The Man Who Wasn't Anders Voss - 1200 words

Status
Not open for further replies.

psychotick

Dangerously confused
Joined
Apr 8, 2011
Messages
2,159
Location
Rotorua, New Zealand
Hi,

Since I got challenged a little in the press realease section to put something up for critique I thought I'd throw out the first couple of pages of my latest - The Man Who Wasn't Anders Voss.

As its already out I guess I can't really change very much, but I am curious as to people's thoughts on the work, and particularly the hook. Does it catch you?

Cheers, Greg.


Chapter One



The man who wasn’t Anders Voss arrived in theworld and screamed.

He wasn’t completely sure why he screamed.There was no point in it. It wasn’t for pain or out of fear. It wasn’t for excitement either. It was simply some sort of reaction to having experienced what he had. To have known what no one should. And to know that one day he would be returning that place. Some might have called that horror, but it wasn't. It was something far more terrible than that. But for whatever reason he did it, it felt right somehow, and he screamed again. And then he screamed some more. He kept doing it until he simply couldn’t any more. Until his throat was raw and his strength gone. And then when he could scream no more he just moaned; trying to come to terms with what was unbearable.

And it was unbearable.

They said that being born was painful. And maybe that was what this was. Maybe babies went through this. He didn’t know.What he did know was that he hadn’t really just been born. Not of childbirth anyway. He’d merely just arrived on the planet. In the universe.

They also said that dying was difficult. And maybe that was why he screamed, because of what he had just done. Save that he knew he hadn’t. He had not died at all. Anders Voss had. And he wasn’t AndersVoss.

He had been though. Once. Sort of. Maybe. It was hard to be sure of such things. But he had all of Anders Voss’ memories. His mind and heart, his flesh. Everything he knew told him he was Anders. But he also knew one thing with absolute certainty; Anders Voss had died. He had felt his passing as his body had been torn apart into a million billion pieces. He had felt his shock and outrage at his passing. And finally he had known the terrible pain of his soul being torn apart along with his flesh. And he had known all of that in the same terrible instant that he had been brought into this universe. Created from those same pieces of him.

He wasn't Anders Voss. He was the thing that had been built from his death. And that death was a part of him.

It was a simple equation really. One man died and another took his place. Another identical man. The same in every respect save one. The soul. Until then he would never have believed there was such a thing. Or actually he wouldn’t have known anything about such things. Anders would not have believed that there was such a thing. But Anders was dead, and he had been born out of his death.

And in all of that he knew one thing above all else. No man should ever have to experience death and live. Not true death. It was knowledge that should never be known by the living. And that knowledge would never leave him.

It might be a simple equation. The scientists no doubt thought that nothing had changed, and as far as all their instruments would be concerned, nothing had. But they would be wrong. Profoundly wrong.

They would be murderers too.

As he lay there, simply trying to come to terms with what had happened, he knew that for the truth. They had led him, led Anders Voss into the arena of Terra Nought, laid him down under the machine knowing that it would kill him. They had to know that since others had gone through the thing, and some had reported back. Those reports had been famous. System wide broadcasts that had been seen a million times over. Broadcasts that he now knew for certain were fakes. Those who had arrived at the other end would have told them what had happened. They would have screamed it at them from the highest mountains. And even before they'd started sending people to the stars with the wave function transport they'd done the testing on Earth. They'd pronounced it safe. So the scientists knew, they'd buried those reports, created new ones, and carried on. That was murder.

But they didn’t care. What was one man’s life when compared with the chance to explore the stars? Nothing. Less than nothing when another identical man was there to take his place. But he guessed that even so not a one of them would ever have stepped into the machine. Not even for the chance to explore other worlds. Because they knew that if they did it, they would never explore those worlds. Other people who looked like them would.

Which finally reminded him of one other matter. He wasn’t on Earth any more.

It was then that he opened his eyes, never realising that they had been shut, and saw the light of this new world. The first light his eyes had ever seen.

It was blue. The sky was a perfect blue above him, which he found comforting. It looked like Earth. Maybe they’d made a mistake and sent him to somewhere much closer to Earth rather than G483 as they’d designated the system. But he doubted it. He doubted it a lot more when he twisted his head to one side and saw jungle. Strange jungle. Trees of funny greens and reds, funny shapes too. They looked like giant mushrooms and ferns, competing with one another for space and light.

It wasn’t Earth.

He lay there for a while trying to take that in. That he was alone on an alien world over a hundred light years from Earth.And that he would never go home again. But then he couldn’t actually go home since this was the only world he’d ever known. He hadn’t been born on Earth. Anders Voss had. He'd never been here before and yet this actually was his home. And the only way back to Earth was to build the machine again and broadcast himself back. But then he would die, and another man, another person who not only wasn’t Anders Voss but who also wasn’t him, would arrive on Earth. Screaming in horror.

There was no other world for him. This was his home. He had been born here and he would die here. And he would never build that evil machine. No matter what they wanted.

Who would build a suicide machine?

And yet as he looked around him at the endless assortment of carry bags and plastic crates full of equipment, he realised that that was exactly what they’d expected him to do. Why? What could possibly make him do something so stupid? Or did they have a plan for that? Did they have a way of forcing him to build it? That thought did not fill him with confidence. He was alone on an alien world with nothing between him and it save the machinery and equipment they had sent him. Maybe they had a way.
 
Last edited:
Hi,

By the way, it seems the cut and paste hasn't worked so well and a number of the words seem to be joined together - not sure why. Rest assured they aren't in the book. I'll hunt through and get as many as I can.

Cheers, Greg.
 
Hi there

Yes, we have that problem with cut and paste sometimes. Not sure why. I think you've got most of the joined words, though, so I haven't interfered and edited it further for you.

Just as an aside, for obvious reasons we don't usually allow pieces for critique which have been already published. However, in the circumstances, we're letting this one through. If you do want help with further work, though, do please let us have something where we can make a difference.

As for the piece itself, for me the first sentence was a good one, but the next paragraph let it down. For my taste, although I can see that you're trying to make it hooky, it was going nowhere, telling us nothing and was too repetitive -- and much could be said of many of the subsequent paragraphs to my mind. You then start telling us back-story in one enormous lump.

It's certainly an intriguing premise, but I'd have suggested you prune this right back, and deleted much, if not all, of the infodumping, and made it tauter and leaner. As it stands, the first line had me, but by the end of the first para I was becoming impatient and before half-way I'd switched off. I'm notoriously impatient, though, so my reactions aren't necessarily a good guide in anything.

Good luck with it.
 
The Judge has judged well.

I too was hooked by the premise and the opening. If we could go forward with NotAnders, have him doing things, trying to prevent something or solve something or even get revenge, I would have gone along for the ride. As it is, I don't even know what the ride is.

The premise may be a trap. You have this fellow who isn't Anders Voss, so at once there's this need to explain *why* he isn't Anders Voss, and hey presto we're in BackStoryLand. But then again maybe you could make that work for you. If you dribble hints and revelations through the action scenes that follow (in the rewrite, that is), then the reader is pulled along, wanting to learn more about the why of it. That also gives you a chance to let the reader learn more about NotAnders, so we like him and root for him.

It's such a good premise, and such a good opening, I really do want to like the rest.
 
Oh, and as for cut-and-paste: Word is your enemy. If you absolutely must write in it, when you go to paste into a forum, do this:

Copy entire document (Ctrl-A, Ctrl-C)
Bring up Notepad (or better yet, Notepad++)
Paste
Fix the formatting *there*
Copy corrected text
Paste into the forum


A little tedious, but did I mention Word is your enemy?
 
I liked this: I've always been horrified by the teleporters in Star Trek.

The staccato punctuation style you have chosen. Is it deliberate? There isn't a conjunction in sight. Unless it starts a sentence. It can be effective. But one might start to tire of it.
 
I coudn't finish. It was rough going wading through the first paragraph, and I drowned in the wishy washy verbosity somewhere around "They would be murderers too."

My issue is with the author's voice. I think there is a character there, under all that equivocating language, but I didn't hear from that character at all. Instead, far too many words are used to say far too little, and nothing is said, it seems, that isn't shrouded in deliberate, mechanical attempts by the author to avoid committing to saying anything at all.

Too much of what is defined is only defined through negation. And is the character really as casual as this narration? Is he really so accepting of his fate, whatever that is? There were three or four uses of the words "simply" and/or "merely" before I stopped reading, which, when combined with all the apophatic definitions, gave the authorial voice a pretty ho hum tone; a tone that doesn't make any sense at all for a character who has just came into the world screaming...

Anyway. I know this is bluntly put, but I think it's a reaction to feeling manipulated by the oblique nature of the prose up to that point, which seems specially constructed to draw out the revelation of some secret something or other that the author is keeping hidden. Ideally, like a good magic trick, I shouldn't be able to see the mechanics of how this is done at all; as a fellow writer, I'm looking for them, so I see them, but even then, I should be impressed with the subtlety of it, but these constructions are just not subtle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top