Raising Steam

I feel great disturbance in the force...
seriously, i don't know whether to say wow, or ick.
I find the whole idea brain splitting.
I didn't mind when they steampunked up 'the mummy returns', but then that's a movie on a screen.
 
Last edited:
Ankh-Morpork has been pretty much Victorian since The Truth, so I guess it was inevitable. Could be interesting.
 
Has anyone bought it yet? I believe it came out on Thursday (7 November), in the UK at least. I've seen mixed reviews so far - half say it's classic Pratchett, while the other half think he's lost his former wit and facility with words. Can anyone here who has started reading it give an opinion?
 
I'm about 3 chapters in, and at the moment it feels as if I'm reading something from the lower end of the 300-word challenge. Honestly, it reads like bad fan-fiction - and I've never seen as many comma-splices in a published work in my long and varied reading career.

However, I'll reserve a judgement until I've finished it - but at the moment, it doesn't look as if it will be approval. Which is sad, because I've been a TP fan since I bought The Colour of Magic with my 1985 Xmas book-tokens.
 
From more recent books I was left with the impression that TP peaked with Going Postal. He looked so faded at WFC as well - had to leave the "interview".
 
This felt like the plan of a novel rather than the novel itself. You can really feel the quality drop now the poor man is getting ill.
 
Discworld was always in change. The first two book were not only a tale of Rincewind, but also of the end of the golden age of fantasy. Since then Discworld has advanced very considerably both at a technological and a social level. The arrival of steam is, I think, a very expected move in the ever changing world. Indeed automation and machines have happened before (though a certain, rather bony, character put an end to the advance of the farming industry in one book).

I've got the hardback sitting here, though I've not yet read it. I can agree that Making Money almost felt like Going Postal re-written in some ways, though was still a solid fun read. I'm sad to read that many feel that Rising Steam is falling apart some (its a view I've seen mirrored in many communities). Sadly I think Terry had great plans for the evolution of Discworld and that its a great loss to us that we might not see the end (though my honest view is that there likely was never going to be an end).
 
This felt like the plan of a novel rather than the novel itself. You can really feel the quality drop now the poor man is getting ill.

Uh, no?

For my money, the Discworld series is still just as enjoyable as it was at the beginning. I will agree that something has changed in the latest books, but I would not say it was the quality. There has been a change of tone and focus. This change might not be to everyone's taste -- a fair few people seem none too happy with it -- but that does not mean the quality has in any way diminished.

Now you've made me think of it, I'd say that there has been a maturity in the last few that hasn't been there in the rest. That might be because the world is now changing faster than ever before, affecting how the characters interact with it.

And has nobody else been enjoying how much more we are seeing the inner workings of Vetinari?
 
In my opinion, the quality in this one didn't match the others. It really read like a story plan rather than the story itself.
 
Oh and the insight into the patrician lessens the character eventually. He was better a bit more mysterious and used less.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top