Beginning/Prologue (1179 words)

Status
Not open for further replies.

wulfsbane

Don't Believe In Fate
Joined
Apr 26, 2013
Messages
84
Yay, finally doing my first critique! I've been writing a while, on and off, but certainly not as long as many of the people on these forums. This is the beginning of something I'm writing. I guess you could call it a WIP, but the first section is all I have written so far. I would have posted entire first section but it's a couple hundred words over the limit. This section takes place many years before the events of the book, so it is a prologue of sorts. The story will still follow the main character of this section, though. I'm interested in any criticism you have, really any feedback at all. Don't hold back. I can take it. :)


------------------------------------------------------------------------


Rin looked out across the plain at the foreign army, its flags raised and billowing in the wind. He was afraid, but he was resolved not to show it. Vallus always told him never to show his fear. Never show weakness, to the enemy or to your men, he’d said. Someday, I’ll command an army, Rin thought. I’ll be a great leader, just like him, uniting men from many tribes to a common purpose. Looking out at them, the army of the Blood Men looked huge, but he knew that Vallus’s army was bigger. Three thousand Soltish warriors, the men said, against the two thousand of their enemy. Victory was almost certain, they said. Despite the favorable odds, Rin could not shake the fear that clung to his mind. We may win, he thought, but I could die. Friends could die.

“You ready, boy?” a voice behind him said.

Rin turned to see Vallus, a faint grin on his face, as he leaned on his spear.

“Yes. I am ready,” Rin said, trying to sound confident.

“Good. Remember, no fear. I hear that these Blood Men do not begin their battle training until they are men. You are young, and they will think you weak, a green boy. Let’s give them a lesson. A deadly one. Now mount up, it’s time to crush these spineless northerners. We’ll show your father that these men die like any others, eh?”

Rin, began to smile, “Aye sir. We will.”

“That’s the spirit, son. You’ll make a fine leader someday.”

Vallus rode off to gather the men, and Rin’s fear receded. They would win, and he would survive. It would be a glorious battle, the first step towards retaking the lands that the Blood Men had stolen. Though Vallus was his grandfather, he was the father that Rin always wished he’d had. Maybe father will finally see sense after we win this battle, he thought. He might finally come out from behind his walls of cowardice and join the fight. He would no longer be able to say that it was pointless to fight the Blood Men.

Rin ran through the camp, heading to his tent to prepare for battle. He donned his lizard-scale armor and found his spear and skor, a short handled stone weapon made for close combat. Its blade was a short piece of flint, and its pommel was a jagged stone spike. He went and found his D’rak lizard mount basking in the sun. He mounted the large reptilian beast and guided it over to his place in the battle lines. Most of the men had already formed up, creating a line of riders, and more were streaming in. He could see Vallus at the front, holding his spear above his head.

“It has been many years since the Blood Men first pushed us from our lands,” Vallus shouted, “They think us no more than simple savages. A nuisance to be dealt with quickly. But we will show them that they have made a fatal mistake. Every one of you is worth five of those men out there. They have underestimated us and we will make them pay the price!”

A great cheer rose from the Soltish army and three thousand spears were leveled as they advanced towards the enemy on their D’rak lizards. They picked up speed as they crossed the plain. Rin could see the enemy forming a defensive line of spears. His heart beat faster as they drew close. Four-hundred paces. Arrows flew out at him. He ducked his head behind the horns of his D’rak, feeling the vibrations of arrows glancing off the bony horns. Out of the corner of his eye, he saw a man fall from his mount, an arrow through his eye. Three-hundred paces. He leaned low over his mount, bracing his spear under his arm so he could hold it with one hand. Two-hundred paces. He picked out a target and held his spear steady. One-hundred. He screamed a war cry. Fifty. Impact.

There was an explosion of carnage as the charge smashed into enemy lines. A jolt went up Rin’s arm as his spear ripped through the man’s leather armor and tore through his chest. He screamed, his face contorted in agony. Rin jumped off his D’rak with the man still impaled on his spear.

He was still alive, blood pouring from the hole in his chest. Rin felt a sudden disgust with himself. He is an enemy, he reminded himself. They are the enemy. They deserve to die. Trying not to look at his twitching body, Rin pulled the spear from the dying man. When he looked around, all he saw was chaos. Fighting was everywhere. D’rak lizards rampaged through the fray, killing Solts as well as Blood Men in their frenzy.

Rin heard something behind him and whipped around just in time to parry a spear thrust from an enemy soldier. All thoughts of right and wrong fled. There was only survival. He had to kill this man to survive, so that was what he was going to do. The man made another thrust, and Rin parried it, sprinting to close on him. His skor was out in a second, stabbing at the man’s neck, where he was unarmored. The man dropped his spear later than he should have, but even so his hand snapped out and his grip closed around Rin’s wrist. His other fist smashed into Rin’s temple. Rin fought through the pain and twisted his wrist out of the man’s grasp, blocking another punch with his free hand. He feinted with his skor at the man’s gut and, as he moved to block, Rin took his opportunity.

The man gasped in pain as Rin’s skor found his neck, ripping into soft flesh. The man fell to the ground and Rin moved on. Rin was not sure how much time passed, but soon he could hear Vallus’s voice shouting above the clamor of battle, calling them to regroup on him. He joined the growing mass of Solts surrounding their leader, grouping for another charge. The enemy was fleeing, every single one of them. Victory, Rin thought, we have won! The men were looking up at Vallus, cheering as he raised his bloody spear in the air.

Suddenly, as Rin watched Vallus, an arrow streaked through the air, lodging in the leader’s neck. He tried to cry out as blood filled his throat, but fell to the ground instead, drowning in his own blood. The men stood in shocked silence, looking at the lone archer who had fired the arrow. He stood across a field of corpses, massive bow in hand, and making no move to run. Rin was stunned. Vallus, dead? He had seemed so invincible. Leaders didn’t die, their troops died for them. Somehow, Rin had never expected that Vallus would die so easily, like any common soldier. After a couple seconds of shock, the anger began to bubble through. He would make the Blood Men pay for killing his leader.
 
Welcome and good job on posting a first crit! Overall I thought it was fine, though it didn't give me much to instantly like about these characters. Throwing them straight into battle without any buildup left me a bit cold. The ending was affecting, but only intellectually - I know that Rin is angry and upset, but I don't feel any of that myself.

Maybe having another couple of paragraphs in the camp, where Vellus does something we (as readers) really like might set these characters up a bit more for us to care about them. I would appreciate that more than to only see him with his warface on.

Rin, began to smile
Rogue comma!

a voice behind him said.
Rin heard something behind him
I feel like being specific in these cases would benefit you. In the former case, I found it a bit unlikely that he wouldn't recognise Vallus's voice (though only on reflection). As for the latter, I guess it would be difficult to hear things over the general clangour of the battle - so I wondered what noise he had managed to hear and single out in particular.
 
I found this very readable --a young man's initiation into battle. It doesn't read like a prologue to me though but I'd probably have to read a lot more before I'd know if it worked that way.

One small point to do with ambiguity of pronoun:

'Suddenly, as Rin watched Vallus, an arrow streaked through the air, lodging in the leader’s neck. He tried to cry out as blood filled his throat, but fell to the ground instead, drowning in his own blood.'

Who he? Rin is POV watching Vallus but suddenly we jump to Vallus.
 
Congratulations on your first post for critique.
Overall, it's not bad. The descriptions of the primitive warriors, their equipment and the bloody battle are okay.
Quibbles:
"Rin looked out across the plain at the foreign army, its flags raised and billowing in the wind." A clumsy sentence.
" feeling the vibrations of arrows glancing off the bony horns. " I doubt it.
"He tried to cry out as blood filled his throat," - which 'he'?

Given that this is a prologue set many years in advance, I wonder if describing a battle is the best way of introducing your setting and characters? Perhaps think about cutting the battle, and just have the character-drama and scene of Before and After?
 
Rin looked out across the plain at the foreign army, its flags raised and billowing in the wind. He was afraid, but he was resolved not to show it. Vallus always told him never to show his fear. Here is three lines about fear, one or two would have done. Never show weakness, to the enemy or to your men, he’d said. Someday, I’ll command an army, Rin thought. I’ll be a great leader, just like him, uniting men from many tribes to a common purpose. Looking out at them, the army of the Blood Men looked huge, but he knew that Vallus’s army was bigger. Three thousand Soltish warriors, the men said, against the two thousand of their enemy. Victory was almost certain, they said. Despite the favorable odds, Rin could not shake the fear that clung to his mind. We may win, he thought, but I could die. Friends could die. – It’s not a bad opening but it goes on too long and needs to be tighter.

“You ready, boy?” a voice behind him said.

Rin turned to see Vallus, a faint grin on his face, as he leaned on his spear.
– There is more from Vallus but he’s never described, what does he look like. While I’m at it, what does the battle field look like, there’s very little background given.

“Yes. I am ready,” Rin said, trying to sound confident.

“Good. Remember, no fear. I hear that these Blood Men do not begin their battle training until they are men. You are young, and they will think you weak, a green boy. Let’s give them a lesson. A deadly one. Now mount up, it’s time to crush these spineless northerners. We’ll show your father that these men die like any others, eh?”
– A big chunk of dialogue, with no character actions or anything to add depth.

Rin, began to smile, “Aye sir. We will.”

“That’s the spirit, son. You’ll make a fine leader someday.”
– Repeating fear and leadership from the intro in the dialogue – so let me guess, he becomes a great leader? Even if Rin doesn’t become the great leader in your plot, it’s what I’m now expecting and I’m only a few lines in. So your showing too much.

Vallus rode off to gather the men, and Rin’s fear receded. They would win, and he would survive. It would be a glorious battle, the first step towards retaking the lands that the Blood Men had stolen. Though Vallus was his grandfather, he was the father that Rin always wished he’d had. Maybe father will finally see sense after we win this battle, he thought. He might finally come out from behind his walls of cowardice and join the fight. He would no longer be able to say that it was pointless to fight the Blood Men.
– Not a bad bit of plot development here.

Rin ran through the camp, heading to his tent to prepare for battle. He donned his lizard-scale armor and found his spear and skor, a short handled stone weapon made for close combat. Its blade was a short piece of flint, and its pommel was a jagged stone spike. He went and found his D’rak lizard mount basking in the sun. He mounted the large reptilian beast and guided it over to his place in the battle lines. Most of the men had already formed up, creating a line of riders, and more were streaming in. He could see Vallus at the front, holding his spear above his head.
– So, we start on the battle field – then Rin runs off to get dressed for battle and then runs back to the battle. I’m wondering why the enemy don’t just attack the undressed and badly prepared Soltish army while they had the chance? This whole section was an aside that ruined the pace and tension of the pending battle.

“It has been many years since the Blood Men first pushed us from our lands,” Vallus shouted, “They think us no more than simple savages. A nuisance to be dealt with quickly. But we will show them that they have made a fatal mistake. Every one of you is worth five of those men out there. They have underestimated us and we will make them pay the price!”
– No actions, no descriptions, just dialogue. Me the reader has no images, nothing has been given to place me in the scene.

A great cheer rose from the Soltish army and three thousand
– did someone count the men. Sorry 3,001, you have to go home, we only need 3,000 today. spears were leveled as they advanced – advanced how? towards the enemy on their D’rak lizards. They picked up speed as they crossed the plain. Rin could see the enemy forming a defensive line of spears. His heart beat faster as they drew close. Four-hundred paces. Arrows flew out at him. He ducked his head behind the horns of his D’rak, feeling the vibrations of arrows glancing off the bony horns. Out of the corner of his eye, he saw a man fall from his mount, an arrow through his eye. Three-hundred paces. He leaned low over his mount, bracing his spear under his arm so he could hold it with one hand. Two-hundred paces. He picked out a target and held his spear steady. One-hundred. He screamed a war cry. Fifty. Impact. – You’ve tried to build tension here but for me it didn’t work. There’s very little emotion and because I have little or no feel for placement or character development, I’m not engaged.

There was an explosion of carnage as the charge smashed into enemy lines. A jolt went up Rin’s arm as his spear ripped through the man’s leather armor and tore through his chest. He screamed, his face contorted in agony. Rin jumped off his D’rak with the man still impaled on his spear.

He was still alive, blood pouring from the hole in his chest. Rin felt a sudden disgust with himself.
He is an enemy, he reminded himself. They are the enemy. They deserve to die. Trying not to look at his twitching body, Rin pulled the spear from the dying man. When he looked around, all he saw was chaos. Fighting was everywhere. D’rak lizards rampaged through the fray, killing Solts as well as Blood Men in their frenzy.

Rin heard something behind him and whipped around just in time to parry a spear thrust from an enemy soldier. All thoughts of right and wrong fled. There was only survival.
He had to kill this man to survive, so that was what he was going to do. The man made another thrust, and Rin parried it, sprinting to close on him. His skor was out in a second, stabbing at the man’s neck, where he was unarmored. The man dropped his spear later than he should have, but even so his hand snapped out and his grip closed around Rin’s wrist. His other fist smashed into Rin’s temple. Rin fought through the pain and twisted his wrist out of the man’s grasp, blocking another punch with his free hand. He feinted with his skor at the man’s gut and, as he moved to block, Rin took his opportunity. – The action was ok, I could follow it – but it lacked emotion. Lots of “they have to die” in there, which was repeating – in general I think you could be a lot tighter.

The man gasped in pain as Rin’s skor found his neck, ripping into soft flesh. The man fell to the ground and Rin moved on. Rin was not sure how much time passed, but soon he could hear Vallus’s voice shouting above the clamor of battle, calling them to regroup on him. He joined the growing mass of Solts surrounding their leader, grouping for another charge. The enemy was fleeing, every single one of them. Victory, Rin thought, we have won! The men were looking up at Vallus, cheering as he raised his bloody spear in the air.
– Despite all the action, the battlefield is never described. Just what is Rin seeing, I have no idea.

Suddenly, as Rin watched Vallus, an arrow streaked through the air, lodging in the leader’s neck.
He tried to cry out as blood filled his throat, but fell to the ground instead, drowning in his own blood. The men stood in shocked silence, looking at the lone archer who had fired the arrow. He stood across a field of corpses, massive bow in hand, and making no move to run. Rin was stunned. Vallus, dead? He had seemed so invincible. Leaders didn’t die, their troops died for them. Somehow, Rin had never expected that Vallus would die so easily, like any common soldier. After a couple seconds of shock, the anger began to bubble through. He would make the Blood Men pay for killing his leader. – By the end of this section I was glad Vallus had died, it took long enough!

Welcome, Wulfsbane, I do like to see new members with enthusiasm and excitement when it comes to their writing, don’t lose that. I waited till my 35th posting, so I jumped right into it as well. You have the bones of a good story here and what seems like a cracking idea, but your forgetting to describe details that I know are in your head. There is no description other than “a plain” for the battlefield, nothing of the weather or of what anyone or anything looked like. Yet you went into great detail over his stone spike, which in the end I’m not sure he even used. There was far too much padding in there, too much description from you the author instead of this coming from the character. Some emotion to be fair, but not enough, so it felt flat because of that. The running off to get changed/dressed for battle was not needed at all. A little bit comma happy, but I’ll leave grammar to my betters, so fingers crossed a member in the know comes along. Lastly on the writing, I think you need to be tighter, saying what you need to say with the least words possible.

To be fair, I think what you’ve done here was way better than my first post – I got killed, blood all over.
Remember, all the above is just what I think.
 
Well done on the first crit! If this is epic fantasy, you might want to take some of my comments with a pinch on salt!


Rin looked outfrom where? across the plain at the foreign army, its flags raised and billowing in the wind. He was afraidThis is a little bit tell-y -- can you show it instead? Is he gripping his sword too tightly, is his chest tight with fear, bowels churning... , but he was resolved not to show it. Vallus always told him never to show his fear. Never show weakness, to the enemy or to your men, he’d said. Someday, I’ll command an army, Rin thought. I’ll be a great leader, just like him, uniting men from many tribes to a common purpose. Looking out at them, the army of the Blood Men looked huge, but he knew that Vallus’s army was bigger. Three thousand Soltish warriors, the men said, against the two thousand of their enemy. Victory was almost certain, they said. Despite the favorable odds, Rin could not shake the fear that clung to his mind. We may win, he thought, but I could die. Friends could die.As an opening it didn't grip me, sorry. Partly because there's a lot of watching an army and not a lot happening, and secondly because he's telling me all his thoughts and what not and I don't know if I even like him yet.

“You ready, boy?” a voice behind him said.

Rin turned to see Vallus, a faint grin on his face, as he leaned on his spear.

“Yes. I am ready,” Rin said, trying to sound confident.

“Good. Remember, no fear. I hear that these Blood Men do not begin their battle training until they are men. You are young, and they will think you weak, a green boy. Let’s give them a lesson. A deadly one. Now mount up, it’s time to crush these spineless northerners. We’ll show your father that these men die like any others, eh?”

Rin,no comma began to smile,full stop “Aye sir. We will.”

“That’s the spirit, son. You’ll make a fine leader someday.”the dialogue is nice and natural.

Vallus rode off to gather the men, and Rin’s fear receded. They would win, and he would survive. It would be a glorious battle, the first step towards retaking the lands that the Blood Men had stolen. Though Vallus was his grandfather, he was the father that Rin always wished he’d had.this moves us into information dump. If we need to know any of this is there any way you can show it in the exchange above? Referencing Vallus as his grandfather might be a nice, neat way of getting that in, and for the other -- the father he wished he had -- a quick mention of that around the time showing his father the northerners... might be neater? Maybe father will finally see sense after we win this battle, he thought. He might finally come out from behind his walls of cowardice and join the fight. He would no longer be able to say that it was pointless to fight the Blood Men.

Rin ran through the camp, heading to his tent to prepare for battle. He donned his lizard-scale armor and found his spear and skor, a short handled stone weapon made for close combat. Its blade was a short piece of flint, and its pommel wasdrop? a jagged stone spike. He went to where?and found his D’rak lizard mount basking in the sun. He mounted the large reptilian beast and guided it over to his place in the battle lines. Most of the men had already formed up, creating a line of riders, and more were streaming in. He could see Vallus at the front, holding his spear above his head.I'd have liked to see a bit more of the activity -- there must be others getting ready? What does it smell like -- I like the idea of the giant lizards, but I bet their pen stinks... just a few more details to give us the richness of the scene?

“It has been many years since the Blood Men first pushed us from our lands,” Vallus shoutedfull stop, “They think us no more than simple savages. A nuisance to be dealt with quickly. But we will show them that they have made a fatal mistake. Every one of you is worth five of those men out there. They have underestimated us and we will make them pay the price!”

A great cheer rose from the Soltish army and three thousand spears were leveled as they advanced towards the enemy on their D’rak lizardssounds like the enemy are on the lizards. They picked up speed as they crossed the plain. Rin could seeHere, in an action scene, using could see, could hear, could feel etc distances the action from the reader. Try it without, and I think it might make the scene quicker and closer... The enemy formed a defensive lines of spears. Rin's heart... (but you might not want that.) the enemy forming a defensive line of spears. His heart beat faster as they drew close. Four-hundred paces. Arrows flew out at him. He ducked his head behind the horns of his D’rak, feeling the vibrations of arrows glancing off the bony horns. Out of the corner of his eye, he saw a man fall from his mount, an arrow through his eyequite a bit of detail from the corner of his eye.. Three-hundred pacesnice and active. He leaned low over his mount, bracing his spear under his arm so he could hold it with one hand. Two-hundred paces. He picked out a target and held his spear steady. One-hundred. He screamed a war cry. Fifty. Impactnice end to the paragraph.

There was an explosion of carnage as the charge smashed into enemy lines. A jolt went up Rin’s arm as his spear ripped through the man’s leather armor and tore through his chest. Hethe man? screamed, his face contorted in agony. Rin jumped off his D’rak with the man still impaled on his spear.

He was stillrepeat of still alive, blood pouring from the hole in his chest. Rin felt a sudden disgust with himself. He is an enemy, he reminded himself. They are the enemy. They deserve to die. Trying not to look at his twitching body, Rin pulled the spear from the dying man. When he looked around, all he saw was chaos. Fighting was everywhere. D’rak lizards rampaged through the fray, killing Solts as well as Blood Men in their frenzy.

Rin heard something behind himI think this could be stronger. What did he hear? A sword drawn, footsteps? and whipped around just in time to parry a spear thrust from an enemy soldier. All thoughts of right and wrong fled. There was only survival. He had to kill this man to survive, so that was what he was going to do. The man made another thrust, and Rin parried it, sprinting to close on him. His skor was out in a second, stabbing at the man’s neck, where he was unarmored. The man dropped his spear later than he should have, but even so his hand snapped out and his grip closed around Rin’s wrist. His other fist smashed into Rin’s temple. Rin fought through the pain and twisted his wrist out of the man’s grasp, blocking another punch with his free hand. He feinted with his skor at the man’s gut and, as he moved to block, Rin took his opportunity.

The man gasped in pain as Rin’s skor found his neck, ripping into soft flesh. The man fell to the ground and Rin moved on. Rin was not sure how much time passed, but soon he could hearheard? and drop could? Vallus’s voice shouting above the clamor of battle, calling them to regroup on him. Hetechnically Vallus joined the growing mass of Solts surrounding their leader, grouping for another charge. The enemy was fleeing, every single one of them. Victory, Rin thought, we have won! The men were looking up at Vallus, cheering as he raised his bloody spear in the air.

Suddenlydrop suddenly - it's more shocking without the warning that something is going to happen, as Rin watched Vallus,In fact, I'd start here.. an arrow streaked through the air, lodging in the leader’s neck. He tried to cry out as blood filled his throat, but fell to the ground instead, drowning in his own blood. The men stood in shocked silence, looking at the lone archer who had fired the arrow. He stood across a field of corpses, massive bow in hand, and making no move to run. Rin was stunned. Vallus, dead? He had seemed so invincible. Leaders didn’t die, their troops died for them. Somehow, Rin had never expected that Vallus would die so easily, like any common soldier. After a couple seconds of shock, the anger began to bubble through. He would make the Blood Men pay for killing his leader.I felt this paragraph needed a lot more emotion, and more action -- someone is bound to go for that archer, surely? They're trained soldiers, they're not going to stand and wait to be next. [/QUOTE]

I thought the scene was quite nice, into the action, close into the character and his thoughts. I think, though, there is some stuff you could do to make it more active, closer... the veiled actions - watching, feeling, hearing - slow it a little. Also, there are a few long sentences during the battle (which I mostly liked, btw) which, if they were broken up, would give a more active feel. The first paragraph, where he's watching -- I'm not sure it added anything, I'd consider dropping it and seeing if you can fit this into the action somehow. Good luck with it.
 
Thanks everyone for all your great critiques! Lots of really good advice. :) I'll post the second part of the chapter soon.
 
I'd echo the above who have lots more experience than me, but the main thing I think is to give your guys a bit more character. I'm guessing Vallus is someone the men have affection for, and look up to, but I shouldn't be guessing. Show us why that is, maybe he is walking among the men, chatting to them, lifting their spirits, making them laugh and then he comes to Rin and gives the pep talk that you did show.

I really like the different setting you've given this, nice to see the ambition of doing something different, having soldiers riding lizards and having flint weapons. Keep it going.
 
Rin looked out across the plain at the foreign army, its (would "their" work better here?) flags raised and billowing in the wind. He was afraid, but he was resolved not to show it. Vallus always told him never to show his fear. Never show weakness, to the enemy or to your men, he’d said ("He'd said" might not be necessary to include). Someday, I’ll command an army, Rin thought. (Personally, I prefer a character's thoughts to be written in italics. This helps distinguish between thoughts and narrative.) I’ll be a great leader, just like him, uniting men from many tribes to a common purpose. Looking out at them, the army of the Blood Men looked huge, but he knew that Vallus’s army was bigger. Three thousand Soltish warriors, the men said, against the two thousand of their enemy. Victory was almost certain, they said (Again, I'm not sure "they said" is necessary. Without it, it's still clear that Rin is mulling over what he's heard, or what he's been told.). Despite the favorable odds, Rin could not shake the fear that clung to his mind. We may win, he thought, but I could die. Friends could die.

“You ready, boy?” a voice behind him said.

Rin turned to see Vallus, a faint grin on his face, as he leaned on his spear.

“Yes. I am ready,” Rin said, trying to sound confident.

“Good. Remember, no fear. I hear that these Blood Men do not begin their battle training until they are men. You are young, and they will think you weak, (maybe a dash instead of a comma) a green boy. Let’s give them a lesson. A deadly one. Now mount up, it’s time to crush these spineless northerners. We’ll show your father that these men die like any others, eh?” (I like that you've decided to tell us about the Blood Men through dialogue instead of narrative.)

Rin, began to smile, “Aye sir. We will.”

“That’s the spirit, son. You’ll make a fine leader someday.”

Vallus rode off to gather the men, and Rin’s fear receded. They would win, and he would survive. It would be a glorious battle, the first step towards retaking the lands that the Blood Men had stolen. Though Vallus was his grandfather, he was the father that Rin always wished he’d had. Maybe father will finally see sense after we win this battle, he thought. (Again, italicised thoughts are handy.) He might finally come out from behind his walls of cowardice and join the fight. He would no longer be able to say that it was pointless to fight the Blood Men.

Rin ran through the camp, heading to his tent to prepare for battle. He donned his lizard-scale armor and found his spear and skor, a short handled stone weapon made for close combat. Its blade was a short piece of flint, and its pommel was a jagged stone spike. He went and found his D’rak lizard mount basking in the sun. He mounted the large reptilian beast and guided it over to his place in the battle lines. Most of the men had already formed up, creating a line of riders, and more were streaming in. He could see Vallus at the front, holding his spear above his head. (I like this paragraph. You describe his mount and weapon well, and not overbearingly so, while painting a good bit of bustle.)

“It has been many years since the Blood Men first pushed us from our lands,” Vallus shouted, (A period in place of a comma here.) “They think us no more than simple savages. A nuisance to be dealt with quickly. But we will show them that they have made a fatal mistake. Every one of you is worth five of those men out there. They have underestimated us and we will make them pay the price!” (Love that bit of rallying.)

A great cheer rose from the Soltish army and three thousand spears were leveled as they advanced towards the enemy on their D’rak lizards. They picked up speed as they crossed the plain. Rin could see the enemy forming a defensive line of spears. His heart beat faster as they drew close. Four-hundred paces. Arrows flew out at him. He ducked his head behind the horns of his D’rak, feeling the vibrations of arrows glancing off the bony horns. Out of the corner of his eye, he saw a man fall from his mount, an arrow through his eye (Sudden repetition of the word "eye", here. Maybe you could say "corner of his vision", instead?). Three-hundred paces. He leaned low over his mount, bracing his spear under his arm so he could hold it with one hand. Two-hundred paces. He picked out a target and held his spear steady. One-hundred. He screamed a war cry. Fifty. Impact.

There was an explosion of carnage as the charge smashed into enemy lines. (I think "explosion of carnage as the charge smashed" sounds just a bit clumsy. How about, "There was mayhem as the charge smashed"?) A jolt went up Rin’s arm as his spear ripped through the man’s leather armor and tore through his chest. He screamed, his face contorted in agony. Rin jumped off his D’rak with the man still impaled on his spear.

He was still alive, blood pouring from the hole in his chest. Rin felt a sudden disgust with himself. He is an enemy, he reminded himself. They are the enemy. They deserve to die. Trying not to look at his twitching body, Rin pulled the spear from the dying man. When he looked around, all he saw was chaos. Fighting was everywhere. D’rak lizards rampaged through the fray, killing Solts as well as Blood Men in their frenzy.

Rin heard something behind him and whipped around just in time to parry a spear thrust from an enemy soldier. All thoughts of right and wrong fled. There was only survival. He had to kill this man to survive, so that was what he was going to do. The man made another thrust, and Rin parried it, sprinting to close on him. His skor was out in a second, stabbing at the man’s neck, where he was unarmored. The man dropped his spear later than he should have, but even so his hand snapped out and his grip closed around Rin’s wrist. His other fist smashed into Rin’s temple. Rin fought through the pain and twisted his wrist out of the man’s grasp, blocking another punch with his free hand. He feinted with his skor at the man’s gut and, as he moved to block, Rin took his opportunity. (I like this scene. Nice and curt and powerful.)

The man gasped in pain as Rin’s skor found his neck, ripping into soft flesh. The man fell to the ground and Rin moved on. Rin was not sure how much time passed, but soon he could hear Vallus’s voice shouting above the clamor of battle, calling them to regroup on him. He joined the growing mass of Solts surrounding their leader, grouping for another charge. The enemy was fleeing, every single one of them. Victory, Rin thought, (Another period in place of the comma, I think) we have won! The men were looking up at Vallus, cheering as he raised his bloody spear in the air.

Suddenly, as Rin watched Vallus, an arrow streaked through the air, lodging in the leader’s neck. He tried to cry out as blood filled his throat, but fell to the ground instead, drowning in his own blood. The men stood in shocked silence, looking at the lone archer who had fired the arrow. He stood across a field of corpses, massive bow in hand, and making no move to run. Rin was stunned. Vallus, dead? He had seemed so invincible. Leaders didn’t die, their troops died for them. Somehow, Rin had never expected that Vallus would die so easily, like any common soldier. After a couple seconds of shock, the anger began to bubble through. He would make the Blood Men pay for killing his leader. (I would have thought you'd choose "grandfather" instead of "leader" here.)

As battle scenes go, I think this is an all-round good effort. The PoV follows Rin nicely, and the death of Vallus does set the scene for Rin's predicament throughout the story. Well done. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top