[,]DELETE as if [they could]DELETE brush[]ING away its mysteries.

"Water," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Oxygen. No life."

"As far as we can tell from here," Sorensen said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."
Haruna leaned forward [a bit]DELETE and folded her hands together. She was tall and slender, and the gesture reminded Sorensen of a long-limbed water bird seeking [its]DELETE prey. "True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data [are] IS consistent with bare rock and empty oceans. [Not]IT WOULDN’T BE [uncommon] ANOMALOUS, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. Without [something] A PROCESS similar to photosynthesis, that's a puzzle."
Thrin, the other Vrax aboard , shuffled its front legs as it examined the [slowly spinning]DELETE image. It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck [on a ceramic chain]DELETE. Anxiety? Excitement? It was impossible to tell. "More information wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at Thrin's grammatical confusion. Rarely did a human [being]DELETE master even a few words of [any]DELETE Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple tenses for past, present, and future. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of human speech might suggest.
 
"So we go down and take a look." Haruna waved a hand through the hologram. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds.


"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the control center without further discussion. Although Curiosityfunctioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of the funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of [anything resembling]DELETE irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. " Promising. Dangerous." Instead of walking backwards like Slarik, Thrin turned until [it was]DELETE facing away from the image. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.
"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Haruna left the control center, [walking briskly toward her station]DELETE. Once again Sorensen wondered why she had chosen to work aboard a scout ship, when she had [the]DELETE skills to be [valued as]DELETE a flatspace navigator anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a youthful sense of adventure, the willingness to waste years for [the chance to make one of the]DELETE rare discoveries that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

Sorensen made [his]DELETE way to his [own]DELETE station. The [slightly]ADVERB stronger pull of simulated gravity[,]DELETE as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was [conforting]. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.
 
[Many thanks to those of you kind enough to do so much hard work helping me with this story. I have tried to improve the most obvious flaws with the first version of the opening scene. In particular, I have tried to stay with one viewpoint character; I have removed confusing metaphors; I have removed the plot hole almost everyone pointed out; and I have have tried to make it it clearer who the characters are. I hope this is a little better.]

[P.S. Please disregard the strange change in typeface shown below. I don't how I messed this up, or how to correct it.]

_____________________________________________________________

Niels Sorensen entered Curiosity's control center as quietly as possible. Why as quietly as possible? Later it sounds like he's lake... perhaps as quickly as possible instead? The three other crew members stood around a holographic image of the unnamed planet the ship orbited. Scattered clouds floated over countless small islands. The planet's ocean was a deep, inviting blue.

Akimi Haruna lifted a hand in greeting. "Nice of you to join us." A quick wink took some of the sting out of her words, but Sorensen felt himself blushing. Would you really blush at a reprimand? It wasn't always easy being the newcomer aboard a small scout ship.

"I was using the cycler when I got your message." Sorensen moved closer to the image. It looked like a ghostly pearl half a meter in diameter. "What have we got here?"

Haruna stood between two Vrax aboard Curiosity. She seemed perfectly at ease working with hermaphroditic, pseudo-reptilian centaurs twice her mass. One of the Vrax -- Sorensen thought it was Slarik, the elder of the two (I don't think you need that) -- lifted a massive arm over the projection. Dozens of the long, delicate tendrils that served it as fingers wriggled over the planet, as if they could brush away its mysteries.

"Water," Slarik said. Its voice was a quiet rumble, like distant thunder. "Oxygen. No life."

"As far as we can tell from here," Sorensen said. "Sensors don't tell the whole story."

Haruna leaned forward a bit and folded her hands together. She was tall and slender, and the gesture reminded Sorensen of a long-limbed water bird seeking its prey. "True enough," she said. "Still, the evidence we have is convincing. All data is consistent with bare rock and empty oceans. Not uncommon, if it weren't for that damn oxygen. Without something similar to photosynthesis, that's a puzzle."

Thrin, the other Vrax aboard, shuffled its front legs as it examined the slowly spinning image. It touched the jeweled icon that hung around its thick neck on a ceramic chain. Anxiety? Excitement? It was impossible to tell. "More information wished for," it said.

Sorensen tried not to smile at Thrin's grammatical confusion. Rarely did a human being master even a few words of any Vrax language, most of which had bewildering multiple tenses for past, present, and future I don't think you need the second half of this sentence; from the fact that it's rare for humans to master even a few words, it's obvious they have a very complex and difficult language. Thrin and Slarik were far more intelligent than their stumbling use of human speech might suggest.
 
"So we go down and take a look." Haruna waved a hand through the hologram. Points of light danced on her fingers like diamonds.


"Agreed." Slarik backed out of the control center without further discussion. Although Curiosity functioned as a rough democracy, the fact that Slarik's clan had provided the lion's share of the funding made the elder Vrax first among equals.

Thrin continued to study the image. Its large silvery eyes, devoid of anything resembling irises or pupils, were impossible to read.

"Anomaly," it said. " Promising. Dangerous." Instead of walking backwards like Slarik, Thrin turned until it was facing away from the image. Sorensen wondered at the significance, if any, of this gesture.

"They don't fool around," he said. "We better get ready."

With a lazy half-salute Haruna left the control center, walking briskly toward her station. Once again Sorensen wondered why she had chosen to work aboard a scout ship, when she had the skills to be valued as a flatspace navigator anywhere in the Protectorate. Xenophilia, a youthful sense of adventure, the willingness to waste years for the chance to make one of the rare discoveries that would make her filthy rich -- none of the usual explanations seemed to fit perfectly.

Sorensen made his way to his own station. The slightly stronger pull of simulated gravity, as he moved from the center of Curiosity to the periphery, was comforting. He strapped himself into his familiar chair, the winking monitors surrounding him like old friends.

"Approach begins." Thrin's voice, somehow gentler than Slarik's, seemed to be coming from everywhere. Sorensen thought he could hear the whisper of ion jets, although they were supposed to be silent. He relaxed and closed his eyes for a moment as acceleration pushed him back into his seat.

"Feel like going for a swim, Niles?" The playfulness in Haruna's voice brought him out of his reverie.

"Do I have a choice?" Sorensen glanced at his monitors. "The whole place seems to be nothing but one big beach."

Sorensen watched the planet approach on his viewscreen. The light from its primary, a shade more orange than Sol, illuminated three-quarters of it this isn't actually possible; a single light point can't possibly illuminate more than 50% of a sphere. As Curiosity drew nearer, the light grew until it nearly covered the entire hemisphere I'm not sure what this means? As the ship drew closer the star started to illuminate more thant 3/4 of the planet?. Could this truly be a world which had never lived?

The image suddenly seemed to blur, as if waves of heat rose before it. Sorensen tried to focus his viewscreen, but nothing seemed to help. He scanned the monitors quickly. There were odd fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and chemical composition.

"Something strange, Thrin," he said. "You might want to reduce--"

Sorensen's body slammed into his restraints, as if a giant hand had grabbed Curiosity. He felt as if he were inside a monstrous church bell, swinging from side to side as his ears were blasted by sound. The ship shuddered for an endless moment, then stood still.

Sorensen opened his eyes. Half his monitors were damaged, and the rest displayed readings which baffled him. He winced as he moved out of his restraints. There was blood on his left arm where one strap had bitten deeply.

"Who survives?" Slarik's voice seemed as commanding as ever.

"Back legs injured," Thrin said weakly. "Movement difficult."

"I've got some cuts, nothing serious." Sorensen rose to his feet. "What the hell happened?"

"Unknown," Slarik said. "Haruna, report."

'I'm here," she said. "I think I broke my wrist. Damn."

"No injury here," Salrik replied. "All go Thrin."



I feel like this is a good piece until the very end. The ship stops too quickly, to my mind. I envisioned this as something akin to a single abrupt jolt, mid-entry. If they've actually made it all the way to the surface, I think this needs to play out much longer, and you need to make it clear.

I'm also not really buying the response. Whether still orbiting, still re-entering, or having crash-landed, I find it hard to believe Sorensen would get out of his restraints so quickly. Wouldn't you want to make sure the ship was stable first, and not in danger of more movement?

I also agree with JoanDrake; they'd want to check the ship, as it has clearly been hammered, and if something is wrong they could be in serious strife. Reporting on the ship's status is far more important than any individual crew member's health. If I was Sorensen I'd immediately be reporting my strange readings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top