How do you feel about this opening? 1100 words.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Philosopher

Philosopher
Joined
May 6, 2011
Messages
81
I've got the feeling it comes across a little boring, but that may be because I've read it many times over. Please let me know what you think, I'm more interested in how you receive it than nit-picky editing at the moment. Many thanks in advance!

If at any point you get bored, stop reading and let me know why, thanks.

P.S I sometimes get formatting issues when pasting from msft word, where words get bunched / paired together. I've tried to make sure this isn't the case but if you spot one please ignore it.

------


James crept through the woods, he was hunting a well-sized boar, or so the tracks suggested.

It was cold for spring time, his feet felt the bite from the ground and his breath steamed a tinting mist in front of him. The greenery had taken it’s time to show up this year, so he found himself amongst scantily clad trees, but also some greener ones with fruits trying to grow.

He went to the ground and examined a fresh print. He was getting closer. The thrill sent him faster, trying to be quieter, heart beating quicker, sweatier. The fatally sharp tip of the spear he carried caught his eye as he moved forward, it pushed his beat harder.

The thought of bacon teased his hunger further and his stomach screamed at him for it, quickly, quickly, find the pig now! Just beyond the enclosure ahead he heard the distinct snap of a dry twig on the ground, the pig was there! He could almost smell roasting pork, it danced on his nose as he tried to control his breathing and make it quieter.

He crouched behind the bushes and gently prized his way through, being as stealthy as could be. What he saw shocked him more than if an Icewolf had charged at him.

He’d never seen her before, she certainly wasn’t from the village and it was a very peculiar thing for a non-villager to be in these parts of the outskirts. He had to force himself to look away and back again, in case she wasn’t real. Yep, still there, the most beautifully intriguing girl he’d ever seen. Her skin glowed like mature honey or light oak and her hair was the colour of well nourished soil, but silky, and her eyes were a deep, vigorous brown.

“What’re you looking at?” She said.

He realised that he’d been staring at her longer than he thought. “I’m sorry, I...” Those words came but with them nothing. “I...”

“Come out of those bushes would you. How long have you been spying on me?”

As he edged out she lurched backwards, her eyes pointing at his spear. He quickly jammed it into the ground and she eased. “I wasn’t spying on you! Where are you from?”

She was looking at him in a way no one had ever looked at him before; it was quite odd but also very nice. Her eyes were wide, curious, but also very welcoming with a gentle smile to accompany them. Her teeth were very white and small and they were not perfectly straight, though that made them more attractive. “I’m Nicola,” she said.

“James,” he said, kicking himself that he’d forgotten his manners and hadn't introduced himself first.

“I am from Avenia,” she said.

“My uncle has told me about those with skin tanned from birth. It’s quite amazing to see in life. What are you doing here? You must be lost.”

She giggled. “In Avenia we have people of all skin colours, but this place is quiet, I like it. I won’t be here long. Come, I’ll show you,” she grabbed his hand and led him away.

They walked further from the village than James usually goes, through lush plains scattered with daisies and over a stream, and finally she stopped him near some woods which nestled at the foot of a hill.

“We can’t be seen,”

By who? James thought.

They slipped into the woods and around the hill, and they crawled through the bushes until there was an opening where they could see into a huge valley beyond.

“My father’s army.”

The words hit him before his eyes could process what he saw. That’s what it was: an army! He’d never seen anything like it. Never had he seen so many people, or so many tents, or so many horses or sheep or pigs or so many of... well any of it!

The tents were white pyramids of many different sizes. The flags had jade backgrounds and the shape of a white jagged leaf as the emblem.

“Is that the emblem of Avenia?”

“Yes, of the Avenian Guard. Look it’s on their shields too,” she pointed at one of the guards manning the edges of the camp.

The shields were huge, of a jade tinted metal and shaped like a leaf, rounder at the top end and sharp at the bottom. “Why are you travelling with an army?” was all James could find to say.

She was quiet for a second. “We’re travelling south to honour an ancient allegiance. Father says that war is brewing and that it is our duty to go.”

“Is your mother with you?” James found the thought of a Warman marching with his daughter most unusual. “Are you royalty?”

She said nothing.

“Nicolaaaa!” He heard a voice bellow from the distance.

“Oh, mud cakes! We’d better go.” She got up and crept through the woods, he followed her. They went back the way they came.

“Nicola!” The sound was closer now.

“Run!” she bolted.

They sprinted across the plains and he heard, “there she is!” and the sound of metal clanking, groaning under the strain of the chase, this he’d never heard before. It sent shivers down him, such an unnatural sound.

“Quickly!” she said.

He looked back to see four men gaining on them. Their swords were sheathed but the blades sung an unsavoury tune to him and it fired him onwards. He grabbed Nicola’s hand and pulled her into the woods they’d met in, then they scrambled to the stream and into a canyon that the water ran through, and then through a cave that was as dark as night, it went on for some time but finally they arrived at his favourite place, the hidden lake.

All around it was a thick wall of trees, aside from the path leading to it. They sat on a fallen tree trunk. It was smooth and dry, but cold. She shot an intense smile at him, and when he let out a huge breath and started panting as if he’d been holding it that whole time, she laughed at him so hard he couldn't help but feel embarrassed.

“Why are they chasing you?” James finally managed to catch a moment with enough breath to speak.

“Father said not to leave the camp.”

“What would they have done to me if they’d caught us?”

“Depends on what they thought your intentions were,” she said coldly. This place is beautiful,” she was looking in the direction of the lake.

“My favourite,” he said. The sky cast a crisp reflection of milk and gentle silver over the water. Through that there was ochre, rich rust deep set in the bed and blackish green weeds grew under the crystal clear water, swaying ever so subtly.

Schools of fish glided tranquilly and then out of nowhere they’d find reason to dart off, only to fall back into their original flow once more, and all was calm in the water again.
 
James crept through the woods, he was hunting a well-sized boar, or so the tracks suggested. – This line didn’t work for me, what is well sized.

It was cold for spring time, his feet felt the bite from the ground and his breath steamed a tinting mist in front of him. The greenery had taken it’s time to show up this year, so he found himself amongst scantily clad trees, but also some greener ones with fruits trying to grow. – A contradiction of description with the trees, and I’m not sure about tinting. Good descriptions that were over worked just a little and because of that didn’t engage me.

He went to the ground and examined a fresh track/print. He was getting closer. The thrill sent him faster, trying to be quieter, heart beating quicker, sweatier. The fatally sharp tip of the spear he carried caught his eye as he moved forward, it pushed his beat harder. – Too much description for me and it over worked the images.

The thought of bacon teased his hunger further and his stomach screamed at him for it, quickly, quickly, find the pig – I thought it was a boar? now! Just beyond the enclosure – what enclosure? ahead he heard the distinct snap of a dry twig on the ground, the pig was there! He could almost smell roasting pork, it danced on his nose as he tried to control his breathing and make it quieter. – It’s a mix of hunger, hunting and cooking - mixed images that don’t do it for me.

He crouched behind the bushes and gently prized his way through, being as stealthy as could be. What he saw shocked him more than if an Icewolf had charged at him.

He’d never seen her before, she certainly wasn’t from the village and it was a very peculiar thing for a non-villager to be in these parts of the outskirts. He had to force himself to look away and back again, in case she wasn’t real. Yep, still there, the most beautifully intriguing girl he’d ever seen. Her skin glowed like mature honey or light oak and her hair was the colour of well nourished soil, but silky, and her eyes were a deep, vigorous brown.

“What’re you looking at?” She asked/said.

He realised that he’d been staring at her longer than he thought. “I’m sorry, I...” Those words came but with them nothing. “I...”

“Come out of those bushes would you. How long have you been spying on me?”

As he edged out she lurched backwards, her eyes looking/pointing at his spear. He quickly jammed it into the ground and she eased. “I wasn’t spying on you! Where are you from?”

She was looking at him in a way no one had ever looked at him before; it was quite odd but also very nice. Her eyes were wide, curious, but also very welcoming with a gentle smile to accompany them. Her teeth were very white and small and they were not perfectly straight, though that made them more attractive. “I’m Nicola,” she said. – It’s very flowery description with very bland dialogue and it’s jarring with me.

“James,” he said, kicking himself that he’d forgotten his manners and hadn't introduced himself first.

“I am from Avenia,” she said.

“My uncle has told me about those with skin tanned from birth. It’s quite amazing to see in life. What are you doing here? You must be lost.” – This does not feel like a natural conversation to me.

She giggled. “In Avenia we have people of all skin colours, but this place is quiet, I like it. I won’t be here long. Come, I’ll show you,” she grabbed his hand and led him away.

They walked further from the village than James usually goes, through lush plains scattered with daisies and over a stream, and finally she stopped him near some woods which nestled at the foot of a hill.

“We can’t be seen,”

By who? James thought.

They slipped into the woods and around the hill – confusing, and they crawled through the bushes until there was an opening where they could see into a huge valley beyond. – And during all this long walk he never once thought to ask – where are we going?

“My father’s army.” – I wasn’t expecting that, an army!

The words hit him before his eyes could process what he saw. That’s what it was: an army! He’d never seen anything like it. Never had he seen so many people, or so many tents, or so many horses or sheep or pigs or so many of... well any of it! – Over worked descriptions again for me.
He meets a girl in the woods while armed. She says hello and drags the heavily armed man off to see her army, an army by the way that lost her in the woods. I’m going to carry on, but I would have stopped reading here. My sense of reality was pushed too far, sorry.

The tents were white pyramids of many different sizes. The flags had jade backgrounds and the shape of a white jagged leaf as the emblem.

“Is that the emblem of Avenia?”

“Yes, of the Avenian Guard. Look it’s on their shields too,” she pointed at one of the guards manning the edges of the camp.

The shields were huge, of a jade tinted metal and shaped like a leaf, rounder at the top end and sharp at the bottom. “Why are you travelling with an army?” was all James could find to say.

She was quiet for a second. “We’re travelling south to honour an ancient allegiance. Father says that war is brewing and that it is our duty to go.” – Very un-natural dialogue, she’s just telling him everything?

I’m not really too sure what the plot is all about, apart from running around the woods with a nice looking girl. The descriptions are over worked, but I can see what your trying to do and it’s a case of experimenting and learning a balance and a style that works for you. The dialogue is weak and very un-natural. This is to some extent because of the weak plot so far, but also something you’ll have to work on – plenty of threads on here about dialogue so lots of help available. So some work to do. Sadly the posted section is not really engaging me right now, sorry buddy.

If I were you I would encourage nit picking editing right now, I think you need the help. It did wonders for me, it was painful, but it worked.
 
Sorry, I tend to nit as I go. Take what you will from it.

James crept through the woods,I'd take a new sentence he was hunting a well-sized boarin what way? What is well-sized?, or so the tracks suggested.

It was cold for spring time,again, maybe a new sentence. It feels splicey to me. his feet felt the bite from the ground and his breath steamed a tinting mist in front of him. The greenery had taken it’sits (it doesn't have a posessive apostrophe and is only it's, if it is is shortened) time to show up this year, so he found himself amongst scantily clad trees, but also some greener ones with fruits trying to growSorry, I'm confused; the season is behind but some of it is green and the fruits are growing? If the season is late, everything should be late. Fruit are especially grumpy about cold weather.

He went to the ground and examined a fresh print. He was getting closer. The thrill sent him faster, trying to be quieter, heart beating quicker, sweatier.I rather like that sentence The fatallybut I'd lose this adverb; we know it's going to be fatally sharp, he's a hunter sharp tip of the spear he carried caught his eye as he moved forward, it pushed his beat hardereh?.

The thought of bacon teased his hunger further and his stomach screamed at him for it, quickly, quickly, find the pig now! Just beyond the enclosurewhat type of enclosure? ahead he heard the distinct snap of a dry twig on the ground,something stronger than a comma here the pig was there! He could almost smell roasting porkpoor pig, it danced on his nose as he tried to control his breathing and make it quieter.

He crouched behind the bushes and gently prized his way through, being as stealthy as could be. What he saw shocked him more than if an Icewolf had charged at him.

He’d never seen her before, she certainly wasn’t from the village and it was a very peculiar thing for a non-villager to be in these parts of the outskirts. He had to force himself to look away and back again, in case she wasn’t real. Yep, still there, the most beautifully intriguing girl he’d ever seen. Her skin glowed like mature honey or light oak and her hair was the colour of well nourished soil, but silky, and her eyes were a deep, vigorous brown.

“What’re you looking at?” sheShe said.

He realised that he’d been staring at her longer than he thought. “I’m sorry, I...” Those words came but with them nothingdon't know what this means. “I...”

“Come out of those bushescomma would you?. How long have you been spying on me?”

As he edged out she lurched backwards, her eyes pointinghmm, can eyes point? at his spear. He quickly jammed it into the ground and she easedin what way, what does this mean? Did she relax, did her eyes soften, did her stance changed. . “I wasn’t spying on you! Where are you from?”If this is him speaking, new paragraph; the last action was hers.

She was looking at him in a way no one had ever looked at him before; it was quite odd but also very nicesorry, this tells me nothing. What way? How did it make him feel?. Her eyes were wide, curious, but also very welcoming with a gentle smile to accompany them. Her teeth were very white and small and they were not perfectly straight, though that made them more attractiveHmm, there's a bit too much physical description for me.. “I’m Nicola,” she said.

“James,” he said, kicking himself that he’d forgotten his manners and hadn't introduced himself first.all very civil, considering he's starving and supposed to be hunting, and she's in his territory.

“I am from Avenia,” she said.

“My uncle has told me about those with skin tanned from birth. It’s quite amazing to see in life. What are you doing here? You must be lost.”

She giggled. “In Avenia we have people of all skin colours, but this place is quiet, I like it. I won’t be here long. Come, I’ll show you,.”." She (you're moving to an action) she grabbed his hand and led him away.

They walked further from the village than James usually goeswent? otherwise it sounds like a tense change, through lush plains scattered with daisies and over a stream,New sentence? and finally she stopped him near some woods which nestled at the foot of a hill.

“We can’t be seen,.”

By whom?? James thought. He's being very trusting, I'm struggling to believe it. And here is where my interest waned, which is, I think, one of things you wanted to know. I don't feel anything much about the characters, I don't think it's a plausible setting, that he'd drop his hunt and go with her, or that he'd be relaxed about an army in his territory. There are a fair few punctuation issues etc in it, I don't know if this is a draft or a final? On the plus side, there's some nice description, and the bit where he's running is nicely done. :)
 
Hi Springs - it sounds a bit forced to me. It seems more like a montage of what an observer might think he should be thinking, rather than what he is thinking. It doesn't sound authentic. Bacon references don't help.

***Sorry for being negative!**

I would try a blind re-write, maybe, and then combine best bits.
 
Hi Springs - it sounds a bit forced to me. It seems more like a montage of what an observer might think he should be thinking, rather than what he is thinking. It doesn't sound authentic. Bacon references don't help.

***Sorry for being negative!**

I would try a blind re-write, maybe, and then combine best bits.

See, when the blokes see my avatar, they get hynotised. :p Not mine, Glen. :) (unless you meant something in the crit, but I don't think so?)
 
The problem I see after Bowler's and Spring's critique is that this piece isn't close enough to the character. It shows a great promise to become one, but without Philosopher taking this apart and reconstructing it in closer perspective, a lot what's in the in prose reads to me like telling. The reader has to take granted that's how it is instead of them utilising their imagination and seeing it as it should be.
 
First of all, drop the first sentence! It adds nothing, and takes everything away, by killing any possible following tension by telling us, too matter of factly, what is happening. You're writing in third person limited so keep us there to enjoy the character experience. :)

Wasn't too sure about the bacon reference, though - if you're going for period realism simply roasting pork might be treat enough - though do be aware boar was a prize hunting animal and you needed permission from the land owner to hunt, under normal circumstances (doesn't mean to say it can't happen, just adds another element of tension if you wanted to use it).

“What’re you looking at?” She said.
she said. Lower case after speech marks.

Overall, I think you've made a clear effort with this piece and there are some nice strengths to it, not least with how you try and give the character experience in the hunt.

However, the meeting of Nicola does stop the pace and change the mood completely - I'm left wondering why she would give James any attention at all? Just feels a little ... forced, at this point. Which would probably be fine in a YA novel anyway. In that regard as well, not quite sure about the names - James and Nicola seem far too ordinary and everyday, when you want to take your reader away from the ordinary and everyday.

Other than that, some nice promise here, but probably with room to develop your skills further.
 
Thanks all for the feedback.

If I was hunting whilst very hungry and came across a beautiful girl I'd never seen, I think I would follow her still. Is it really that far fetched? I've seen men do sillier things for women they've just met than simply follow them. Let me know what you think? Perhaps it doesn't come across that this is the case in the writing.

The fact she is telling him everything / being very open, I guess I wanted to show an instant bond between them, but maybe I need to create that a bit more blatantly in the writing.

I also figured that the daughter travelling with her father's army wouldn't really know how to act / feel so she's just going with her mind, and why not show her new friend what she's doing, its not as if they're marching in secret (they're flying banners and armed)...

I agree with the points that I need to make it a bit more believable by getting closer to the character(s) and probably get a bit more detail in there to make sense of one radical thing happening to another.

Thanks for the feedback so far.
 
Oh - my bad - just been reading through a mediaeval cookbook and one of the recipes is "Poached fowl and bacon with pudding". So the term was very much in use in the Middle Ages.
 
I've got the feeling it comes across a little boring, but that may be because I've read it many times over. Please let me know what you think, I'm more interested in how you receive it than nit-picky editing at the moment. Many thanks in advance!

If at any point you get bored, stop reading and let me know why, thanks.

P.S I sometimes get formatting issues when pasting from msft word, where words get bunched / paired together. I've tried to make sure this isn't the case but if you spot one please ignore it.

------


James crept through the woods. He was hunting a well-sized boar, or so the tracks suggested.

It was cold for spring time, his feet felt the bite from the ground and his breath steamed a tinting mist in front of him. The greenery had taken it’s time to show up this year, so he found himself amongst scantily clad trees, but also some greener ones with fruits trying to grow. In spring? Research required.

He went to the ground and examined a fresh print. He was getting closer. The thrill sent him faster, trying to be quieter, heart beating quicker, sweatier. The fatally sharp tip of the spear he carried caught his eye as he moved forward, it pushed his beat harder. You should research boar hunts - I have a recollection that they involved several hunters.

The thought of bacon teased his hunger further and his stomach screamed at him for it, quickly, quickly, find the pig now! Just beyond the enclosure ahead he heard the distinct snap of a dry twig on the ground, the pig was there! He could almost smell roasting pork, it danced on his nose as he tried to control his breathing and make it quieter.

He crouched behind the bushes and gently prized pushed his way through, being as stealthy as could be. What he saw shocked him more than if an Icewolf had charged at him.

He’d never seen her before, she certainly wasn’t from the village and it was a very peculiar thing for a non-villager to be in these parts of the outskirts. He had to force himself to look away and back again, in case she wasn’t real. Yep, still there, the most beautifully intriguing girl he’d ever seen. Her skin glowed like mature honey or light oak and her hair was the colour of well nourished soil, but silky, and her eyes were a deep, vigorous brown.
What's she wearing? You don't tell us!
“What’re you looking at?” She said.

He realised that he’d been staring at her longer than he thought. “I’m sorry, I...” Those words came but with them nothing. “I...”

“Come out of those bushes would you. How long have you been spying on me?”

As he edged out she lurched backwards, her eyes pointing at his spear. He quickly jammed it into the ground and she eased. “I wasn’t spying on you! Where are you from?”
No, no, no! You've dropped the ball now. This reads like a stock scene from an anime.
She was looking at him in a way no one had ever looked at him before; it was quite odd but also very nice. Her eyes were wide, curious, but also very welcoming with a gentle smile to accompany them. Her teeth were very white and small and they were not perfectly straight, though that made them more attractive. “I’m Nicola,” she said.
(cut)
“My favourite,” he said. The sky cast a crisp reflection of milk and gentle silver over the water. Through that there was ochre, rich rust deep set in the bed and blackish green weeds grew under the crystal clear water, swaying ever so subtly.

Schools of fish glided tranquilly and then out of nowhere they’d find reason to dart off, only to fall back into their original flow once more, and all was calm in the water again.

I wouldn't say boring, and your descriptions are not bad. But it all falls apart once the couple meet. Nothing they say and nothing they do seems at all like how real people would behave. And that army just happens to be there. And their names sound like they come from a posh part of the UK, not from some fantasy world.
You also describe the girl (rather too much) without, so far as I could see, mentioning what she is wearing.

Keep writing, pay attention to points that more than one critic has mentioned, and you WILL improve!
 
Oh - my bad - just been reading through a mediaeval cookbook and one of the recipes is "Poached fowl and bacon with pudding". So the term was very much in use in the Middle Ages.
Yep, "bacon" as a word is early 14th century, and I dare say the concept is a lot older, but in the recipe, is it bacon as we know it -- ie thin slices to be fried? Or is it just the joint? Bacon could also mean fresh meat from the pig's flank/back.

Whether this chap would be thinking of bacon as we imagine it would also depend on how many mouths he had to feed with the creature and for how long. If it's just him and his aged granny, they'd necessarily have to cure a lot of the meat in order to make it last, but the bacon would be very much what they had when the fresh meat was gone, not something to make his mouth water now. If it's for the whole village, it's more likely to be eaten while fresh so no bacon at all.

I got confused, though, as to the reference to "boar" and then "pig". An uncastrated male domestic pig is a boar, but if this guy is hunting it I rather assume we're talking wild boar here. In which case he's very unlikely to think "pig" even to himself. If it is a domestic pig, it would be owned by someone even if was allowed to run loose in the woods (though that's an autumn thing with pannage, not spring). If it's a wild boar, then as Brian says, in most feudal societies it was a game animal and therefore protected from the likes of the local oiks. However...

If it's a wild boar, no one in his right mind would be hunting it alone just because he's a bit peckish. They are fierce, pugnacious and deadly creatures capable of disembowelling him. Therefore, to me, the whole idea is unrealistic. And when, in the very next paragraph we have unspecified, generic, fruits trying to grow in spring, I'd have stopped reading there, to be frank. (Yes, I know it's fantasy, and you can have fruit in spring and blossom in autumn should you so wish, but I would need to see incredible writing and world-building before I accepted that, and it simply isn't here, I'm afraid.)

As to the premise that this guy would follow a girl like this, no, to my mind it isn't believable. Nor are any of her actions, come to that. It simply doesn't read as real people living in any kind of non-teenage-oriented society. And I share the concerns over the dialogue.

You're trying very hard with the description, and it's clear you enjoy writing lyrical passages, but always remember that this is best if grounded in character experience. Would a boy of his age/situation/education think in these terms?

Anyway, you've got the first draft down, which is always the diffilcut bit, so well done there. Now to build on it further.
 
See my problem with the text started at "or so the tracks suggested". Somehow I just knew then and there that he would never come up against a boar so the hunting never got exciting, I was just plodding through the text looking for what he would find instead.

It was a girl and I lost interest.

A bit harsh perhaps but realy is what happened. Otherwise I would have been kinda psyched about a boar hunt. Boars can be freaking vicious and going up against one alone with only a spear... Well, I wouldn't do it.

I did read the rest of the text just to see what happened but I had allready lost my investment in the story so I can't say too much about it.

I would say that James could fall head over heels for the girl at first glance and follow her anywhere if this was a YA novel but it would still need a bit more explanation.

As for the language I don't want to say too much not being an expert, but it felt a bit stilted and a bit repetitous at times. Can't put my finger on why but there you go.

With all that said there is something to work with here. Make the hunt more real, and make me belive it. Then shock me with the girl, make me see what makes her som mesmerizing. And BAM! An Army!? Oh hell no. What will happen next?

I guess what I'm saying is that the piece need more drama and emotion, action and movement. Pacing in a word.
 
My first thought was that the girl was the pig, magically transformed.

My second thought is why would any Army commander bring his daughter along to a battle.

And my third is how much of a ****poor scouting corps this army must have to just let their commander's daughter wander off in foreign territory on a hostile mission.

Now maybe this is an expected thing, the Army having been given safe passage by Diplomacy or maybe it's even waiting to join up with the Army of James's realm (but then why hasn't he been "volunteered" as was the custom in those days) and sees itself as safe. Whatever, you have to indicate that they were an expected thing somehow (I can think of several ways you could do this "James had heard of the xxx war but had thought them further south etc") Otherwise, you're forfeiting a lot of credibility from what is otherwise a well-written scene.

And far from boring, IMO
 
In itself it could be good - it is well written but it is not giving me a reason to feel the characters.

I won't rewrite it or go through it but for example the first line:

James crept through the woods, he was hunting a well-sized boar, or so the tracks suggested.

James studied the tracks and his mouth watered at the thought of the large boar that had made them. He crept through the woods hunting down his quarry. (maybe include a bit about how he would cook it).

Or just start from the third paragraph that is a lot more exciting. It is an opening and a lot need explaining but how about not revealing so much? Have her cagey about her real identity. That will allow you to bring in information about who she is later.

You just need to be believable rather than real.
 
Right, so believability is the key.

For some reason I thought Boar and pig were the same thing, I had it in my head that pigs were human's product of domesticating wild boar over time but I guess I should have researched that!

Thank you all once again for the feedback, I think I'm going to blind rewrite the piece with all that's been said in mind to see what comes out.

Mainly that it needs to be believable!
 
For some reason I thought Boar and pig were the same thing, I had it in my head that pigs were human's product of domesticating wild boar over time but I guess I should have researched that!

Oh, pigs are certainly a domestic form - but remember, dogs as domesticated wolves, and there's a big difference between those two as well. :)

You are right about the hunting spear, though - I seem to recall two being the norm, though I suspect this is more for safety in case the other breaks. An angry wild boar is a fearsome adversary.
 
I quite liked the reveal of 'my father's army' - I was expecting you to go somewhere else with the story. But as others have said, I think you didn't bring out the characters clearly enough. I can definitely believe the girl as a precocious do-what-she-likes type, who would sneak out of an army camp and show it off to whoever she met first. But she didn't come across that way - it was only after you told us that I began to see her like that.

If she's that cheeky, how else would she behave? Wouldn't she try to show off a bit, and maybe bring in dad's army as her trump card? I'm not sure quite how old these characters are so I'm not sure what would be appropriate for them, but hopefully you see what I'm getting at.

Also, if you haven't, I really recommend reading the start of Eragon. Not the greatest fiction in the world, but it starts off with a very similar situation, and I thought it did a fine job at selling me on Eragon's plight - needing to hunt to feed himself and his family.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top