Eightfold Covert - 1080w of First Chapter.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tecdavid

Verdentia's Gardener
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
633
Location
This site will surely be suffering no shortage of
I was speaking with some of the others about first chapters , just recently, and it got me wondering whether mine was any good. I've written an alternate chapter, quite a bit different from this, but I'd like to gather a few opinions on this one (or the first 1080 words of it) before showing anyone the alternate.
Thanks very much. :)


~~~~~~

The clear night sky did little to please the soldiers in black. Their uniforms, dark and durable, melded well against their cool, still surroundings: the forest-covered valley. A silence was shared between the five men, doing well to keep them discreet, though it wasn’t long before the group’s most restless member stood up to gaze over the night-steeped cliffside. That hardy helmet of his helped hide his enthusiasm, and his anxiety.

‘Can’t you feel them?’ he muttered. ‘I can. Sharper than ever before, I’d reckon.’ He almost jittered with anticipation. A rotund soldier, wielding what appeared to be a lance, tried to soothe the man.

‘Think of it like any other assignment: we head down, we force our way through, we leave fretting for later. We know you care for a little slaying, so be thankful the pickings are rich. Endbringers are hardly the most coordinated marks, Avion. You should know not to let their numbers scare you.’

Avion slowed and nodded quietly. There was something very strange about Endbringers. The very sight of so many could mould your emotions like putty, riling your mind, sending your senses into a frenzy. They all knew it. The peculiar beings crept through the shadows, through the murk, through each and every nook and cranny your mind would never dare think about. Places where you could only envision fear being spun and woven. That’s where they spawned, and what better place to suit them than here? Amidst this particular valley?

Avion hated the place. His company weren’t at all keen on it either.

‘Loc!’ Avion hollered. The squad leader was rather used to the nickname. ‘It’s started, I can see it! They’ve begun to swarm.’

The soldiers’ heads shot up, suddenly tense, and they quickly joined Avion overlooking the cliffside. The valley beneath was filled with twisted trees, like a monstrous mouth filled with fangs. Thousands of branches reached up to a cold, merciless moon, all tangled and chaotic. The Endbringers had grown restless. Something odd filled their still, plagued hearts tonight. Only through an occasional gap in the forest’s muddle could the soldiers see the swarm.

Their leader turned to the lancer,
‘Warze, fend off their largest for as long as possible. Overpower any if you get even the slightest chance, but for the Light’s sake, pull back if they grow too troublesome. We cannot afford even the slightest casualty. Not tonight. Not with so few of us.’
Warze nodded, still peering down into that ever-darkening maw.

‘Vorne, you’ll fight alongside him. Back him up if the situation demands it.’ He took a quick look over the edge himself. ‘And tonight, we may very well need all the help we can get.’ A blade-wielding soldier, slim, long-limbed and silent, gave a simple nod.
‘Marley, you’ll join me in the battle behind Warze and Vorne. We’ll keep the littler ilk at bay until the Soulus charges. Only then will we have a chance at besting the lot of them.’

‘Then, home,’ said Avion, sighing a smile.

‘But just how long will it take to charge?’ asked Marley.

To that, the leader looked hesitant, and worried. ‘That, I cannot say. The Soulus is volatile . . . The Vaidriant Sphera’s Light may simply refuse to shine in a place such as this, where its villain resides.’ A little uncertainty pricked his sullen, troubled face. ‘I’ve . . . never had to fight down here before. Krieliss is their territory. Their advantage. It’d only be wise to imagine what makes the Light here glimmer so sparsely.’ He raised his head skyward, as if to challenge the very night, noticing the worried way his men shifted. ‘All I hope is that I can lead you as capably down here as anywhere else.’

The soldiers didn’t respond. They didn’t want anyone’s guard lowered by words of comfort or kindness. They would wait, and let the battle decide how their leader fared here of all places. Krieliss was a place where night seemed endless. A place where winds cut like daggers, where mountains were earth-born claws, and where screams blew like gales from the emptiest hollows. It wasn’t moonlight, lamplight, or candlelight Loc spoke about. It was a light of their own. A different Light. Something brighter, and truly unwelcome in a land like this.

‘Avion,’ the leader went on, ‘I want you to keep the Ethereal in a form befitting a firearm. Attend to the enemies of the air.’

Avion nodded and reached into a sealed pocket of his belt, from which he produced what looked like a glowing orb. It shimmered, though sat still. Yet there was something about that shimmer which promised it held great worth, and value.

The soldier focussed hard with the orb in his grasp, and felt it slowly reshape. The air – the very reality – around it began rippling, warping as the bizarre object performed its shifting dance. Within seconds, the orb had grown, moulded, reshaped into something peculiar but brutal. Something like a bow-gun, resting firmly in Avion’s grasp. The others watched, and none did so much as blink.

Everyone rose, clutching their weapons tight, trying to block out the sounds of those Endbringer hordes, writhing in their masses. The Endbringers they were about to leap into the midst of.

The last moments of peace were then shattered by a roar from the lightless, thorn-like trees behind them. A beast, lithe as a lion, built like a bear, but bigger than both, leapt for them from those woods. An Endbringer at last.

Marley was the one to react. His battlestaff struck the beast clean across the face, swiping by its eyes. The creature was blinded, and what followed for it was a fatal stab through the skull. It fell, having been mere inches from ravaging Marley’s neck. He knew how to deal with this particular sort of Endbringer. He and the others had been selected for this assignment for a reason.

‘Now!’ Loc bellowed. ‘Each of you, I want to see you down there now!’ He was now well aware they hadn’t any time to waste. The soldiers leapt over the edge – an act that’d be declared insane by anyone else. But each knew their mission, each knew their strengths, and each knew their foes’ weakness. Their kind weren’t as quick to fall as the demon on the clifftop, so long as the slightest shard of hope still shimmered.

A capable swordarm was nothing without inner strength to keep it steady.

~~~~~

I should probably mention: The narrative might have seemed a bit distant, but there is in fact a reason for this, given by the end of the chapter. Still, please say so if it came across as bothersome.
 
I'm just leaving work, but had a look and I have to say I really like it. There are parts that can be improved and I will come back to point some of it out. Just wanted to let you know I enjoyed reading it for what it was.

I really liked "A beast, lithe as a lion, built like a bear, but bigger than both, leapt for them from those woods."
 
The clear night sky did little to please the soldiers in black. Their uniforms, dark and durable, melded well against their cool, still surroundings: the forest-covered valley. A silence was shared between the five men, doing well to keep them discreet, though it wasn’t long before the group’s most restless member stood up and gazed over the night-steeped cliffside. That hardy helmet of his helped hide his enthusiasm, and his anxiety (You can do without).

‘Can’t you feel them?’ he muttered. ‘I can. Sharper than ever before, I’d reckon.’ He almost jittered with anticipation. A rotund soldier, wielding what appeared to be a lance, tried to soothe the man.

Two last sentences takes you out from the PoV, where as if you would had taken them out or moved the description in next bit, you could had stayed in. But then there's "what appeared to be" ... doesn't the narrator know what his characters are wielding?
‘Think of it like any other assignment: we head down, we force our way through, we leave fretting for later. We know you care for a little slaying, so be thankful the pickings are rich. Endbringers are hardly the most coordinated marks, Avion. You should know not to let their numbers scare you.’
Oh dear, just as I was getting excited and thought what a wonderful dialogue, you drop in totally unnecessary exposition. So to leave it brute marking, could add a bit a description between the two characters. Maybe a slap on the back or friendly poke in the shoulder or even a wind and glance to other party members?
Avion slowed (what?) and nodded quietly. There was something very strange about Endbringers. The very sight of so many could mould your emotions like putty, riling your mind, sending your senses into a frenzy. They all knew it. The peculiar beings crept through the shadows, through the murk, through each and every nook and cranny your mind would never dare think about. Places where you could only envision fear being spun and woven. That’s where they spawned, and what better place to suit them than here? Amidst this particular valley?

Avion hated the place. His company weren’t at all keen on it either.

Too telling. Take it out and you'll be fine.
‘Loc!’ Avion hollered. The squad leader was rather used to the nickname. ‘It’s started, I can see it! They’ve begun to swarm.’

The soldiers’ heads shot up, suddenly tense, and they quickly joined Avion overlooking the cliffside. (need better description) The valley beneath was filled with twisted trees, like a monstrous mouth filled with fangs. Thousands of branches reached up to a cold, merciless moon, all tangled and chaotic. The Endbringers had grown restless. Something odd filled their still, plagued hearts tonight. Only through an occasional gap in the forest’s muddle could the soldiers see the swarm.
Ooh so tense. I'm intrigued.
Their leader turned to the lancer:
‘Warze, fend off their largest for as long as possible. Overpower any if you get even the slightest chance, but for the Light’s sake, pull back if they grow too troublesome. We cannot afford even the slightest casualty. Not tonight. Not with so few of us.’

Warze nodded, still peering down into that ever-darkening maw.


‘Vorne, you’ll fight alongside him. Back him up if the situation demands it.’ He took a quick look over the edge himself. ‘And tonight, we may very well need all the help we can get.’ A blade-wielding soldier, slim, long-limbed and silent, gave a simple nod.

‘Marley, you’ll join me in the battle behind Warze and Vorne. We’ll keep the littler ilk at bay until the Soulus charges. Only then will we have a chance at besting the lot of them.’

‘Then, home,’ said Avion, sighing a smile.
I feel bad. Maybe there's a reason for you to give reader the order information, but thing is, you could had done it in a description and let the flow carry the reader throughout the scene. Instead, you take the reader out from the tensile flow and plant him or her in middle of the dialogue which gives the audience so little.

Then there's another thing and this is the same thing I've said to Bowler1 - "dialogue," said, action. - looks jerky. Make a decision to go with the tag or then use descriptive action, not both.
‘But just how long will it take to charge?’ asked Marley.

To that, the leader looked hesitant, and worried. ‘That, I cannot say. The Soulus is volatile . . . The Vaidriant Sphera’s Light may simply refuse to shine in a place such as this, where its villain resides.’ A little uncertainty pricked his sullen, troubled face. ‘I’ve . . . never had to fight down here before. Krieliss is their territory. Their advantage. It’d only be wise to imagine what makes the Light here glimmer so sparsely.’ He raised his head skyward, as if to challenge the very night, noticing the worried way his men shifted. (headhop) ‘All I hope is that I can lead you as capably down here as anywhere else.’

The soldiers didn’t respond. They didn’t want anyone’s guard lowered by words of comfort or kindness. They would wait, and let the battle decide how their leader fared here of all places. Krieliss was a place where night seemed endless. A place where winds cut like daggers, where mountains were earth-born claws, and where screams blew like gales from the emptiest hollows. It wasn’t moonlight, lamplight, or candlelight Loc spoke about. It was a light of their own. A different Light. Something brighter, and truly unwelcome in a land like this.

To be honest, I don't feel the story any more, and I'm now looking technicalities instead of focusing on the characters or to the plot. But thing is, you developed a hook at the very beginning of this chapter and now it's just simply gone because of all these technical problems.

If you would had used the Avion constantly then I would had been more accepting. But you didn't, as you felt that you need to drop in the leader's perspective instead of letting his characteristics being played through Avion's thoughts and observations.

‘Avion,’ the leader went on, ‘I want you to keep the Ethereal in a form befitting a firearm (what is this thing?). Attend to the enemies of the air.’

Avion nodded and reached into a sealed pocket of his belt, from which he produced what looked like a glowing orb. It shimmered, though sat still. Yet there was something about the way it shimmer which promised it held great worth, and value.

The soldier focussed hard with the orb in his grasp, and felt it slowly reshape. The air – the very reality – around it began rippling, warping as the bizarre object performed its shifting dance. Within seconds, the orb had grown, moulded, reshaped into something peculiar but brutal. Something like a bow-gun, resting firmly in Avion’s grasp. The others watched, and none did so much as blink.

Everyone rose, clutching their weapons tight, trying to block out the sounds of those Endbringer hordes, writhing in their masses. The Endbringers they were about to leap into the midst of.

The last moments of peace were then shattered by a roar from the lightless, thorn-like trees behind them. A beast, lithe as a lion, built like a bear, but bigger than both, leapt for them from those woods. An Endbringer at last.
You go too distant here, and I certainly don't want to mark whole sections with a red paint. And I don't know how much it would help you if I'd had rewritten these things in closer perspective. This is your story. So you'll choose the way you want it go forward, but for me, I'd had put this piece on floor and picked something else from the shelve.
Marley was the one to react. His battlestaff struck the beast clean across the face, swiping by its eyes. The creature was blinded, and what followed for it was a fatal stab through the skull. It fell, having been mere inches from ravaging Marley’s neck. He knew how to deal with this particular sort of Endbringer. He and the others had been selected for this assignment for a reason.

‘Now!’ Loc bellowed. ‘Each of you, I want to see you down there now!’ He was now well aware they hadn’t any time to waste. The soldiers leapt over the edge – an act that’d be declared insane by anyone else. But each knew their mission, each knew their strengths, and each knew their foes’ weakness. Their kind weren’t as quick to fall as the demon on the clifftop, so long as the slightest shard of hope still shimmered.

A capable swordarm was nothing without inner strength to keep it steady.

~~~~~

I should probably mention: The narrative might have seemed a bit distant, but there is in fact a reason for this, given by the end of the chapter. Still, please say so if it came across as bothersome.

It did. I'm sorry. :( Please let me know if you need help on developing a closer perspective.
 
Hi Tecdavid,

I'm fairly new to this, but as no-one's bit my head off as of yet I shall tentatively keep going... Overall I found it well written & atmospheric.

(Rather than writing it, I've altered the paragraphs to where I'd break them if it were me.)

~~~~~~

The clear night sky did little to please the soldiers in black. Their uniforms, dark and durable, melded well against their cool, still surroundings: the forest-covered valley. A silence was shared between the five men, doing well to keep them discreet[not sure this is the best word], though it wasn’t long before the group’s most restless member stood up to gaze over the night-steeped cliffside. That hardy helmet of his helped hide his enthusiasm, and his anxiety [if it's night his face'd be already hidden].

‘Can’t you feel them?’ he muttered. ‘I can. Sharper than ever before, I’d reckon.’ He almost jittered with anticipation.

A rotund soldier, wielding what appeared to be a lance, tried to soothe the man.
‘Think of it like any other assignment: we head down, we force our way through, we leave fretting for later. We know you care for a little slaying, so be thankful the pickings are rich. Endbringers are hardly the most coordinated marks, Avion. You should know not to let their numbers scare you.’[not sure if marks short for marksman?]

Avion slowed- does that mean they're walking, only when restless member stood up earlier I thought they were squatting in hiding.
Avion slowed and nodded quietly. There was something very strange about Endbringers. The very sight of so many could mould your emotions like putty, riling your mind, sending your senses into a frenzy. They all knew it. The peculiar beings crept through the shadows, through the murk, through each and every nook and cranny your mind would never dare think about. Places where you could only envision fear being spun and woven. That’s where they spawned, and what better place to suit them than here? Amidst this particular valley? [nice para.]

Avion hated the place. His company weren’t at all keen on it either.

‘Loc!’ Avion hollered. The squad leader was rather used to the nickname [bit ambiguous if you're referring to Loc or Avion (if I'm not being thick)]. ‘It’s started, I can see it! They’ve begun to swarm.’

Next sentence has 2 adverbs. Oh no. Maybe, "The other soldiers rushed from the shadows to join Avion..."
The soldiers’ heads shot up, suddenly tense, and they quickly joined Avion overlooking the cliffside. The valley beneath was filled with twisted trees, like a monstrous mouth filled with fangs. Thousands of tangled & chaotic branches reached up to a cold, merciless moon, all tangled and chaotic. The Endbringers had grown restless. Something odd filled their still, plagued hearts tonight. Only through an occasional gap in the forest’s muddle[harsher word? stranglehold?] could the soldiers see the swarm.[good para]

Leader's already mentioned, if it's Loc, so can use his name.
Their leader turned to the lancer, ‘Warze, fend off their largest for as long as possible. Overpower any if you get even the slightest chance, but for the Light’s sake, pull back if they grow too troublesome. We cannot afford even the slightest casualty. Not tonight. Not with so few of us.’Warze nodded, still peering down into that ever-darkening maw.

‘Vorne, you’ll fight alongside him. Back him up if the situation demands it.’ Loc took a quick look over the edge himself. ‘And tonight, we may very well need all the help we can get.’ A blade-wielding soldier, slim, long-limbed and silent, gave a simple nod.
‘Marley, you’ll join me in the battle behind Warze and Vorne. We’ll keep the littler ilk at bay until the Soulus charges. Only then will we have a chance at besting the lot of them.’

‘Then, home,’ said Avion, sighing a smile.
[had envisaged it too dark to see expressions unless well moonlit, maybe it's a full moon]

‘But just how long will it take to charge?’ asked Marley.

To that, the leader looked hesitant, and worried. ‘That, I cannot say. The Soulus is volatile . . . The Vaidriant Sphera’s Light may simply refuse to shine in a place such as this, where its villain resides.’ A little uncertainty pricked his sullen, troubled face. ‘I’ve . . . never had to fight down here before. Krieliss is their territory. Their advantage. It’d only be wise to imagine what makes the Light here glimmer so sparsely.’ He raised his head skyward, as if to challenge the very night, noticing the worried way his men shifted. ‘All I hope is that I can lead you as capably down here as anywhere else.’

The soldiers didn’t respond. They didn’t want anyone’s guard lowered by words of comfort or kindness. They would wait, and let the battle decide how their leader fared here of all places. Krieliss was a place where night seemed endless. A place where winds cut like daggers, where mountains were earth-born claws[nice], and where screams blew like gales from the emptiest hollows. It wasn’t moonlight, lamplight, or candlelight Loc spoke about. It was a light of their own. A different Light. Something brighter, and truly unwelcome in a land like this.

‘Avion,’ the leader went on, ‘I want you to keep the Ethereal in a form befitting a firearm. Attend to the enemies of the air.’

Avion nodded and reached into a sealed pocket of his belt, from which he produced what looked like a glowing orb. It shimmered, though sat still. Yet there was something about that shimmer which promised it held great worth, and value.

The soldier focussed hard with the orb in his grasp, and felt it slowly reshape. The air – the very reality – around it began rippling, warping as the bizarre object performed its shifting dance. Within seconds, the orb had grown, moulded, reshaped into something peculiar but brutal. Something like a bow-gun, resting firmly in Avion’s grasp. The others watched, and none did so much as blink. [really well written couple of para's]

Everyone rose, clutching their weapons tight, trying to block out the sounds of those Endbringer hordes, writhing in their masses. The Endbringers they were about to leap into the midst of.

The last moments of peace were then shattered by a roar from the lightless, thorn-like trees behind them. A beast, lithe as a lion, built like a bear, but bigger than both, leapt for them from those woods. An Endbringer at last.

Or maybe just, 'In a flash, Marley's battlestaff...' Could have some audio here, the creature's blood-curdling wail or it's piercing shriek of primal agony.
Marley was the one to react. His battlestaff struck the beast clean across the face, swiping by its eyes. The creature was blinded, and what followed for it was a fatal stab through the skull. It fell, having been mere inches from ravaging Marley’s neck. He knew how to deal with this particular sort of Endbringer. He and the others had been selected for this assignment for a reason.

‘Now!’ Loc bellowed. ‘Each of you, I want to see you down there now!’ He was now well aware they hadn’t any time to waste. The soldiers leapt over the edge – an act that’d be declared insane by anyone else. But each knew their mission, each knew their strengths, and each knew their foes’ weakness. Their kind weren’t as quick to fall as the demon on the clifftop, so long as the slightest shard of hope still shimmered.

A capable swordarm was nothing without inner strength to keep it steady.

~~~~~


Great opening scene.

 


The clear night sky did little to please the soldiers in black. Their uniforms, dark and durable, melded well against their cool, still surroundings: the forest-covered valley (I would cut the underlined part as it didn't flow for me and felt too much). A silence was shared between the five men, doing well to keep them discreet, though it wasn’t long before the group’s most restless member stood up to gaze over the night-steeped cliffside. That hardy helmet of his helped hide his enthusiasm, and his anxiety. (Cut, you're telling some here, more show less tell)

‘Can’t you feel them?’ he muttered. ‘I can. Sharper than ever before, I’d reckon.’ He almost jittered with anticipation. A rotund soldier, wielding what appeared to be a lance, tried to soothe the man.

‘Think of it like any other assignment: we head down, we force our way through, we leave fretting for later. We know you care for a little slaying, so be thankful the pickings are rich. Endbringers are hardly the most coordinated marks, Avion. You should know not to let their numbers scare you.’

Avion slowed and nodded quietly. There was something very strange about Endbringers. The very sight of so many could mould your emotions like putty, riling your mind, sending your senses into a frenzy. They all knew it. The peculiar beings crept through the shadows, through the murk, through each and every nook and cranny your mind would never dare think about. Places where you could only envision fear being spun and woven. That’s where they spawned, and what better place to suit them than here? Amidst this particular valley? (Lots of telling instead of showing here... you have a real chance to describe how he sees them "crept through the shadows, through the murk, through each and every nook and cranny" is more like what you should be doing, not " riling your mind, sending your senses into a frenzy".)

Avion hated the place (Don't tel, show). His company weren’t at all keen on it either.

‘Loc!’ Avion hollered. The squad leader was rather used to the nickname. ‘It’s started, I can see it! They’ve begun to swarm.’

The soldiers’ heads shot up, suddenly tense, and they quickly joined Avion overlooking the cliffside. The valley beneath was filled with twisted trees, like a monstrous mouth filled with fangs. Thousands of branches reached up to a cold, merciless moon, all tangled and chaotic. The Endbringers had grown restless. Something odd filled their still, plagued hearts tonight. Only through an occasional gap in the forest’s muddle could the soldiers see the swarm. (Other than the underlined bits I think you should cut, this paragraph is a good example how you can get things to the reader without telling.)

Their leader turned to the lancer,
‘Warze, fend off their largest for as long as possible. Overpower any if you get even the slightest chance, but for the Light’s sake, pull back if they grow too troublesome. We cannot afford even the slightest casualty. Not tonight. Not with so few of us.’
Warze nodded, still peering down into that ever-darkening maw.

‘Vorne, you’ll fight alongside him. Back him up if the situation demands it.’ He took a quick look over the edge himself. ‘And tonight, we may very well need all the help we can get.’ A blade-wielding soldier, slim, long-limbed and silent, gave a simple nod.
‘Marley, you’ll join me in the battle behind Warze and Vorne. We’ll keep the littler ilk at bay until the Soulus charges. Only then will we have a chance at besting the lot of them.’

‘Then, home,’ said Avion, sighing a smile.

‘But just how long will it take to charge?’ asked Marley.
(this type of dialogue and structure is easy to follow compared to that of the below.)

To that, the leader looked hesitant, and worried. ‘That, I cannot say. The Soulus is volatile . . . The Vaidriant Sphera’s Light may simply refuse to shine in a place such as this, where its villain resides.’ A little uncertainty pricked his sullen, troubled face. ‘I’ve . . . never had to fight down here before. Krieliss is their territory. Their advantage. It’d only be wise to imagine what makes the Light here glimmer so sparsely.’ He raised his head skyward, as if to challenge the very night, noticing the worried way his men shifted. ‘All I hope is that I can lead you as capably down here as anywhere else.’ (Too much going on like most of your dialogue, I think you should make it smoother, less packed.)

The soldiers didn’t respond. (The next bit just explains the first bit, buut you should have confidence in yourself and in your reader that they don't need you to explain things that should be coming to them anyway) They didn’t want anyone’s guard lowered by words of comfort or kindness. They would wait, and let the battle decide how their leader fared here of all places. Krieliss was a place where night seemed endless. A place where winds cut like daggers, where mountains were earth-born claws, and where screams blew like gales from the emptiest hollows. It wasn’t moonlight, lamplight, or candlelight Loc spoke about. It was a light of their own. A different Light. Something brighter, and truly unwelcome in a land like this. (I like it when you go all poetic, but that's just me)

‘Avion,’ the leader went on, ‘I want you to keep the Ethereal in a form befitting a firearm. Attend to the enemies of the air.’

Avion nodded and reached into a sealed pocket of his belt, from which he produced what looked like a glowing orb (Is it a glowing orb or not? "What looked like" isn't strong writing). It shimmered, though sat still. Yet there was something about that shimmer which promised it held great worth, and value.

The soldier focussed hard with the orb in his grasp, and felt it slowly reshape. The air – the very reality – around it (cut underlined) began rippling, warping as the bizarre object performed its shifting dance. Within seconds (weak, much like "what looked like"), the orb had grown, moulded, reshaped into something peculiar but brutal. Something like (weak again) a bow-gun, resting firmly in Avion’s grasp. The others watched, and none did so much as blink. (You aren't very confident about what this orb actually is? Or you doubt the reader can imagine what you see, either way it comes through and into your writing here)

Everyone rose, clutching their weapons tight, trying to block out the sounds of those Endbringer hordes, writhing in their masses. The Endbringers they were about to leap into the midst of.

The last moments of peace were then shattered by a roar from the lightless, thorn-like trees behind them. A beast, lithe as a lion, built like a bear, but bigger than both, leapt for them from those woods. An Endbringer at last. (I really like the last two paragraphs)

Marley was the one to react. His battlestaff struck the beast clean across the face, swiping by its eyes. The creature was blinded, and what followed for it was a fatal stab through the skull. It fell, having been mere inches from ravaging Marley’s neck. He knew how to deal with this particular sort of Endbringer (cut, it's obvious he does). He and the others had been selected for this assignment for a reason. (same, you're explaining stuff mid action, it will only slow it down.)

‘Now!’ Loc bellowed. ‘Each of you, I want to see you down there now!’ He was now well aware they hadn’t any time to waste. The soldiers leapt over the edge – an act that’d be declared insane by anyone else. But each knew their mission, each knew their strengths, and each knew their foes’ weakness. Their kind weren’t as quick to fall as the demon on the clifftop, so long as the slightest shard of hope still shimmered.

A capable swordarm was nothing without inner strength to keep it steady.

Like I said in the earlier post, I like the theme and other than your dialogue, followed it easily. Have more confidence in yourself and your reader, stop telling instead of showing and clear up the dialogue / tags, and I think you're onto something.
 
The word well in "doing well to keep" echoes too strongly for me from "melded well against." If it were me, I'd change one or the other.

It seems to me that jittering is something that would be difficult to almost do. Either it's done, or it isn't?

I get the same weird echo with "we know you care for a little slaying" and "you should know not to let." The word know echoes strangely in my ears here.

The valley beneath was filled with twisted trees, like a monstrous mouth filled with fangs. Thousands of branches reached up to a cold, merciless moon, all tangled and chaotic.

Yes! Love that first line. The "all tangled and chaotic" dangles for me though, as it seems to describe the moon at first.

Not so sure about sighing a smile. Hard for me to see that action. Made me stop to try.

Where you say it may refuse to shine in a place such as this, where its villain resides, I'd probably say enemy or even arch-enemy, or maybe nemesis. I don't really think of villain the same way as I do those other terms, as part of a pair.

In talking about fighting down here, "down here" again echoes strangely for me. Maybe because it is so ambiguous?


A place where winds cut like daggers, where mountains were earth-born claws, and where screams blew like gales from the emptiest hollows.

Yes! Great stuff, that.

"It shimmered, though sat still" falls short for me as a description. Not sure what to make of it.

A beast, lithe as a lion, built like a bear, but bigger than both, leapt for them from those woods.

Nice!

‘Now!’ Loc bellowed. ‘Each of you, I want to see you down there now!’ He was now well aware they hadn’t any time to waste.

The now in the prose bit here echoes strangely for me. The "he was now well" now.


OVERALL:

There's a lot of good action here, but its muddled by too many words. Lots of strange, bizarre, etceteras that should come through in the description, not be description themselves, I suppose. Now, I tend toward terse writing, but even if I try to pull away from that stylistic preference, it still seems a bit overwrought.
 
The clear night sky did little to please the soldiers in black.
The 1st sentence should be clear if nothing else and I'm wondering what the sky pleasing some soldiers has to do with anything.
Since this is action, a battle looming, minimize adjectives and get on wit it.
Their uniforms (black) melded well (into the) landscape, a forest-covered valley.
I dunno, if this battle is forthcoming, try and get there without pages of characters, objects etc. being introduced first.
 
‘Think of it like any other assignment: we head down, we force our way through, we leave fretting for later. We know you care for a little slaying, so be thankful the pickings are rich. Endbringers are hardly the most coordinated marks, Avion. You should know not to let their numbers scare you.’ – Later you break up long sections of dialogue with character actions and I thought you needed the same here.

The soldiers’ heads shot up,
from where? Just a little more placement would have been nice. suddenly tense, and they quickly joined Avion overlooking the cliffside. The valley beneath was filled with twisted trees, like a monstrous mouth filled with fangs. Thousands of branches reached up to a cold, merciless moon, all tangled and chaotic. The Endbringers had grown restless. Something odd filled their still, plagued hearts tonight. Only through an occasional gap in the forest’s muddle could the soldiers see the swarm.



This is good, but I had the following thoughts.
Some of the dialogue was long and could have been broken up some with character actions. You do this in one section of dialogue, but not in others.
Emotion as well, are they scared etc.
Placement and description, I’d have liked more for a clearer picture of what is happening. Heads shot up by a cliff, but from where? How tall was the cliff, did the Endbringers climb the cliff – the Endbringer leaps from the woods, from the woods over/up a cliff, I’m not sure.
You give me a lot of information very quickly and because of the speed the information was given, I’m left feeling a little confused.
Do we need all the characters all at once?
To really confuse you and be unhelpful, I liked a lot of the descriptions used and the images given.
Less can sometimes be more and let the reader join you, showing not telling.
What’s the rush, set the scene slowly and build tension.
I liked a lot of the images and ideas, I really did. It was just too much information at a fast pace that lost me near the end.

I’ve just read the above and it’s a bit random, so sorry about that. Hopefully of some help!
 
Hmm, I think I'm noticing a pattern here, and I think I know exactly which bad idea of mine is to blame... :D
What I'm gathering is that the imagery and descriptions are rather good, but there's call for more detail in some places, and less in others. More importantly, though, the distant PoV is a problem. Because of it, there's less emotion and attachment to the characters, leading to a lot of 'telling', instead of 'showing'.
It's irrelevant to the actual quality of the piece, but here's the reason for that PoV: I wanted the PoV to seem as if we were looking down upon the scene, and not through any character's eyes, because it is a dream/illusion experienced by a different character, who is introduced by the chapter's end. This opening serves something like a "foreshadowing prologue". I didn't want to make the PoV too close, as I worried it would form a closer connection between Avion and the reader, making the dreaming character's "awakening" so much more jarring. That said, I've heard bad things about dream-based openings, so maybe I'll try posting that alternate chapter sometime...

I'll try redrafting this. It's apparent now that distant PoVs are disengaging, regardless of whether there's a reason for them. (I can safely say every other scene in the story is closer than this one, PoV-wise.) If I work on telling the scene through Avion's eyes, would anyone be willing to give it another go? :)

One thing I'd like to ask about your critique, Ctg: You mention about the line, "suddenly tense, and they quickly joined Avion overlooking the cliffside" being poorly described. Looking at the rest of the feedback regarding description, I'm not sure what would make it better. Did you have something in mind that could improve it?


[FONT=&quot]Thanks for giving it a read, everyone. It's a scary thing when you think a scene is perfectly fine aside from a few wee flaws, only to learn those few flaws are the tip of the iceberg. :p
[/FONT]
 

[FONT=&quot]Thanks for giving it a read, everyone. It's a scary thing when you think a scene is perfectly fine aside from a few wee flaws, only to learn those few flaws are the tip of the iceberg. :p
[/FONT]

That's why putting things up for critique is fun, most of the time. You get to learn and improve if you manage to figure out that not everything everyone says will help you.

There will be people who hate what you do and still comment on style or theme, but these people you will learn to ignore. What's important is understanding why people have said / commented on certain bits and deciding if it's actually going to help you.
 
Prologues seem to cause as many problems as they fix from what I've seen over the last few months. Mine was trying for a distant snapshot as well as an introduction, and I bombed big time. I've now jumped directly in with the characters and kicked my prologue into touch, but what's right for me won't be right for you.

From CN above, it's not so much members that hate your stuff but what they say. I've commented on style that I've not liked, I've said so, and still rated the writing as good. The point is still well made, but I still fiddled with CN's point! ;)
 
Your original:

The clear night sky did little to please the soldiers in black. Their uniforms, dark and durable, melded well against their cool, still surroundings: the forest-covered valley. A silence was shared between the five men, doing well to keep them discreet, though it wasn’t long before the group’s most restless member stood up to gaze over the night-steeped cliffside. That hardy helmet of his helped hide his enthusiasm, and his anxiety.

‘Can’t you feel them?’ he muttered. ‘I can. Sharper than ever before, I’d reckon.’ He almost jittered with anticipation. A rotund soldier, wielding what appeared to be a lance, tried to soothe the man.

‘Think of it like any other assignment: we head down, we force our way through, we leave fretting for later. We know you care for a little slaying, so be thankful the pickings are rich. Endbringers are hardly the most coordinated marks, Avion. You should know not to let their numbers scare you.’

Avion slowed and nodded quietly. There was something very strange about Endbringers. The very sight of so many could mould your emotions like putty, riling your mind, sending your senses into a frenzy. They all knew it. The peculiar beings crept through the shadows, through the murk, through each and every nook and cranny your mind would never dare think about. Places where you could only envision fear being spun and woven. That’s where they spawned, and what better place to suit them than here? Amidst this particular valley?

Avion hated the place. His company weren’t at all keen on it either.

‘Loc!’ Avion hollered. The squad leader was rather used to the nickname. ‘It’s started, I can see it! They’ve begun to swarm.’

The soldiers’ heads shot up, suddenly tense, and they quickly joined Avion overlooking the cliffside. The valley beneath was filled with twisted trees, like a monstrous mouth filled with fangs. Thousands of branches reached up to a cold, merciless moon, all tangled and chaotic. The Endbringers had grown restless. Something odd filled their still, plagued hearts tonight. Only through an occasional gap in the forest’s muddle could the soldiers see the swarm.

My edits:

The clear night sky did little to please the soldiers in black. Yet, they were able to trust their uniforms, dark and durable, melded well against their cool, still surroundings: the forest-covered valley. But even then it wasn't wasn’t long before the group’s most restless member gazed over the calmly waving grassy cliff top.

"Can’t you feel them?" Avion muttered. "Because I surely can. Sharper than ever before, I’d reckon."

A rotund stopped next to him and poked a lance end in ground before he laid a hand on Avon's shoulder. "Think it like any other assignment: we head down, force our way through them and leave all that fretting for later."
Then he glanced the others coming to stand on their side. "In fact, don't think that, but think about how rich you're going to be later on. Endbringers are hardly the most coordinated punch, and with all that chaos going around, the slaying is going to be easy."

Avion nodded quietly. But he couldn't stop thinking there was something very strange about Endbringers. The very sight of so many could mould your emotions like putty, rile your mind and sending your senses into a frenzy. And they all knew about it. But none of them mention it even though he felt abnormal fear spun from every nook and cranny of his mind.

This was the place where they spawned, and what better place to suit them than here? Amidst this particular valley?


Avion hated the place. And he was sure that his companions weren’t at all keen on it either.

Then it happened... the twisted trees started pulling up their roots as their horribly disfigured mouths filled with fangs.

"Loc!" Avion hollered. "It’s started, I can see it! They’ve begun to swarm."

The soldiers’ moved forward to gaze down in the valley, where thousands of branches reached up towards the cold and merciless moon.

I'm sorry if it annoys you that I felt necessary to edit the beginning to get down that one line. But I needed to get into his head in order to be fill in the details as I see them fit the story. You got a good story and it starts to creep the people when you fill in the description properly. Someone could it even call it a layer cake, where one thing add up to another - if that makes any sense.
 
Thanks folks! Not only is it helpful to have flaws (or perceived flaws) pointed out, but it's always nice to hear a little reassurance. :D
The chapter is definitely going to be touched up somewhat. I'll try rewriting it in close third-person, rather than distant third-person.

Thanks very much for the suggestions there, Ctg! You actually helped me notice another mistake I'd made, too... Context. I didn't properly clarify the context, so some parts of this excerpt might have seemed a bit unusual! That's another thing I'll need to remember, next time I ask for a Crit or two.
 
It's very well written. Extremely moody and evocative in tone.

I'd probably be able to say more good things about it if I could figure out more of what was going on.

I've read it three times and each time I understood more, but also less.

One thing I am sure of, the commander is one bad example of one. He lets the men talk when they should be silent and even seems to join in when they're amplifying each others fear.
 
Thanks very much, JoanDrake. Yes, some things will be confusing, since... well, this only an excerpt of the first chapter, sadly. I couldn't really add much more without crossing the word limit. I suppose that's one small problem with critiques - you need to be sure you've given everything a good context before posting an excerpt.

As for the squad leader, again this is an example of not enough info being conveyed. Although he's their superior, he doesn't really rank much higher than the rest of them. He's a close friend of the others, too, and the order he belongs to isn't quite so strict with rules, which is why he's willing to talk with them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Tecdavid Critiques 7
Tecdavid Critiques 10
D Writing Discussion 3

Similar threads


Back
Top